Increased apical enlargement contributes to excessive dentin removal in curved root canals: a stepwise microcomputed tomography study

Introduction

To determine whether increased apical enlargement would result in a complete preparation of curved canals and to progressively assess shaping quality using multiple microcomputed tomography (MCT) scans.

Methods

Ninety root canals with a curvature of 25° to 50° were selected. Five MCT scans, 1 preoperative and 4 postoperative, were acquired from each canal. Canal preparation was performed up to size 50 using 3 techniques, nickel-titanium (NiTi) hand files, Mtwo (VDW, Munich, Germany), and ProTaper (Maillefer, Ballaigue, Switzerland), by experienced operators in a dental mannequin so as to simulate the clinical conditions. At a level of 1 mm short of the working length, 2 parameters were evaluated in each of the 4 postoperative acquisitions: the percentage of the prepared outline and the amount of dentin removed (the prepared area).

Results

Statistically, there was no significant difference between the 3 systems used regarding the prepared outline. The maximum prepared outline was achieved by the use of NiTi hand files (63%; confidence interval [CI], 54%–73%), whereas Mtwo and ProTaper amounted to 58% (CI, 50%–66%) and 60% (CI, 51%–70%), respectively. In contrast, the dentin area removed by ProTaper was significantly higher than that of Mtwo and NiTi hand files.

Conclusions

Increased apical enlargement of curved canals did not result in a complete apical preparation, whereas it did lead to the unnecessary removal of dentin.