TKI治疗转移性肾细胞癌伴横纹肌样分化与伴肉瘤样分化的疗效比较

目的:比较酪氨酸激酶抑制剂(TKI)治疗转移性肾细胞癌伴横纹肌样分化(mRCC-R)与伴肉瘤样分化(mRCC-S)的疗效。方法:回顾性分析天津医科大学肿瘤医院2016年2月至2018年12月采用TKI治疗的5例mRCC-R和9例mRCC-S患者的临床资料。mRCC-R患者5例，男3例，女2例；年龄(60.2±7.1)岁...

Efficacy of tyrosine kinase inhibitors in metastatic renal cell carcinoma with rhabdoid or sarcomatoid differentiation:a single-center retrospective analysis

Objective To investigate the efficacy of tyrosine kinase inhibitors(TKI)in the treatment of metastatic renal cell carcinoma with rhabdoid differentiation(mRCC-R)or sarcomatoid differentiation(mRCC-S)and the survival of the patients.Methods The clinicopathological and postoperative follow-up data of 5 patients with mRCC-R and 9 with mRCC-S confirmed by pathology from February 2016 to December 2018 in Tianjin Medical University Cancer Hospital were reviewed.There were 3 male and 2 female patients in mRCC-R group,with the average age of(60.2±7.1)years old.The clinic manifestation included back or abdominal pain in 2 cases,loss of appetite and weight in one case and founding during physical examination in 2 cases,with the average maximum diameter was(8.8±4.1)cm.The site of tumor included left kidney in 3 cases and right kidney in 2 cases.Lung metastasis was found in 4 cases.Lung and peritoneum metastasis was found in one case.There were 8 male and 1 female patients in mRCC-S group,with the average age of(58.0±8.0)years old.The clinic manifestation included back or abdominal pain in one case,loss of weight in one case,gross hematuria in one case and founding during physical examination in 6 cases.The average diameter of tumor was(8.9±3.5)cm.The site of tumor included left kidney in 4 cases and right kidney in 5 cases.Postoperative metastasis included lung in 3 cases,bone in one case,retroperitoneal lymph node in one case,brain in one case,lung associated with bone in one case.All of the patients were pathologically diagnosed with renal clear cell carcinoma.After metastasis,5 cases of mRCC-R and 6 cases of mRCC-S were treated with Sorafenib,2 cases of mRCC-S were treated with Sunitinib,and 1 case of mRCC-S was treated with Axitinib.The efficacy of TKI for the two specific pathological types and for single pathological type at the early postoperative period(within 3 months)and 3 months later was compared.Meanwhile,subgroup analysis was performed on the efficacy of TKI and survival of patients with same metastatic sites in the two groups.Results The mean overall survival(OS)of mRCC-R and mRCC-S treated with TKI was(26.5±5.5)months and(20.7±4.7)months(P=0.329),and the mean progression-free survival(PFS)was(21.9±5.5)months and(6.3±2.1)months(P=0.013),respectively.Comparing the efficacy of using TKI in the early postoperative period and after 3 months,the mean OS was(27.5±6.5)months and(16.8±6.1)months(P=0.619),and the mean PFS was(12.3±3.3)months and(3.3±1.7)months(P=0.096),respectively.There was only 1 patient with mRCC-R who used TKI within 3 months after surgery,and the result was disease progressed and eventually died,OS was 3 months.Comparing the efficacy of TKI in mRCC-R and mRCC-S with lung metastasis alone,the mean OS was(33.3±2.2)months and(19.5±8.9)months(P=0.118),and the mean PFS was(27.3±3.1)months and(7.8±4.2)months(P=0.009),respectively.Patients with liver,bone or brain metastasis only occurred in mRCC-S,so it is unable to identify the efficacy of TKI in the two groups.Conclusions The efficacy of TKI in the treatment of mRCC-R was better than mRCC-S,and there was statistically significant difference in PFS,especially in patients with lung metastasis alone in the two groups.There was no significant difference in the efficacy between patients with mRCC-R who took TKI in the early postoperative period(within 3 months)and those who took TKI after 3 months.