Islet Xenotransplantation: Are We Really Ready for Clinical Trials?

Four clinical trials of porcine islet transplantation have been reported, and there are verbal reports that clinical trials on much larger scales are continuing in centers in China and Russia. The four reported trials are briefly reviewed and, in the light of the present status of experimental islet xenotransplantation, consideration is given to whether such trials are currently justified. The Ethics Committee of the International Xenotransplantation Association has (1) emphasized the need for encouraging studies in non-human primates before clinical trials should be undertaken, (2) mandatory monitoring for the transfer of porcine microorganisms, and (3) careful regulation and oversight by recognized bodies. Other aspects of the topic, such as the need for informed consent, are briefly discussed. We conclude that, at the present time, more data documenting convincing efficacy, focused on clinically applicable immunosuppressive regimens, are needed to justify the initiation of closely monitored clinical trials. A clinical trial may then be justified even though the potential risk to the patients, and possibly for society, will not be zero.     

Xenogeneic bone marrow transplantation: II. Porcine-specific growth factors enhance porcine bone marrow engraftment in an in vitro primate microenvironment

Abstract: Establishment of mixed bone marrow chimerism in pig-to-primate transplantation, as a means of inducing specific immune tolerance, will require that both immune and nonimmune barriers be overcome. As a preliminary step in evaluating nonimmune barriers in this system, we have developed an in vitro model of engraftment in which long-term culture of porcine bone marrow-derived hematopoietic cells is supported on preformed primate bone marrow stromal layers. In the absence of cytokine supplementation, primate stromal cells were unable to support long-term porcine hematopoiesis in these cultures. Supplementation with porcine Steel Factor was required for long-term maintenance of hematopoietic progenitor cell content and total hematopoietic activity. Addition of porcine IL-3, in combination with porcine Steel Factor, increased long-term progenitor cell content and hematopoietic activity on primate stroma to levels comparable to that obtained in cultures on porcine stroma. The combination of porcine GM-CSF and Steel Factor increased progenitor cell content and hematopoietic activity early in the cultures, but had little effect in long-term cultures. The Steel Factor and IL-3 combination was species-specific in its action in these cultures, as the corresponding human cytokines were unable to effectively support long-term porcine hematopoiesis. Likewise, the combination of porcine cytokines had only minimal effects on long-term bone marrow culture of primate CD34+ cells I on primate stroma.     

Warfarin or Low-Molecular-Weight Heparin Therapy does not Prolong Pig-To-Primate Cardiac Xenograft Function

Microvascular thrombosis is a prominent feature in cardiac delayed xenograft rejection (DXR). We investigated the impact of warfarin or low-molecular-weight heparin (LMWH) anti-coagulation on xenograft function using a heterotopic pig-to-primate model. Donor hearts were from CD46 transgenic pigs and baboon immunosuppression included tacrolimus, sirolimus, anti-CD20 and TPC, an alpha-galactosyl-polyethylene glycol conjugate. Three groups of animals were studied. Group 1 (n = 9) was treated with warfarin, Group 2 (n = 13) with LMWH and Group 3, received no anti-coagulant drugs. The median duration of xenograft function was 20 days (range 3-62 days), 18 days (range 5-109 days) and 15 days (range 4-53 days) in Groups 1 to 3 respectively. Anti-coagulation achieved the targeted international normalized prothrombin ratio (INR) and anti-factor Xa levels consistent with effective in vivo therapy yet, no significant impact on median xenograft function was observed. At rejection, a similar histology of thrombosis and ischemia was apparent in each group and the levels of fibrin deposition and platelet thrombi in rejected tissue was the same. Anti-coagulation with warfarin or LMWH did not have a significant impact on the onset of DXR and microvascular thrombosis. However, a role for specific anti-coagulant strategies to achieve long-term xenograft function cannot be excluded.     

Xenograft rejection--all that glitters is not Gal.

Xenotransplantation is being developed in the hope of resolvingthe critical shortage of donor organs for transplantation. TheEurotransplant waiting lists [1] for donor organs of variouskinds number almost 16 000 patients and the US lists [2] morethan 90 000 patients. Renal transplantation, for instance, cost-effectivelyconfers a significant survival advantage [3] and improvementof quality of life [4]. But whereas currently, in Europe, nearly12 000 end-stage renal disease patients await a suitable donor,only 3383 kidney transplants were performed in 2005, with anaverage waiting time of 1174 days [1]. Substantial researchefforts are being made in the field of xenotransplantation,and the immunological barriers are gradually being elucidated.Pig-to-human xenogeneic     

Human CD4+CD25+ Regulatory T Cells Suppress Anti-Porcine Xenogeneic Responses

Due to the shortage of human organs, xenotransplantation is being explored as an alternative to allotransplantation, but immune rejection remains a major hurdle to its implementation. We tested the ability of human CD4+CD25+ T cells (Treg cells) to suppress CD4+ T cell-mediated anti-porcine xenoresponses usingin vitroassays. Human Treg cells were hyporesponsive to porcine cell stimulation and suppressed the proliferative response of CD4+CD25- T cells in a dose-dependent manner, and comparison of the allo- and xenoresponses indicated that more Treg cells might be required to suppress the xenogeneic response than the allogeneic response. Stimulation of CD4+CD25- T cells with porcine cells resulted in secretion of IFN-gamma, TNF-alpha, IL-10, IL-6 and IL-2, and Treg cells suppressed the secretion of these cytokines, as well as the CD4+CD25- T-cell cytolytic response against porcine cells. These results suggest a potential role for Treg cells in promoting xenograft survival.     

Sensitisation to Swine Leukocyte Antigens in Patients with Broadly Reactive HLA Specific Antibodies

We have previously shown that IgG HLA specific antibodies in the sera of highly sensitised patients awaiting renal transplantation can cross-react with swine leukocyte antigens (SLA). In this study we determined the frequency of patient serum IgG HLA specific antibody binding to a porcine lymphocyte panel and the likelihood of locating a cross-match negative pig donor for sensitised patients. Serum samples (n = 82) were obtained from 35 sensitised [current IgG panel reactive antibodies (PRA) > 10%] and seven nonsensitised patients awaiting renal transplantation at Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge, UK. Fifty sera had IgG HLA specific PRA of 11-84%, 20 had IgG PRA of >84% and 12 had 0% PRA (negative controls). Sera were absorbed with porcine erythrocytes to remove xenoreactive natural antibodies and tested for cross-reactive IgG HLA specific antibody binding by flow cytometry against a panel of porcine lymphocytes obtained from 23 human decay accelerating factor (hDAF) transgenic pigs. A total of 1,884 cross-match combinations were tested and 369 (20%) gave a positive porcine lymphocyte cross-match. For sera from sensitised patients with IgG PRA (11-64%), only 6 of 805 (0.75%) cross-match tests were positive. In contrast, for sera from patients with high IgG PRA (>64%), 363 of 805 (45%) cross-match tests were positive (p < 0.0001). There was no difference in the frequency of positive cross-matches between patient sera with IgG PRA 65-84% and highly sensitised patient sera with IgG PRA 85-100% [156/345 (45%) vs. 207/460 (45%)]. This study demonstrates that only patient sera with broadly reactive IgG HLA specific PRA (>64%) cross-react with porcine lymphocytes. If future clinical trials of xenotransplantation are undertaken, it may be of value to select a cross-match-negative pig organ donor for such patients.     

Protective genes expressed in endothelial cells of second hamster heart transplants to rats carrying an accommodated first graft

Abstract: Accommodation refers to survival of a xenograft despite the presence of anti-donor organ antibodies and complement. We have recently shown that accommodation of a hamster heart transplanted to a rat receiving short-term cobra venom factor (CVF) and continuing cyclosporine A (CyA) therapy is associated with i) the expression in the endothelial cells (EC) and smooth muscle cells of the graft of a number of "protective" genes, ii) a prominent intragraft Th2 cytokine profile, and iii) the relatively heavy deposition of IgG2c antibodies on the EC of the graft. In contrast, rejecting grafts do not express the protective genes, have a Th1 cytokine profile, and apparently have lesser amounts of IgG2c. These findings are consistent with host factors (Th2 cytokines and IgG2c) contributing to xenograft accommodation. To test whether these host factors may predispose to the development of accommodation, we placed a second hamster heart into each of 12 rats carrying a surviving first heart; recipients were, at the time, receiving only CyA. Whereas first grafts transplanted to rats receiving only CyA survive for 3 to 4 days, 11 out of 12 second transplants survived more than 20 days, and the other survived for 7 days. Nine of the twelve were not rejected: of these, four were removed between day 35 and 132 for study, and the remainder are still beating at 35 to 52 days. The surviving second hearts we studied had accommodated in that the picture on immunopathology was the same as for surviving first hearts. We suggest that the Th2 cytokines and perhaps the IgG2c response are factors in allowing prolonged survival of the second grafts and, further, that these factors contribute to the expression in the EC and smooth muscle cells of the surviving second hearts of the protective genes.     

Characteristics of human neural stem cells In Vitro and after transplantation into rat brain

We studied the effect of culturing conditions on the fate of human neural stem cells after transplantation into rat brain. Human neural stem cells cultured in the presence of mitogens without LIF migrated along the ependyma and cerebral vessels of recipients, but to a great extent degenerated by the 20th day after transplantation. Neural stem cells cultured with LIF migrated, apart from the above mentioned pathways, in the cortex and hippocampus, well survived; proliferating cells were retained 30 days after transplantation.__________This revised version was published online in July 2005 with the addition of the issue title and article categoryTranslated from Kletochnye Tekhnologii v Biologii i Meditsine, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 13–19, January, 2005