Limited plasticity in the recognition of peptide epitope variants by an alloreactive CTL clone correlates directly with conservation of critical residues and inversely with peptide length

Although self-restricted T cells are peptide-specific and can distinguish among closely related ligands, they have some flexibility in the recognition of sequence variants of their natural peptide epitopes. Alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) can recognize specific peptides bound to the allo-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule, but their plasticity in the recognition of related peptide variants has not been properly defined. The anti-B*2705 alloreactive CTL 27S69 specifically recognizes a natural octamer ligand of HLA-B*2705. In this study, we tested the recognition of a nested set of epitope variants by this CTL clone. Although none of these peptides was recognized equally as the natural epitope, two of the peptide variants were recognized with only slightly decreased efficiency. Peptide sensitization assays showed that CTL recognition of epitope variants correlated directly with conservation of two non-anchor residues that were critical for recognition of the natural epitope, and inversely with peptide length. Molecular modeling of the peptide variants complexed with B*2705 provided a rational explanation for their differential recognition. Location of the two critical peptide residues at the right three-dimensional space favored efficient recognition by CTL 27S69. The negative effect of increasing peptide length on recognition was due to the bigger bulging surface between the two critical residues, which precluded for optimal interaction with the specific T-cell receptors (TCR). Our results demonstrate that an alloreactive CTL has a degree of plasticity in the recognition of peptide epitope variants that is comparable to that of peptide-specific self-restricted CTL, and define the structural features determining crossreaction among related peptides.