Dynamic Three-Dimensional Ultrasound to Evaluate Scapular Movement Among Manual Wheelchair Users and Healthy Controls

Background:

A large percentage of individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI) report shoulder pain that can limit independence and quality of life. The pain is likely related to the demands placed on the shoulder by transfers and propulsion. Shoulder pathology has been linked to altered scapular mechanics; however, current methods to evaluate scapular movement are invasive, require ionizing radiation, are subject to skin-based motion artifacts, or require static postures.

Objective:

To investigate the feasibility of applying 3-dimensional ultrasound methods, previously used to look at scapular position in static postures, to evaluate dynamic scapular movement.

Method:

This study evaluated the feasibility of the novel application of a method combining 2-dimensional ultrasound and a motion capture system to determine 3-dimensional scapular position during dynamic arm elevation in the scapular plane with and without loading.

Results:

Incremental increases in scapular rotations were noted for extracted angles of 30°, 45°, 60°, and 75° of humeral elevation. Group differences were evaluated between a group of 16 manual wheelchair users (MWUs) and a group of age- and gender-matched able-bodied controls. MWUs had greater scapular external rotation and baseline pathology on clinical exam. MWUs also had greater anterior tilting, with this difference further accentuated during loading. The relationship between demographics and scapular positioning was also investigated, revealing that increased age, pathology on clinical exam, years since injury, and body mass index were correlated with scapular rotations associated with impingement (internal rotation, downward rotation, and anterior tilting).

Conclusion:

Individuals with SCI, as well as other populations who are susceptible to shoulder pathology, may benefit from the application of this imaging modality to quantitatively evaluate scapular positioning and effectively target therapeutic interventions.Key words: kinematics, scapula, ultrasound, wheelchair userThe shoulder is a common site of injury across many populations. Because it is the most mobile joint in the body, the high prevalence of disorders is not surprising. Individuals are at increased risk for shoulder pathology when exposed to high forces, sustained postures, and repetitive movements.¹ Wheelchair users are exposed to all of these factors in activities of daily living. Among manual wheelchair users (MWUs), 35% to 67% report shoulder pain.^2–7 In this population, the presence of shoulder dysfunction significantly affects function and decreases quality of life.^8,9 With altered scapular kinematics being linked to a multitude of shoulder problems, the identification of changes in kinematics may allow for earlier detection of pathology and targeting of appropriate interventions.^10–25 However, evaluation of dynamic scapular movement is a challenging task, as the scapula rotates about 3 axes while also gliding underneath overlying tissue. Direct visualization of the bone is ideal but is often limited by cost, availability, and exposure to radiation, and skin-based systems are prone to error.^26–33The overall goal of this study was to investigate the feasibility of applying 3-dimensional ultrasound methods, previously used to look at scapular position in static postures, to evaluate dynamic scapular movement.³⁴ The specific goals were as follows:

1. Evaluate intermediate angles of functional elevation during dynamic movement (30°, 45°, 60°, and 75°). We hypothesize that we will see incremental increases in external rotation, upward rotation, and posterior tipping throughout the movement to maintain the distance between the acromion and humerus.
2. Compare dynamic scapular movement between MWUs and able-bodied controls (ABs). We anticipate that the nature of wheelchair propulsion and demands of activities of daily living will elucidate differences between this population and ABs with comparably lower daily demands on the shoulder.
3. Evaluate the effect of loading on scapular movement, as other studies have suggested that differences in kinematics are clearer in the presence of loading.^10,35,36
4. Investigate the relationship between shoulder pathology, age, years since injury, and body mass index (BMI) and scapular positioning.