The role of imperatives in psychopathology: A reply to Ellis

In his recent formulations of rational emotive therapy (RET), Ellis (1985) has increasingly emphasized what he believes to be the central role of necessitous thinking or musturbation in the development of depression. In his most recent article (Ellis, 1987), he suggests that necessitous thinking is the primary cognitive component of depression and that RET stands alone in its recognition of the role of this cognitive element. The present study addressed three issues raised by Ellis's paper: (1) Clarify whether necessitous thinking has been neglected by other cognitive theorists, (2) test empirically the role of necessitou thinking in depression relative to other established cognitive constructs, e.g., the cognitive triad (Beck, 1967), and (3) determine whether necessitous thinking is particularly salient in depression as compared with other forms of psychopathology. It was predicted that necessitous thinking would be found in other forms of psychology in addition to depression, and this was confirmed. The results are discussed as highlighting the importance of empirically testing theoretical predictions.From the Foundation for Cognitive Therapy.