Motion artifact reduction in MR imaging of the abdomen: gradient moment nulling versus respiratory-sorted phase encoding

Two currently available methods of reducing motion-induced artifact on magnetic resonance (MR) images, respiratory-sorted phase encoding (RSPE) and gradient moment nulling (GMN), were compared in images of the upper abdomen obtained with long repetition and long echo times. For ten subjects, two series of axial MR images were obtained with identical parameters except that RSPE was used in one and GMN in the other. Images were evaluated by three independent radiologists, and region-of-interest measurements were obtained to calculate signal-difference-to-noise ratios (SD/Ns) for liver versus gallbladder and liver versus the right kidney. Maximum ghost intensity and the standard deviation of motion-induced noise were also calculated. GMN was superior to RSPE for motion artifact reduction in all ten cases. The SD/N for liver versus both gallbladder and right kidney was significantly higher with GMN. Presaturation pulses applied outside the volume of interest reduced aortic and inferior vena cava signal and virtually eliminated artifact from these vessels but did not noticeably affect signal from intrahepatic vessels. GMN combined with presaturation pulses is a highly effective method of motion artifact reduction in the upper abdomen.