Management of lower limb fractures in polytrauma patients with delayed referral in a mass disaster. The role of the Ilizarov method in conversion osteosynthesis

Polytrauma cases in mass disasters present several challenges to the orthopaedic surgeon. Delayed referral, multisystem involvement and the requirement to manage coexisting injuries by interhospital transfer often make infection an inevitable risk. 28 patients with polytrauma were studied after being referred after being recovered from the debris of their homes in the Kashmir earthquake. All patients were referred more than 24h after sustaining their injuries. The lower limb fractures were fixed by external fixators in all these cases before interhospital transfer for the management of their co existing injuries. Return referral to the orthopaedic facility occurred after an average of 25 days. All cases were converted to Ilizarov fixation. The results bear out the fact that the Ilizarov method may be well suited for conversion osteosynthesis of lower limb fractures in polytrauma cases.     

Comparative study of the results of compound tibial shaft fractures treated by Ilizarov ring fixators and limb reconstruction system fixators

Purpose: Ilizarov ring fixator and limb reconstruction system (LRS) fixators have been used in the management of complex tibial fractures with severe soft tissue injuries, compound tibial fractures, and infected tibial nonunion for which conventional internal fixation cannot be contemplated. Fracture union and distraction osteogenesis can be done simultaneously with these external fixators, allowing early weight bearing. Several previous studies have shown almost equal results of rail and ring fixators for the compound tibial shaft fractures. Thus we performed a prospective study to evaluate the union rate, functional outcome and amount of limb lengthening after the treatment of compound tibial shaft fractures with or without infected nonunion by ring or LRS fixators. Methods: This prospective study was done at Sarojini Naidu Medical College and Hospital, Agra, India and included 32 patients of compound tibial shaft fractures with or without infected nonunion. There were 26 males and 6 females and the average age was 40 years. Patients were randomly divided into two groups (n=16 for each): one underwent Ilizarov fixation and the other received LRS fixation. Cases were followed up for 3e24 months, 6 months on average from September 2012 to October 2014. Functional and radiological outcomes were assessed using the Association for the Study and Application of Methods of Ilizarov (ASAMI) criteria for both rail and ring fixators. Results: Union was achieved in all cases. Radiological outcome was found excellent in 68.75%, good in 18.75% and fair in 12.50% of cases treated by rail fixators whereas it was excellent in 56.25%, good in 18.75%, fair in 12.50% and poor in 12.50% of cases treated by ring fixators. Functional result was satisfactory in 75.00% of cases treated by rail fixator and 68.75% of cases treated by ring fixators whereas the corresponding rate of unsatisfactory was 25.00% vs. 31.25%. Conclusion: In our short-term assessment, LRS fixators show a better result than Ilizarov fixators in terms of fracture union and functional outcome with soft tissue care and limb length.     

Infected nonunion of the tibia

The treatment of infected nonunited fractures of the tibia using the techniques of Ilizarov was compared with autogenous cancellous bone graft application under a well vascularized soft tissue envelope. There were 10 patients in the Ilizarov group and 17 in the bone graft group. Soft tissue coverage with a free vascularized or a rotational muscle flap was used more frequently among the patients having bone graft (71%) than the Ilizarov group (30%). All 27 patients had bony defects (average, 3.7 cm; range, 1-18 cm). At an average followup of 6 years, 26 patients had a functional limb, and one patient (Ilizarov group) ultimately required a below knee amputation. Three patients in each group required a second plate and bone graft procedure to gain union. Infection persisted in four patients (all in the Ilizarov group). If a well vascularized soft tissue envelope is present (particularly after flap coverage), bone grafting procedures are safe and efficacious. The Ilizarov technique may be best suited for the treatment of very proximal or distal metaphyseal nonunions and nonunions associated with large leg length discrepancies.     

Orthopaedic management in a mega mass casualty situation. The Israel Defence Forces Field Hospital in Haiti following the January 2010 earthquake

Following the January 2010 earthquake in Haiti, the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) established a field hospital in Port au Prince. The hospital started operating 89 h after the earthquake. We describe the experience of the orthopaedic department in a field hospital operating in an extreme mass casualty situation.The hospital contained 4 operating table and 72 hospitalization beds. The orthopaedic department included 8 orthopaedic surgeons and 3 residents.1111 patients were treated in the hospital, 1041 of them had adequate records for inclusion. 684 patients were admitted due to trauma with a total of 841 injuries. 320 patients sustained 360 fractures, 18 had joint dislocations and 22 patients were admitted after amputations. 207 patients suffered 315 soft tissue injuries. 221 patients were operated on under general or regional anaesthesia. External fixation was used for stabilization of 48 adult femoral shaft fractures, 24 open tibial fractures and 1 open humeral fracture. All none femoral closed fractures were treated non-operatively. 18 joint reductions and 23 amputations were performed.Appropriate planning, training, operational versatility, and adjustment of therapeutic guidelines according to a constantly changing situation, enabled us to deliver optimal care to the maximal number of patients, in an overwhelming mass trauma situation.     

Outcome analysis of ilizarov and monorail fixators in the treatment of nonunion of long bones: A systematic review and proportion meta-analysis

IntroductionNonunion of long bones is a major complication following fractures that requires a substantial amount of investment both monetary and time from patients and surgeons. The need to comprehensively understand the complications, outcomes and distraction capability is profound, which necessitates a review of current evidence on special fixators used for distraction. The current systematic review aims to study the available literature on distraction osteogenesis using special fixators (Ilizarov and Limb Reconstruction System) in the management of nonunion (infected and non-infected).MethodsCochrane Library, PubMed, Scopus were searched until January 2022. The review included all original studies which used Ilizarov or Monorail Fixators/LRS in the treatment of nonunion of long bones. The quality of studies was assessed using the Modified Coleman Methodology Score.ResultsA total of 35 original studies with Ilizarov (n = 29) and LRS (n = 8) were selected including two comparative studies. The pooled data meta-analysis and the subgroup analysis of these studies found both Ilizarov and LRS fixator yield similar functional outcomes for the treatment of long bones nonunion.ConclusionThe review was conducted to understand the scenario of nonunion in long bones. Pin tract infection is found to be the most common complication followed by adjacent joint stiffness and deformity. In our review we observed that both external fixator time and index were lower in LRS compared to Ilizarov group. Further RCT are required comparing Ilizarov and LRS fixators to effectively comment upon the superiority of the implants.     

Segmental tibial fractures: an assessment of procedures in 27 cases

Twenty-seven patients (two women) with segmental tibial fractures (19 open) were treated in our institution with a mean age of 38.9 years (range 22-67 years) and a mean Injury Severity Score of 11.5 (9-34). Sixteen fractures were stabilised initially with an interlocking nail, seven with an external fixator, one with a hybrid external fixator, two cases were plated and one was treated in plaster. The mean size of the segment was 11.5 cm (range 4-20 cm). Soft tissue coverage was required in 17 cases. There were three cases of compartment syndrome, six cases of superficial infection and four deep infection cases (two of which required amputation). In four cases, excision of the non-viable segment was necessary. Overall, 13 patients were subjected to a second operative procedure (OP) (four external fixators were replaced with the AO solid tibial nail, two Ilizarov bone transports following excision of the dead bone segment, 2 below knee amputations, 3 exchange reamed nailings, 1 LISS plate application for stability and 1 ring fixator for compression of a fracture). Five patients underwent third procedure (two Ilizarov for bone transport, two exchange nailing, and one bone grafting). The mean time to union of the proximal segment was 38.8 weeks (range 10-78 weeks) and 41.4 weeks (range 12-65 weeks) for the distal segment, respectively. The treatment of segmental tibial fractures poses many problems to the surgeon due to the precarious blood supply of the intermediate segment. The risk of non-union delayed union, infection and additional procedures is high as seen in this series of patients.     

External circular fixation: a comparison of infection rates between wires and conical half-pins with threads outside or inside the skin

BACKGROUND: The purpose of this study was to evaluate if there is a difference in the rates of infection between Ilizarov wires and half-pins and between half-pins with threads outside and inside the skin in circular fixators modified by Catagni and Cattaneo. METHODS: Between May and December 2004, 218 patients with circular Ilizarov fixators for various orthopaedic indications who visited our Ilizarov clinic were subjected to a one-time evaluation of half-pins and wires. RESULTS: A total of 1,093 half-pins were checked and 34 (3.11%) of these were infected (50% with threads outside and 50% with threads inside the skin). Among a total number of 951 wires (1,092 pin tracts) checked, 45 (4.73%) were infected. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that the circular Ilizarov fixation with conical half-pins and wires has similar rate of infection compared with conventional Ilizarov circular fixator. Moreover, there is no difference in infection rates between pins with threads inside the skin as compared to those with threads outside the skin.     

外固定架在地震致重度胫腓骨开放性骨折早期处理中的应用

目的 评估外固定架应用于地震伤致重度胫腓骨开放性骨折的早期治疗效果.方法 2008年5月12至17日收治83例(116侧)地震伤致胫腓骨开放性骨折伤员(均为Gustilo Ⅲ度开放性骨折),均采用积极清创结合外固定架治疗,主要评估指标包括深部感染的发生、截肢及伤口愈合情况.结果 83例(116侧骨折)伤员获18-23d随访.9侧Ⅲc型骨折术后出现肢体缺血坏死而行截肢术,1侧Ⅲb型骨折因肢体感染坏死合并脓毒败血症而行截肢术.20侧肢体出现深部感染,经反复创口清创、扩创后感染得到控制.伤口一期愈合52侧,二期愈合54侧(包括使用皮瓣、肌瓣、肌皮瓣转移及植皮术等治疗).结论 地震伤致重度胫腓骨开放性骨折的早期治疗中,应用外固定架固定可作为一种有效的治疗手段.     

Management of infected fractures of the tibia with associated soft tissue loss: experience with external fixation, bone grafting and soft tissue reconstruction using pedicle muscle flaps or microvascular composite tissue grafts

The aim of this study was to assess the results of treatment given by a team of orthopaedic and plastic surgeons in a series of infected unhealed fractures of the tibia associated with loss of adjacent soft tissues. Twenty-five lower leg fractures, treated during a 10 year period, entered the study and were grouped according to the principles of treatment followed. In the earlier Group A (nine patients), the osteosynthesis implants were retained or changed to more stable internal fixation devices, the soft tissue defects were closed by conventional muscle or musculocutaneous flaps and bone grafting procedures were performed late in the treatment scheme. In the later Group B (16 patients) the implants were removed and the fracture stabilised by external fixation; the defects were covered with pedicle muscle flaps or with microvascular composite tissue grafts and cancellous bone grafting was performed at the same operation. Twenty-three fractures healed. One fracture developed non-union and in one patient infection necessitated below-knee amputation. The time of union after surgical reconstruction was significantly shorter in Group B (24 +/- 3 weeks) than in Group A (47 +/- 11 weeks). The results suggested that: in severe infected fractures of the tibia surgical implants used previously for fracture treatment should be removed and replaced with an external frame using firm axial compression, microvascular composite grafts seem to improve greatly the rate of healing, early bone grafting should be included in the reconstruction and late infections can be largely avoided even after extensive one-stage reconstructive procedures.     

A retrospective analysis of comminuted intra-articular fractures of the tibial plafond: Open reduction and internal fixation versus external Ilizarov fixation

Intra-articular fractures of the tibial plafond are complex injuries which continue to challenge orthopaedic surgeons in achieving anatomic reduction, while allowing early weight bearing and return to activity. Although a wide range of treatment options has been described for fixation of pilon fractures, the unique characteristic of each injury makes it difficult to advocate a general method of choice. We have attempted to compare a subset of AO/OTA type C pilon fractures treated either by a staged procedure of external fixation and conversion to open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) versus definitive external Ilizarov fixation. Between 1998 and 2004, 42 patients admitted to our level 1 trauma centre underwent either procedure and were followed prospectively. Twenty-eight patients were treated with ORIF and 14 were treated by Ilizarov ring fixator. The outcome measures included time to union, as well as the rates of union, nonunion, malunion and infection. Although the ORIF group had a longer time to heal, the rates of nonunion, malunion and infection were lower compared to the Ilizarov group. However, these differences between the groups were not statistically significant. Thus, based on these results, no clinical recommendation can be made as to which procedure is better and safer for the patient. Future prospective randomised trials are required to determine with more scientific accuracy the optimal treatment strategy for these challenging injuries.     

Ten year experience with use of Ilizarov bone transport for tibial defects

Tibial defects greater than 4 cm and secondary to high-energy trauma or debridement for infected nonunion pose a significant challenge to the treating orthopaedic surgeon. Twelve patients who had been treated with Ilizarov bone transport for tibial defects over the past ten years were retrospectively reviewed. All patients were male with an average age of thirty-two. Ten of the twelve limbs were categorized as Grade IIIB fractures initially. The average tibial defect at initiation of bone transport was 9.45 cm (range 4 to 20 cm). The mean external fixator time (EFT) was 16.7 months with a mean external fixator index (EFI) of 2.0 months per centimeter. There were a total of 36 complications. Twenty were minor, fourteen were major without sequelae and two were major with sequelae. Overall bone results were good or excellent in nine patients. Overall functional results were good or excellent in eight patients. Ten patients achieved union after Ilizarov bone transport. Use of Ilizarov bone transport can be an effective tool for treating large tibial defects. However, the treatment time is lengthy with a considerable risk of complications.     

Open grade III “floating ankle” injuries: a report of eight cases with review of literature

Introduction “Floating ankle” injuries result from high-energy trauma and are usually associated with extensive soft tissue damage. Such rare and complex injuries in the acute phase pose therapeutic dilemma to the treating surgeon. When salvage instead of amputation is preferred, a variety of treatment options are available ranging from open reduction along with minimal internal fixation to external fixation. In this retrospective case series study we report eight patients with open “floating ankle” injuries who had been treated with external fixation with or without internal fixation. Materials and methods Eight consecutive patients (7M: 1F) with mean age of 28 years (range 18–35 years) were treated. All had Grade III open fractures of the distal tibia with foot fractures and various degrees of soft tissue injuries. ISS and MESS were used to assess injury severity. Immediate radical wound debridement; skeletal stabilization and early soft tissue coverage were done by combined trauma and plastic surgical services followed by standard post-operative rehabilitation. All the patients were assessed with SF-36 questionnaire at mean follow-up of 2.5 years (range 2–4 years). Results Three patients were treated primarily with Ilizarov ring fixators, one had hybrid fixation and the other four had Hoffman frames. Four patients needed further surgeries. One patient developed metatarsal osteomyelitis, which was debrided and treated with antibiotics. The SF-36 results were compared with age matched UK norms for men and women in all categories. Only two patients returned to their previous employment. Six suffered varying degrees of disability out of which one underwent amputation. Conclusions External fixation with or without internal fixation is an option when salvaging rare injuries like open grade III “floating ankle” injuries. Salvaged patients do suffer a cocktail of crippling disease characterized by psycho-socio-economic and physical disability and result in increased hospital costs. We recommend more prospective studies with long-term follow-up of such complex injuries to identify the indications for salvage and also the criteria for a successful salvage.     

Treatment of post-traumatic humeral diaphyseal nonunion with bone loss

Four patients with post-traumatic nonunion and shortening of the humeral diaphysis were treated with a hybrid advanced Ilizarov technique. The mean age of the patients was 32 years, and the mean total amount of humeral shortening was 6.63 cm. Three nonunions were atrophic and infected, and one was hypertrophic. All patients obtained union of the humeral fracture with resolution of infection at a mean external fixation time of 8 months. Restoration of normal humeral length was achieved in two patients, with a third having a residual discrepancy of 1 cm. The final patient, who had an infected nonunion with 11 cm of total humeral shortening, had a residual limb length discrepancy of 3 cm. All had improvement in shoulder and elbow motion after treatment. Superficial pin tract infections were seen in all patients, but all responded to pin-site care and oral antibiotics. Two patients had three refractures after removal of the fixator, two of which were treated by a second application of an Ilizarov frame and one by a cast. All patients had reduced pain and improved function at completion of the treatment. The Ilizarov method, though not a panacea for all humeral nonunions with extensive bone loss, does offer a viable salvage procedure in this unusual and often complex clinical problem.     

Management of shotgun-induced fractures of the humerus with Ilizarov external fixator

Abstract We retrospectively reviewed 11 shotgun-induced open humeral fractures treated with immediate application of Ilizarov type ring external fixation. Eight patients had grade III A and three had grade III B open fractures. No patient had associated neurovascular injury. All fractures were stabilized with Ilizarov external fixator immediately after meticulous debridement and irrigation under emergent conditions. Complete bony union occurred in all patients in 14–44 weeks (mean, 21 weeks). One patient required a second intervention to adjust the external fixator rings. Two patients required a rotational fasciocutaneous flap to handle the soft tissue coverage problem. Superficial pin tract infection was present in eight patients; however none of them had deep infection or osteomyelitis. A good to excellent result was achieved in 10 patients according to the rating system of Smith and Cooney. Immediate Ilizarov external fixation is a safe method of obtaining a functional limb in the treatment of shotgun-induced open humeral fractures with severe soft tissue damage.     

Modified Ilizarov technique for infected nonunion of the femur: the principle of distraction-compression osteogenesis

PURPOSE. To evaluate the treatment outcome of the modified Ilizarov technique in infected nonunion of the femur. METHODS. Between 1989 and 2002, records of 20 patients with infected nonunion of the femur treated with the modified Ilizarov technique were retrospectively reviewed. The modified Ilizarov frame was fixed after necrectomy of the dead infected bone and tissues. A proximal or distal corticotomy was performed following biological principles. For regeneration of gap, segmental transport was performed in 11 patients with a gap of more than 5 cm; acute docking followed by lengthening at the corticotomy site was performed in 9 patients with a gap of smaller than 5 cm. Mobilisation was started early with active participation of the physical therapist and the patients. Bone and functional results were measured and complications were categorised according to the Association for the Study and Application of the Method of Ilizarov guidelines. RESULTS. The mean follow-up period was 62.8 months. Bony union and eradication of the infection was achieved in all patients except one who underwent amputation due to uncontrolled infection. Bone results were excellent in 13 patients, good in 4, fair in one, poor in one, and treatment failure (amputation) in one. Functional results were excellent in 3 patients, good in 9, fair in 3, poor in 4, and failure in one. A total of 71 complications occurred: 35 problems, 6 obstacles, and 30 true complications. The mean healing index was 38.3 day/cm (standard deviation, 1.6 day/cm). CONCLUSION. The Ilizarov technique is a good salvage operation for infected nonunion of the femur. Limb salvage is preferable to prosthesis if the limb is viable, adequately innervated and the patient is mentally and financially committed to save the limb.     

The timing of amputation for lower limb trauma

We reviewed 35 patients who had an amputation following the failure of treatment for severe lower limb trauma. Seven of the amputations were for ischaemia, within one month of injury; 13 were between one month and one year for infection complicating loss of wound cover in un-united fractures; and 15 were later than one year after injury, mainly for infected non-union. The latter group of patients had had an average of 12 operations and 50 months of treatment, including eight months in hospital. We used a new limb injury score based on damage to the individual tissue elements; this indicated that, even in the absence of neurovascular injury, the presence of severe damage to skin, bone and muscle, with wound contamination, particularly in the lower tibia, had a poor prognosis. We therefore recommend, to avoid multiple operations, with prolonged hospitalisation and suffering, that these patients should have early independent review by orthopaedic and plastic surgeons with the aim of establishing an accurate prognosis for the salvage of a useful limb.     

Location of treatment of supracondylar fractures of the humerus in children

A change in the locations where children are treated for supracondylar fractures of the humerus has occurred during the past 13 years. Pediatric orthopaedic surgeons at specialist centers are seeing an increased number of such fractures. In New England, the number of supracondylar fractures of the humerus treated by closed reduction and percutaneous pinning has remained relatively constant between 1991 and 1999 with a range of 276 to 346 fractures per year, averaging 320 per year. In 1991, 63% of patients were treated by general orthopaedic surgeons in a nonspecialist setting. By 1999, 68% of the fractures were treated at centers with pediatric orthopaedic specialists available whereas only 32% were treated in a general orthopaedic setting. Associated with this change is a decreased length of stay from 2.2 (+/- 0.6) days in nonspecialist centers to 1.4 (+/- 0.4) days average in specialist centers.     

Compound tibial fractures with bone loss treated by the Ilizarov technique

We report our experience of the use of the Ilizarov technique to treat nine patients with severe compound tibial fractures. The mean defect in bone was 6.3 cm, and four cases were infected. All nine patients had satisfactory union and function without the use of bone grafts or antibiotics. The Ilizarov technique was very satisfactory; there were no major complications.