Spine dynamics of PSD-95-deficient neurons in the visual cortex link silent synapses to structural cortical plasticity

Critical periods (CPs) are time windows of heightened brain plasticity during which experience refines synaptic connections to achieve mature functionality. At glutamatergic synapses on dendritic spines of principal cortical neurons, the maturation is largely governed by postsynaptic density protein-95 (PSD-95)-dependent synaptic incorporation of α-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionic acid (AMPA) receptors into nascent AMPA-receptor silent synapses. Consequently, in mouse primary visual cortex (V1), impaired silent synapse maturation in PSD-95-deficient neurons prevents the closure of the CP for juvenile ocular dominance plasticity (jODP). A structural hallmark of jODP is increased spine elimination, induced by brief monocular deprivation (MD). However, it is unknown whether impaired silent synapse maturation facilitates spine elimination and also preserves juvenile structural plasticity. Using two-photon microscopy, we assessed spine dynamics in apical dendrites of layer 2/3 pyramidal neurons (PNs) in binocular V1 during ODP in awake adult mice. Under basal conditions, spine formation and elimination ratios were similar between PSD-95 knockout (KO) and wild-type (WT) mice. However, a brief MD affected spine dynamics only in KO mice, where MD doubled spine elimination, primarily affecting newly formed spines, and caused a net reduction in spine density similar to what has been observed during jODP in WT mice. A similar increase in spine elimination after MD occurred if PSD-95 was knocked down in single PNs of layer 2/3. Thus, structural plasticity is dictated cell autonomously by PSD-95 in vivo in awake mice. Loss of PSD-95 preserves hallmark features of spine dynamics in jODP into adulthood, revealing a functional link of PSD-95 for experience-dependent synapse maturation and stabilization during CPs.

Early life of an animal is characterized by time windows of functionally and structurally enhanced brain plasticity known as critical periods (CPs), which have been described initially in the primary visual cortex (V1) of kittens (1). During CPs, experience refines the connectivity of principal excitatory neurons to establish the mature functionality of neural networks. This refinement is governed by the constant generation and elimination of nascent synapses on dendritic spines that sample favorable connections to be consolidated and unfavorable ones to be eliminated (2–5). A fraction of nascent synapses is or becomes α-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionic acid (AMPA)-receptor silent, expressing N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors only (6–8). At eye opening, silent synapses are abundant in the primary visual cortex (V1) (9, 10) and mature during CPs by stable AMPA receptor incorporation (11–14). The pace of silent synapse maturation is governed by the opposing yet cooperative function of postsynaptic density protein of 95 kDa (PSD-95) and its paralog PSD-93, two signaling scaffolds of the postsynaptic density of excitatory synapses (12, 13). However, whether silent synapses are preferential substrates for spine elimination during CPs remains to be investigated.In juvenile mice (postnatal days [P] 20 to 35), a brief monocular deprivation (MD) of the dominant contralateral eye results in a shift of the ocular dominance (OD) of binocular neurons in V1 toward the open eye, mediated by a reduction of responses to visual stimulation of the deprived eye (15–17). Structurally, MD induces an increase in spine elimination in apical dendrites of layer (L) 2/3 and L5 pyramidal neurons (PNs) which is only observed during the CP and constitutes a hallmark of juvenile OD plasticity (jODP) (18–20). After CP closure, cortical plasticity declines progressively, and in standard cage-raised mice beyond P40, a 4-d MD no longer induces the functional nor anatomical changes associated with jODP (21–24).At least three different mechanisms involved in experience-dependent maturation of cortical neural networks have been described, but the molecular and cellular mechanisms that cause CP closure remain highly debated (18, 25, 26). First, plasticity of local inhibitory neurons, such as increased inhibitory tone or a reduction of release probability by experience-dependent endocannabinoid receptor 1 (CB1R) activation was reported to close the critical period in rodent V1 (27–29). Second, the expression of so-called “plasticity brakes,” such as extracellular matrix (ECM), Nogo receptor 1 (NgR1), paired immunoglobulin-like receptor B (PirB), and Lynx1 were correlated with the end of critical periods (30–33). Experimentally decreasing the inhibitory tone or absence of plasticity brakes enhanced ODP expression in various knockout (KO) mouse models (32, 34, 35), among which only Lynx1 KO mice were shown to exhibit functional hallmarks of jODP, such as selective deprived eye depression after a short MD (36). Structurally, Lynx1 KO mice exhibited elevated spine dynamics at baseline; however, MD induced a reduction in spine elimination in apical dendrites of L5 PNs, whereas in L2/3 PNs there was no change (37). Thus, the effects of removing plasticity brakes on structural plasticity are variable, and it remains unclear to what extend manipulating the plasticity brakes can reinstate cellular signatures of CP plasticity in the adult wild-type (WT) brain (38). Third, the progressive maturation of AMPAR-silent synapses was correlated with the closure of the CP for jODP (12, 13). Consequently, in PSD-95 KO mice, the maturation of silent synapses is impaired; their fraction remains at the eye opening level, and jODP is preserved lifelong (13). Furthermore, visual cortex-specific knockdown (KD) of PSD-95 in the adult brain reinstated jODP. In contrast, in PSD-93 KO mice, silent synapses mature precociously and the CP for jODP closes precociously (12), correlating the presence of silent synapses with functional plasticity during CPs.While these three mechanisms of CP closure are not mutually exclusive in regulating cortical plasticity (26), it remains elusive whether CP-like structural plasticity can be expressed in the adult brain and whether silent synapses might be substrates for it. Here, we performed chronic two-photon imaging of dendrites of L2/3 pyramidal neurons in binocular V1 of PSD-95 KO (and KD) and WT mice, tracking the same dendritic spines longitudinally before, during, and after a 4-d period of MD. As previous studies have reported anesthesia effects on spine dynamics (39–41), we performed our experiments in awake mice, thoroughly trained for head fixation under the two-photon microscope. Our chronic spine imaging experiments revealed that in adult PSD-95 KO and KD mice, a brief MD indeed increased spine elimination about twofold, while adult WT mice did not display experience-dependent changes in spine elimination or spine formation. Thus, the loss of PSD-95 led to a high number of AMPAR-silent synapses which were correlated with jODP after MD, and with juvenile-like structural plasticity even in the adult brain, underscoring the importance of silent synapses for CP-timing and network maturation and stabilization.