32P敷贴与鱼肝油酸钠局部注射治疗皮肤血管瘤疗效比较

目的比较32P敷贴与鱼肝油酸钠局部注射治疗皮肤血管瘤疗效.方法32P敷贴药片敷贴于血管瘤表面,根据年龄不同敷贴16～45h不等,3～6个月敷贴1次,常规1～2次;对照组用5%鱼肝油酸钠加曲安奈德-A瘤内注射,7～10 d 1次,共2～10次.最后进行疗效和副作用评判.结果:32P敷贴总有效率为97%(159/164例),痊愈70.7%(116/164),基本痊愈20.1%(33/164例).对照组总有效率91.2%(124/136例),痊愈53.7%(73/136),基本痊愈13.2%(18/136例).两组间差异有显著性(x2=27,P＜0.05).结论32P敷贴治疗皮肤血管瘤疗效优于鱼肝油酸钠,且无明显副作用.

Comparison of therapeutic effect of 32 p plaster and local injection of sodium morrhuate on skin hemangiomas

Objective :To compare the therapeutic effect of 32p plaster with that of sodium morrhuate on skin he mangiomas. Methods:In accordance with patients'age,32P plasters were placedon the surfaces of skin hemangiomas for 16 ～45 hours, once every 3 ～6 months with one or two therapeutic courses in common practice. The control group was treated by local injection of 5% sodium morrhuate and Triamcinolone Acetonide - A every 7 ～ 10 days, 2 ～ 10 times in all. Then the therapeutic effect and side effects of both groups were evaluated. Results:Positive effect of 32p plaster was observed in 159/164(97% ) cases. 116/164(70. 7% ) cases were completely recovered and 33/164(20.1% ) cases were recovered. But the total efficiency of the control group was only 91.2% ( 124/136), including 53.7% (73/136) of full recovery and 13.2% (18/136) of recovery. There was a significant difference in the therapeutic effect of both groups (χ2 = 27, P ＜ 0.05 ). Conclusions: The therapeutic effect of 32p plaster on skin hemangiomas was better than that of sodium morrhuate, and no evident side effect was found.