Is MED13L-related intellectual disability a recognizable syndrome?

Introduction

MED13L-related intellectual disability is characterized by moderate intellectual disability (ID), speech impairment, and dysmorphic facial features. We present 8 patients with MED13L-related intellectual disability and review the literature for phenotypical and genetic aspects of previously described patients.

Updating the neurodevelopmental profile of Alazami syndrome: Illustrating the role of developmental assessment in rare genetic disorders

Alazami syndrome, caused by biallelic pathogenic variants in LARP7, is a recently‐described rare genetic disorder, with 17 patients currently reported in the literature. We present a case of a male infant referred for genetics evaluation at 5 months of age, found at 17 months of age to have Alazami syndrome. He was promptly referred for developmental evaluation, where he was found to be higher functioning than prior reports of individuals with this condition. This demonstrates the neurodevelopmental phenotypic variability seen in rare genetic disorders; it also demonstrates the important role of developmental programs to measure and track outcomes and provide support for infants with genetic disorders that put them at risk of developmental disabilities.     

The complete loss of function of the SMS gene results in a severe form of Snyder-Robinson syndrome

Snyder-Robinson syndrome (SRS) is an X-linked syndromic intellectual disability condition caused by variants in the spermine synthase gene (SMS). The syndrome is characterized by facial dysmorphism, thin body build, kyphoscoliosis, osteoporosis, hypotonia, developmental delay and associated neurological features (seizures, unsteady gait, abnormal speech). Until now, only missense variants with a functionally characterized partial loss of function (LoF) have been described. Here we describe the first complete LoF variant, Met303Lysfs*, in a male patient with a severe form of Snyder-Robinson syndrome. He presented with multiple malformations and severly delayed development, and died at 4 months of age. Functional in vitro assays showed a complete absence of functional SMS protein. Taken together, our findings and those of previously reported patients confirm that pathogenic variants of SMS are indeed LoF and that there might exist a genotype-phenotype correlation between the type of variant and the severity of the syndrome.     

Expanding the phenotype of Seckel syndrome associated with biallelic loss-of-function variants in CEP63

Seckel syndrome is an ultrarare autosomal recessive genetically heterogenous condition characterized by intrauterine and postnatal growth restriction, proportionate severe short stature, severe microcephaly, intellectual disability, and distinctive facial features including a prominent nose. Up to now, 40 patients with molecularly confirmed Seckel syndrome have been reported with biallelic variants in nine genes: ATR, CENPJ, CEP63, CEP152, DNA2, NIN, NSMCE2, RBBP8, and TRAIP. Homozygosity for nonsense variant (c.129G>A, p.43*) in CEP63 was described in three cousins with microcephaly, short stature, mild to moderate intellectual disability and diagnoses of Seckel syndrome. Here, we report a second family with three siblings who are compound heterozygous for loss-of-function variants in CEP63, c.1125T>G, p.(Tyr375*) and c.595del, p.(Glu199Asnfs*11). All siblings present with microcephaly, prominent nose, and intellectual disability but only one has severe short stature. Two siblings have aggressive behavior, a feature previously not reported in Seckel syndrome. This report adds two novel truncating variants in CEP63 and extends the clinical knowledge on CEP63-related conditions.     

Expanding the spectrum of KCNJ6-related disorders: Milder phenotype with pathological startle responses

Keppen–Lubinsky syndrome is caused by pathogenic variants in KCNJ6, which encodes the inwardly rectifying channel subfamily J6. The four confirmed cases reported to date were characterized by severe intellectual disability, global developmental delay, feeding difficulties, and dysmorphic features. All but one of the cases also had a severe form of lipodystrophy, resulting in tightly adherent facial skin and appearance of premature aging. Here, we describe a 36-year-old female with a de novo pathogenic variant in KCNJ6 (NM_002240.5: c.460G>T; p.(Gly154Cys)) presenting with mild intellectual disability, subtle dysmorphic features, obsessive–compulsive disorder, and an exaggerated startle response. This case indicates that KCNJ6-related disorders should be considered in patients with less pronounced dysmorphic features and milder cognitive impairment, as well as in patients with startle disorders.     

Jansen de Vries syndrome: Report of four new patients and review of the literature

Jansen de Vries syndrome (JDVS, OMIM: 617450) is a rare neurodevelopmental disorder associated with hypotonia, behavioral features, high threshold to pain, short stature, ophthalmological abnormalities, dysmorphism and occasionally a structural cardiac condition. It is caused by truncating variants of the last and penultimate exons of PPM1D. So far, 21 patients with JVDS have been reported in the literature.Here, we describe four novel cases of JVDS and review the current literature. Notably, our patients 1, 3 and 4 do not have intellectual disability albeit they have significant developmental difficulties. Thus, the phenotype may span from a classic intellectual disability syndrome to a milder neurodevelopmental disorder. Interestingly, two of our patients have received successful growth hormone treatment. Considering the phenotype of all the known JDVS patients, a cardiological consultation is recommended, as at least 7/25 patients showed a structural cardiac defect. Episodic fever and vomiting may associate with hypoglycemia and may even mimic a metabolic disorder. We also report the first JDVS patient with a mosaic gene defect and a mild neurodevelopmental phenotype.     

Novel de novo heterozygous loss-of-function variants in MED13L and further delineation of the MED13L haploinsufficiency syndrome

MED13L haploinsufficiency has recently been described as responsible for syndromic intellectual disability. We planned a search for causative gene variants in seven subjects with intellectual disability and overlapping dysmorphic facial features such as bulbous nasal tip, short mouth and straight eyebrows. We found two de novo frameshift variants in MED13L, consisting in single-nucleotide deletion (c.3765delC) and duplication (c.607dupT). A de novo nonsense variant (c.4420A>T) in MED13L was detected in a further subject in the course of routine whole-exome sequencing. By analyzing the clinical data of our patients along with those recently described in the literature, we confirm that there is a common, recognizable phenotype associated with MED13L haploinsufficiency, which includes intellectual disability and a distinctive facial appearance. Congenital heart diseases are found in some subjects with various degree of severity. Our observation of cleft palate, ataxia, epilepsy and childhood leukemia observed in single cases broadens the known clinical spectrum. Haploinsufficiency for MED13L should be considered in the differential diagnosis of the 1p36 microdeletion syndrome, due to overlapping dysmorphic facial features in some patients. The introduction of massive parallel-sequencing techniques into clinical practice is expected to allow for detection of other causative point variants in MED13L. Analysis of genomic data in connection with deep clinical evaluation of patients could elucidate genetic heterogeneity of the MED13L haploinsufficiency phenotype.     

Impairment of different protein domains causes variable clinical presentation within Pitt-Hopkins syndrome and suggests intragenic molecular syndromology of TCF4

Pitt-Hopkins syndrome is a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by severe intellectual disability and a distinctive facial gestalt. It is caused by haploinsufficiency of the TCF4 gene. The TCF4 protein has different functional domains, with the NLS (nuclear localization signal) domain coded by exons 7–8 and the bHLH (basic Helix-Loop-Helix) domain coded by exon 18. Several alternatively spliced TCF4 variants have been described, allowing for translation of variable protein isoforms. Typical PTHS patients have impairment of at least the bHLH domain. To which extent impairment of the remaining domains contributes to the final phenotype is not clear. There is recent evidence that certain loss-of-function variants disrupting TCF4 are associated with mild ID, but not with typical PTHS. We describe a frameshift-causing partial gene deletion encompassing exons 4–6 of TCF4 in an adult patient with mild ID and nonspecific facial dysmorphisms but without the typical features of PTHS, and a c.520C > T nonsense variant within exon 8 in a child presenting with a severe phenotype largely mimicking PTHS, but lacking the typical facial dysmorphism. Investigation on mRNA, along with literature review, led us to suggest a preliminary phenotypic map of loss-of-function variants affecting TCF4.An intragenic phenotypic map of loss-of-function variants in TCF4 is suggested here for the first time: variants within exons 1–4 and exons 4–6 give rise to a recurrent phenotype with mild ID not in the spectrum of Pitt-Hopkins syndrome (biallelic preservation of both the NLS and bHLH domains); variants within exons 7–8 cause a severe phenotype resembling PTHS but in absence of the typical facial dysmorphism (impairment limited to the NLS domain); variants within exons 9–19 cause typical Pitt-Hopkins syndrome (impairment of at least the bHLH domain). Understanding the TCF4 molecular syndromology can allow for proper nosology in the current era of whole genomic investigations.     

Extending the phenotype associated with the CSNK2A1‐related Okur–Chung syndrome—A clinical study of 11 individuals

Variants in the Protein Kinase CK2 alpha subunit, encoding the CSNK2A1 gene, have previously been reported in children with an intellectual disability and dysmorphic facial features syndrome: now termed the Okur–Chung neurodevelopmental syndrome. More recently, through trio‐based exome sequencing undertaken by the Deciphering Developmental Disorders Study (DDD study), a further 11 children with de novo CSNK2A1 variants have been identified. We have undertaken detailed phenotyping of these patients. Consistent with previously reported patients, patients in this series had apparent intellectual disability, swallowing difficulties, and hypotonia. While there are some shared facial characteristics, the gestalt is neither consistent nor readily recognized. Congenital heart abnormalities were identified in nearly 30% of the patients, representing a newly recognized CSNK2A1 clinical association. Based upon the clinical findings from this study and the previously reported patients, we suggest an initial approach to the management of patients with this recently described intellectual disability syndrome.

     

Okamoto syndrome has features overlapping with Au–Kline syndrome and is caused by HNRNPK mutation

Okamoto syndrome is characterized by severe intellectual disability, generalized hypotonia, stenosis of the ureteropelvic junction with hydronephrosis, cardiac anomalies, and characteristic facial gestalt. Several patients have been reported. The basic mechanism of Okamoto syndrome has not been clarified. Au–Kline syndrome is a new syndrome due to loss‐of‐function variants in the HNRNPK (heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein K) gene. A new patient with Okamoto syndrome visited our hospital. We noticed that the patient had features overlapping with Au–Kline syndrome. We studied the HNRNPK gene by Sanger sequencing, and identified a novel splicing variant. We suggest that Okamoto syndrome is identical to Au–Kline syndrome.     

Phenotypic spectrum associated with SPECC1L pathogenic variants: new families and critical review of the nosology of Teebi,Opitz GBBB,and Baraitser-Winter syndromes

The SPECC1L protein plays a role in adherens junctions involved in cell adhesion, actin cytoskeleton organization, microtubule stabilization, spindle organization and cytokinesis. It modulates PI3K-AKT signaling and controls cranial neural crest cell delamination during facial morphogenesis. SPECC1L causative variants were first identified in individuals with oblique facial clefts. Recently, causative variants in SPECC1L were reported in a pedigree reported in 1988 as atypical Opitz GBBB syndrome. Six families with SPECC1L variants have been reported thus far. We report here eight further pedigrees with SPECC1L variants, including a three-generation family, and a further individual of a previously published family. We discuss the nosology of Teebi and GBBB, and the syndromes related to SPECC1L variants. Although the phenotype of individuals with SPECC1L mutations shows overlap with Opitz syndrome in its craniofacial anomalies, the canonical laryngeal malformations and male genital anomalies are not observed. Instead, individuals with SPECCL1 variants have branchial fistulae, omphalocele, diaphragmatic hernias, and uterus didelphis. We also point to the clinical overlap of SPECC1L syndrome with mild Baraitser-Winter craniofrontofacial syndrome: they share similar dysmorphic features (wide, short nose with a large tip, cleft lip and palate, blepharoptosis, retrognathia, and craniosynostosis), although intellectual disability, neuronal migration defect, and muscular problems remain largely specific to Baraitser-Winter syndrome. In conclusion, we suggest that patients with pathogenic variants in SPECC1L should not be described as “dominant (or type 2) Opitz GBBB syndrome”, and instead should be referred to as “SPECC1L syndrome” as both disorders show distinctive, non overlapping developmental anomalies beyond facial communalities.     

Congenital diaphragmatic hernia and early lethality in PIGL-related disorder

We report on three male siblings who presented prenatally with a nearly identical combination of congenital anomalies and who died shortly after preterm birth. The first baby was a singleton pregnancy, and the other two babies were dichorionic diamniotic twins. Key features included: left-sided congenital diaphragmatic hernia, inferior vermian dysgenesis/hypoplasia, prenasal edema, cleft palate, micropenis/ambiguous genitalia (in 2 of 3 babies), bilateral renal pelvic dilatation (in twins, first baby showed slightly enlarged kidneys) and polyhydramnios (in 2 of 3). Whole genome sequencing performed on DNA from all three babies revealed homozygous missense PIGL gene variants: c.438C>A, p.(Phe146Leu). Both parents were heterozygous carriers of the variant. The reporting clinical laboratory classified the change as a variant of uncertain significance (VUS), and concluded “A genetic diagnosis of autosomal recessive CHIME syndrome is possible”. The PIGL gene has been reported to cause two different autosomal recessive conditions: CHIME syndrome and Mabry syndrome. CHIME (Zunich neuroectodermal syndrome) is characterized by ocular Colobomas, Heart defects, Ichthyosiform dermatosis, Mental retardation (intellectual disability), and Ear anomalies, including conductive hearing loss. Mabry [aka hyperphosphatasia mental retardation syndrome (HPMRS)] is characterized by severe developmental delay, moderate to severe intellectual disability, distinctive facial features, brachytelephalangy, increased serum levels of alkaline phosphatase (ALP), and recurrent seizures. Neonatal demise and lack of postmortem examination precluded assessment of some key features (including seizures, developmental delay, ALP levels, colobomas and deafness), but overlapping features observed included cleft palate, brain anomalies, genitourinary abnormalities and prenasal edema. Notably, diaphragmatic hernia is not a common feature of either condition, but is a cardinal feature of Fryns syndrome. The genetic etiology of Fryns syndrome has not been definitively established, although, much like CHIME and Mabry syndrome, can be caused by variants in glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI) anchor pathway genes. Our findings suggest further overlap between inherited GPI deficiencies, and possible expansion of the clinical phenotype of PIGL-related disorders to include prenatal presentations with congenital diaphragmatic hernia. Although reported as a VUS, we present phenotypic and familial segregation evidence that supports likely pathogenicity of the c.438C>A variant.     

Maternally inherited MAF variant associated with variable expression of Aymé‐Gripp syndrome

Aymé‐Gripp syndrome is an intellectual disability syndrome characterized by autism spectrum disorder, cataracts, sensorineural hearing loss, skeletal involvement, seizures, cardiac anomalies, and distinctive facial features. The condition is caused by pathogenic variants in MAF. To date, less than 20 cases have been reported, the majority having de novo mutations. Here, we report a patient with classical features of Aymé‐Gripp syndrome who inherited a MAF variant, c.206C>G (p.P69R), from a mother with normal intellectual function and normal hearing but with cataract and significant proteinuria. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report of a patient who inherited a MAF causative variant from a parent with normal intellect. Although the syndrome typically has multiple malformations and intellectual disability, we suggest that a mild phenotype could exist. In addition, we suggest that the basal ganglia calcifications present in our proband could be a novel finding associated with MAF variants and offer further support for the relationship between these variants and late manifestations of renal disease.     

A novel homozygous synonymous variant further expands the phenotypic spectrum of POLR3A-related pathologies

Pathogenic biallelic variants in POL3RA have been associated with different disorders characterized by progressive neurological deterioration. These include the 4H leukodystrophy syndrome (hypomyelination, hypogonadotropic hypogonadism, and hypodontia) and adolescent-onset progressive spastic ataxia, as well as Wiedemann–Rautenstrauch syndrome (WRS), a recognizable neonatal progeroid syndrome. The phenotypic differences between these disorders are thought to occur mainly due to different functional effects of underlying POLR3A variants. Here we present the detailed clinical course of a 37-year-old woman in whom we identified a homozygous synonymous POLR3A variant c.3336G>A resulting in leaky splicing r.[3336ins192, =, 3243_3336del94]. She presented at birth with intrauterine growth retardation, lipodystrophy, muscular hypotonia, and several WRS-like facial features, albeit without sparse hair and prominent scalp veins. She had no signs of developmental delay or intellectual disability. Over the years, above characteristic facial features, she showed severe postnatal growth retardation, global lipodystrophy, joint contractures, thoracic hypoplasia, scoliosis, anodontia, spastic quadriplegia, bilateral hearing loss, aphonia, hypogonadotropic hypogonadism, and cerebellar peduncles hyperintensities in brain imaging. These manifestations partially overlap the clinical features of the previously reported POLR3A-associated disorders, mostly mimicking the WRS. Thus, our study expands the POLR3A-mediated phenotypic spectrum and suggests existence of a phenotypic continuum underlying biallelic POLR3A variants.     

Tectonic gene mutations in patients with Joubert syndrome

So far very few patients with sequence variants in the closely related tectonic genes TCTN1-3 have been described. By multi-gene panel next-generation sequencing (NGS) in patients with Joubert syndrome, we identified two more patients and summarize what is currently known about the phenotypes associated with sequence variants in these genes. In a boy aged 12 years with intellectual disability and the classical molar tooth sign on MRI, a homozygous splice-site sequence variant in TCTN3 leading to in-frame skipping of exon 7 was detected. A previously described non-truncating sequence variant in TCTN3 was also associated with Joubert syndrome, whereas four truncating sequence variants were detected in patients with Meckel–Gruber or Mohr–Majewski syndrome. The second patient, a boy aged 7 years with severe psychomotor retardation, was found to carry a homozygous canonic splice-site sequence variant in TCTN2. So far, only three sequence variants associated with Joubert syndrome and two with Meckel–Gruber syndrome have been described in this gene. Reviewing the clinical data on patients with sequence variants in the tectonic genes TCTN1-3 reveals that all of them have a neurological phenotype with vermis hypoplasia or occipital encephalocele associated with severe intellectual disability in the surviving patients. In contrast, other features frequently seen in patients with ciliopathies such as nephronophthisis, liver fibrosis, retinal dystrophy or coloboma have not been reported. Our patients emphasize the usefulness and efficacy of a comprehensive NGS panel approach. A concise genetic diagnosis may help to prevent unnecessary investigations and improve the clinical management of these patients.     

EED and EZH2 constitutive variants: A study to expand the Cohen‐Gibson syndrome phenotype and contrast it with Weaver syndrome

Overgrowth‐intellectual disability (OGID) syndromes are characterized by increased growth (height and/or head circumference ≥+2 SD) in association with an intellectual disability. Constitutive EED variants have previously been reported in five individuals with an OGID syndrome, eponymously designated Cohen‐Gibson syndrome and resembling Weaver syndrome. Here, we report three additional individuals with constitutive EED variants, identified through exome sequencing of an OGID patient series. We compare the EED phenotype with that of Weaver syndrome (56 individuals), caused by constitutive EZH2 variants. We conclude that while there is considerable overlap between the EED and EZH2 phenotypes with both characteristically associated with increased growth and an intellectual disability, individuals with EED variants more frequently have cardiac problems and cervical spine abnormalities, boys have cryptorchidism and the facial gestalts can usually be distinguished.