Light exposure required for optimum conversion of light activated resin systems

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the relationship between the degree of conversion (DC) of composites and the light intensity using LED-curing units and also to determine the amount of exposure required to achieve optimal curing. METHOD: The light outputs of light-curing units and the depths of cure of composites exposed to these units were determined using the methods outlined in modified ISO standards, ISO/TS10650 and ISO 4049, respectively. The distributions of DC in composites were investigated by IR spectra of microareas obtained at various depths from the irradiated surface of thin specimens cut out from the cured composites. IR spectra were measured using a Fourier transform infrared spectrometer equipped with a microscopic unit. DC was calculated from the changes in the amount of C=C double bonds in the IR spectra. RESULTS: The light intensity at various depths through the cured composite was calculated from the attenuation coefficient of each material, obtained from the linear relationship between the depth of cure and the logarithm of the amount of exposure, which is defined as the product of the irradiance and irradiation time. There was a third or fourth order regression relationship between DC and the logarithm of total light energy at a particular depth. SIGNIFICANCE: The minimum light energy required to produce a saturated DC was about 1000 s mW/cm2.     

光量子疗法中圆面紫外灯辐照度的定量研究

本文根据光辐射的基本概念，应用数学物理方法，导出了血液辐射治疗仪中带反射罩的紫外线灯的辐照度的计算公式，用ＸＴ－Ａ型紫外光功率计，对ＸＬ－２００型血液辐射治疗仪进行实测，经过计算分析，定出了公式中的待定参数，并应用公式对各实测点进行计算对比，计算值与实测值符合得非常好，发现紫外灯辐射度并简单的指标衰减，为近距离辐照剂量的估算提供了一个有价值的公式，从而将光量子疗法中关于辐照剂量问题的研究定量化。     

Photodynamic therapy in the bladder: Can the light dose be easily quantified?

The shape of the bladder and the optical characteristics of the tissue within the wall can be shown to play an important role in the amount of light actually received at the wall. The use of estimated doses even assuming spherical geometry, cannot therefore be relied upon. This paper describes some experimental work carried out on a glass model that was used to simulate the bladder. A specially constructed dual detector was used which consisted of an isotropic probe and semiconductor detector. This enabled measurements of irradiance and space irradiance (light energy fluence rate) to be made simultaneously. By changing the optical characteristics of the wall a four-fold increase in space irradiance was measured. Contamination of the water contained within the model by blood was also investigated and has shown that with concentrations as low as 0.5% the delivered light dose reaching the wall can be reduced by up to 50% at a wavelength of 510 nm. Some in vivo measurements are also presented together with some comments on the difficulties that have been encountered when transferring measurements from the model to the patient.     

Influence of various irradiation processes on the mechanical properties and polymerisation kinetics of bulk-fill resin based composites

ObjectivesTo assess the effect of irradiation time and distance of the light tip on the micro-mechanical properties and polymerisation kinetics of two bulk-fill resin-based composites at simulated clinically relevant filling depth.MethodsMicro-mechanical properties (Vickers hardness (HV), depth of cure (DOC) and indentation modulus (E)) and polymerisation kinetics (real-time increase of degree of cure (DC)) of two bulk-fill resin-based composites (Tetric EvoCeram^® Bulk Fill, Ivoclar Vivadent and x-tra base, Voco) were assessed at varying depth (0.1–6 mm in 100 μm steps for E and HV and 0.1, 2, 4 and 6 mm for DC), irradiation time (10, 20 or 40 s, Elipar Freelight2) and distances from the light tip (0 and 7 mm). Curing unit's irradiance was monitored in 1 mm steps at distances up to 10 mm away from the light tip on a laboratory-grade spectrometer.ResultsMultivariate analysis (α = 0.05), Student's t-test and Pearson correlation analysis were considered. The influence of material on the measured mechanical properties was significant (η² = 0.080 for E and 0.256 for HV), while the parameters irradiation time, distance from the light tip and depth emphasise a stronger influence on Tetric EvoCeram^® Bulk Fill. The polymerisation kinetics could be described by an exponential sum function, distinguishing between the gel and the glass phase. The above mentioned parameters strongly influenced the start of polymerisation (gel phase), and were of less importance for the glass phase.ConclusionsBoth materials enable at least 4 mm thick increments to be cured in one step under clinically relevant curing conditions.Clinical significanceThe susceptibility to variation in irradiance was material dependent, thus properties measured under clinically simulated curing conditions might vary to a different extent from those measured under ideal curing conditions.     

Predicting transmitted irradiance through CAD/CAM resin composite crowns in a simulated clinical model

ObjectiveTo predict the clinically relevant transmitted irradiance that is available for luting when a CAD/CAM restoration is inserted. The influence of irradiance, exposure distance, light curing unit (LCU) angulation and direction of polymerization is analyzed when curing through crowns of different thicknesses.MethodsThree modern CAD/CAM resin-based composites (RBCs) were used to produce 45 crown-shaped specimens. The distance between fissure and crown base was set at 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 mm (n = 5). Transmitted irradiance, while using a violet-blue LCU, was measured with a photo-spectrometer. 180 exposure conditions per specimen were investigated by variation in LCU curing mode, angulation, exposure distance and direction. Data was analyzed using univariate ANOVA followed by Tukey HSD (α = 0.05) and comparison of 95% confidence intervals.ResultsThe CAD/CAM-RBC’s decadic absorption coefficient ranges from 0.317 mm^?1 to 0.387 mm^?1 and the reflection correcting factor for crowns ranges from 0.305 to 0.337. Transmitted irradiance decreases significantly with increasing exposure distance and decreasing incident irradiance. For tilt angles greater than 10°, transmitted irradiances are significantly reduced (?11% for 20°, ?23% for 30°). Significantly lowest transmitted irradiances were measured for vestibular curing direction (up to ?15%).SignificanceA calculation model can predict the transmitted irradiance through a CAD/CAM restoration in dependence of restoration thickness and radiant emittance. The practitioner can be supported by this model to adapt material choice of dental restoration and adhesive system to the individual situation. Variation in exposure conditions shows negative effect on the transmission of light and should be limited.     

Improvement on properties of experimental resin cements containing an iodonium salt cured under challenging polymerization conditions

ObjectiveThe use of resin cements in clinical practice entails photopolymerization through prosthetic devices, which precludes light penetration. The objective of this study was to modify experimental resin cements (ERCs) with diphenyliodonium hexafluorophosphate (DPI) in an attempt to improve chemical and mechanical properties of materials cured with reduced irradiance and final radiant exposure.MethodsA co-monomer base containing a 1:1 mass ratio of 2.2-bis[4-(2-hydroxy-3-methacryloxypropoxy)phenyl]propane (bis-GMA) and triethyleneglycol dimethacrylate (TEGDMA) was prepared, with 1 mol% of camphorquinone and 2 mol% of ethyl 4-(dimethylamino)benzoate as initiator system. The resin was divided into 4 fractions according to the DPI concentrations (0, 0.5, 1 and 2 mol%). The challenging polymerization condition was simulated performing the light activation (12, 23 and 46 s) through a ceramic block (3 mm thick). The irradiance was assessed with a calibrated spectrometer (1320 mW/cm²), resulting in three levels of radiant exposure (0.58, 1.1 and 2.2 J/cm²). The polymerization kinetics was evaluated in real-time using a spectrometer (Near-IR). Water sorption and solubility was analyzed and the cohesive strength of resins obtained through the microtensile test. Polymerization stress was assessed by Bioman method.ResultsResins containing DPI had higher degree of conversion and rate of polymerization than the control (without DPI). The use of DPI reduced water sorption and solubility, and led to higher cohesive strength compared to resins without the iodonium salt. However, the stress of polymerization was higher for experimental resins with DPI.SignificanceEven under remarkably reduced irradiance, cements containing a ternary initiating system with an iodonium salt can present an optimal degree of conversion and chemical/mechanical properties.     

Reduced polymerization stress of MAPO-containing resin composites with increased curing speed,degree of conversion and mechanical properties

Objectives

The degree and rate of photopolymerization in resin-based dental composites will significantly affect polymer network formation and resultant material properties that may determine their clinical success. This study investigates the mechanical properties, the generation of stress from polymerization, tooth cusp deflection and marginal integrity of experimental resin composites that contain different photoinitiators.

Methods

Experimental light-activated resin composites (60 vol% particulate filled in 50/50 mass% bis-GMA/TEGDMA) were formulated using a monoacylphosphine oxide (MAPO) photoinitiator and compared with a conventional camphoroquinone (CQ)-based system. Similar radiant exposure was used (18 J cm⁻²) for polymerization of each material although the curing protocol was varied (400 mW cm⁻² for 45 s, 1500 mW cm⁻² for 12 s and 3000 mW cm⁻² for 6 s). Degree and rate of polymerization was calculated in real-time by near infrared spectroscopy and the generation of stress throughout polymerization measured using a cantilever beam method. Flexural strength and modulus were acquired by three-point bend tests. Standardized cavities in extract pre-molar teeth were restored with each material, the total cuspal deflection measured and post-placement marginal integrity between the tooth and restoration recorded.

Results

Generally, MAPO- exhibited a significantly higher degree of conversion (72 ± 0.8 to 82 ± 0.5%) compared with CQ-based materials (39 ± 0.7 to 65 ± 1.6%) regardless of curing protocol (p < 0.05) and MAPO-based materials exhibited less difference in conversion between curing protocols. CQ-based materials exhibited between ∼85 and 95% of the maximum rate of polymerization at <15% conversion, whereas MAPO-based RBCs did not approach the maximum rate until >50% conversion. Higher irradiance polymerization had a significant deleterious effect on the mechanical properties of CQ-based materials (p < 0.05) whereas MAPO-based materials exhibited increased strength and modulus and were less affected by the curing method. Total cuspal deflection in restored extracted teeth was higher for CQ- compared with MAPO-based materials cured at the lowest irradiance curing protocol (12.9 ± 4.0 and 8.3 ± 1.5 μm) and similar at 3000 mW cm⁻¹ for 6 s (10.1 ± 3.5 and 9.0 ± 1.5 μm). A significant decrease in marginal integrity was observed for CQ-based RBCs cured at high irradiance for short exposure time compared with that of the MAPO-based RBC cured using a similar protocol (p = 0.037).

Significance

Polymer network formation dictates the final properties of the set composite and the use MAPO photoinitiators may provide an effective restorative material that exhibits higher curing speeds, increased degree of conversion, strength and modulus without compromise in terms of polymerization stress and marginal integrity between tooth and restoration.     

Effects of halogen light irradiation variables (tip diameter, irradiance, irradiation protocol) on flexural strength properties of resin-based composites

OBJECTIVE: Investigation of halogen light irradiation variables (tip diameter, irradiance, irradiation protocol) on flexural strength and modulus of four methacrylate resin-based composites (RBCs). METHODS: Rectangular bar-shaped specimens (25 mm x 2 mm x 2 mm; n=20 per group) of four RBCs were irradiated at varying irradiances (640 and 790 mW/cm2; standard and boosted mode) with different tip diameters (8, 11, 13 and 25 mm) and for the 8mm Turbo light tip diameter at irradiances of 880 and 1040 mW/cm2 (standard and boosted mode). Following irradiation the specimens were stored in a light-proof container for 24h at 37+/-1 degrees C and tested in three-point flexure. One-way analyses of variance were made at P=0.05, guided as necessary by Tukey's correction in multiple partial analyses, in addition to a Weibull analysis. RESULTS: The mean three-point flexure strengths, Weibull moduli and flexure moduli of the four RBC materials, irradiated with varying irradiances, tip diameters and irradiation protocols highlighted no significant differences although the values were material specific. Similarly the 8mm conventional and Turbo tip diameter resulted in no significant differences for varying irradiances and irradiation protocols. CONCLUSION: Within the limitations of the experiment halogen tip diameter, irradiance and irradiation protocol have no influence on three-point flexural strength and modulus data. The efficacy of the overlapping irradiation regime was upheld for the conditions tested.     

Effect of CAD/CAM aesthetic material thickness and translucency on the polymerisation of light- and dual-cured resin cements

ObjectivesThis study investigated potential variations in polymerisation of light- and dual-cured (LC and DC) resin cements photoactivated through four CAD/CAM restorative materials as a function of substrate thickness.MethodsFour CAD/CAM materials [two resin composites CeraSmart (CS) and Grandio Blocs (GB); a polymer infiltrated ceramic Vita Enamic (VE) and a feldspathic ceramic Vita Mark II (VM)], with five thicknesses (0.5, 1, 1.5, 2, and 2.5 mm) were prepared and their optical characteristics measured. 1 mm discs of LC and DC resin cement (Variolink® Esthetic, Ivoclar AG) were photoactivated through each specimen thickness. After 1 h post-cure, polymerisation efficiency was determined by degree of conversion (DC%) and Martens hardness (H_M). Interactions between materials, thicknesses and properties were analysed by linear regressions, two-way ANOVA and one-way ANOVA followed by post hoc multiple comparisons (α = 0.05).ResultsAll substrates of 0.5- and 1.0-mm thickness transmitted sufficiently high peak irradiances at around 455 nm: (I_t = 588–819 mW/cm²) with translucency parameter TP = 21.14 – 10.7; ranked: CS> GB = VM> VE. However, increasing the substrate thickness (1.5–2.5 mm) reduced energy delivery to the luting cements (4 – 2.8 J/cm²). Consequently, as their thicknesses increased beyond 1.5 mm, H_M of the cement discs differed significantly between the substrates. But there were only slight reduction of DC% in LC cements and DC cement discs were not affected.Significance: Photoactivating light-cured Ivocerin? containing cement through feldspathic ceramics and polymer-infiltrated ceramics achieved greater early hardness results than dual-cured type, irrespective of substrate thickness (0.5 – 2.5 mm). However, only 0.5 and 1 mm-thick resin composites showed similar outcome (LC>DC). Therefore, for cases requiring early hardness development, appropriate cement selection for each substrate material is recommended.     

Total effective fluence: a useful concept in photodynamic therapy

Photodynamic therapy is generally carried out using a laser, usually a dye laser with the wavelength tuned to suit the particular sensitizer. The availability of broad-band sources for use in photodynamic therapy is challenging the role of the laser, since the non-laser sources are more portable and less expensive. Also, the wavelengths utilized may easily be changed by optical filtering. However, the use of a broad-band source introduces serious problems with dosimetry. The concept of the total effective fluence takes account of the incident spectral irradiance from the light source, optical transmission through tissue (preferably including backscatter), and absorption by the sensitizer. Application of the concept to various light sources demonstrates the potential value of this simple concept.