腰椎间盘造影一致性疼痛反应和纤维环破裂程度的相关性研究

目的: 研究椎间盘源性下腰痛病人纤维环破裂程度和腰椎间盘造影一致性疼痛之间的关系。方法: 105例慢性下腰痛且无椎间盘突出的病人, 行腰椎间盘造影术。询问造影时病人疼痛反应, 分析造影后的X线片和造影后的CT片, 比较纤维环破裂程度与腰椎间盘造影一致性疼痛之间的相关性。结果: 105例病人中的 285个造影的腰椎间盘中, 67个腰椎间盘诱发一致性疼痛反应, 且全部呈现 2级以上的纤维环破裂。纤维环破裂分级越高, 椎间盘造影时一致性疼痛比例越大, 两者之间有显著的正相关性。结论: 椎间盘造影诱发的一致性疼痛反应比例和纤维环外层破裂程度呈正相关, 研究结果表明纤维环外层撕裂是疼痛复制的起源部位。     

椎间盘源性腰痛的治疗进展

Crock[1]1970年首次提出椎间盘内破裂(internal disc disruption,IDD)是导致腰痛的一种独立因素.经过将近40年的研究,人们逐渐认识到椎间盘源忭腰痛(discogenic low back pain)是指腰椎间盘退变、终板损伤以及纤维环破裂后,椎问盘内的疼痛感受器受到异常应力以及炎性介质等化学物质的刺激而导致的腰部疼痛,且不伴有神经根受累及脊柱节段不稳的临床和影像学证据[2].Schwarzer等[3]的流行病学和临床研究表明,椎间盘源性腰痛在慢性腰痛患者中的比例高达39%,最常见于L4-5和L5S1.     

腰椎间盘MRI高信号区在诊断椎间盘源性下腰痛中的意义

目的:探讨腰椎间盘MRI高信号区(HIZ)在诊断椎间盘源性下腰痛中的作用。方法:对52例经保守治疗无效、CT影像上无腰椎间盘突出的下腰痛患者行腰椎MRI检查和腰椎间盘造影术,分析腰椎间盘MRI高信号区与腰椎间盘造影诱发的下腰痛之间的关系。结果:在行腰椎间盘造影的142个椎间盘中,共有38个椎间盘呈现疼痛复制反应,其中17个椎间盘显示高信号区。这17个有高信号区的椎间盘在椎间盘造影过程中全部呈现2～3级的纤维环破裂和疼痛复制反应。结论:无椎间盘突出的下腰痛患者在腰椎MRI上存在椎间盘内高信号区,可表明该椎间盘是产生腰痛的破裂椎间盘。     

椎间盘源性腰痛的诊断方法及其临床价值

Park等于1979年首先提出椎间盘源性腰痛的概念，其定义为：影像学除外神经根压迫的情况，由椎间盘内部结构紊乱、退变导致的顽固性腰痛。当时这一概念并未得到广泛的认同。之后Crock通过对退变椎间盘内部结构的形态学研究提出了椎间盘内破裂（internal disc disruption，IDD）的概念，并认为IDD是导致椎间盘源性腰痛的原因。此后，椎间盘源性腰痛越来越广泛地引起各国学者的重视。     

椎间盘封闭术对纤维环破裂型椎间盘源性腰痛的诊治价值

 目的 探讨椎间盘封闭术对纤维环破裂型椎间盘源性腰痛的诊治价值。方法 临床高度怀疑椎间盘源性腰痛行椎间盘造影及单个椎间盘封闭术且有完整随访资料的患者120例,男72例,女48例;年龄25～60岁,平均48岁。根据造影术中纤维环破裂Dallas分级将患者分为0级组7例、1级组36例、2级组48例、3级组29例。采用疼痛视觉模拟评分(visual analogue scale,VAS)及罗兰莫里斯功能评分表(Roland Morris Disability Questionnaire,RMDQ)对术前及术后2周、2个月、6个月、12个月及24个月的疗效进行评估。结果 对高度怀疑的“责任椎间盘”进行封闭阻滞后患者腰痛症状明显改善,术后疼痛VAS和RMDQ评分与术前比较差异有统计学意义;Dallas 3级组中期疗效优于Dallas 1级组及2级组,差异有统计学意义;重度纤维环破裂患者(Dallas分级3级)术后各时间点腰痛症状复发率均低于其他各组患者。结论 椎间盘封闭术能有效缓解椎间盘源性腰痛的症状,并有一定的诊断价值,可作为造影术不能复制疼痛病例的补充诊断依据;纤维环破裂型椎间盘源性腰痛患者,特别是重度纤维环破裂患者,接受椎间盘局部封闭术后缓解疼痛的效果确切。     

椎间盘源性下腰痛的发病机制

1934年Mixter和Barr首次提出腰椎间盘突出可导致腰腿痛的观点：在之后很长一段时期内，椎间盘突出被看作是椎间盘疾病导致疼痛的先决条件和惟一原因。Lindblom及Wilson等。相继发现，即使在没有椎间盘突出的情况下行椎间盘造影仍可诱发腰痛．1986年Crock提出“椎间盘内破裂症”(internal disc disruption，IDD）的概念，     

腰椎终板、椎间盘退变及椎间盘造影疼痛激发试验的相关性研究

目的探讨下腰痛患者腰椎终板Modic退变、椎间盘退变及CT引导下腰椎间盘造影疼痛激发试验的相关性.方法对45例下腰痛患者常规行腰椎X线和MR检查,分别按Modic终板退变标准（0～3级）与Pearce椎间盘退变标准（Ⅰ～Ⅴ级）对终板和椎间盘进行评估.在CT引导下对45例患者中的40例（120个椎间盘）进行造影和疼痛激发试验,并按Dallas椎间盘造影分级系统（DDD）测评椎间盘退变程度.采用SPSS 11.5统计学软件分析腰椎终板Modic退变、椎间盘退变与腰椎间盘造影疼痛激发试验之间的相关性.结果40例下腰痛患者的腰椎终板Modic分级与椎间盘退变Pearce分级存在较强的相关性（Pearson x^2=43.326,P=0.000）,与椎间盘造影疼痛激发试验有显著相关性（Pearson x^2=27.858,P=0.000）;椎间盘退变Pearce分级与CT椎间盘造影椎间盘退变Dallas分级也呈较强的相关性.结论腰椎终板Modic退变分级与椎间盘退变Pearce分级密切相关,而与椎间盘疼痛激发试验有显著相关性,提示终板Modic退变可能是下腰痛的原因之一.     

复方倍他米松椎间盘内注射治疗盘源性下腰痛

目的探讨椎间盘内注射复方倍他米松治疗盘源性下腰痛的临床疗效。方法在CT引导下椎间盘内注射复方倍他米松,治疗经椎间盘造影证实有单节段的盘源性下腰痛患者48例,其中椎间盘内裂型（internal disc disruption,IDD）19例,椎间盘退变型（degenerative disc disease,DDD）29例。于术后2、12周随访,采用WHO疼痛缓解标准和视觉模拟量表（visual analogue scale,VAS）评分,回顾性分析其疗效。结果术后2周的总体有效率79.2%（38例）,术后12周有效率64.6%（31例）。术后2、12周IDD组和DDD组的VAS评分及疼痛缓解程度分级比较,差异无统计学意义,但IDD和DDD组在各自的2周与12周VAS评分做自身前后的相互比较,差异无统计学意义;两组间在各个时间点上的VAS评分比较,差异无统计学意义。结论椎间盘内注射复方倍他米松治疗可同时缓解IDD型和DDD型盘源性下腰痛的疼痛程度,对于接受此治疗的患者而言,这是一种安全、有效的方法。     

青年士兵盘源性下腰痛CT椎间盘造影与MRI表现的相关性

目的探讨CT椎间盘造影(CTD)诱发青年士兵盘源性下腰痛患者一致性疼痛与腰椎间盘MRI表现的相关性。方法对54例盘源性下腰痛青年士兵行MR检查后,共对152个腰椎间盘进行CTD,分析CTD分型、对比剂剂量、诱发一致性疼痛与MRI表现的相关性。结果青年士兵盘源性下腰痛患者椎间盘内破裂类型主要为CTDⅡ型和Ⅳ型,其分型、对比剂注射剂量与诱发一致性疼痛具有相关性(P0.01),腰椎间盘MRI表现与CTD诱发一致性疼痛存在明显相关性(P0.01)。结论 CTD能够定性诊断腰椎间盘内破裂,进一步确定责任椎间盘;MRI改变可能与青年士兵盘源性下腰痛的病因相关。     

MRI高信号区与椎间盘造影在椎间盘源性腰痛诊断中的相关性研究

目的 研究腰椎间盘MRI高信号区(HIZ)与椎间盘造影诱发疼痛反应之间的关系,为椎间盘源性下腰痛诊断和治疗提供参考.方法 对37例长期慢性下腰痛、无典型的神经根性症状和体征,且CT证实无椎间盘突出的患者行MRI检查和腰椎间盘造影.分析造影后的X线片和CT片,并结合造影时诱发的疼痛反应,比较其与腰椎间盘MRI高信号区之间的关系.结果 37例患者共行98个腰椎间盘造影,21个椎间盘疼痛反应阳性,其中有HIZ的间盘10个,占47.6%.77个疼痛反应阴性的椎间盘中,有HIZ的间盘29个,占37.6%.纤维环破裂程度分级越高,MRI出现高信号区的比例也越高,说明有高信号区的纤维环破裂程度高,无高信号区的纤维环破裂程度低(P＜0.01);而高信号区与造影疼痛反应阳性之间并无明显一致性(P＞0.05).结论 MRI高信号区在诊断椎间盘源性腰痛中仅为提示性和筛选性的影像学征象,不能替代椎间盘造影的金标准.     

The pathogenesis and clinical significance of a high-intensity zone (HIZ) of lumbar intervertebral disc on MR imaging in the patient with discogenic low back pain

Recently, the presence of a high-intensity zone (HIZ) within the posterior annulus seen on T2-weighted MRI has aroused great interest and even controversy among many investigators, particularly on whether the HIZ was closely associated with a concordant pain response on awake discography. The study attempted to interpret the correlation between the presence of the HIZ on MRI and awake discography, as well as its characteristic pathology. Fifty two patients with low back pain without disc herniation underwent MRI and discography successively. Each disc with HIZ was correlated for an association between the presence of a HIZ and the grading of annular disruption and a concordant pain response. Eleven specimens of lumbar intervertebral discs which contain HIZ in the posterior annulus from 11 patients with discogenic low back pain were harvested for histologic examination to interpret the histologic basis of a nociceptive response during posterior lumbar interbody fusion (PLIF). The study found that in all of 142 discograms in 52 patients, 17 presented HIZ. All 17 discs with HIZ showed painful reproduction and abnormal morphology with annular tears extending either well into or through the outer third of the annulus fibrosus. The consecutive sagittal slices through the HIZ lesion showed that a notable histologic feature of the formation of vascularized granulation tissue in the outer region of the annulus fibrosus. The current study suggests that the HIZ of the lumbar disc on MRI in the patient with low back pain could be considered as a reliable marker of painful outer anular disruption.     

Cytokine evaluation in individuals with low back pain using discographic lavage

Background contextThe pathophysiology underlying degenerative disc disease and its implication in painful syndromes remain unclear. However, spine magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can demonstrate changes in disc water content and the annulus; provocative discography purportedly identifies degenerate discs causing serious low back pain; and biochemical assays have identified local inflammatory markers. No study to date has correlated pain on disc injection during discography evaluation with relevant MRI findings and biochemical markers.PurposeThe purpose of this study was to correlate concordant pain on during discography to biochemical markers obtained by disc lavage and MRI findings.Study designThis is a Phase 1 Diagnostic Test Assessment Cohort Study (Sackett and Haynes).Patient sampleThe patient sample included 21 symptomatic patients with suspected discogenic pain and three Phase 1 control subjects.Outcome measuresThe outcome measures included discography pain scores, MRI degenerative grades, and immunoreactivity to various inflammatory cytokine concentrations present in disc lavage samples.MethodsTwenty-one symptomatic patients with lumbar degenerative disc disease and three control subjects underwent discography, MRI, and biochemical analysis of disc lavage fluid. Lumbar MRI was scored for Pfirrmann grading of the lumbar discs, and annular disruption was identified by nuclear disc lavage. Disc lavage samples were analyzed for biochemical markers by high-sensitivity immunoassay.ResultsEighty-three discs from 24 patients were studied: 67 discs from 21 patients with axial back pain (suspected discogenic pain group) and 16 discs from 3 scoliosis patients without back pain (Phase 1 control subjects). Among the biochemical markers surveyed, interferon gamma (IFN-γ) immunoreactivity was most consistently identified in patients with axial back pain. Discs with annular disruption and concordant pain reproduction at a visual analog scale of 7 to 10/10 had greater IFN-γ immunoreactivity than those without this finding (p=.003); however, at least some IFN-γ immunoreactivity was found in all but one disc in the symptomatic group.ConclusionsAmong the potential inflammatory markers tested in this Phase 1 study, IFN-γ immunoreactivity was most commonly elevated in discogram “positive” discs but absent in asymptomatic controls. However, this marker was also frequently elevated in degenerative but “negative” discography discs. From these findings, Phase 2 and Phase 3 validity studies are reasonable to pursue. Phase 4 utility studies may be performed concurrently to assess this method's predictive value in outcome studies.     

Clinical relevance of discography combined with CT scanning. A study of 100 patients

Two different classifications of discograms have been used in a prospective study of 279 injected discs in 100 patients. The five-stage classification of Adams, Dolan and Hutton (1986) showed increased degeneration in the lower lumbar discs and more degenerative changes in men than in women. Exact reproduction of the patient's pain on injection was more common in fissured or ruptured discs than in less degenerate discs, with 81% sensitivity and 64% specificity of the discogram for pain. The additional information obtained by comparing computerised tomography (CT) with discograms was minimal. Discography was found to be useful in the evaluation of chronic low back pain in patients whose ordinary CT scans, myelograms and flexion-extension radiographs were normal. In spondylolysis and spondylolisthesis, discography can disclose whether fusion needs to be extended above the lytic level, and it may show if the pain in patients who have had posterolateral fusion is discogenic. Thus, discography gives information which is useful in deciding whether to operate on patients with chronic low back pain.     

Comparison of discographic findings in asymptomatic subject discs and the negative discs of chronic LBP patients: can discography distinguish asymptomatic discs among morphologically abnormal discs?

BACKGROUND CONTEXT: Lumbar discography has been widely used for evaluating discogenic low back pain (LBP). Comparison of pain responses from suspected symptomatic discs with pain responses from asymptomatic negative discs is routine. However, the ability of discography to distinguish asymptomatic morphologically abnormal discs from those that are symptomatic has been understudied. In addition, the discographic characteristics of negative discs in patients with chronic discogenic LBP have not been reported. Criteria for negative morphologically abnormal discs may be valuable for excluding discs from further treatment and examination. PURPOSE: To determine if discography can distinguish asymptomatic discs among morphologically abnormal discs in patients with suspected chronic discogenic LBP and establish the standard characteristics of negative discs. STUDY DESIGN/SETTING: Prospective, experimental with control group. PATIENT SAMPLE: Fifty-five discs from a control group of 16 healthy volunteers without current back pain (11 men, 5 women, 32-61 years of age, mean age: 47 years) and 282 discs from a patient group of 90 LBP patients (59 men, 31 women, 20-70 years of age, mean age: 44.7 years) were recruited. METHODS: Discography was performed using a pressure-controlled manometric technique with an injection rate of 0.05 mL/s and a 3.5 mL restricted total volume. Concordance was rated as none/unfamiliar, or familiar. Pain was rated via a 0-10 numerical rating scale (NRS). The pressure and volume at which pain was evoked and NRS pain responses at 15, 30, and 50 psi were recorded. Annular disruption grade was rated during the procedure by computed tomography discography and fluoroscopic imaging. Negative discogram required no pain described by the participant as "familiar," with no pain responses >or=6/10 NRS at pressures 相似文献   

腰椎间盘MRI高信号区的组织病理学特点和临床意义

目的研究椎间盘源性下腰痛患者腰椎间盘纤维环后方MRI高信号区的组织病理学特征及其临床意义。方法对52例经保守治疗无效、CT片显示无腰椎间盘突出的下腰痛患者行腰椎MR检查及腰椎间盘造影术。男39例,女13例;平均年龄38.8岁。选择纤维环后方出现高信号区的部分病例行腰椎后路椎间盘切除、椎体间融合、椎弓根螺钉内固定术,术中收集包括高信号区部位的椎间盘。对标本行矢状面连续组织学切片,光镜下观察高信号区椎间盘组织的组织病理学结构,并分析其临床意义。结果在行腰椎间盘造影的52例142个椎间盘中,17例17个椎间盘显示高信号区,且在椎间盘造影过程中全部呈现2或3级的纤维环破裂和疼痛复制反应。敏感性和特异性均为100%。高信号区与纤维环破裂程度分级呈正相关,说明纤维环破裂程度分级越高,越易出现高信号区(R=0.462,P<0.01)。共收集11例患者11个椎间盘,组织学研究发现对应高信号区的椎间盘组织表现为沿纤维环裂隙形成的不同程度的血管化肉芽组织,有成熟的瘢痕化胶原组织。结论症状性下腰痛患者的腰椎MRI上有椎间盘高信号区,可以作为椎间盘源性下腰痛诊断的重要征象。     

Provocative discography in volunteer subjects with mild persistent low back pain.

BACKGROUND CONTEXT: Whether discographic injections would be positive in subjects with benign persistent "backache" who are not seeking treatment is unknown. This information is important, because benign backache undoubtedly co-exists in patients with chronic low back pain (CLBP) illness that is not discogenicin origin. If these subjects had a high rate of positive discography, the high background incidence of common backache would allow many positive tests in patients in whom discogenic processes were unrelated to their severe CLBP illness. Conversely, if subjects with benign low back pain rarely if ever had significant concordant pain reproduction on disc injections, the basic tenet of discographic diagnosis would be strengthened. PURPOSE: To compare, using a strict experimental design, the relative pain and concordancy response to provocative discography in subjects with clinically insignificant "backache" and clinical subjects with CLBP illness considering surgical treatment. STUDY DESIGN: Comparison of experimental disc injections in subjects with persistent mild backache and those with chronic low back pain (CLBP) illness. PATIENT SAMPLE: Twenty-five subjects with mild persistent low back pain (LBP) were recruited for an experimental discography study. Subjects were recruited from a clinical study of patients having had cervical spine surgery. Inclusion criteria required that subjects not be receiving or seeking medical treatment for LBP, be taking no medications for backache, have no activity restrictions because of LBP, and have normal psychometric scores. To more closely approximate the pain behavior in CLBP illness, 50% (12) of the "backache" group were recruited with a chronic painful condition (neck/shoulder) unrelated to the low back. CLBP subjects, patients coming to discography for consideration of surgical treatment, were used as control subjects. OUTCOME MEASURES: Results of discography were determined using the criteria of Walsh et al.: pain response of 3 or greater, two or more pain behaviors, a negative "control" discographic injection, and a similar or exact concordancy rating. METHODS: Discography was performed on experimental subjects and control patients. Experienced raters, who were blinded to control versus experimental status of the subjects, scored the magnetic resonance image, discogram, psychometric tests and discography videotapes of the subjects' pain behavior. RESULTS: Thirteen of 25 volunteer subjects had pain rated as "bad" or worse with disc injection. There were 12 painful and fully concordant disc injections in 9 of these 25 "backache" subjects (36%). These injections met all the Walsh et al. criteria for a positive diagnosis of discogenic pain. All positive discs had annular disruption to or through the outer annulus. Of the 9 subjects with positive discograms, 3 had no chronic pain states and 6 did. All subjects with positive injections had negative control discs. In comparison, in 52 subjects with CLBP illness 38 (73%) had at least one positive disc injection. CONCLUSIONS: In a group of volunteer subjects with persistent "backache," 36% were found to have significant pain on disc injection, which is reported to be concordant with their usual pain. The presence of positive concordant pain responses and negative control discs in 33% of subjects without CLBP illness seriously challenges the specificity of provocative discography in identifying a clinically relevant spinal pathology.     

Lumbar discogenic pain

Lumbar discogenic pain in the sense of an internal disc disruption (IDD) represents a nociceptive pain syndrome with the source of pain in the innervated outer third of the annulus. Such discs anatomically appear with almost normal contours. Neither clinical nor technical assessments have any diagnostic value, with the exception of MRI which has been shown, if present in symptomatic patients, to have a positive predictive value of up to 89 % to indicate a strong correlation to a painful grade 3 or 4 fissure. However, only the stimulation of a disc (controlled provocation discography) with a subsequent CT scan is of exclusive diagnostic value. As an underlying pathomechanism, a compression fracture of the superior subchondral endplate like a fatigue fracture is discussed. In this way, a deterioration of the homogeneous intradiscal stress distribution could occur with consecutive damage to the internal disc environment and the expression of a radial fissure. The clinical picture of discogenic pain is non-specific. It does not correlate with degenerative changes. It does not differ from any other back pain. Thus, it has to be differentiated from zygapophysial joint pain as well as from sacroiliac joint pain and muscular-ligamentous pain sources. In a single study of American workers, the prevalence of IDD was 39 %, rendering it one of the most important causes for patients with a specified source of back pain.