Sex selection may be inadvertently performed in in-vitro fertilization--embryo transfer programmes

The present study aims to ascertain whether sex selection maybe inadvertently performed in human in-vitro fertilization (IVF)and embryo transfer (IVF-embryo transfer) programmes when selectingfor high quality embryos (those with the fastest cleaving ratesand/or the best morphology) at the fresh transfer cycle. Allpatients entering into the study were treated with gonadotrophinsafter pituitary suppression with gonadotrophin-releasing hormoneagonists (GnRHa) and had intrauterine embryo transfer on day2 post-insemination. These patients were retrospectively dividedinto three groups according to whether the difference in meannumber of cells between embryos transferred and all embryosavailable for transfer in a given cycle was less than (negativeselection), equal to (no selection) or greater (positive selection)than zero. In cycles resulting in singleton births, the sexratio of the resulting babies was significantly (P 0.005) shiftedtoward the female (88.8%) and to the male (90.0%) in the negativeand positive selection groups respectively. No shift in sexratio was observed in cycles resulting in multiple births. Maternalage was another independent factor affecting sex ratio at birth.Sex ratio was significantly (P 0.05) skewed in favour of males(62.7%) and females (71.4%) in women <35 and 235 years ofage respectively. Maternal age, number of embryos transferredand the event of selecting or not selecting the slowest cleavingembryos for transfer were entered automatically in a three-groupdiscriminant model for distinguishing cycles resulting in onlyboys, both boys and girls, and only girls. These data suggestthat (i) sex selection may be inadvertently performed in IVF-embryotransfer programmes when selecting for high quality embryosat the fresh transfer cycles; (ii) human endometria may be favourable,indifferent or hostile to either fast cleaving or slow cleavingembryos depending on maternal age; and (iii) ‘natural’sex selection may be performed for social, psychological ormedical reasons.