Management of suspected thyroglossal duct cysts

Aim of study

The aim of this study was to evaluate management of children with an anterior midline neck swelling by establishing 1) whether a preoperative ultrasound scan (USS) was appropriately requested, performed and reported; 2) whether there was preoperative infection; 3) whether a Sistrunk procedure was performed; 4) the rate of thyroglossal duct cyst (TGDC) recurrence following simple excision vs. Sistrunk procedure.

Methods

A single centre retrospective study of children who underwent surgery for anterior midline neck swelling between April 2000 and May 2015 at our institution was performed. These were identified using a clinical coding system, and data were collected from electronic medical records, radiology, and histopathology reports. Recurrence rates between simple excision and Sistrunk groups were compared using Chi-square test.

Main results

227 patients were identified (115 male, 112 female). 169 (74%) had a preoperative USS. The presence of a thyroid gland was stated in 79% of USS reports. This increased to 92% when the requesting surgeon had specifically asked about this. 48 (21%) patients underwent simple excision, while 175 (77%) had a Sistrunk procedure. Recurrence was significantly more likely following simple excision than a Sistrunk procedure (29% vs 6.9%; P < 0.0001). Of 25 TGDC recurrences, 9 (36%) had an inconclusive or alternative histopathological diagnosis at first operation.

Conclusion

Preoperative USS should be performed in all patients with an anterior midline neck swelling. Appropriate requesting increases likelihood of a report confirming (or otherwise) the presence of a thyroid gland. A Sistrunk procedure is the operation of choice in all children presenting with an anterior midline neck swelling. The surgeon cannot reliably differentiate a TGDC from alternative pathology intraoperatively.

Level of evidence

Treatment study: level IV.