Evaluation of the "N" factor in nonsmall cell lung cancer. Correlation between computerized tomography and pathologic anatomy

PURPOSE: To evaluate the role of CT in identifying other morphological signs of metastatic lymph node involvement from non small cell bronchogenic carcinoma. This is done to improve N staging, a critical step in this disease. In fact, since diameter is the only criterion used to distinguish normal form abnormal lymph nodes, medistinal CT only has 80% diagnostic accuracy. MATERIAL AND METHODS: 137 patients with known or suspected lung cancer were examined with Helical CT during early and late arterial phases (2 min delay, 3 mm thickness, 5 mm interslice gap) to depict node characteristics. Mediastinal lymph nodes, located according to the American Thoracic Society mapping, were considered normal when they were not visible or, if visible, less than 1 cm in diameter and of homogeneous density; lymph nodes over 1 cm in diameter and homogeneous density were considered reactive. A lymph node was considered metastatic when, independent of size, the following signs were found: central hypodensity; hyperdense thin/thick rim, with nodules within; hyperdense strands or diffuse hyperdensity in perinodal adipose tissue. The tumor site was also considered. RESULTS: Seventy patients were excluded because they were inoperable. Sixty-five of the remaining 67 patients were operated on, 1 underwent mediastinoscopy and another one mediastinoscopy followed by surgery. Based on the above CT signs, 46 patients were staged as N0, 61 as N1 and 15 as N2. In 44/46 N0 patients there was agreement between anatomical and pathologic findings; 3 of the 44 patients had lymph nodes over 1 cm in diameter and with homogeneous density. Micrometastases to mediastinal lymph nodes (N2) were found at histology in 2/46 patients (CT false negatives). In the 6 N1 and the 15 N2 patients there was complete agreement between anatomical and pathologic findings; in particular, 9 N2 patients had lymph nodes less than 1 cm in diameter with signs of metastasis and 4 had lymph nodes over 1 cm in diameter with signs of metastasis and 2 had lymph nodes either over or less than 1 cm. In all N2 patients the tumor histotype and the mediastinal location were also considered relative to the lesion site. DISCUSSION: A closer correlation was found with node morphology and density than with size. Indeed, CT sensitivity, specificity and diagnostic accuracy were 97, 100 and 97%, respectively, for the former versus 52, 93 and 77% for the latter. Adenocarcinoma was the predominant histotype (70.5%) in N2 patients. Metastases to node region 4 were predominant in right upper lobe carcinomas while node region 5 was predominant in left upper lobe lesions. CONCLUSIONS: Other criteria can be associated with size to improve CT diagnostic accuracy in N staging. Technique optimization plays a major role particularly in the late, thin slice, examination phase.