Comparison of outcomes between minimally invasive and median sternotomy for double and triple valve surgery: A meta-analysis

Background

Limited data exists demonstrating the efficacy of minimally invasive surgery (MIS) compared to median sternotomy (MS) for multiple valvular disease (MVD). This systematic review and meta-analysis aims to compare operative and peri-operative outcomes of MIS vs MS in MVD.

Methods

PubMed, Ovid, and Embase were searched from inception until August 2019 for randomized and observational studies comparing MIS and MS in patients with MVD. Clinical outcomes of intra- and postoperative times, reoperation for bleeding and surgical site infection were evaluated.

Results

Five observational studies comparing 340 MIS vs 414 MS patients were eligible for qualitative and quantitative review. The quality of evidence assessed using the Newcastle-Ottawa scale was good for all included studies. Meta-analysis demonstrated increased cardiopulmonary bypass time for MIS patients (weighted mean difference [WMD], 0.487; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.365-0.608; P < .0001). Similarly, aortic cross-clamp time was longer in patients undergoing MIS (WMD, 0.632; 95% CI, 0.509-0.755; P < .0001). No differences were found in operative mortality, reoperation for bleeding, surgical site infection, or hospital stay.

Conclusions

MIS for MVD have similar short-term outcomes compared to MS. This adds value to the use of minimally invasive methods for multivalvular surgery, despite conferring longer operative times. However, the paucity in literature and learning curve associated with MIS warrants further evidence, ideally randomized control trials, to support these findings.

     

Laparoscopic vs open subtotal colectomy for benign and malignant disease

AIM: The present meta-analysis aims to compare short-term and long-term outcomes in patients undergoing laparoscopic or open subtotal colectomy for benign and malignant disease. METHODS: A literature search of Medline, Ovid, Embase and Cochrane databases was performed to identify studies published between 1992 and 2005, comparing laparoscopic (LSC) and open (OSC) subtotal colectomy. A random effect meta-analytical technique was used and sensitivity analysis performed on studies published since the beginning of 2000, higher quality papers, those reporting on more than 40 patients, and those studies reporting on adult cases or acute colitis. RESULTS: A total of eight studies satisfied the criteria for inclusion. These included outcomes on 336 patients, 143 (42.6%) of whom had undergone laparoscopic resection, with an overall conversion rate to open surgery of 5% (range 0-11.8%). Operative time was significantly longer in the laparoscopic group by 86.2 min (P < 0.001) and throughout subgroup analysis, although it was only in patients with acute colitis that this finding was without significant heterogeneity. Operative blood loss was less in the laparoscopic group by 57.5 millilitres in high quality and studies published since 2000, and 65.3 millilitres in those reporting on more than 40 patients. There was no significant difference in early or long-term complications between the groups. A statistically significant reduction in length of postoperative stay was observed in the laparoscopic groups by 2.9 days (P < 0.001). CONCLUSION: Laparoscopic subtotal colectomy was associated with longer operating times but a reduced length of stay compared to open surgery. Although short-term outcomes were equivalent in both groups, the suggested benefits in terms of reduced long-term obstructive complications were not supported by this meta-analysis.     

进展期霍奇金病经化疗达完全缓解后,巩固放疗的Meta分析

目的 应用Meta分析的方法评价进展期霍奇金病经化疗达完全缓解后巩固放疗的作用。材料和方法 在MEDLINE、CBMdisc数据库检索进展期霍奇金病化疗达完全缓解行巩固性放疗或不行巩固性放疗的前瞻性随机对照研究。对入选研究的总生存、无事件生存优势比进行Meta分析。结果 4项研究入选，以α=0．05为检验水准，巩固性放疗组与对照组(不作巩固性放疗)相比，5年总生存优势比=1．18，P=0．46；5年无事件生存优势比=1．05．P=0．83：巩固性侵犯野放疗组与对照组相比，5年总生存优势比=0．96，P=0．87。结论 进展期霍奇金病经化疗达到完全缓解后，巩固性放疗对总生存及无事件生存均无益处。     

The nocturnal jejunal migrating motor complex: defining normal ranges by study of 51 healthy adult volunteers and meta-analysis

Interdigestive human small bowel motility is characterized by the migrating motor complex (MMC). The aims of this study were to: (i) establish the normal range of variables of the nocturnal jejunal MMC and (ii) incorporate these data in a subsequent meta-analysis. Eighty-one recordings were performed by prolonged (24 h) ambulatory manometry in 51 subjects in two centres. Quantitative analysis was undertaken of 419 Phase III and 332 Phase II episodes. Adjusted mean values of seven variables were calculated using a mixed-effects model. Meta-analysis of pooled published data to generate a reliable 95% reference range was also performed. Adjusted mean values and confidence intervals are presented for all seven variables. Intrasubject variances were large in comparison with intersubject. Meta-analysis of 19 studies (356 pooled patients) meeting inclusion criteria produced wide reference ranges. At least five such ranges are useful for the detection of abnormality in the individual. This is the largest study of normal volunteers presented to date, with ranges for many variables produced using appropriate statistical methodology. A model for definition of abnormality has been proposed. We recommend that these data may be used by investigators in this field as a complement to other existing indicators of small bowel dysmotility.     

Boerhaave’s syndrome: Primary repair vs. esophageal resection—Case reports and meta-analysis of the literature

Boerhaave’s syndrome is a life-threatening disease with a high mortality. With regard to the heterogeneity of treatment strategies, no comparative studies exist and recommendations remain controversial. Seventeen cases of Boerhaave’s syndrome operated on between 1989 and 2000 at our hospital were reviewed retrospectively to compare the time period between perforation and diagnosis, and the morbidity and mortality among the different treatment options. In addition, we conducted a meta-analysis of the literature including all series containing five or more patients and compared the findings with our own data. Our patients with a perforation history of less than 12 hours showed significantly fewer signs of sepsis compared to patients with a history of more than 12 hours. In a comparison of patients with primary repair vs. patients treated with esophageal resection or an exclusion operation, no differences were found. In the literature, patients with a long period of perforation (more than 24 hours) were treated more often with an esophageal resection than patients with primary repair. In cases of Boerhaave’s syndrome, primary suturing of the esophageal perforation should be reserved only for those patients presenting within 12 hours after perforation. In all other cases, depending on the extent of the tissue damage, a two-stage esophageal resection with cervical esophagostomy and gastrostomy is recommended as the safest treatment.     

西地那非治疗勃起功能障碍的有效性:中文文献的meta分析

目的评价西地那非治疗ED的有效性。方法通过中国生物医学文摘光盘(CBMdisc 2004新版)和清华同方数据库中CHKD期刊全文库检索公开发表的中文文献。凡摘要或方法中出现随机对照字样,无论有无盲法均予纳入。对纳入的试验设计特征用Jadad计分评价。以IIEF中Q3和Q4评分及IIEF总评分为疗效指标,采用RevMan4．1软件进行Meta分析。结果共有9个随机对照试验被纳入。其中6个为Jadad计分3分以上高质量试验。5个试验的IIEF Q3和Q4评分meta分析,OR=8．83,95％CI为(6．67,11．69),P<0．0001。4个高质量试验的IIEF总评分meta分析OR=13．76,95％CI为(9．50,19．92),P<0．0001。显示西地那非能够显著提高ED患者的疗效指标。结论西地那非能有效改善男性勃起功能,是一种有效治疗ED的口服药物。     

S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAMe) as antidepressant: meta-analysis of clinical studies

Introduction - S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAMe) is a naturally-occurring substance which is a major source of methyl groups in the brain. Material and methods - We conducted a meta-analysis of the studies on SAMe to assess the efficacy of this compound in the treatment of depression compared with placebo and standard tricyclic antidepressants. Results - Our meta-analysis showed a greater response rate with SAMe when compared with placebo, with a global effect size ranging from 17% to 38% depending on the definition of response, and an antidepressant effect comparable with that of standard tricyclic antidepressants. Conclusion - The efficacy of SAMein treating depressive syndromes and disorders is superior with that of placebo and comparable to that of standard tricyclic antidepressants. Since SAMe is a naturally occurring compound with relatively few side-effects, it is a potentially important treatment for depression.     

变应性鼻炎、哮喘患者血白细胞介素的循证医学研究

目的 评价变应性鼻炎、哮喘患者血清中白细胞介素IL-4、IL-6、IL-8检测指标的意义。方法 检索策略:通过中国生物医学文献数据库(CBMdisc)、中文全文数据库全面检索国内已发表的相关文献。选择标准:中国成人变应性鼻炎、哮喘患者与对照组血清白细胞介素IL-4、IL-6、IL-8水平检测。资料收集和分析:由2位评价者按照上述检索策略收集文献。排除那些不符合选择标准要求的试验。结果 经Meta分析,发作期、缓解期变应性鼻炎患者血清中IL-4水平分别较对照组上升129.45 ng/mL(95％CI 124.95～133.96)、35.00 ng/mL(95％CI 32.01～39.78),有显著统计学意义(P<0.000 01):缓解期IL-6水平较对照组上升21.87 ng/mL(95％CI 19.83～23.91),有显著统计学意义(P<0.000 01);发作期、缓解期IL-8水平分别较对照组上升41.75 ng/mL(95％CI 29.14-54.36)、98.94 ng/mL(95％CI 96.48-101.41),有显著统计学意义(P<0.000 01);发作期IL-4水平较缓解期上升129.99 ng/mL(95％CI 125.00～134.99),有显著统计学意义(P<0.000 01)。结论 IL-4、IL-6和IL-8参与了变应性鼻炎、哮喘的发生和促进了变态反应性疾病的发展,有必要开展更广泛研究和更深层的原因探索。