Bone-like tissue formation using an equine COLLOSS E-filled titanium scaffolding material

COLLOSS, a bovine extracellular matrix product containing native BMPs has already shown osteoinductive properties. To overcome problems with risk of transmissable spongiform encephalopathy (TSE) infection, an equine derived version was investigated in this study, named COLLOSS E. Disc- and tube-shaped implants were made from titanium fibre mesh. The central space of tubes was filled and the discs were impregnated with the COLLOSS E material to assess osteo-induction. These implants and non-loaded controls were implanted subcutaneously into the back of Wistar rats. After implantation periods of 2, 8, and 12 weeks, the implants were retrieved and sections were made. Histology showed a thin fibrous capsule surrounding the titanium mesh and a very mild tissue reaction. The disc implants, loaded or non-loaded, showed no bone formation at all. After 2 weeks of implantation 3 out of 5 of the loaded tubes showed bone formation with a mean of 0.3 mm2 areas of new formed bone, after 8 weeks 3 out of 6 and 0.7 mm2, and after 12 weeks this increased to 6 out of 6 and 1.0 mm2. In the non-loaded tubes only connective tissue in growth was seen. In conclusion, it was demonstrated that COLLOSS E material, loaded in a titanium fibre mesh tube shows osteoinductive properties. The effect of COLLOSS E has to be investigated further in orthotopic sites, which resemble more the final clinical application for bone reconstruction.     

Osteoinduction of porous bioactive titanium metal

This is the first report of bone induction in a non-osseous site by titanium metal, which has long been recognized as a non-bioactive material. After undergoing specific chemical and thermal treatments, porous bioactive titanium induced bone formation without the need of additional osteogenic cells or osteoinductive agents. Four types of titanium implants were implanted in the dorsal muscles of mature beagle dogs, and were examined histologically after periods of 3 and 12 months. Chemically and thermally treated titanium, as well as pure titanium, was implanted either as porous blocks or as fibre mesh cylinders. Bone formation was found only in the chemically and thermally treated porous block implants removed after 12 months. The present study shows that even a non-soluble metal that contains no calcium or phosphorus can be an osteoinductive material when treated to form an appropriate macrostructure and microstructure. This finding may elucidate the nature of osteoinduction, and lead to the advent of epochal osteoinductive biomaterials for tissue regeneration.     

Osteoinduction of porous titanium: a comparative study between acid-alkali and chemical-thermal treatments

In this study, a slurry foaming method was developed to fabricate porous titanium, and two different surface treatments were applied to investigate their effects on the osteoinduction of the implants. Three types of implants, that was porous titanium with no treatment, with chemical-thermal treatment (CTPT), and with acid-alkali treatment (AAPT), were implanted in the dorsal muscles of adult dogs for 3 and 5 months. After implantation for 3 months, new bone was only found in the inner pores of AAPT by histological analysis and field emission scanning electron microscopy observation. After implantation for 5 months, new bone was also found in CTPT, but it was absent in AAPT. This study not only confirmed that porous titanium with appropriate surface treatments could possess osteoinduction but also showed that its osteoinductive potential was tightly related to the surface treatment. As a simpler method, acid-alkali treatment could endow porous titanium with faster osteoinduction, and AAPT might have potential in clinical application.     

Influence of the in vitro culture period on the in vivo performance of cell/titanium bone tissue-engineered constructs using a rat cranial critical size defect model

The aim of this study was to investigate the in vivo performance in bone-regenerating capability of cell/scaffold constructs implanted into an orthotopic site. Bone marrow stromal osteoblasts were seeded on titanium fiber mesh scaffolds using a cell suspension (5 x 10(5) cells per scaffold) and cultured for 1, 4, and 8 days under either static or flow perfusion conditions forming six different treatment groups. A total of 16 constructs from each one of the six treatment groups were then implanted into an 8-mm critical size calvarial defect created in the cranium of adult syngeneic male Fisher rats. Half of the constructs from each group were retrieved 7 days postimplantation, and the other half of the constructs were retrieved 30 days postimplantation and examined for new bone formation and tissue response. Constructs retrieved 7 days postimplantation were filled with fibrous tissue and capillaries, but no bone formation was observed in any of the six treatment groups. Constructs retrieved 30 days postimplantation showed bone formation (at least 7 out of 8 constructs in all treatment groups). Titanium fiber meshes seeded with bone marrow stromal osteoblasts and cultured for 1 day under flow perfusion conditions before implantation appeared to give the highest percentage of bone formation per implant (64 +/- 17%). They also showed the highest ratio of critical size cranial defects that resulted in union of the defect 30 days postimplantation (7 out of 8) together with the constructs cultured for 1 day under static conditions before implantation. There were no significant differences between the different treatment groups; this finding is most likely due to the large variability of the results and the small number of animals per group. However, these results show that titanium fiber mesh scaffolds loaded with bone marrow stromal osteoblasts can have osteoinductive properties when implanted in an orthotopic site. They also indicate the importance of the stage of the osteoblastic differentiation and the quality of the in vitro generated extracellular matrix in the observed osteoinductive potential.     

Viable osteogenic cells are obligatory for tissue-engineered ectopic bone formation in goats

In this study we investigated the bone-forming capacity of tissue-engineered (TE) constructs implanted ectopically in goats. As cell survival is questionable in large animal models, we investigated the significance of vitality, and thus whether living cells instead of only the potentially osteoinductive extracellular matrix are required to achieve bone formation. Vital TE constructs of porous hydroxyapatite (HA) covered with differentiated bone marrow stromal cells (BMSCs) within an extracellular matrix (ECM) were compared with identical constructs that were devitalized before implantation. The devitalized implants did contain the potentially osteoinductive ECM. Furthermore, we evaluated HA impregnated with fresh bone marrow and HA only. Two different types of HA granules with a volume of approximately 40 microm were investigated: HA70/800, a microporous HA with 70% interconnected macroporosity and an average pore size of 800 microm, and HA60/400, a smooth HA with 60% interconnected macropores and an average size of 400 microm. Two granules of each type were combined and then treated as a single unit for cell seeding, implantation, and histology. The tissue-engineered samples were obtained by seeding culture-expanded goat BMSCs on the HA and subsequently culturing these constructs for 6 days to allow cell differentiation and ECM formation. To devitalize, TE constructs were frozen in liquid nitrogen according to a validated protocol. Fresh bone marrow impregnation was performed perioperatively (4 mL per implant unit). All study groups were implanted in bilateral paraspinal muscles. Fluorochromes were administered at three time points to monitor bone mineralization. After 12 weeks the units were explanted and analyzed by histology of nondecalcified sections. Bone formation was present in all vital tissue-engineered implants. None of the other groups showed any bone formation. Histomorphometry indicated that microporous HA70/800 yielded more bone than did HA60/400. Within the newly formed bone, the fluorescent labels showed that mineralization had occurred before 5 weeks of implantation and was directed from the HA surface toward the center of the pores. In conclusion, tissue-engineered bone formation in goats can be achieved only with viable constructs of an appropriate scaffold and sufficient BMSCs.     

Evaluation of titanium plasma-sprayed and plasma-sprayed hydroxyapatite implants in vivo

In this study, bone interfacial strength and bone contact length at the plasma-sprayed hydroxyapatite (HA) and titanium plasma-sprayed (TPS) implants were evaluated in vivo. Non-coated titanium (Ti) implants were used as controls. Cylindrical coated or non-coated implants (4.0mm diameter by 8mm long) were implanted in the dogs' mandibles. Loading of the implants was performed at 12 weeks after implantation. At 12 weeks after implantation (prior to loading) and 1 year after loading, implants were evaluated for interfacial bone-implant strength and bone-implant contact length. No significant differences in interfacial bone-implant strength for all groups at 12 weeks after implantation and after 1 year loading in normal bone were found. However, bone contact length for HA implants was significantly higher than the TPS and Ti implants for both periods tested (12 weeks after implantation and 1 year after loading). It was concluded that TPS implants exhibited similar pull-out strength compared to the HA implants. In addition, the lower bone contact length on the TPS surface compared to HA surfaces did not affect the interfacial bone-implant strength for both implants.     

Investigation as to the osteoinductivity of macroporous calcium phosphate cement in goats

For bone formation in critical-sized or poor healing defects, osteoinductive behavior of synthetic bone grafts is crucial. Although the osteoconductive behavior of calcium phosphate (CaP) cement is generally accepted, its osteoinductive potential is less reported. In this study, osteoinduction of porous CaP cement was investigated. Four goats received each six subcutaneous placed prehardened porous CaP cement implants. Implantation time was 3 and 6 months. After explantation, histological evaluation and scoring with a histological grading scale for soft-tissue implants were performed. The histological sections revealed that the implants degraded for more than 50% over time. The implants had lost their macroporous structure from 3 months on. A medium-thick fibrous capsule with a few inflammatory cells surrounded the implants after 3 months. This capsule significantly decreased in thickness after 6 months. Throughout the implant ingrowth of fibrous tissue was seen with scattered foci of inflammatory cells. Cement particles were surrounded by a layer of inflammatory cells. The massive inflammatory response in the interstice was seen after 3 months, which disappeared after 6 months implantation. No bone formation was detected in any of the specimens. The fast degradation and thereby collapsing of the porous structure of our CaP cement implant might have prevented osteoinduction.     

Analysis of the osteoinductive capacity and angiogenicity of an in vitro generated extracellular matrix

In this study, the osteoinductive potential of an in vitro generated extracellular matrix (ECM) deposited by marrow stromal cells seeded onto titanium fiber mesh scaffolds and cultured in a flow perfusion bioreactor was investigated. Culture periods of 8, 12, and 16 days were selected to allow for different amounts of ECM deposition by the cells as well as ECM with varying degrees of maturity (Ti/ECM/d8, Ti/ECM/d12, and Ti/ECM/d16, respectively). These ECM-containing constructs were implanted intramuscularly in a rat animal model. After 56 days, histologic analysis of retrieved constructs revealed no bone formation in any of the implants. Surrounding many of the implants was a fibrous capsule, which was often interspersed with fat cells. Within the pore spaces, the predominant tissue response was the presence of blood vessels and young fibroblasts or fat cells. The number of blood vessels on a per area basis calculated from a histomorphometric analysis increased as a function of the amount of ECM within the implanted constructs, with a significant difference between Ti/ECM/d16 and plain Ti constructs. These results indicate that although an in vitro generated ECM alone may not induce bone formation at an ectopic site, its use may enhance the vascularization of implanted constructs.     

Bone inductive properties of rhBMP-2 loaded porous calcium phosphate cement implants inserted at an ectopic site in rabbits

Recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2) is known for its osteoinductive potential in bone tissue engineering. Calcium phosphate (Ca-P) cements are injectable, osteoconductive ceramic materials in which a macroporous structure can be induced during the setting reaction. In this study, the osteoinductive capability of rhBMP-2 loaded porous Ca-P cement was evaluated. Porous Ca-P cement discs were made and loaded with rhBMP-2 in vitro and implanted subcutaneously in the back of New Zealand white rabbits. The implantation period was either 2 or 10 weeks. Histological analysis of retrieved specimens revealed evident bone formation in the rhBMP-2 loaded Ca-P cement discs (pore fill: 18+/-6%) after 10 weeks of implantation. Bone formation occurred only in rhBMP-2 loaded porous Ca-P cement discs. Degradation of the Ca-P cement could not be confirmed after 10 weeks of implantation. The scaffold maintained its shape and stability during this time period. We conclude that porous Ca-P cement is a suitable carrier material for ectopic bone engineering.     

The induction of bone formation by coral-derived calcium carbonate/hydroxyapatite constructs

The spontaneous induction of bone formation in heterotopic rectus abdominis and orthotopic calvarial sites by coral-derived biomimetic matrices of different chemical compositions was investigated in a long-term study in the non-human primate Papio ursinus. Coral-derived calcium carbonate constructs were converted to hydroxyapatite by hydrothermal exchange. Limited conversion produced hydroxyapatite/calcium carbonate (HA/CC) constructs of 5% and 13% hydroxyapatite. Rods of 20 mm in length and 7 mm in diameter were implanted in heterotopic rectus abdominis sites; discs 25 mm in diameter were implanted in orthotopic calvarial defects of six adult non-human primates P. ursinus. Heterotopic samples also included fully converted hydroxyapatite replicas sintered at 1100 °C. To further enhance spontaneous osteoinductive activity, fully converted hydroxyapatite replicas were coated with the synthetic peptide P15 known to increase the adhesion of fibroblasts to anorganic bovine mineral. Bone induction was assessed at 60, 90 and 365 days by histological examination, alkaline phosphatase and osteocalcin expression, as well as by the expression of BMP-7, GDF-10 and collagen type IV mRNAs. Induction of bone occurred in the concavities of the matrices at all time points. At 365 days, bone marrow was evident in the P15-coated and uncoated implants. Resorption of partially converted calcium carbonate/hydroxyapatite was apparent, as well as remodeling of the newly formed bone. Northern blot analyses of samples from heterotopic specimens showed high levels of expression of BMP-7 and collagen type IV mRNA in all specimen types at 60 days, correlating with the induction of the osteoblastic phenotype in invading fibrovascular cells. Orthotopic specimens showed prominent bone formation across the different implanted constructs. The concavities of the matrices biomimetize the remodeling cycle of the osteonic primate cortico-cancellous bone and promote the ripple-like cascade of the induction of bone formation. This study demonstrates for the first time that partially converted HA/CC constructs also induce spontaneous differentiation of bone, albeit only seen one year post-implantation.     

成骨诱导脂肪基质细胞在骨组织工程体内成骨中的作用

背景：以往研究认为,经过成骨诱导后的脂肪基质细胞通过转化为成骨细胞分泌骨基质进而修复骨缺损,然而并没有明确结论证实。 目的：将经过体外成骨诱导的脂肪基质细胞复合支架材料分别植入骨缺损区和非骨区,根据是否成骨,验证经过成骨诱导后的脂肪基质细胞是否转化为成骨细胞。 方法：取12月龄犬背部皮下脂肪,经胶原酶消化法获得单个核细胞,将培养的第3代细胞与双相磷酸钙陶瓷形成复合物。在犬下颌骨两侧制备长20 mm、高10 mm的箱状缺损,拔除术区牙齿,将细胞支架复合物植入一侧术区,空白侧留作对照;另外在犬背部皮下肌肉区植入细胞支架复合物及骨诱导性磷酸钙陶瓷材料,术后6周及12周经组织学检测骨缺损修复情况。 结果与结论：脂肪基质细胞复合双相磷酸钙陶瓷在骨缺损区成骨,在肌肉区未形成新骨;骨诱导性磷酸钙陶瓷在肌肉区形成新骨。提示成骨诱导并不能将脂肪基质细胞转化为成骨细胞,其确切机制有待进一步研究。     

阳极氧化伴水热处理制备纯钛羟基磷灰石薄涂层

为了解纯钛阳极氧化伴水热处理的技术路线及羟基磷灰石薄涂层在体内的成骨效应，以钛片为阳极，β－磷酸甘油钠和醋酸钙为电解质，经200－400V直流电解15min，维持电流密度≤50mA/cm^2，而后经280℃－300℃水热处理2h，取光滑，喷砂表面作对照，分别植入12只兔股骨内，枯术后4，8，16周取出带种植体骨块制作磨片，观察新骨生成情况及术后8周光滑和涂层种植体的界面超微结构，并作表面能谱分析，结果发现水热处理后，钛片表面出现了羟基磷灰石涂层，动物实验显示涂层种植体8周后编织骨的转化和成熟较快，未见剥脱的羟基磷灰石碎片，其表面的钙，磷含量在种植后增加明显，这说明阳极氧化伴水热处理可以制备出纯钛表面羟基磷灰石薄涂层，其早期促编织骨形成作用明显，可以加快编织骨转化成板层骨。     

Analysis of primary bone formation in porous alumina: a fluorescence and scanning electron microscopic study of marrow cell induced osteogenesis.

Porous alumina ceramics alone and combined with rat marrow cells were implanted subcutaneously in the back of syngeneic Fischer rats. Fluorochrome-labeling was performed post operatively and the ceramics were harvested 6 and 8 weeks after implantation. Undecalcified sections of the implants were observed under fluorescence microscopy and the de novo bone-ceramic interfacial areas were analyzed by a scanning electron microscope equipped with an electron probe microanalyzer. Alumina ceramics alone did not show any bone formation, while all marrow cell loaded ceramics showed new bone formation 6 and 8 weeks after implantation. Bone formation was first observed in the center of the pores and proceeded in a centrifugal direction, leading to contact with the ceramic. These results suggest that bone marrow cells have inherent osteogenic capacity and in the pore region of alumina ceramics progression of the osteogenesis causes the dissipation of intervening fibrous tissue between the de novo bone and alumina ceramic surface.     

Human alveolar bone cell adhesion and growth on ion-implanted titanium

Surface characteristics play a vital role in determining the biocompatibility of materials used as bone implants. Calcium ion implantation of titanium was previously reported to enhance osseointegration and bone formation in vivo, although the lack of consistent and reproducible effects highlight the need to understand the basic mechanisms involved in the response of target cells to such surfaces. The aim of this study was therefore to measure the precise effects of ion implantation of titanium on bone cells in vitro. Alveolar bone cells were seeded on the surface of polished titanium disks implanted with calcium, potassium, and argon ions. Using radioisotopically tagged bone cells, the results showed that although the calcium ion implanted surface reduced cell adhesion, it nevertheless significantly enhanced cell spreading and subsequent cell growth. In contrast, few differences in bone cell behavior were observed between the potassium- and argon-implanted titanium and the control nonimplanted titanium disks. These findings suggest the possibility that the calcium-implanted surface may significantly affect the biocompatibility of titanium implants by enhancing bone cell growth. Surface modification by ion implantation could thus prove to be a valuable tool for improving the clinical efficacy of titanium for bone repair and regeneration in vivo.     

Bone tissue reconstruction using titanium fiber mesh combined with rat bone marrow stromal cells

The study aim was to evaluate the effect of bone marrow stromal cells (BMSCs) cultured in titanium fiber mesh and implanted in a rat cranial defect. A total of 24 titanium meshes were placed in a tube containing 10 ml BMSC suspension (3 x 10(6)cells/ml) and the tube was rotated on a rotation plate (2 rpm) during 3 h. Thereafter, meshes with cells were subcultured for 1 day under standard conditions. Cell-loaded implants and non-cell-loaded controls were placed in a 8 mm cranial defect and retrieved after 3, 15 and 30 days of implantation. Histology showed that after 3 days of implantation, the mesh porosity of both implant groups was mainly invaded with blood cells. On the other hand, at 15 days of implantation, the cell-loaded implants were filled for 15 +/- 10% of their volume with bone, while the controls showed 1.5 +/- 3.5% of bone. The 30-day cell-loaded implants showed 40 +/- 12.5% of bone and the 30-day control implants 17 +/- 14.5%. At both implantation times the differences were statistically significant. Therefore, we conclude that inoculation of titanium fiber mesh with BMSCs can improve the bone healing capacity of this material.     

Functionalization of dental implant surfaces using adhesion molecules

The aim of the present study was to test the hypothesis that organic coating of titanium screw implants that provides binding sites for integrin receptors can enhance periimplant bone formation. Ten adult female foxhounds received experimental titanium screw implants in the mandible 3 months after removal of all premolar teeth. Four types of implants were evaluated in each animal: (1) implants with machined titanium surface, (2) implants coated with collagen I, (3) implants with collagen I and cyclic RGD peptide coating (Arg-Gly-Asp) with low RGD concentrations (100 micromol/mL), and (4) implants with collagen I and RGD coating with high RGD concentrations (1000 micromol/mL). Periimplant bone regeneration was assessed histomorphometrically after 1 and 3 months in five dogs each by measuring bone implant contact (BIC) and the volume density of the newly formed periimplant bone (BVD). After 1 month, BIC was significantly enhanced only in the group of implants coated with the higher concentration of RGD peptides (p = 0.026). Volume density of the newly formed periimplant bone was significantly higher in all implants with organic coating. No significant difference was found between collagen coating and RGD coatings. After 3 months, BIC was significantly higher in all implants with organic coating than in implants with machined surfaces. Periimplant BVD was significantly increased in all coated implants in comparison to machined surfaces also. It was concluded that organic coating of machined screw implant surfaces providing binding sites for integrin receptors can enhance bone implant contact and periimplant bone formation.     

Histological evidence concerning the osseointegration of titanium implants in the fractured rabbit femur

Stabilization of the broken bone is achieved using biocompatible materials. Since histology is still considered the gold standard technique for the assessment of bone formation around metallic implants, this report investigated the titanium implant integration in the accidentally broken bone in rabbits. The experimental protocol was reviewed and approved by the Ethical Committee of the Faculty of Medicine and Pharmacy Oradea, Romania. Holes were drilled in the diaphysis of the femur, and titanium implants were inserted in the created bone defect. In two subjects, fractures occurred on days two and three after the metallic alloy implantation. The other two rabbits presented no fractures following the surgical procedure. The rabbits were euthanized and the bones (with metallic implants) were harvested for histopathological investigation. Following decalcification, the bone samples were processed using the standard paraffin technique and stained by Goldner’s trichrome procedure. In subjects with a perfect immobilization of the titanium implants, the osseointegration occurred with minimal callus formation (i.e. primary cortical healing). In rabbits with bone fractures, the callus was more exuberant. A progressive replacement of the granulation tissue with hyaline cartilage and woven bone occurred soon after. The former aspects suggested an indirect metaplasia in the created callus. In all subjects, no inflammatory cells were identified in the created callus. The bone regeneration occurred either by primary cortical healing (in perfectly immobilized titanium implants) or by a process similar to the endochondral ossification (in poorly immobilized titanium implants following accidental post-implantation bones fracture).     

A preliminary study on osteoinduction of two kinds of calcium phosphate ceramics.

With respect to the effect of material factors on calcium phosphate biomaterial-induced osteogenesis, the osteoinductive property of two kinds of porous hydroxyapatite ceramics, which were made by different producers, was investigated in dorsal muscles of dogs. One hydroxyapatite ceramic (S-HA), macroporous implants with rough pore walls containing abundant micropores, was made by Sichuan Union University (Chengdu, China); the other hydroxyapatite ceramic (J-HA), porous implants with smooth macropore walls composed of regularly aligned crystal grains, was provided by Mitsubishi Ceramic Int. (Japan). Different tissue response was detected histologically and microradiographically after the ceramic samples had been implanted in dorsal muscles of dogs for 3 and 6 months. Bone formation was found in S-HA at 3 months, which increased at 6 months. In contrast, no bone formation was detected in J-HA at both 3 and 6 months. These results indicate that with the special architecture, calcium phosphate ceramic can induce bone formation in soft tissue. As both materials were very similar in their chemical and crystallographic structures, but varied in their microstructures, the latter seem to be an important factor affecting the osteoinductive capacity of calcium phosphate ceramics. These data suggest that, by controlling the preparation of calcium phosphate ceramic, bone substitutes with intrinsic osteoinductive property can be developed from calcium phosphates.     

Novel in vivo method for evaluation of healing around implants in bone

A material implanted in bone is always inserted into coagulating blood. Protein and cell interactions during this initial implantation time will govern later healing. Many studies have focused on the tissue surrounding implants. We have developed a method for evaluation of healing around implants in bone by studying cells adhering to the implant surface. Hydrophilic titanium discs were inserted into rat tibiae. Samples were retrieved after 1, 2, 4, and 8 days of implantation and were analyzed by fluorescence microscopy techniques and scanning electron microscopy. Both proliferating and apoptotic cells were found on the surface. Generally, cells closest to the implant surface were nonviable whereas cells in the fibrin network a distance from the surface were viable. Bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) is an osteogenic substance. An increase in BMP-2-positive cells was seen during the implantation period, and a population of large BMP-2-positive cells appeared on the surface after 4 days of implantation. The method developed here is a suitable tool for rapid evaluation of the initial healing around implant material.     

Biocompatibility and osteogenesis of refractory metal implants, titanium, hafnium, niobium, tantalum and rhenium

To evaluate the biocompatibility of refractory metals, titanium, hafnium, niobium, tantalum and rhenium were implanted in rats, and histological observation and elemental mapping were performed by X-ray scanning analytical microscope (XSAM) and electron probe microanalyzer (EPMA). The titanium, hafnium, niobium, tantalum and rhenium wires were implanted in the subcutaneous tissue of the abdominal region and in femoral bone marrow of rats for either 2 or 4 weeks. No inflammatory response was observed around the implants, and all the implants were encapsulated with thin fibrous connective tissue. No dissolution of these metals was detected by XSAM in the soft tissue. Histological examination of the hard tissue showed that the amount of new bone formation decreased slightly from the second to the fourth week after implantation, and that the percentage of bone in contact with the implant increased markedly over the same period. No dissolution of these metals was detected by EPMA in the hard tissue. The Ca and P intensities in the mapping images of newly formed bone were higher after 4 weeks than those after 2 weeks, which suggests that the newly formed bone continued to mature from 2 to 4 weeks after implantation. These results indicate that titanium, hafnium, niobium, tantalum and rhenium have good biocompatibility and osteoconductivity.