Prognosis and surgical management of patients with palpable inguinal lymph node metastases from melanoma

BACKGROUND: The appropriate management of melanoma metastatic to inguinal lymph nodes remains controversial. The aim of this study was to identify disease- and treatment-related factors that influence the outcome of patients undergoing therapeutic groin dissection for clinically detectable melanoma lymph node metastases. METHODS: A retrospective analysis was performed on data collected from the case records of patients who had a therapeutic inguinal lymph node dissection performed between 1984 and 1998. RESULTS: Some 132 patients were suitable for inclusion. Sixty patients had superficial inguinal lymph node dissection (SLND) and 72 had combined superficial inguinal and pelvic lymph node dissection (CLND). There was no difference in postoperative morbidity or major lymphoedema between SLND and CLND. The overall survival rate was 34 per cent at 5 years. On univariate analysis, age (P = 0.003), the number of involved superficial lymph nodes (P = 0.001) and the presence of extracapsular spread (P = 0.003) were found to have a significant impact on survival. The presence or absence of pelvic lymph node metastases in patients who had CLND was a significant prognostic factor for survival (5-year survival 19 versus 47 per cent; P = 0.015). CONCLUSION: The prognosis of patients with clinically detectable melanoma metastases to the groin is variable and related to the biological characteristics of each case. CLND provided additional prognostic information and optimal regional control with no increased morbidity compared with SLND.     

Treatment strategy for patients with middle and lower third bile duct cancer

BACKGROUND: The prognosis for patients with middle and lower third bile duct carcinoma remains poor. This study was conducted to identify independent predictors for survival, as well as the patterns of recurrence after curative resection. METHODS: Sixty-seven patients with pathologically verified middle and/or lower third bile duct carcinoma were analysed retrospectively by Cox regression analysis for predictors of survival. RESULTS: The overall 5-year survival rate after resection was 39 per cent, and 0 per cent for patients who did not undergo resection. The 5-year survival rate was 63 per cent in 26 patients without microscopic residual disease (R0), 16 per cent in 25 patients with microscopic residual tumour (R1) and 0 per cent in six patients with macroscopic residual tumour (R2); ten patients did not undergo resection. Radiotherapy improved the 5-year survival rate in eight patients who had R1 resection compared with the rate in 17 patients who underwent resection alone (8 versus 0), but not significantly so (P = 0.137); however, median survival was significantly longer (P = 0.004) in six patients who had R2 resection compared with that in ten inoperable patients (11.4 versus 3.5 months). Multivariate analysis revealed that the primary tumour and tumour node metastasis (TNM) stage were independent predictors of survival; 13 clinicopathological factors were not independent prognostic factors. Of 26 patients having R0 resection, one had a locoregional relapse only, six had distant metastases only, and five had both types of recurrence. The liver was the most frequent site for metastasis, and microscopic venous invasion (MVI) in the primary tumour was a significant predictor of liver metastasis. CONCLUSION: Curative (R0) resection is only one step in curing cancer, and radiotherapy may play a beneficial role in controlling locoregional residual tumour. MVI could be a useful indicator of when systemic adjuvant therapy should be implemented to prevent liver metastasis after R0 resection, although no effective systemic treatment has yet been developed.     

Combined inguinal and pelvic lymph node dissection for stage III melanoma

BACKGROUND: The incidence of melanoma is increasing in the UK and a significant number of patients are still presenting with primary lesions of poor prognosis. As a consequence there is likely to be an increasing number of patients with lymph node metastases for whom the appropriate extent of groin dissection remains controversial. This review summarizes the evidence to enable surgeons to make an informed decision about the management of patients with melanoma metastases to the groin lymph nodes. METHODS: A Medline search was performed to identify all English language articles about melanoma containing the words lymphadenectomy, lymph nodes, inguinal or lymphoedema. Eighty-seven relevant articles were selected from 3904 abstracts retrieved; 34 were related directly to the aim of this review. RESULTS: There are no randomized controlled trials comparing the outcome of combined inguinal and pelvic lymph node dissection (CLND) and superficial inguinal lymph node dissection (SLND). Excision of pelvic lymph node metastases is reported to yield a 5-year survival rate of 0-35 per cent. Recurrence within the pelvis occurs in 9-18 per cent of patients after SLND and in less than 5 per cent after CLND. Morbidity following either CLND or SLND is poorly reported. Major long-term lymphoedema limiting patient activity affects 6-20 per cent of patients after groin dissection. Cloquet's node was demonstrated in one study to be a useful predictor of pelvic lymph node involvement. Patients may be selected for pelvic node dissection on the basis of clinical findings, the results of pelvic computed tomography and the status of Cloquet's node. CONCLUSION: The controversy surrounding the appropriate management of cytologically positive inguinal nodes in melanoma can be resolved only by a prospective randomized trial comparing CLND with SLND. Morbidity and local disease control must be measured as outcomes in addition to disease-free and overall survival.     

Surgeons’ Opinions on Lymphadenectomy in Melanoma Patients with Positive Sentinel Nodes: A Worldwide Web-Based Survey

Purpose

A worldwide web-based survey was conducted among melanoma surgeons to investigate opinions about completion lymph node dissection (CLND) in patients with positive sentinel nodes (SN).

Methods

A questionnaire was designed following input from a group of melanoma surgeons. Cognitive interviews and pilot testing were performed. Surgeons identified through a systematic-review of the SN and CLND literature were invited by email.

Results

Of 337 surgeons, 193 (57.2?%) from 25 countries responded (January?CJuly 2011). Most respondents work in melanoma (30.1?%) and surgical oncology (44.6?%) units. In patients with a positive SN, 169 (91.8?%) recommend CLND; the strength of the recommendation is mostly influenced by patient comorbidities (64.7?%) and SN tumor burden (59.2?%). Seventy-one responders enroll patients in the second Multicenter Selective-Lymphadenectomy Trial (MSLT-2), and 64 of them (76?%) suggest entering the trial to majority of patients. In cases requiring neck CLND, level 1?C5 dissection is recommended by 35?% of responders, whereas 62?% base the extent of dissection on primary site and lymphatic mapping patterns. Only inguinal dissection or ilioinguinal dissection is performed by 36 and 30?% of surgeons, respectively. The remaining 34?% select either procedure according to number of positive SNs, node of Cloquet status, and lymphatic drainage patterns. Most surgeons (81?%) perform full axillary dissections in positive SN cases.

Conclusions

The majority of melanoma surgeons recommend CLND in SN-positive patients. Surgeons participating in the MSLT-2 suggest entering the trial to the majority of patients. More evidence is needed to standardize the extent of neck and groin CLND surgeries.     

Axillary recurrence is low in patients with breast cancer who do not undergo completion axillary lymph node dissection for micrometastases in sentinel lymph nodes

Completion axillary lymph node dissection (CLND) is presently the standard of care after a positive sentinel lymph node biopsy (SLNB). We hypothesize that the incidence of axillary recurrence in patients who do not undergo CLND for micrometastases is low, and CLND is not necessary for locoregional control. We performed a retrospective chart review of patients with invasive breast carcinoma and micrometastases detected on SLNB. The Memorial Sloan Kettering Nomogram (MSKN) predicting the likelihood of nonsentinel lymph node (NSN) metastases was compared with the incidence of positive NSN. There were 61 patients identified with a mean follow-up of 70 months. The average tumor size was 2 cm. The median number of positive SLNs was one. Twenty-eight (46%) patients had a CLND; of these, 20 patients had one positive NSN (2 of 28 [7%]) and the mean MSKN score was 12 per cent. There were 33 (54%) patients who had SLNB alone, and their mean MSKN score was 13 per cent. Axillary recurrence in this group was 1.6 per cent. We conclude the incidence of axillary recurrence in patients with micrometastases detected by SLN biopsy who do not undergo CLND is low. The use of a predictive nomogram to estimate likelihood of metastatic disease to NSN may overestimate the actual incidence of positive NSN in patients with micrometastases.     

Factors influencing survival after resection of pulmonary metastases from colorectal cancer

BACKGROUND: Selection of patients for resection of lung metastases from colorectal cancer is problematic. The aim of this study was to evaluate clinically relevant prognostic factors and to define a subgroup of patients who would most benefit from such surgery. PATIENTS: Seventy-five patients (median age 58 (range 33-82) years) with pulmonary metastases from colorectal cancer underwent 104 R0 lung resections. Median follow-up was 33 (range 4-116) months. Patients who had no evidence of recurrent extrathoracic disease, no more than three metastases on either side, lobectomy as the maximal surgical procedure, and adequate cardiorespiratory function were eligible for surgery. Univariate and multivariate Cox regression, and classification and regression tree subgroup analyses were performed. RESULTS: Overall median survival was 33 months, with 3- and 5-year survival rates of 47 and 27 per cent respectively. Size of metastases (relative risk (RR) 2.6) and extent of resection (RR 0.4) were identified as independent prognostic factors. Primary tumour stage was significant in univariate analysis. Subgroup analysis defined two statistically relevant prognostic groups: patients with a maximum metastasis size of 3.75 cm or less with a disease-free interval of more than 10 months and patients with larger metastases and a shorter disease-free interval. Median survival and 5-year survival were 45 months and 39 per cent in the former group, and 24 months and less than 11 per cent in the latter. CONCLUSION: Subgroup analysis provided criteria for the selection of patients for R0 resection of lung metastases from colorectal cancer and differentiated between those at high or low risk of early tumour progression; the latter patients would benefit most from surgery.     

Chemotherapy by regional perfusion for limb melanoma

The administration of chemotherapy by isolated regional perfusion was developed in 1957 at Tulane University and was found to be of greatest benefit for patient with melanoma of the limbs. From 1957 to 1984, 897 patients were treated by this method. The 10-year survival rate for 831 patients with primary melanoma was 77 per cent. Women survived longer than men, with 10-year rates of 81 per cent and 65 per cent, respectively. Prophylactic lymph node dissection was of benefit for males with poor prognosis distal lower limb lesions, but other groups did not benefit. Primary lesions on the arm and thigh did better than lesions of the hand or foot, with plantar and subungual lesions having the least favorable results. Thickness, level, and histologic type were also significant prognostic indicators. Thirty-three patients with locally recurrent melanoma (stage II) treated by perfusion and excision had a 10-year survival rate of 59 per cent. For 129 patients with metastases to the regional lymph nodes (IIIB), perfusion plus RLND produced a 10-year rate of 51 per cent; survival rates for those with a single positive node was 64 per cent. Seventy patients with satellitosis or intransit metastases (IIIA) had a 10-year survival rate of 23 per cent. Thirty-eight patients with metastases to limbs from unknown primaries had a 10-year survival rate of 52 per cent. The overall 10-year rate for all stage III patients was 41 per cent. Perfusion produced useful palliation in 144 patients with limb melanoma in the presence of systemic metastases.     

Sentinel node biopsy for early-stage melanoma: accuracy and morbidity in MSLT-I, an international multicenter trial

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to evaluate, in an international multicenter phase III trial, the accuracy, use, and morbidity of intraoperative lymphatic mapping and sentinel node biopsy (LM/SNB) for staging the regional nodal basin of patients with early-stage melanoma. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Since our introduction of LM/SNB in 1990, this technique has been widely adopted and has become part of the American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) staging system. Eleven years ago, the authors began the international Multicenter Selective Lymphadenectomy Trial (MSLT-I) to compare 2 treatment approaches: wide excision (WE) plus LM/SNB with immediate complete lymphadenectomy (CLND) for sentinel node (SN) metastases, and WE plus postoperative observation with CLND delayed until the subsequent development of clinically evident nodal metastases. METHODS: After each center achieved 85% accuracy of SN identification during a 30-case learning phase, patients with primary cutaneous melanoma (> or =1 mm with Clark level > or =III, or any thickness with Clark level > or =IV) were randomly assigned in a 4:6 ratio to WE plus observation (WEO) with delayed CLND for nodal recurrence, or to WE plus LM/SNB with immediate CLND for SN metastasis. The accuracy of LM/SNB was determined by comparing the rates of SN identification and the incidence of SN metastases in the LM/SNB group versus the subsequent development of nodal metastases in the regional nodal basin of those patients with tumor-negative SNs. Early morbidity of LM/SNB was evaluated by comparing complication rates between the 2 treatment groups. Trial accrual was completed on March 31, 2002, after enrollment of 2001 patients. RESULTS: Initial SN identification rate was 95.3% overall: 99.3% for the groin, 95.3% for the axilla, and 84.5% for the neck basins. The rate of false-negative LM/SNB during the trial phase, as measured by nodal recurrence in a tumor-negative dissected SN basin, decreased with increasing case volume at each center: 10.3% for the first 25 cases versus 5.2% after 25 cases. There were no operative mortalities. The low (10.1%) complication rate after LM/SNB increased to 37.2% with the addition of CLND; CLND also increased the severity of complications. CONCLUSIONS: LM/SNB is a safe, low-morbidity procedure for staging the regional nodal basin in early melanoma. Even after a 30-case learning phase and 25 additional LM/SNB cases, the accuracy of LM/SNB continues to increase with a center's experience. LM/SNB should become standard care for staging the regional lymph nodes of patients with primary cutaneous melanoma.     

Principles of sentinel lymph node identification: background and clinical implications

The management of clinically negative regional lymph nodes in early-stage melanoma has been controversial for many years. While some advocate wide excision of the primary with elective node dissection (ELND), others recommend excision of the primary alone and therapeutic node dissection (TLND) for recurrences in the nodal basin. ELND is based on the concept that metastases occur by passage of the tumor from the primary to the regional nodes and distant sites, in which case early dissection of regional nodes will disrupt metastatic progression and prevent the spread of disease. Advocates of the "wait and watch" approach suggest that regional node metastases are markers for disease progression and that distant disease can occur without node metastases. Four randomized prospective studies comparing ELND and TLND have not demonstrated overall survival advantage for ELND, but suggest that patients with early regional metastases may benefit from ELND. As an alternative, Morton et al., from UCLA and the John Wayne Cancer Institute, devised intraoperative lymphatic mapping and sentinel lymphadenectomy (LM/SL). These minimally invasive operative procedures allow identification of the first and key (sentinel) lymph node (SN). The technique accurately maps the lymphatics by lymphoscintigraphy, and vital blue dye leads the surgeon to the SN. The pathologist then concentrates on seeking metastases in the nodes most likely to contain metastases. Patients with tumor-positive SN undergo completion lymph node dissection (CLND), while those without SN metastases avoid the complications and costs associated with this procedure. Morton et al., in a report on their initial experience of LM/SL, performed CLND in all cases regardless of SN tumor status and demonstrated the precise staging capacity of the procedure. Since this initial report, numerous studies have validated the accuracy and low morbidity of the procedure. Each center must master a learning phase. The procedure is dependent on the close cooperation of nuclear medicine physicians, surgeons, and pathologists. While LM/SL is now almost standard practice in the US, the results of clinical trials are awaited to determine whether LM/SL can replace ELND and TLND in the management of early-stage melanoma.     

Population-based study of prognostic factors in stage II colonic cancer

BACKGROUND: Adjuvant chemotherapy in stage II colorectal cancer may be considered for patients whose tumours have poor prognostic features. The aim of this study was to evaluate the prognostic significance of commonly reported clinical and pathological features of stage II colonic cancer. METHODS: A population-based observational study of all patients with stage II colonic cancer diagnosed in the state of Western Australia from 1993 to 2003 was performed. A total of 1306 patients treated by surgery alone were identified, with a median follow-up of 59 (range 0-145) months. RESULTS: Multivariable analysis revealed that the only independent prognostic factors for disease-specific survival were stage T4 (hazard ratio (HR) 1.75 (95 per cent confidence interval (c.i.) 1.32 to 2.32); P < 0.001) and vascular invasion (HR 1.63 (95 per cent c.i. 1.15 to 2.30); P < 0.001). In younger patients (aged 75 years or less), who are more likely to be considered for chemotherapy, these two features showed independent prognostic significance but with higher HR values (1.96 for stage T4 and 2.73 for vascular invasion). Stage T4 and/or the presence of vascular invasion identified a 'poor' prognostic group, comprising 26.6 per cent of younger patients and with a 5-year survival rate of 71.2 per cent. The remaining 'good' prognostic group had a survival rate of 84.3 per cent at 5 years' follow-up. CONCLUSION: This study highlights the importance of accurate pathological assessment of tumour stage and vascular invasion for the prognostic stratification of patients with stage II colonic cancer. The results provide clarification of guidelines for the management of stage II disease in relation to recommendations for chemotherapy.     

Size of sentinel node metastases predicts other nodal disease and survival in malignant melanoma

BACKGROUND: A positive sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy is an indication for completion lymph node dissection (CLND) in malignant melanoma; however, most CLNDs are negative. We hypothesized SLN metastatic size of < or =2 mm would predict CLND status and prognosis. METHODS: We evaluated 80 consecutive patients undergoing CLND for positive SLNs over a 10-year period. Incidence of positive nonsentinel nodes and survival were compared for patients with SLN metastases < or =2 mm and >2 mm. RESULTS: Of 504 patients undergoing SLN biopsy, 49 patients had SLN deposits < or =2 mm and a 6% incidence of positive CLNDs. Five-year survival was 85%, essentially the same as negative SLN biopsies. In contrast, 31 had SLN metastases >2 mm, a 45% incidence of addition disease at CLND, and 5-year survival of 47% (P < .0001). CONCLUSION: An SLN metastatic cut point of 2 mm is an efficient predictor of CLND status and survival in malignant melanoma.     

DNA ploidy pattern and tumour spread in gastric cancer

The DNA ploidy pattern of gastric cancer was studied in 58 patients to investigate the heterogeneity between primary tumour and metastases. In both primary tumours and lymph node metastases, diploid patterns accounted for 33 per cent, whereas all liver metastases were aneuploid. The percentage of polyploid cells was higher in the liver metastases than in primary tumours and lymph node metastases. When the heterogeneity of DNA ploidy pattern between primary tumour and metastasis was evaluated, diploid tumours had a significantly lower rate of lymph node metastasis heterogeneity than aneuploid tumours. When the DNA ploidy pattern and survival were evaluated, the patients who had a diploid pattern in both primary tumour and metastasis had a significantly higher survival rate than the patients who had an aneuploid pattern in the primary tumour and metastasis (57 per cent versus 26 per cent at 5 years). These data suggest that cell heterogeneity is a common phenomenon in gastric cancer, and this may be important in the evolution of the disease. Furthermore, the role of the DNA ploidy pattern as a prognostic factor is emphasized.     

Tumour thickness as a predictor of occult lymph node metastases in patients with stage I and II melanoma undergoing sentinel lymph node biopsy

BACKGROUND: Sentinel lymph node biopsy (SLNB) is a minimally invasive procedure used accurately to stage nodal basins at risk of occult metastases. There are no data as yet to show a survival benefit from SLNB and its use remains controversial. If Breslow thickness of the tumour correlates well with positive SLNB, it could be used to select patients for SLNB. METHODS: A quantitative systematic review of published studies on SLNB in patients with melanoma available by September 2001 was performed. RESULTS: Twelve studies containing 4218 patients with stage I and II melanoma were identified; 17.8 (95 per cent confidence interval 16.7 to 19.0) per cent of patients had nodal micrometastases detected by SLNB. The incidence of micrometastasis in sentinel nodes correlated directly with Breslow tumour thickness; it was 1.0 per cent for lesions of less than or equal to 0.75 mm, 8.3 per cent for 0.76-1.50 mm, 22.7 per cent for 1.51-4.0 mm and 35.5 per cent for more than 4.0 mm. CONCLUSION: The Breslow thickness of primary melanoma predicts the presence of a sentinel node metastasis. The published data are not sufficient to demonstrate a correlation between other known prognostic indicators and a positive SLNB.     

One hundred patients with hepatic metastases from colorectal cancer treated by resection: analysis of prognostic determinants

One hundred patients with hepatic metastases from colorectal cancer underwent 'radical' liver resection from 1980 to 1989. At least 1 cm of normal parenchyma surrounded the tumour and no microscopic invasion of resection margins was evident. The disease was staged according to our own staging system. Lobectomy was performed in 50 patients and non-anatomical resection in the remainder. The postoperative mortality rate was 5 per cent and the major morbidity rate was 11 per cent. The actuarial 5-year survival rate for patients in stages I, II and III was 42 per cent, 34 per cent and 15 per cent respectively (P less than 0.001). The overall actuarial 5-year survival rate was 30 per cent. The prognostic importance of various patient and tumour variables was evaluated by univariate analysis and then by multivariate analysis. Age of patient, site of primary, disease-free interval between treatment of primary and of hepatic metastases, preoperative carcinoembryonic antigen levels, and number of metastases, did not relate to prognosis, while sex (P = 0.024), stage of primary (P = 0.026), extent of liver involvement (P less than 0.001), distribution of metastases (P = 0.01) and type of surgery (P = 0.028) significantly affected prognosis as single factors. Multivariate analysis revealed that only the extent of liver involvement and stage of the primary tumour were independent predictors of survival. We conclude that liver resection is effective in selected patients with hepatic metastases from colorectal cancer. In resectable patients it is not yet possible to formulate a clear prognosis based on clinical factors. The extent of liver involvement and the staging system used may be significant, although not absolute, indicators of outcome.     

Histological Features of Melanoma Sentinel Lymph Node Metastases Associated with Status of the Completion Lymphadenectomy and Rate of Subsequent Relapse

Background The current recommendation for patients with cutaneous melanoma and a positive sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy is a completion lymph node dissection (CLND). This study sought to define a population of SLN-positive patients, based on their histological pattern of SLN metastases, who may not require CLND. Methods All patients with SLN-positive cutaneous melanoma who underwent CLND between March 1999 and December 2004 at a single academic institution were enrolled. Metastatic deposits in the SLN were categorized by their histological zone of involvement (subcapsular, parenchymal and/or sinusoidal). Logistic regression was used to examine the effect of SLN zone, size of nodal metastases, and other histological factors on CLND positivity. Kaplan-Meier and Cox models were used to study disease recurrence. Results A total of 127 patients were included, and 15.8% had positive non-sentinel nodes. In adjusted analyses, the size of the largest tumor deposit in the SLN was the only factor associated with CLND status. No patients with a tumor deposit ≤0.20 mm had a positive CLND. Although a specific zone of tumor involvement was not predictive of CLND status, involvement of all three zones was independently associated with increased recurrence. Size of the largest tumor deposit was also associated with recurrence, with no recurrences in patients with nodal deposits ≤0.20 mm. Conclusion Histologic features of tumor metastases in positive SLN may be useful in defining a population of patients who may be spared CLND and a group at high risk of recurrence.     

Prognostic value of subclassification of T2 tumours in patients with gastric cancer

Background:

This study was designed to evaluate the prognostic value of tumour stage T2 subcategorization (T2a and T2b) in patients with gastric carcinoma.

Methods:

Clinicopathological details of a prospective series of patients who had radical resection of gastric adenocarcinoma in a single institution were analysed. Univariable and multivariable survival analyses were performed with the log rank test and Cox's model respectively.

Results:

Of 373 evaluable patients, 49 (13·1 per cent) had a T2a and 143 (38·3 per cent) a T2b tumour. At a median follow‐up of 35·5 months, the 5‐year overall survival rate was 73 and 31·1 per cent for patients with T2a and T2b lesions respectively (P < 0·001). On multivariable analysis, T stage remained an independent prognostic factor. Compared with T1a, the mortality risk for patients with T1b (hazard ratio (HR) 1·00; P = 0·992) and T2a (HR 0·97; P = 0·916) tumours was similar; by contrast, the risk of death associated with T2b (HR 1·81; P = 0·031) and T3 (HR 1·89; P = 0·038) lesions was significantly greater than for T1a tumours.

Conclusion:

Subclassification of T2 tumours should be undertaken routinely in order to stratify patients with gastric cancer more accurately in terms of their mortality risk. Copyright © 2009 British Journal of Surgery Society Ltd. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Lateral pelvic lymph node dissection for advanced lower rectal cancer

BACKGROUND: The oncological outcome of patients who underwent curative surgery for lower rectal cancer was investigated to clarify whether lateral pelvic lymph node dissection (LPLD) conferred any benefit. METHODS: A total of 246 patients who underwent curative surgery for stage II and III lower rectal cancer (below the peritoneal reflection) between 1985 and 1998 was reviewed. Forty-two of these patients did not undergo LPLD. RESULTS: Patients who did not undergo LPLD were older, more likely to have anterior resection and pelvic nerve preservation, and had smaller tumours and lymph node metastasis at an earlier stage than those who underwent LPLD. There was no difference in survival among patients with stage II and III disease between the two groups. However, in patients with pathological N1 lymph node metastasis, the 5-year disease-free survival rate was 73.3 per cent in patients who had LPLD compared with 35.3 per cent among those who did not (P = 0.013). Multivariate analysis showed that LPLD was a significant prognostic factor. CONCLUSION: LPLD improved the prognosis of patients with stage III disease and a small number of lymph node metastases. A randomized clinical trial is needed to verify the benefit of LPLD.     

Is completion lymphadenectomy after a positive sentinel lymph node biopsy for cutaneous melanoma always necessary?

HYPOTHESIS: Completion lymph node dissection (CLND) has usually been recommended after metastatic disease is identified in the sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy to eradicate further metastases in nonsentinel nodes. We hypothesized that patients with negative lymph nodes included in the initial SLN specimen have low risk of metastases in the residual draining basin and may not require CLND. DESIGN: Chart review. SETTING: University-affiliated tertiary care referral center. PATIENTS: Between January 1, 1997, and May 31, 2003, 506 consecutive patients underwent SLN biopsy for staging of primary cutaneous melanoma. INTERVENTION: The SLN biopsy identified 87 patients (17.2%) with metastatic melanoma, of whom 80 underwent CLND. RESULTS: In 28 patients, all SLNs were found to contain metastatic melanoma. Seven (25%) of these patients had additional metastases identified in the CLND specimen. In 52 patients, 1 or more SLNs did not contain metastatic melanoma. Five (10%) of these patients had additional metastases in the CLND specimen (P =.02). CONCLUSIONS: Although no evidence of metastatic melanoma was found on CLND in most patients in whom negative nodes had been removed with positive SLNs at the initial biopsy, 10% of these patients did have further metastases. This subgroup of patients (positive SLNs and negative nodes in the SLN biopsy specimen) is at significantly lower risk for further metastasis, but CLND cannot be safely omitted even for these patients.     

Risk evaluation in cutaneous melanoma patients undergoing lymph node dissection: impact of POSSUM

INTRODUCTIONWhen lymphatic metastasis occurs, surgery is the primary treatment modality in melanoma patients. Depending on the tumour stage, patients receive a completion lymph node dissection (CLND) when a positive sentinel node is detected. Patients with clinically evident disease of the regional lymph nodes are recommended to undergo a therapeutic lymph node dissection (TLND). The aim of this study was to assess the morbidity of CLND and TLND and to evaluate the Physiological and Operative Severity Score for the enUmeration of Mortality and morbidity (POSSUM) for preoperative risk adjustment of postoperative morbidity.METHODSThe hospital files of 143 patients who underwent CLND and TLND for malignant melanoma were analysed. The POSSUM score was used to predict morbidity rates after surgery for the total patient group as well as separated for CLND and TLND patients.RESULTSThe overall complication rate was 28.0% and the mortality rate was 0%. The morbidity rate predicted by POSSUM was 32.9%, the mortality 8.3%. Morbidity in patients undergoing CLND was significantly higher with regard to overall wound complications compared with patients with TLND. In these subgroups, POSSUM failed to predict the rates precisely.CONCLUSIONSThe POSSUM score predicted the morbidity of the total patient group accurately but failed to predict the rates in the TLND and CLND subgroups. Patients receiving CLND showed the highest morbidity rates. Preoperative sentinel lymph node biopsy therefore has more influence on postoperative morbidity than the physiological parameters represented in the POSSUM physiological score.     

Melanoma Patients with Positive Sentinel Nodes Who Did Not Undergo Completion Lymphadenectomy: A Multi-Institutional Study

Background Completion lymph node dissection (CLND) is considered the standard of care in melanoma patients found to have sentinel lymph node (SLN) metastasis. However, the therapeutic utility of CLND is not known. The natural history of patients with positive SLNs who do not undergo CLND is undefined. This multi-institutional study was undertaken to characterize patterns of failure and survival rates in these patients and to compare results with those of positive-SLN patients who underwent CLND. Methods Surgeons from 16 centers contributed data on 134 positive-SLN patients who did not undergo CLND. SLN biopsy was performed by using each institution’s established protocols. Patients were followed up for recurrence and survival. Results In this study population, the median age was 59 years, and 62% were male. The median tumor thickness was 2.6 mm, 77% of tumors had invasion to Clark level IV/V, and 33% of lesions were ulcerated. The primary melanoma was located on the extremities, trunk, and head/neck in 45%, 43%, and 12%, respectively. The median follow-up was 20 months. The median time to recurrence was 11 months. Nodal recurrence was a component of the first site of recurrence in 20 patients (15%). Nodal recurrence–free survival was statistically insignificantly worse than that seen in a contemporary cohort of patients who underwent CLND. Disease-specific survival for positive-SLN patients who did not undergo CLND was 80% at 36 months, which was not significantly different from that of patients who underwent CLND. Conclusions This study underscores the importance of ongoing prospective randomized trials in determining the therapeutic value of CLND after positive SLN biopsy in melanoma patients. Presented at the 58th Annual Cancer Symposium of the Society of Surgical Oncology, Atlanta, Georgia, March 3–6, 2005.