Discordant carbamazepine values between two immunoassays: carbamazepine values determined by ADVIA Centaur correlate better with those determined by LC-MS/MS than PETINIA assay

Discordant carbamazepine values as determined by two different immunoassays may be due to different cross-reactivities with the active metabolite carbamazepine 10, 11-epoxide and may cause confusion in interpreting carbamazepine serum levels. In this study, we compared carbamazepine values in samples containing carbamazepine and the epoxide metabolite, as determined by liquid chromatography coupled to tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) and by two commercial carbamazepine immunoassays: the PETINIA and the ADVIA Centaur carbamazepine. Clinical specimens were used for the comparative studies wherein we determined carbamazepine concentrations using the PETINIA, ADVIA Centaur, and LC-MS/MS assays. We observed an excellent correlation between carbamazepine concentrations determined by the ADVIA Centaur and LC-MS/MS methods while carbamazepine values were overestimated using the PETINIA assay. When aliquots of drug-free serum were supplemented with clinically relevant concentrations of the carbamazepine epoxide metabolite, we observed negligible cross-reactivity of epoxide with the ADVIA Centaur assay but over 90% cross-reactivity with the PETINIA assay. We conclude that the ADVIA centaur assay accurately measures carbamazepine concentrations in plasma or serum and that the PETINIA assay significantly overestimates true carbamazepine concentration. Such discordance may cause confusion in interpreting serum carbamazepine levels.