Simple fold composition and modular architecture of the nuclear pore complex

The nuclear pore complex (NPC) consists of multiple copies of approximately 30 different proteins [nucleoporins (nups)], forming a channel in the nuclear envelope that mediates macromolecular transport between the cytosol and the nucleus. With <5% of the nup residues currently available in experimentally determined structures, little is known about the detailed structure of the NPC. Here, we use a combined computational and biochemical approach to assign folds for approximately 95% of the residues in the yeast and vertebrate nups. These fold assignments suggest an underlying simplicity in the composition and modularity in the architecture of all eukaryotic NPCs. The simplicity in NPC composition is reflected in the presence of only eight fold types, with the three most frequent folds accounting for approximately 85% of the residues. The modularity in NPC architecture is reflected in its hierarchical and symmetrical organization that partitions the predicted nup folds into three groups: the transmembrane group containing transmembrane helices and a cadherin fold, the central scaffold group containing beta-propeller and alpha-solenoid folds, and the peripheral FG group containing predominantly the FG repeats and the coiled-coil fold. Moreover, similarities between structures in coated vesicles and those in the NPC support our prior hypothesis for their common evolutionary origin in a progenitor protocoatomer. The small number of predicted fold types in the NPC and their internal symmetries suggest that the bulk of the NPC structure has evolved through extensive motif and gene duplication from a simple precursor set of only a few proteins.     

Escape from Adaptive Conflict follows from weak functional trade-offs and mutational robustness

A fundamental question in molecular evolution is how proteins can adapt to new functions while being conserved for an existing function at the same time. Several theoretical models have been put forward to explain this apparent paradox. The most popular models include neofunctionalization, subfunctionalization (SUBF) by degenerative mutations, and dosage models. All of these models focus on adaptation after gene duplication. A newly proposed model named "Escape from Adaptive Conflict" (EAC) includes adaptive processes before and after gene duplication that lead to multifunctional proteins, and divergence (SUBF). Support for the importance of multifunctionality for the evolution of new protein functions comes from two experimental observations. First, many enzymes have highly evolvable promiscuous side activities. Second, different structural states of the same protein can be associated with different functions. How these observations may be related to the EAC model, under which conditions EAC is possible, and how the different models relate to each other is still unclear. Here, we present a theoretical framework that uses biophysical principles to infer the roles of functional promiscuity, gene dosage, gene duplication, point mutations, and selection pressures in the evolution of proteins. We find that selection pressures can determine whether neofunctionalization or SUBF is the more likely evolutionary process. Multifunctional proteins, arising during EAC evolution, allow rapid adaptation independent of gene duplication. This becomes a crucial advantage when gene duplications are rare. Finally, we propose that an increase in mutational robustness, not necessarily functional optimization, can be the sole driving force behind SUBF.     

Computational design of a self-assembling symmetrical β-propeller protein

The modular structure of many protein families, such as β-propeller proteins, strongly implies that duplication played an important role in their evolution, leading to highly symmetrical intermediate forms. Previous attempts to create perfectly symmetrical propeller proteins have failed, however. We have therefore developed a new and rapid computational approach to design such proteins. As a test case, we have created a sixfold symmetrical β-propeller protein and experimentally validated the structure using X-ray crystallography. Each blade consists of 42 residues. Proteins carrying 2–10 identical blades were also expressed and purified. Two or three tandem blades assemble to recreate the highly stable sixfold symmetrical architecture, consistent with the duplication and fusion theory. The other proteins produce different monodisperse complexes, up to 42 blades (180 kDa) in size, which self-assemble according to simple symmetry rules. Our procedure is suitable for creating nano-building blocks from different protein templates of desired symmetry.It is generally accepted that evolution is driven by duplications of genetic material. These events allow gene copies to develop independent regulation (1) and to express new proteins that inherit the stable architecture of the parent protein but possess a novel function (2, 3). Although this process largely explains the diversity of proteins with similar folds, it cannot account for the appearance of new protein folds. However, many proteins have a modular internal structure that most probably arose from duplication and fusion of structural elements. This type of process is most clearly demonstrated by proteins consisting of conserved domains repeated in tandem, giving a highly symmetrical tertiary structure (4, 5). Although symmetry remains a common feature of proteins (6), many present-day proteins show more limited symmetry than that of the ancestral intermediate forms suggested by the duplication theory of evolution (7–9). Since the group of Wilmanns demonstrated that a (β/α)₈−barrel protein could be constructed out of two identical halves in 2000 (10), several other groups have also reported the artificial construction of symmetrical or modular proteins, providing evidence for duplication and fusion events in nature (11–15). In the case of β-trefoil proteins, a design procedure based on Rosetta proved much more efficient than directed evolution methods at producing a symmetrical structure (15). Structural plasticity and domain swapping (16, 17) allow such extended proteins to adopt novel tertiary and quaternary structures (18), but to date there is no report of a perfectly symmetrical β-propeller protein.β-propeller proteins are composed of different numbers of repeats, each made from a single β-sheet, roughly 40 residues in length, that resembles the blade of a propeller (19, 20). β-propeller proteins are good examples of how proteins may have evolved from duplication and fusion events of simple peptide motifs (21). Examples are known of 4-, 5-, 6-, 7-, 8-, and 10-bladed proteins. These proteins have diverse functions, including varied enzymatic activities and protein–protein interactions, making them a highly interesting class to redesign both for synthetic biochemistry and as nano-building blocks. Previous attempts to create stable perfectly symmetrical β-propeller proteins have failed. Yadid and Tawfik (3, 22) screened genetic libraries encoding about 100 amino acid residues from a 236-residue five-bladed propeller (tachylectin-2) in attempts to create a fivefold symmetrical propeller. The initial proteins produced were poorly stable, but subsequent directed evolution to improve expression and folding led to domain-swapped structures through strand exchange (18). An artificial WD40-based repeat protein was designed by Nikkhah et al. using computational methods, but this protein failed to fold and adopted a molten globule state (23). Similarly, Figueroa et al. have recently described a putative artificial TIM barrel structure called “octarellin VI,” but this protein proved to be poorly soluble, and NMR indicated that it is not stably folded (24). It is widely believed that proteins with a perfectly repeated sequence motif experience “folding frustration,” the absence of a single strongly preferred tertiary structure, leading to unstable folds (11, 25). In fact, a search for identical sequence repeats within the same polypeptide chain failed to find any duplicated domains containing regular secondary structure in known natural proteins (26).We have applied a novel computational approach to the problem of creating a stable, perfectly symmetrical propeller by reverse engineering the supposed evolutionary pathway. Specifically, we wanted to address the question whether we can construct from a nonsymmetrical protein a symmetrical one that could have originated from smaller protein fragments. Ancestral sequence reconstruction was used to derive likely parent sequences assuming evolution through duplication, and then these sequences were computationally evaluated for protein stability (Fig. S1). We chose a six-bladed protein, given its additional two- and threefold pseudosymmetry. To agree with the duplication and fusion theory, such a protein should be divisible into a self-assembling unit consisting of 2 or 3 domains. Additionally, we created polypeptides carrying up to 10 identical blades and showed that these molecules also fold to give stable structures.     

An unusual signal peptide facilitates late steps in the biogenesis of a bacterial autotransporter

Bacterial autotransporters are proteins that use a C-terminal porin-like domain to facilitate the transport of an upstream "passenger domain" across the outer membrane. Although autotransporters are translocated across the inner membrane (IM) via the Sec pathway, some of them contain exceptionally long signal peptides distinguished by a unique N-terminal sequence motif. In this study, we used the Escherichia coli O157:H7 autotransporter EspP as a model protein to investigate the function of the unusual signal peptides. We found that removal of the N-terminal motif or replacement of the EspP signal peptide did not affect translocation of the protein across the IM. Remarkably, modification of the signal peptide caused EspP to misfold in the periplasm and blocked transport of the passenger domain across the outer membrane. Further analysis suggested that the EspP signal peptide transits slowly through the Sec machinery. Based on these results, we propose that the unusual signal peptides not only function as targeting signals, but also prevent misfolding of the passenger domain in the periplasm by transiently tethering it to the IM.     

Crystal and NMR structures of a Trp-cage mini-protein benchmark for computational fold prediction

To provide high-resolution X-ray crystallographic structures of a peptide with the Trp-cage fold, we prepared a cyclized version of this motif. Cyclized Trp-cage is remarkably stable and afforded two crystal forms suitable for X-ray diffraction. The resulting higher resolution crystal structures validate the prior NMR models and provide explanations for experimental observations that could not be rationalized by NMR structural data, including the structural basis for the increase in fold stability associated with motif cyclization and the manner in which a polar serine side chain is accommodated in the hydrophobic interior. A hexameric oligomer of the cyclic peptide is found in both crystal forms and indicates that under appropriate conditions, this minimized system may also serve as a model for protein-protein interactions.     

Genome-scale comparative analysis of gene fusions,gene fissions,and the fungal tree of life

During the course of evolution genes undergo both fusion and fission by which ORFs are joined or separated. These processes can amend gene function and represent an important factor in the evolution of protein interaction networks. Gene fusions have been suggested to be useful characters for identifying evolutionary relationships because they constitute synapomorphies or cladistic characters. To investigate the fidelity of gene-fusion characters, we developed an approach for identifying differentially distributed gene fusions among whole-genome datasets: fdfBLAST. Applying this tool to the Fungi, we identified 63 gene fusions present in two or more genomes. Using a combination of phylogenetic and comparative genomic analyses, we then investigated the evolution of these genes across 115 fungal genomes, testing each gene fusion for evidence of homoplasy, including gene fission, convergence, and horizontal gene transfer. These analyses demonstrated 110 gene-fission events. We then identified a minimum of three mechanisms that drive gene fission: separation, degeneration, and duplication. These data suggest that gene fission plays an important and hitherto underestimated role in gene evolution. Gene fusions therefore are highly labile characters, and their use for polarizing evolutionary relationships, without reference to gene and species phylogenies, is limited. Accounting for these considerable sources of homoplasy, we identified fusion characters that provide support for multiple nodes in the phylogeny of the Fungi, including relationships within the deeply derived flagellum-forming fungi (i.e., the chytrids).     

Phages have adapted the same protein fold to fulfill multiple functions in virion assembly

Evolutionary relationships may exist among very diverse groups of proteins even though they perform different functions and display little sequence similarity. The tailed bacteriophages present a uniquely amenable system for identifying such groups because of their huge diversity yet conserved genome structures. In this work, we used structural, functional, and genomic context comparisons to conclude that the head–tail connector protein and tail tube protein of bacteriophage λ diverged from a common ancestral protein. Further comparisons of tertiary and quaternary structures indicate that the baseplate hub and tail terminator proteins of bacteriophage may also be part of this same family. We propose that all of these proteins evolved from a single ancestral tail tube protein fold, and that gene duplication followed by differentiation led to the specialized roles of these proteins seen in bacteriophages today. Although this type of evolutionary mechanism has been proposed for other systems, our work provides an evolutionary mechanism for a group of proteins with different functions that bear no sequence similarity. Our data also indicate that the addition of a structural element at the N terminus of the λ head–tail connector protein endows it with a distinctive protein interaction capability compared with many of its putative homologues.     

Gene cooption without duplication during the evolution of a male-pregnancy gene in pipefish

Comparative studies of developmental processes suggest that novel traits usually evolve through the cooption of preexisting genes and proteins, mainly via gene duplication and functional specialization of paralogs. However, an alternative hypothesis is that novel protein function can evolve without gene duplication, through changes in the spatiotemporal patterns of gene expression (e.g., via cis-regulatory elements), or functional modifications (e.g., addition of functional domains) of the proteins they encode, or both. Here we present an astacin metalloprotease, dubbed patristacin, which has been coopted without duplication, via alteration in the expression of a preexisting gene from the kidney and liver of bony fishes, for a novel role in the brood pouch of pregnant male pipefish. We examined the molecular evolution of patristacin and found conservation of astacin-specific motifs but also several positively selected amino acids that may represent functional modifications for male pregnancy. Overall, our results pinpoint a clear case in which gene cooption occurred without gene duplication during the genesis of an evolutionarily significant novel structure, the male brood pouch. These findings contribute to a growing understanding of morphological innovation, a critically important but poorly understood process in evolutionary biology.     

Unique scorpion toxin with a putative ancestral fold provides insight into evolution of the inhibitor cystine knot motif

The three-disulfide inhibitor cystine knot (ICK) motif is a fold common to venom peptides from spiders, scorpions, and aquatic cone snails. Over a decade ago it was proposed that the ICK motif is an elaboration of an ancestral two-disulfide fold coined the disulfide-directed β-hairpin (DDH). Here we report the isolation, characterization, and structure of a novel toxin [U(1)-liotoxin-Lw1a (U(1)-LITX-Lw1a)] from the venom of the scorpion Liocheles waigiensis that is the first example of a native peptide that adopts the DDH fold. U(1)-LITX-Lw1a not only represents the discovery of a missing link in venom protein evolution, it is the first member of a fourth structural fold to be adopted by scorpion-venom peptides. Additionally, we show that U(1)-LITX-Lw1a has potent insecticidal activity across a broad range of insect pest species, thereby providing a unique structural scaffold for bioinsecticide development.     

Structural diversity in twin-arginine signal peptide-binding proteins

The twin-arginine transport (Tat) system is dedicated to the translocation of folded proteins across the bacterial cytoplasmic membrane. Proteins are targeted to the Tat system by signal peptides containing a twin-arginine motif. In Escherichia coli, many Tat substrates bind redox-active cofactors in the cytoplasm before transport. Coordination of cofactor insertion with protein export involves a "Tat proofreading" process in which chaperones bind twin-arginine signal peptides, thus preventing premature export. The initial Tat signal-binding proteins described belonged to the TorD family, which are required for assembly of N- and S-oxide reductases. Here, we report that E. coli NapD is a Tat signal peptide-binding chaperone involved in biosynthesis of the Tat-dependent nitrate reductase NapA. NapD binds tightly and specifically to the NapA twin-arginine signal peptide and suppresses signal peptide translocation activity such that transport via the Tat pathway is retarded. High-resolution, heteronuclear, multidimensional NMR spectroscopy reveals the 3D solution structure of NapD. The chaperone adopts a ferredoxin-type fold, which is completely distinct from the TorD family. Thus, NapD represents a new family of twin-arginine signal-peptide-binding proteins.     

Crystal structure of LpxC,a zinc-dependent deacetylase essential for endotoxin biosynthesis

The outer leaflet of the outer membrane of the Gram-negative bacterium serves as a permeability barrier and is composed of lipopolysaccharide, also known as endotoxin. The membrane anchor of lipopolysaccharide is lipid A, the biosynthesis of which is essential for cell viability. The first committed step in lipid A biosynthesis is catalyzed by UDP-(3-O-(R-3-hydroxymyristoyl))-N-acetylglucosamine deacetylase (LpxC), a zinc-dependent deacetylase. Here we report the crystal structure of LpxC from Aquifex aeolicus, which reveals a new alpha+beta fold reflecting primordial gene duplication and fusion, as well as a new zinc-binding motif. The catalytic zinc ion resides at the base of an active-site cleft and adjacent to a hydrophobic tunnel occupied by a fatty acid. This tunnel accounts for the specificity of LpxC toward substrates and inhibitors bearing appropriately positioned 3-O-fatty acid substituents. Notably, simple inhibitors designed to target interactions in the hydrophobic tunnel bind with micromolar affinity, thereby representing a step toward the structure-based design of a potent, broad-spectrum antibacterial drug.     

Genetic polymorphism of Plasmodium vivax msp1p, a paralog of merozoite surface protein 1, from worldwide isolates

Plasmodium vivax msp1p, a paralog of the candidate vaccine antigen P. vivax merozoite surface protein 1, possesses a signal peptide at its N-terminus and two epidermal growth factor-like domains at its C-terminus with a glycosylphosphatidylinositol attachment site. The msp1p gene locus may have originated by a duplication of the msp1 gene locus in a common ancestor of the analyzed Plasmodium species and lost from P. yoelii, P. berghei, and P. falciparum during their evolutionary history. Full-length sequences of the msp1p gene were generally highly conserved; they had a few amino acid substitutions, one highly polymorphic E/Q-rich region, and a single-to-triple hepta-peptide repeat motif. Twenty-one distinguishable allelic types (A1-A21) of the E/Q-rich region were identified from worldwide isolates. Among them, four types were detected in isolates from South Korea. The length polymorphism of the E/Q-rich region might be useful as a genetic marker for population structure studies in malaria-endemic areas.     

Identification and preliminary characterization of a protein motif related to the zinc finger.

We have identified a protein motif, related to the zinc finger, which defines a newly discovered family of proteins. The motif was found in the sequence of the human RING1 gene, which is proximal to the major histocompatibility complex region on chromosome six. We propose naming this motif the "RING finger" and it is found in 27 proteins, all of which have putative DNA binding functions. We have synthesized a peptide corresponding to the RING1 motif and examined a number of properties, including metal and DNA binding. We provide evidence to support the suggestion that the RING finger motif is the DNA binding domain of this newly defined family of proteins.     

Evolution of an antifreeze protein by neofunctionalization under escape from adaptive conflict

The evolutionary model escape from adaptive conflict (EAC) posits that adaptive conflict between the old and an emerging new function within a single gene could drive the fixation of gene duplication, where each duplicate can freely optimize one of the functions. Although EAC has been suggested as a common process in functional evolution, definitive cases of neofunctionalization under EAC are lacking, and the molecular mechanisms leading to functional innovation are not well-understood. We report here clear experimental evidence for EAC-driven evolution of type III antifreeze protein gene from an old sialic acid synthase (SAS) gene in an Antarctic zoarcid fish. We found that an SAS gene, having both sialic acid synthase and rudimentary ice-binding activities, became duplicated. In one duplicate, the N-terminal SAS domain was deleted and replaced with a nascent signal peptide, removing pleiotropic structural conflict between SAS and ice-binding functions and allowing rapid optimization of the C-terminal domain to become a secreted protein capable of noncolligative freezing-point depression. This study reveals how minor functionalities in an old gene can be transformed into a distinct survival protein and provides insights into how gene duplicates facing presumed identical selection and mutation pressures at birth could take divergent evolutionary paths.     

Topography of the histone octamer surface: repeating structural motifs utilized in the docking of nucleosomal DNA.

The histone octamer core of the nucleosome is a protein superhelix of four spirally arrayed histone dimers. The cylindrical face of this superhelix is marked by intradimer and interdimer pseudodyad axes, which derive from the nature of the histone fold. The histone fold appears as the result of a tandem, parallel duplication of the "helix-strand-helix" motif. This motif, by its occurrence in the four dimers, gives rise to repetitive structural elements--i.e., the "parallel beta bridges" and the "paired ends of helix I" motifs. A preponderance of positive charges on the surface of the octamer appears as a left-handed spiral situated at the expected path of the DNA. We have matched a subset of DNA pseudodyads with the octamer pseudodyads and thus have built a model of the nucleosome. In it, the two DNA strands coincide with the path of the histone-positive charges, and the central 12 turns of the double helix contact the surface of the octamer at the repetitive structural motifs. The properties of these complementary contacts appear to explain the preference of histones for double-helical DNA and to suggest a possible basis for allosteric regulation of nucleosome function.     

Design of a directed molecular network

An ability to rationally design complex networks from the bottom up can offer valuable quantitative model systems for use in gaining a deeper appreciation for the principles governing the self-organization and functional characteristics of complex systems. We report herein the de novo design, graph prediction, experimental analysis, and characterization of simple self-organized, nonlinear molecular networks. Our approach makes use of the sequence-dependent auto- and cross-catalytic functional characteristics of template-directed peptide fragment condensation reactions in neutral aqueous solutions. Starting with an array of 81 sequence similar 32-residue coiled-coil peptides, we estimated the relative stability difference between all plausible A(2)B-type coiled-coil ensembles and used this information to predict the auto- and cross-catalysis pathways and the resulting plausible network motif and connectivities. Similar to most complex systems, the generated graph displays clustered nodes with an overall hierarchical architecture. To test the validity of the design principles used, nine nodes composing a main segment of the graph were experimentally analyzed for their capacity in establishing the predicted network connectivity. The resulting self-organized chemical network is shown to display 25 directed edges in good agreement with the graph analysis estimations. Moreover, we show that by varying the system parameters (presence or absence of certain substrates or templates), its operating network motif can be altered, even to the extremes of turning pathways on or off. We suggest that this approach can be expanded for the construction of large-scale networks, offering a means to study and to understand better the emergent, collective behaviors of networks.     

Mimicking enzyme evolution by generating new (betaalpha)8-barrels from (betaalpha)4-half-barrels

Gene duplication and fusion events that multiply and link functional protein domains are crucial mechanisms of enzyme evolution. The analysis of amino acid sequences and three-dimensional structures suggested that the (betaalpha)8-barrel, which is the most frequent fold among enzymes, has evolved by the duplication, fusion, and mixing of (betaalpha)4-half-barrel domains. Here, we mimicked this evolutionary strategy by generating in vitro (betaalpha)8-barrels from (betaalpha)4-half-barrels that were deduced from the enzymes imidazole glycerol phosphate synthase (HisF) and N'[(5'-phosphoribosyl)formimino]-5-aminoimidazole-4-carboxamide-ribonucleotide isomerase (HisA). To this end, the gene for the C-terminal (betaalpha)4-half-barrel (HisF-C) of HisF was duplicated and fused in tandem to yield HisF-CC, which is more stable than HisF-C. In the next step, by optimizing side-chain interactions within the center of the beta-barrel of HisF-CC, the monomeric and compact (betaalpha)8-barrel protein HisF-C*C was generated. Moreover, the genes for the N- and C-terminal (betaalpha)4-half-barrels of HisF and HisA were fused crosswise to yield the chimeric proteins HisFA and HisAF. Whereas HisFA contains native secondary structure elements but adopts ill-defined association states, the (betaalpha)8-barrel HisAF is a stable and compact monomer that reversibly unfolds with high cooperativity. The results obtained suggest a previously undescribed dimension for the diversification of enzymatic activities: new (betaalpha)8-barrels with novel functions might have evolved by the exchange of (betaalpha)4-half-barrel domains with distinct functional properties.