Anterior capsule opacification: correlation of pathologic findings with clinical sequelae

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the degree of anterior capsule opacification (ACO) in human eyes obtained postmortem containing various rigid and foldable posterior chamber intraocular lens (PC-IOL) designs and compare the findings with clinical sequelae of capsular shrinkage. DESIGN: Comparative autopsy tissue study with clinicopathologic correlations. MATERIALS: Three hundred formalin-fixed human eyes containing the following PC-IOL styles were analyzed: (1) one-piece polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) optic-PMMA haptic (n = 50), one-piece silicone-plate IOL, with large (2) or small (3) fixation holes (n = 35), (4) three-piece PMMA optic-Prolene haptic (n = 50), (5) three-piece acrylic optic-PMMA haptic (n = 55), three-piece silicone optic with PMMA (6) or polyimide (7) haptics (n = 30), and (8) three-piece silicone optic-Prolene haptic (n = 80) lenses. TESTING: The eyes were sectioned in the equatorial plane for gross examination of the capsular bag from a posterior view. The cornea and iris were then excised for evaluation from an anterior view. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: ACO was scored in each eye from 0 to IV, according to the degree/area of capsule opacification. Capsulorrhexis size and IOL decentration were measured with calipers. RESULTS: The overall differences among the IOL groups regarding the three parameters were significant (ACO score: P < 0.001; capsulorrhexis diameter: P = 0.036; IOL decentration: P = 0.012). Mean ACO scores were highest with the large- and small-hole one-piece silicone-plate lenses (2.543 +/- 0.950) and lowest with the three-piece acrylic optic-PMMA haptic lenses (0.600 +/- 0.710). Of 10 cases of capsulorrhexis phimosis observed in the study, 7 cases were associated with three-piece silicone optic-Prolene haptic lenses, which also presented the highest mean decentration (0.375 +/- 0.601 mm). CONCLUSIONS: Our results confirm previous histopathologic observations that the rate of ACO is the lowest with acrylic lenses and higher with plate-haptic silicone IOLs. Nevertheless, clinical sequelae of capsular shrinkage are also very important with three-piece silicone optic-Prolene haptic designs. Thus, IOL material and design are significant factors in the development of ACO, but they ultimately also influence the clinical presentation of capsular shrinkage.     

Anterior capsule opacification: a histopathological study comparing different IOL styles

OBJECTIVE: To compare the degree of anterior capsule opacification (ACO) in human eyes obtained post-mortem containing various rigid and foldable posterior chamber intraocular lens (PC-IOL) designs. DESIGN: Comparative autopsy tissue study with clinicopathologic correlations. MATERIALS: Four hundred sixty human globes containing the following PC-IOL styles were analyzed: (1) one-piece polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) optic-PMMA haptic (n = 50), (2) one-piece silicone-plate IOL, large hole (n = 40), (3) one-piece silicone-plate IOL, small hole (n = 67), (4) three-piece PMMA optic-PMMA/Prolene haptic (n = 51), (5) three-piece acrylic optic-PMMA haptic (n = 96), (6) three-piece silicone optic-PMMA haptic (n = 24), (7) three-piece silicone optic-polyimide haptic (n = 40), and (8) three-piece silicone optic-prolene haptic (n = 92). TESTING: The globes were sectioned in the equatorial plane for gross examination and then processed through paraffin; sectioned, and stained with hematoxylin-eosin, periodic acid-Schiff, and Masson's trichrome stains; and examined by light microscopy. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Anterior capsule opacification was scored in each eye by grading the histologic sections from 0 to III, according to the amount (thickness) of proliferative tissue and cells measured in sagittal sections on the inner surface of the anterior capsule at the capsulorhexis margin. RESULTS: The difference among the eight groups was significant (P < 0.0001). Mean ACO scores were highest with the large and small hole one-piece silicone-plate lenses (1.77 +/- 0.86 and 1.28 +/- 0.77, respectively). The lowest mean score was observed in the group of three-piece acrylic optic-PMMA haptics lenses (0.51 +/- 0.52). CONCLUSIONS: Our results confirm previous clinical observations that the rate of ACO is relatively high with plate-haptic silicone IOLs. The lowest rate was noted with the three-piece acrylic optic-PMMA haptic IOL. The IOL design and IOL material are significant factors in the development of ACO.     

Piggyback silicone intraocular lenses of opposite power

A patient with high myopia and astigmatism had cataract extraction with implantation of 2 silicone intraocular lenses (IOLs) of opposite power (ie, 1 plus and 1 minus). A Staar AA4203TL toric IOL (+9.50 diopters [D]/3.50 D) and a Staar AQ5010V additive lens (-3.00 D) were used to correct both the astigmatism and the high myopia. The use of the 2 lenses was necessary because the toric IOL was not available in low dioptric powers. A crystalline interpseudophakos deposit developed after 1 week and resolved after 4 weeks. Three months postoperatively, the patient had an uncorrected visual acuity of 20/25.     

A retrospective analysis of five intra-ocular lenses and the predictive value of six different intra-ocular lens power calculation formulas

PURPOSE: To evaluate the refractive and visual outcome after implantation of five different lenses and to evaluate the accuracy of six different intra-ocular lens (IOL) power formulas. SETTING: Department of Ophthalmology, University Medical Centre Rotterdam, The Netherlands. METHODS: In total, 288 eyes had cataract surgery with implantation of a polymethylmethacrylate lens (Centra55B) or a foldable silicone lens (AMO SI40, Staar AA, Silens 5, Pliolens). The pre- and postoperative refraction and visual outcome were analysed for all lenses under study. Six different IOL power formulas have been used to compare the accuracy of the predictive refractive outcome. RESULTS: The Staar Plate Haptic lens was found to have the best uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) compared to the Centra55B, AMO SI40 and the Pliolens. Based on the A constant given by the company, the Pliolens revealed a significant overcorrection and the Staar Plate Haptic lens an undercorrection. The achieved postoperative refraction minus the intended postoperative refraction caused significant myopia with the Pliolens and hyperopia with the Staar Plate Haptic lens. The SRK-T and the Holladay formulas give the best predictive lens calculations in relation to the axial length. CONCLUSION: The A constant of all lenses has to be adjusted for our institute. Especially the AMO SI40, the Staar AA lens and the Silens 5 showed a remarkable difference compared to the A constant given by the company. All foldable lenses were comparable in their visual outcome. The significantly better UCVA of the Staar Plate Haptic lens can be explained by the emmetropic outcome of the postoperative refraction.     

Posterior capsular opacification and intraocular lens decentration. Part I: Comparison of various posterior chamber lens designs implanted in the rabbit model

Experimental phacoemulsification procedures were performed in 54 Rex rabbits. In 96 eyes, posterior chamber intraocular lenses (IOLs) were implanted in the capsular sac, and 12 eyes served as controls with no lens implantation. The IOLs were divided into eight groups consisting of both one-piece and three-piece styles with various optic designs. Each lens was evaluated for the relative effect on posterior capsular opacification (PCO) and optic decentration, two of the most common complications of modern cataract surgery and IOL implantation. Optics with a convex-anterior, plano-posterior design (the type of IOL optic most frequently implanted today) had the highest incidence of PCO. With capsular fixated IOLs, the features that have a statistically significant impact on reducing PCO include (1) one-piece, all-polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) IOL styles, (2) a biconvex or posterior convex optic design, and (3) angulated loops. Lens decentration was not affected by the optic design, but statistical analysis showed that one-piece, all-PMMA IOL construction provided the most consistent centration.     

Posterior capsular opacification and intraocular lens decentration. Part II: Experimental findings on a prototype circular intraocular lens design

In a prospective randomized study, 25 New Zealand white rabbit eyes were implanted with four intraocular lens (IOL) designs. These included a one-piece modified J-loop IOL, a three-piece modified J-loop IOL, a rigid disc IOL, and an experimental compressible disc (CD) IOL. The CD IOL revealed the lowest mean posterior capsular opacification (PCO) of all IOLs tested (P less than .01). With all lenses tested, a positive correlation between PCO and decentration was found (R = 0.55, P less than .05). These results suggest that because of its design features (i.e., one-piece construction, biconvex optic, posterior angulation of the fixation element), the CD lens produces a mechanical barrier against lens epithelial cell migration and reduces the incidence of PCO.     

Effect of optic material and haptic design on anterior capsule opacification and capsulorrhexis contraction

PURPOSE: To examine the influence of optic material (silicone and hydrophobic acrylic) and haptic design (one-piece and three-piece open loop) of sharp optic edge intraocular lenses (IOL) on anterior capsule opacification (ACO) and capsulorrhexis contraction. DESIGN: Randomized, controlled, double-blind clinical trial with intraindividual comparison. METHODS: This study was performed at the Department of Ophthalmology, Medical University of Vienna, Austria, and comprised 210 eyes of 105 patients with bilateral age-related cataract. In group 1 (n = 53 patients), a three-piece acrylic IOL was compared with a three-piece silicone IOL. In group 2 (n = 52 patients), the three-piece acrylic IOL was compared with the one-piece acrylic IOL. One year after the operation, standardized digital slit-lamp images of ACO were taken; 1 week and 1 year after the operation, digital retroillumination images were taken to assess capsulorrhexis size. The intensity of ACO was graded objectively (score, 0% to 100%), and the capsulorrhexis area (square millimeters) was determined objectively. RESULTS: One year after surgery, the mean ACO score was 21% for the acrylic and 20% for the silicone IOL (P = .4) in group 1 and 18% for both the three-piece and one-piece acrylic IOLs (P = .87) in group 2. Concerning the amount of capsulorrhexis contraction, there was no significant difference between the IOL types that were evaluated in this study (after Bonferroni-Holm correction, P > .05). CONCLUSION: In the hydrophobic sharp optic edge IOLs that were examined, neither the optic material nor the haptic design had an influence on the amount of ACO or capsulorrhexis contraction.     

Effect of posterior chamber intraocular lens design and surgical placement on postoperative outcome.

Intraocular lens (IOL) design, optical configuration, and placement have potential effects on postoperative outcome. Laboratory studies have suggested that one-piece, biconvex designs may reduce or delay posterior capsular opacification and that in-the-bag fixation of the posterior chamber IOL may reduce inflammation. To document the clinical significance of IOL design and placement, we conducted a randomized, prospective, clinical trial. Six hundred uncomplicated capsulorhexis and phacoemulsification patients were randomized in a three-factor design to receive an IOL that was one-piece or three-piece, had a biconvex, plano-convex, or laser ridge optic, and was bag-or sulcus-fixated. Treatment differences were related to lens placement. Patients with bag-fixated IOLs had less posterior capsular opacification, fewer YAG laser capsulotomies, a higher percentage of centered lenses, less inflammation, and fewer late posterior capsular striae than those with sulcus-fixated IOLs. In the latter group, patients with three-piece IOLs had fewer posterior capsular striae at three months postoperatively. All six occurrences of haptic loop distortion were in patients with three-piece IOLs. Patients with the one-piece design had less late inflammation than those with the three-piece design. Fewer YAG capsulotomies were necessary at one year in patients with the biconvex design than in those with the plano-convex or laser ridge configurations. Operative complications, endothelial cell loss, and postoperative complications were not IOL-related.     

Anterior chamber lenses. Part II: A laboratory study

An analysis of 606 surgically removed anterior chamber intraocular lens (IOL) specimens revealed that 351 or 58% of these were small-diameter, round loop, closed-loop styles. Because of the extremely high percentage of IOLs with this design received in our laboratory and the correlation of clinical histories with our histopathologic findings, we have concluded that such IOLs do not provide the safety and efficacy achieved by other anterior chamber lens designs. The finely polished, one-piece, all-PMMA styles fared well in our study. Although these one-piece styles comprise well over 50% of the American market share of anterior chamber IOLs, they comprise only 14% of all anterior chamber IOLs accessioned in our laboratory, compared to 58% for closed-loop designs. We believe that implantation of anterior chamber lenses with small-diameter, round, closed loops is no longer warranted. Patients in whom these IOLs have already been implanted should be carefully followed. It is our opinion that the FDA should recall or closely monitor all IOLs of this design and that implantation of closed-loop lenses should be discontinued in the United States. Furthermore, we believe that an IOL deemed to be not medically sound or worthy of implantation in the United States should not be marketed or donated outside of this country.     

Rates and causes of intraoperative removal of foldable and rigid intraocular lenses: clinicopathological analysis of 100 cases

PURPOSE: To analyze the rates of and reasons for intraoperative explantation of foldable and rigid intraocular lenses (IOLs) to determine the complication profile of each IOL design. SETTING: Center for Research on Ocular Therapeutics and Biodevices, Storm Eye Institute, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, South Carolina, USA. METHODS: The study comprised data analysis of foldable (n = 85) and rigid (n = 15) IOL specimens that were explanted immediately after primary implantation. RESULTS: Eighty-five foldable intraoperative explants were accessioned. These comprised 14.5% of the 586 foldable IOL explants received between January 1988 and September 2000. There were 15 rigid poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) intraoperative explants out of 2077 rigid explant specimens (0.7%). Fifty-one (60%) of the foldable IOLs requiring intraoperative explantation were the 1-piece silicone plate-haptic large-hole design, and 29 (34.1%) were the 3-piece silicone polyimide-haptic design. The most frequent reason for explantation of both designs was optic damage, 37.3% in the large-hole design and 55.2% in the polyimide design. Optic damage did not occur in rigid PMMA IOLs. CONCLUSION: Some foldable IOL designs have a higher risk of damage during surgical insertion than rigid designs. Two modern foldable IOLs, the silicone plate-haptic large-hole and the silicone polyimide-haptic, appear to be more prone to damage during folding, loading, and implantation than other IOLs.