Liquid biopsy in germ cell tumors: biology and clinical management

ABSTRACT

Introduction: Liquid biopsy is an increasingly studied approach for optimal and minimally invasive diagnostics of malignant tumors. The aim of this review is to provide evidence and discuss the utility of liquid biopsy in the management of germ cell tumors (GCTs).

Areas covered: Herein, we summarize the evidence on liquid biopsy in GCTs including serum tumor markers, circulating tumor cells, microRNA and cell-free DNA. The search of literature was conducted from Pubmed/Medline, ASCO-meeting library searching for terms ‘liquid biopsy’, ‘germ cell tumors’, ‘circulating tumor cells’, ‘microRNA’, ‘cell-free DNA’. Obtained original studies were included. Reference lists of review articles and key original articles were searched for additional original studies. We included articles published between1990 and 2019.

Expert opinion: Liquid biopsy is a minimally invasive tool using body fluids for diagnostic purposes in cancer. The established value of serum tumor markers may be already considered a liquid biopsy technique in diagnosis of GCTs. Possible near-future refinements in diagnosis of GCTs are emerging. Further information on diagnosis, prognosis and resistance is added with recently described microRNAs, circulating tumor cells and cell-free DNA. While great promise is shown, further large-scale validation is needed to incorporate these novel liquid biopsies into clinical practice.     

Current and emerging bladder cancer biomarkers with an emphasis on urine biomarkers

ABSTRACT

Introduction: Bladder cancer detection typically requires unpleasant and costly cystoscopy, a procedure potentially harmful and often accompanied by variable adverse effects. The use of urine analysis as a noninvasive method is of great scientific interest since it is enriched in tumor-related proteins, DNA and RNA which can provide a molecular landscape with multiple alterations identified in bladder cancer.

Areas covered: Current sensitivity, specificity and diagnostic accuracy of FDA approved urine-based assays are still suboptimal with none of them routinely used by clinics. The recent introduction of RNA/DNA based bladder cancer tests, some of them commercially available, establishes a promising new horizon of clinical applicability.

Expert opinion: There is growing evidence toward the use of minimally invasive ‘liquid biopsies’ to identify biomarkers in urothelial malignancy. Urine has been identified as an optimal noninvasive source of proteins, DNA and RNA; therefore, it has been identified as a type of liquid biopsy likely to soon be routine clinical practice. Cell-free proteins and peptides, exosomes, cell-free DNA, methylated DNA and DNA mutations, circulating tumor cells, miRNA, lncRNA, rtRNA and mRNAs, have been assessed in urine specimens. However, lack of well-designed multicenter clinical studies remain as important limitation, and therefore, precludes their use in clinical practice.     

The role of ctDNA detection and the potential of the liquid biopsy for breast cancer monitoring

Introduction: Recent advances in deep amplicon sequencing have enabled rapid assessment of somatic mutations and structural changes in multiple cancer genes in DNA isolated from tumour tissues and circulating cell-free DNA (cfDNA). This cfDNA is under investigation as a ‘liquid biopsy’ for the real time monitoring of patients with cancer in a growing number of research studies and clinical trials.

Areas covered: Here we will provide a brief overview of the potential clinical utility of cfDNA profiling for detection and monitoring of patients with breast cancer. The review was conducted in English using PubMed and search terms including ‘breast cancer’, ‘plasma DNA’, ‘circulating cell free DNA’ and ‘circulating tumour DNA’.

Expert commentary: Liquid biopsies through circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) enable monitoring of patients with breast cancer. The challenge ahead will be to incorporate cfDNA mutation profiling into routine clinical practice to provide patients with the most appropriate and timely treatment.     

Known epigenetic biomarkers for prostate cancer detection and management: exploring the potential of blood-based liquid biopsies

Introduction: Although prostate cancer (PCa) stands as an important cause of cancer-related deaths, a sizeable proportion of diagnosed cases are clinically insignificant. Hence, novel and more specific biomarkers to identify clinically significant PCa are needed. Liquid biopsies offer the potential to accurately identify cancer markers, including PCa. Epigenetic biomarkers such as cell-free DNA and circulating RNAs have emerged as minimally invasive cancer markers.

Areas covered: Herein, we provide an overview of epigenetic biomarkers current state based on a comprehensive review of the relevant literature in blood-based liquid biopsies and challenges/limitations of this new and growing field of cancer biomarkers.

Expert opinion: The epigenetic-based biomarkers characteristics make them attractive to the clinics and their minimally invasive assessment are a promising opportunity for PCa detection/management. The main limitations are the lack of robust validation studies and integrated approaches. Future studies would benefit from a change in focus to a ‘selected PCa detection’.     

Clinical utility of emerging biomarkers in prostate cancer liquid biopsies

ABSTRACT

Introduction: Prostate cancer (PCa) is one of the most common malignancies in men and a major cause of cancer deaths among men worldwide. Prostate specific antigen (PSA) monitoring and histopathological examination of tumor biopsies remain gold standards in PCa diagnostics. These clinical parameters are not well suited for patient stratification, predicting and monitoring treatment response. On the other hand, liquid biopsies offer a unique opportunity to easily isolate tumor-derived material for longitudinal clinical assessment.

Areas covered: In this review we focus on the clinical application of novel liquid biomarkers that have the potential to monitor and stratify patients in order to achieve better therapeutic effects and improve clinical outcomes. Enumeration and characterization of circulating tumor cells (CTCs), tumor-educated platelets, exosomes, and cell-free nucleic acids have been studied for their clinical utility in PCa diagnostics, prognostics, monitoring treatment response and guiding treatment choice.

Expert opinion: Liquid biomarkers have high potential to be used for prognosis, monitoring treatment response and guiding treatment selection. Although there is a remarkable progress in PCa biomarker discovery, their clinical validation is very limited. Research should be focused on biomarker validation and the incorporation of these biomarkers in clinical practice.     

The potential use of urine cell free DNA as a marker for cancer

Introduction: Although the role of circulating cell free DNA in cancer has been widely demonstrated, less is known about the role of urine cell free DNA (UcfDNA). UcfDNA can serve as a ‘liquid biopsy’ for urological and non-urological tumors, as it carries information on DNA from cells exfoliated in urine and from circulation.

Areas covered: We review the studies on UcfDNA as a source of biomarkers for cancer, focusing on the new techniques and the differences between urological and non-urological tumors. We searched Pubmed for articles published between 1998 and 2016 with the following key words and phrases: ‘urine’ and ‘cell free DNA’ or ‘liquid biopsy’ or ‘cancer’.

Expert commentary: Despite the few papers published on this topic, UcfDNA is an important component of ‘liquid biopsy’, a useful and non-invasive tool for cancer diagnosis, prognosis and treatment monitoring, containing a wide range of genetic information.     

The potential of liquid biopsies in gastrointestinal cancer

BackgroundLiquid biopsy is a novel approach for cancer diagnosis, the value of which in human gastrointestinal (GI) cancer has been confirmed by the previous studies. This article summarized the recent advances in liquid biopsy with a focus on novel technologies and the use of it in the screening, monitoring, and treatment of human GI cancer.ContentThe concept of liquid biopsy was first used to define the detection of circulating tumor cells (CTCs) in cancer patients, and has been expanded to other biomarkers in blood and body fluids, such as circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA), extracellular vesicles (EVs) and circulating tumor RNA. If analyzed with proper and advanced techniques like next generation sequencing (NGS) or proteomics, liquid biopsies can open an enormous array of potential biomarkers. The amount changes of target biomarkers and the mutation of genetic materials provide quantitative and qualitative information, which can be utilized clinically for cancer diagnosis and disease monitoring.SummaryAs a highly efficient, minimally invasive, and cost-effective approach to diagnose and evaluate prognosis of GI cancer, liquid biopsy has lots of advantages over traditional biopsy and is promising in future clinical utility. If the challenges are overcome in the near future, liquid biopsy will become a widely available and dependable option.     

An evaluation of current prostate cancer diagnostic approaches with emphasis on liquid biopsies and prostate cancer

ABSTRACT

Introduction: Knowledge of the complex biology of prostate cancer is constantly growing, opening the field up to new therapeutic advances. The selection of patients on the basis of prognostic and predictive biomarkers is a challenging and emerging clinical need, not yet completely fulfilled. In this scenario, liquid biopsy offers a noninvasive and attractive approach to give important information about tumor biology and eventual resistance to treatments.

Areas covered: The aim of this review of the literature is to evaluate the current knowledge and the promising value of liquid biopsy in prostate cancer. Circulating tumor cells and circulating tumor DNA identified by liquid biopsies are currently under evaluation to guide therapeutic decisions in prostate cancer management, even though practical applications of these approaches are still very limited. We examined the current areas of interest in which circulating tumor cells and circulating tumor DNA are being investigated, such as their prognostic and predictive role in response to chemotherapy or androgen receptor signaling inhibition, especially in the castration-resistant setting.

Expert opinion: As the body of knowledge on liquid biopsy rapidly grows, we need to identify which can be the real applications of this technique in clinical practice and to overcome the problems that are limiting its routinely use.     

Non-coding RNAs as biomarkers in liquid biopsies with a special emphasis on extracellular vesicles in urological malignancies

ABSTRACT

Introduction: Non-coding RNAs (ncRNAs) are important regulators of cellular signaling in tumor-related processes. They can not only be detected in tumor tissues, but also in body fluids. ncRNAs are released into circulation as cell-free RNAs in at least two ways: bound to proteins like Ago2 or packed in extracellular vesicles (EV). Therefore, they have a great potential to serve as biomarkers in liquid biopsies. This review gives an overview of the current knowledge concerning ncRNAs and EVs as putative liquid biomarkers in urological tumor diseases.

Areas covered: Literature was searched for ncRNAs including microRNA, long non-coding RNA, small interfering RNA, small nuclear RNA, small nucleolar RNA and PIWI-interacting RNA in blood (serum, plasma) and urine samples from urological tumor (urothelial, kidney, prostate, testicular germ cell, penile cancer) patients.

Expert opinion: The data demonstrate an important potential of circulating non-coding RNAs as biomarkers in liquid biopsies for diagnosis and follow-up of patients with urological tumors. To translate these markers into clinical practice, independent and prospective validation, standardization of isolation and quantification techniques are inevitable. Another task is the development of predictive ncRNA biomarkers to overcome problems associated with tumor heterogeneity and to select patients individually for systemic therapies.     

Molecular markers related to immunosurveillance as predictive and monitoring tools in non-small cell lung cancer: recent accomplishments and future promises

ABSTRACT

Introduction: The landscape of systemic treatment options for lung cancer has rapidly evolved with the emergence of immunomodulatory agents such as neutralizing antibodies targeting the programmed cell death protein 1 (PD-1) and its ligand (PD-L1). Another major breakthrough was the introduction of biomarkers, such as PD-L1 expression and tumor mutational burden (TMB), predicting response to immunotherapy. However, markers for monitoring treatment response are still lacking.

Areas covered: PD-L1 and TMB represent static pre-treatment evaluations. Dynamic biomarkers are required, along with static ones, to accurately predict and monitor immunotherapy response and to discriminate between responders and non-responders early in the course of treatment. The tumor immune contexture offers potential candidates that can be tested through the liquid biopsy approach, such as circulating tumor cells (CTCs), circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA), exosomes, microRNAs (miRNAs), circular RNAs (circRNAs), RNA splice variants, and immune cell subsets.

Expert opinion: A holistic approach combining information from tissue at the time of diagnosis and serial liquid biopsy data could lead to a novel combinatorial biomarker panel with enhanced treatment monitoring potential. Incorporating information from additional parts of the tumor-host ecosystem, such as metabolic markers and the microbiome is expected to provide added value to this strategy.     

The emerging role of non-coding circulating RNA as a biomarker in renal cell carcinoma

Introduction: Bodily fluids like serum and plasma contain significant amounts of tumor-derived circulating cell-free RNA, which holds the potential to serve as diagnostic biomarker. Consequently, liquid biopsies comprising circulating cell-free RNA might help to facilitate personalized treatment strategies for patients with renal cell carcinoma (RCC).

Areas covered: The present review provides a summary of the literature obtained by a PubMed search and covers the current knowledge on circulating non-coding cell-free RNA in patients with RCC.

Expert commentary: Altered circulating microRNA and long non-coding RNAs signatures allow for the discrimination of patients with RCC and healthy individuals. On the other hand, little is known about non-coding RNA expression in benign tumors. Cell-free microRNA expression levels may help to identify patients at risk for disease recurrence. However, accurate determination of cell-free RNAs is methodologically challenging and currently no biomarker candidate has reached a sufficient level of clinical validation. Thus, short-term implementation of cell-free circulating microRNA into clinical routine seems unlikely.     

Classifying circulating tumor cells to monitor cancer progression

Introduction: The term ‘liquid biopsy’ refers to molecular analysis of a tumor’s genetic features based on circulating genetic material in the peripheral blood derived from circulating tumor cells (CTCs), circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) and circulating miRNAs, and has emerged as a minimally invasive tool in early cancer diagnosis and disease monitoring. CTCs are believed to originate from the primary tumor and obtain genetic heterogeneity during evolution.

Areas covered: The presence of CTCs has been associated with poor clinical outcome in patients with metastatic breast cancer, lung cancer, colorectal cancer and prostate cancer. In addition, the detection of CTCs in patients with early breast cancer has been shown to represent an independent prognostic factor associated with an unfavorable clinical outcome. Moreover, the longitudinal evaluation of CTCs in patients with early breast cancer may reveal the presence of chemo- and hormone-therapy resistant CTCs which are associated with an increased risk for disease relapse and disease-related death.

Expert commentary: The molecular characterization of CTCs may provide an important tool for the monitoring and the evaluation of treatment efficacy in patients with different tumor types such as breast, prostate, colon, and non-small cell lung cancer.     

Liquid biopsy for brain tumors

Introduction: Minimally invasive methods will augment the clinical approach for establishing the diagnosis or monitoring treatment response of central nervous system tumors. Liquid biopsy by blood or cerebrospinal fluid sampling holds promise in this regard.

Areas covered: In this literature review, the authors highlight recent studies describing the analysis of circulating tumor cells, cell free nucleic acids, and extracellular vesicles as strategies to accomplish liquid biopsy in glioblastoma and metastatic tumors. The authors then discuss the continued efforts to improve signal detection, standardize the liquid biopsy handling and preparation, develop platforms for clinical application, and establish a role for liquid biopsies in personalized medicine.

Expert commentary: As the technologies used to analyze these biomarkers continue to evolve, we propose that there is a future potential to precisely diagnose and monitor treatment response with liquid biopsies.     

Extracellular genomic biomarkers of osteoarthritis

Introduction: Osteoarthritis (OA), a chronic, debilitating and degenerative disease of the joints, is the most common form of arthritis. The seriousness of this prevalent and chronic disease is often overlooked. Disease modifying OA drug development is hindered by the lack of soluble biomarkers to detect OA early. The objective of OA biomarker research is to identify early OA prior to the appearance of radiographic signs and the development of pain.

Areas covered: This review has focused on extracellular genomic material that could serve as biomarkers of OA. Recent studies have examined the expression of extracellular genomic material such as miRNA, lncRNA, snoRNA, mRNA and cell-free DNA, which are aberrantly expressed in the body fluids of OA patients. Changes in genomic content of peripheral blood mononuclear cells in OA could also function as biomarkers of OA.

Expert commentary: There is an unmet need for soluble biomarkers for detecting and then monitoring OA disease progression. Extracellular genomic material research may also reveal more about the underlying pathophysiology of OA. Minimally-invasive liquid biopsies such as synovial fluid and blood sampling of genomic material may be more sensitive over radiography in the detection, diagnosis and monitoring of OA in the future.     

Liquid biopsy technologies for hematological diseases

Since the discovery of circulating tumor cells in 1869, technological advances in studying circulating biomarkers from patients' blood have made the diagnosis of nonhematologic cancers less invasive. Technological advances in the detection and analysis of biomarkers provide new opportunities for the characterization of other disease types. When compared with traditional biopsies, liquid biopsy markers, such as exfoliated bladder cancer cells, circulating cell‐free DNA (cfDNA), and extracellular vesicles (EV), are considered more convenient than conventional biopsies. Liquid biopsy markers undoubtedly have the potential to influence disease management and treatment dynamics. Our main focuses of this review will be the cell‐based, gene‐based, and protein‐based key liquid biopsy markers (including EV and cfDNA) in disease detection, and discuss the research progress of these biomarkers used in conjunction with liquid biopsy. First, we highlighted the key technologies that have been broadly adopted used in hematological diseases. Second, we introduced the latest technological developments for the specific detection of cardiovascular disease, leukemia, and coronavirus disease. Finally, we concluded with perspectives on these research areas, focusing on the role of microfluidic technology and artificial intelligence in point‐of‐care medical applications. We believe that the noninvasive capabilities of these technologies have great potential in the development of diagnostics and can influence treatment options, thereby advancing precision disease management.     

Developing biomarkers for improved diagnosis and treatment outcome monitoring of bladder cancer

Importance of the field: A non-invasive marker for the follow-up and diagnosis of bladder cancer is highly needed. Several markers have been studied with regard to sensitivity and specificity in detecting bladder cancer. Comparison of studies is complicated by limited data on tumor characteristics and treatment details. Many studies do not differentiate between primary and recurrent tumors, nor is the performance of the studied marker assessed separately in superficial and invasive or high- versus low-grade tumors.

Areas covered in this review: The field of bladder cancer biomarker research from the past 15 years.

What the reader gain: A summary of the current field of bladder biomarker research with concluding remarks on some specific challenges in developing biomarkers for improved diagnosis and monitoring the disease.

Take home message: In general, the best new markers give higher sensitivity than urinary cytology, but specificity is usually lower. By using new markers, the intervals between follow-up cystoscopies can be increased and the detection of relapse can be improved. But to date no non-invasive biomarker has proven to be sensitive and specific enough available to replace cystoscopy, neither in the diagnosis nor in the follow-up of bladder cancer. However, new marker combinations and algorithms for risk assessment hold promise for the future.     

Improving diagnostic molecular tests to monitor urothelial carcinoma recurrence

Introduction: The high recurrence rates associated with non-muscle invasive bladder cancer require close surveillance with cystoscopy, an invasive and expensive procedure with risk of missing cancer. Finding an accurate urinary biomarker that can detect recurrent disease would represent a significant advancement in management.

Areas covered: This review summarizes the commercially-available urinary biomarkers including cytology, UroVysion, BTA, NMP22, uCyt+, and Cxbladder assays. Additionally, we review recent investigational urinary biomarkers that hold promise in bladder cancer surveillance.

Expert commentary: The quest for a reliable urinary biomarker for bladder cancer is decades-old and seems intuitive given the direct contact of urine with malignant urothelium. Beyond urine cytology, there are many commercially-available products approved for surveillance. However, none of the assays are routinely used due to lack of sensitivity and/or specificity. As such, emerging technologies, in particular the ‘–omic’ technologies have resulted in a proliferation of promising reports on novel biomarkers in recent literature.     

Liquid biopsy in newly diagnosed patients with locoregional (I-IIIA) non-small cell lung cancer

Introduction: Liquid biopsy is a promising method for the management of lung cancer, but previous studies focused mainly on patients with advanced-stage disease. As the methodology has progressed for the detection of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) and its aberrant methylation, researchers are gradually investigating the utility of liquid biopsy in early-stage patients. As a result, liquid biopsy has shown its potential for the application in patients with early- and locally advanced-stage non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC).

Areas covered: This review summarizes the utility of liquid biopsy in NSCLC and provide an outlook for future development. We focus on the role of ctDNA and its aberrant methylation in patients with stage IA to stageⅢA NSCLC, in the field of early detection and screening, perioperative management, and postoperative surveillance.

Expert opinion: Liquid biopsy has shown the potential for clinical application of early-stage patients but has not been routinely applied yet. The utilization of liquid biopsy will be promoted by improved detection methods and data from well-designed clinical trials. With the development of precision medicine, liquid biopsy will likely play an increasingly important clinical role.