4种国产和3种进口第4代HIV抗原抗体检测试剂的质量评价

目的 对4种国产和3种进口第4代HIV诊断试剂的质量进行评价.方法 利用HIV抗体阴性样品库和核酸阳性样品库、BBI阳转血清盘样品等,对4种国产和3种进口第4代试剂的敏感性和特异性、检测HIV-1早期感染的能力进行分析.结果 7种第4代试剂的敏感性均为100％ (95％ CI:99.86％～100％),且1份HIV-1感染窗口期样品均检测为阳性,其中1种进口试剂“8+”值较大(1.0892),其余6种试剂的“δ+”值均比较小(0.0836 ～0.3003).对阴性样品,7种试剂均存在不同程度的假阳性(特异性为97.80％ ～ 99.60％,“δ-”值为-1.3803 -0.4778).对BBI阳转血清盘样品,国产试剂的阳转血清相对敏感性系数为-0.500～0,2种进口试剂则为-0.600和-0.700.结论 7种试剂均具有较高的敏感性和特异性,第4代HIV试剂用于血液筛查可发现HIV感染窗口期样本,对减少HIV传播的风险有一定的意义.但进口第4代试剂检测HIV-1早期感染的能力强于国产第4代试剂.

Evaluation of four domestic and three imported fourth-generation HIV diagnostic reagents

Objective To evaluate the quality of four domestic and three imported fourth-generation HIV diagnostic reagents.Methods The specificity and sensitivity of these assays were analyzed when testing HIV negative samples and HIV-1 RNA positive samples.The relative seroconversion sensitivity index was analyzed when testing BBI seroconversion panels.Results The sensitivity of seven 4th-generation assays were 100％ (95％ CI:99.86％-100％ ),and one sample at the window period of HIV-1 infection were detected as positive.Of the seven assays,one imported assay exhibited the relative large " δ +" value (1.0892),and the small "δ+" value were found on the remaining six assays (0.0836-0.3003 ).For the samples negative for HIV antibody,varying degrees of false positives were observed on the seven assays ( specificity:97.80％ -99.60％,"δ-" value:-1.3803 to -0.4778).When testing the BBI seroconversion panels,the relative seroconversion sensitivity index of domestic assays were -0.500-0,however,which of imported assays were -0.600 and -0.700.Conclusion The seven reagents exhibited high sensitivity and specificity.The 4th generation HIV assays can be used as blood screening reagents to find the samples at window period of HIV-1 infection,thus indicating the certain meaning in reducing the transmission risk of HIV-1 for fourth-generation HIV diagnostic reagents.However,the better efficiency to detect HIV-1 early infection was observed on the imported assays than on the domestic assays.