GENERATION OF CYTOTOXIC T LYMPHOCYTES IN VITRO : I. RESPONSE OF NORMAL AND IMMUNE MOUSE SPLEEN CELLS IN MIXED LEUKOCYTE CULTURES

Mouse cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) were generated in mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC) using spleen cells as responding cells and irradiated allogeneic spleen cells as stimulating cells. Cytotoxicity was assessed by a quantitative ⁵¹Cr assay system and the relative frequency of CTL in individual cell populations was estimated from dose-response curves. Inclusion of 2-mercaptoethanol in the MLC medium resulted in a 20–40-fold increase in the relative number of CTL generated at the peak of the response. Under these culture conditions, cell-mediated cytotoxic activity was detectable in MLC populations as early as 48 h after the onset of the cultures. When spleen cells from mice immunized with allogeneic tumor cells 2–4 mo previously were cultured with irradiated spleen cells of the same alloantigenic specificity (MLC-Imm), it was found that the cell-mediated cytotoxic response was detectable earlier and reached higher levels than that observed in a primary MLC. At the peak of the response, MLC-Imm populations were observed to lyse up to 50% of the target cells within 3 h at a lymphocyte: target cell ratio of 0.3:1. Immunological and physical characterization of the effector cells generated in MLC-Imm indicated that they were medium to large-sized T lymphocytes. Altogether, these studies suggested the existence of an anamnestic cell-mediated cytotoxic response in MLC-Imm.     

GENERATION OF CYTOTOXIC T LYMPHOCYTES IN VITRO : II. EFFECT OF REPEATED EXPOSURE TO ALLOANTIGENS ON THE CYTOTOXIC ACTIVITY OF LONG-TERM MIXED LEUKOCYTE CULTURES

Mouse cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) were generated in unidirectional mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC) using normal C57BL/6 spleen cells as responding cells and irradiated DBA/2 spleen cells as stimulating cells. Cytotoxicity was assayed on ⁵¹Cr-labeled P-815 (DBA/2) target cells, and the relative frequency of CTL in individual cell populations was estimated from dose-response curves. Upon inclusion of 2-mercaptoethanol in the culture medium, it was found that significant CTL activity could be detected for as long as 3 wk in primary MLC. Reexposure of MLC cells to the original stimulating alloantigens after 14–41 days in culture resulted in significant cell proliferation and rapid regeneration of high levels of immunologically specific cytotoxicity. CTL activity in these secondary cultures increased dramatically within the first 24 h and reached higher peak levels than those found at the peak of the primary response. Furthermore, proliferation and reappearance of CTL activity could be demonstrated following each of as many as four sequential alloantigenic stimulations of the same initial cell population at 20-day intervals. Interestingly, cells recovered from MLC at the peak of the primary response on day 4 were insensitive to further allogeneic stimulation. Taken together, these results are consistent with the hypothesis that CTL differentiate in MLC to become long-lived memory cells which gradually lose their cytotoxic activity. Upon reexposure to specific alloantigen, such memory CTL rapidly regain their functional activity and proliferate to generate an expanded CTL population.     

Differentiation of memory T cells to virus plaque-forming cells and cytotoxic T lymphocytes

The aims of this study were to define the T-cell subpopulation(s) detected by the virus plaque assay, and particularly to determine whether the virus plaque assay could be used to enumerate cytotoxic T lymphocytes. In addition, studies were undertaken to ascertain whether cell proliferation was required for development of cytotoxic effector function and virus plaque formation by these subpopulations. The results of experiments with a secondary mouse mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) model indicated that 70 percent of virus plaque-forming cells bore the Ly 1 phenotype and 30 percent the Ly 2,3 phenotype. Three lines of evidence suggested that cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) can be detected by this assay: the fact that some virus plaque-forming cells (V-PFC) bear the same Ly phenotype as CTL; the use of an inhibitor of DNA synthesis indicated that proliferating cells could be eliminated with no effect on V-PFC production and cytotoxic activity of the Ly 2,3 cell population; and that infection of primed lymphocyteswith vesicular stomatitis virus before (MLC) stimulation eliminated cytotoxic activity. In primary MLC, development of V-PFC and CTL was completely abolished by cytosine arabinoside. In contrast, in secondary MLC, some CTL and V- PFC were generated by antigenic stimulation in the absence of proliferation. However, the development of both functions became progressively more susceptible to cytosine arabinoside as the time between primary immunization and in vitro boosting is increased. It is suggested that there may be a considerable disparity between the number of existing effector cells at any given time and the cytotoxic potential, i.e. the number of cells capable of being generated by antigenic stimulation.     

GENERATION OF CYTOTOXIC LYMPHOCYTES IN MIXED LYMPHOCYTE REACTIONS : I. SPECIFICITY OF THE EFFECTOR CELLS

Generation of cytotoxic effector cells by a unidirectional mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) in the mouse H-2 system was studied using labeled YAC (H-2^a) leukemia cells as targets. The responding effector cell displayed a specific cytotoxic effect against target cells of the same H-2 genotype as the stimulating cell population. Killing of syngeneic H-2 cells was not observed, even when the labeled target cells were "innocent bystanders" in cultures where specific target cells were reintroduced. Similar results were found with spleen cells taken from mice sensitized in vivo 7 days earlier. The effector cell was not an adherent cell and was not activated by supernatants from MLR. The supernatants were not cytotoxic by themselves. When concanavalin A or phytohemagglutinin was added to the cytotoxic test system, target and effector cells were agglutinated. Under these conditions, killing of H-2^a target cells was observed in mixed cultures where H-2^a lymphocytes were also the effector cells. These findings indicate that specifically activated, probably thymus-derived lymphocytes, can kill nonspecifically once they have been activated and providing there is close contact between effector and target cells. Thus, specificity of T cell killing appears to be restricted to recognition and subsequent binding to the targets, the actual effector phase being nonspecific.     

INCREASED REACTIVITY OF MOUSE SPLEEN CELLS SENSITIZED IN VITRO AGAINST SYNGENEIC TUMOR CELLS IN THE PRESENCE OF A THYMIC HUMORAL FACTOR

Unprimed mouse spleen cells cultured in vitro on syngeneic tumor cell monolayers have been previously shown to become specifically sensitized and to mediate cytotoxicity against the same type of tumor cells. This complete in vitro system of cell-mediated response has been presently used to test the effect of a thymic humoral factor (THF) upon the differentiation process leading to the generation of specifically committed lymphocytes. Culture media were supplemented with 2% THF during either the sensitization or effector phase, or both phases of the reaction. Whereas the addition of THF during both phases or during sensitization only resulted in a significant increase in the cytotoxicity index, THF added during the effector phase was ineffective. The behavior of unsensitized spleen cells and of spleen cells sensitized against nonrelated transplantation antigens remained unmodified by THF. After showing that the entire reaction is mediated by lymphocytes of thymic origin, THF was directly tested on T or B spleen cells. It was found that only T cells reacted to THF by an increased cytotoxic capacity, while B cells remained inactive after addition of THF. It was therefore concluded that THF activates a postthymic population of lymphoid cells, transforming them into fully competent lymphocytes.     

GENERATION OF CYTOTOXIC T LYMPHOCYTES IN VITRO : III. Velocity Sedimentation Studies of the Differentiation and Fate of Effector Cells in Long-Term Mixed Leukocyte Cultures

Separation of cells by velocity sedimentation at unit gravity was utilized to investigate the physical properties of cytotoxic thymus-derived lymphocytes (CTL) generated in long-term mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC). In kinetic studies, CTL were found almost exclusively in the large cell fractions at the peak of the response on day 4, whereas the majority of CTL in day 14 MLC had the sedimentation properties of small lymphocytes. Reculture until day 14 of cells fractionated on the basis of size on day 4 indicated that the small CTL were derived exclusively from cells which had been large on day 4. Re-exposure of day 14 MLC cells to the original stimulating alloantigens resulted in significant cell proliferation and rapid regeneration of CTL activity. Cell fractionation experiments demonstrated that the cells in the day 14 MLC population which responded to the secondary allogeneic stimulus were small T lymphocytes, and that these cells rapidly developed into large, highly cytotoxic CTL following stimulation. Moreover, by restimulating on day 14 fractions which were selected on the basis of size on day 4, it was found that the responding small lymphocytes were themselves the progeny of cells which were large at the peak of the response. Since CTL and CTL progenitors showed concomitant changes in physical properties with time, the possibility exists that they belong to the same cell lineage, and hence that CTL can differentiate into cells which are no longer cytotoxic, but capable of mounting an anamnestic response.     

Autologous mixed lymphocyte culture reactions and generation of cytotoxic T cells

Autologous mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) reactions were studied utilizing autologous purified B cells and autologous established B lymphoid cell lines as stimulating cells. Similar results were obtained although somewhat greater stimulation of lymphocyte proliferation was found with the autologous lymphoid cell lines. Cytotoxic T cells were not generated against the stimulating cells in either case when peripheral blood cells were used as targets. A low cytotoxicity was detected when lymphoid cell lines were used both as stimulators and target cells. However this was nonspecific and was always greater for heterologous lines than for the stimulator line. Third-party cell experiments demonstrated that the autologous reaction could serve as a proliferative stimulus for specific cytotoxic lymphocyte generation. Heat-treated allogeneic lymphocytes that alone do not stimulate proliferation ro cytotoxic T-cell generation in MLC reactions when added to the autologous system produced specific cytotoxic cells. The separation of the proliferative phase from the cytotoxic cell generation was especially striking in these experiments. Possible uses of this system for the generation of specific cytotoxic cells to other nonstimulatory cells are discussed.     

The Fc receptor on thymus-derived lymphocytes. III. Mixed lymphocyte reactivity and cell-mediated lympholytic activity of Fc- and Fc+ T lymphocytes

The involvement of Fc- and Fc+ T cells, separated on the fluorescence-activated cell sorter, in proliferative and cytotoxic responses to alloantigens was examined. The cytotoxic lymphocytes generated by in vivo exposure to allogeneic tumor cells were shown to express the Fc receptor. The proliferative responses to alloantigen exposure in mixed lymphocyte cultures was equivalent in intensity for unseparated T cells, the Fc+ T-cell fraction, and the Fc- T-cell fraction isolated from nonsensitized spleen cells. In contrast, the cytotoxic responses generated by the Fc- T-cell fraction (less than 1% Fc+) were much weaker than the cytotoxic responses generated by the Fc+ T-cell fraction (80-90% Fc+), and the responses of the Fc+ T-cell fraction were generally weaker than, or equal to the responses of unseparated T cells (Fc- T less than Fc+ T less than or equal to unseparated T). Mixtures of the Fc- and Fc+ T-cell fractions mounted stronger cytotoxic responses than the sum of the responses of either fraction alone. Examination of the Ly phenotypes of the synergizing populations revealed that the CL precursor activity (Ly-2+ T cells) resided in the Fc- T-cell population, and that the amplifier T-cell activity (Ly-1+ T cells) resided in the Fc+ T-cell population. The data are discussed in terms of T-cell heterogeneity, differentiation, and intercellular interaction.     

Killer cells: a functional comparison between natural, immune T-cell and antibody-dependent in vitro systems

Previous reports have shown that spleen cells from nonimmune adult mice of certain strains do regularly kill Moloney leukemia virus-induced lymphomas in short-term 51Cr release assays. This naturally occuring killer (NK) cell had low adherent properties and had the morphological appearance of a lymphocyte. Still it lacked surface characteristics of mature T or B lymphocytes. In the present report a functional study was carried out, comparing in parallel the NK system, the T-cell killing across an H-2 barrier (anti-P815), and the antibody-dependent cell-mediated chicken red blood cell (CRBC) system. In contrast to the effector cells in the CRBC system, the NK cells were insensitive to erythrocyte antibody complement (EAC) rosette depletion and would pass through nylon wool columns. NK activity was not inhibited by the presence of heat-aggregated human or mouse gamma globulin, in contrast to the strong inhibition noted in the CRBC system. Sensitivity to trypsin pretreatment was noted in the NK system as well as in the immune P815 system, whereas the CRBC system was relatively trypsin resistant. Antitheta plus complement eliminated the anti-P815 activity, but did not touch the NK activity. The present results thus further distinguish the NK cell from cytotoxic T lymphocytes or from antibody-dependent killer cells.     

Emergence of insulin receptors upon alloimmune T cells in the rat.

Insulin, as well as other ligands which increase intracellular guanosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate (cGMP), augments thymic-derived (T)- lymphocyte effector activity as revealed by alloimmune lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity. The observation that insulin binds only to monocytes among circulating nonimmune human mononuclear cells fosterd reexamination of the mechanism by which insulin augments T-lymphocyte function. This report concerns a test of the hypothesis that the T cell is directly affected by insulin and that an insulin receptor emerges upon T lymphocytes consequent to immune activation. Spleens were removed from rats skin grafted across a major histocompatibility barrier. Lymphocytes were harvested from Ficoll-Hypaque density gradients and subsequently enriched for T cells by passage over one or two nylon wool columns. This population was composed of more than 98% T cells as assessed by surface marker techniques (Ig staining, erythrocyte antibody, and erythrocyte antibody complement rosetting, anti-T staining). There was no loss of augmentation of lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity induced by insulin, carbamycholine, and 8-bromo-cGMP in the purified cells when compared to unfractionated cells 7 days after transplantation. 125I-insulin bound saturably to the allostimulated T-enriched lymphocytes with maximum binding at 12.8 +/- 0.2 pg and a dissociation constant at equilibrium of 1.3 nM. In contrast, insulin receptors were not present on nonimmune T-enriched cells or on T cells from animals that received syngeneic grafts. The affinity of the lymphocyte insulin receptor was similar to that of more conventional insulin-sensitive tissues e.g., liver, adipocyte. After 89% of T cells from spleens on day 7 were lysed with anti-thy 1.1 antibody and complement, the ability to measure specific insulin binding was lost. These data confirm a physiologic role for insulin in T-lymphocyte effector function and describe the emergence of insulin receptors concomitant with cell sensitivity to ligand. Such receptors may play a role in hormonal modulation of the immune response.     

A clone-specific monoclonal antibody that inhibits cytolysis of a cytolytic T cell clone

Monoclonal antibody 384.5 specifically inhibited cytolysis of P-815 target cells by cloned L3 cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) effector cells. The lytic activity of other cloned CTL that have other distinct specificities was not affected. Antibody 384.5 did not inhibit the cytolytic activity of bulk populations of C57BL/6 mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) cells. Concanavalin A-facilitated cytolysis by T cell clone L3 but not T cell clone B18 was inhibited by antibody 384.5, whereas phytohemagglutinin-facilitated cytolysis by L3 cells was not strongly inhibited. Antibody 384.5 binds specifically to L3 cells but not to several other T lymphocytes clones, or to a detectable portion of populations of primary MLC cells, normal spleen, thymus, lymph node, or bone marrow cells. In contrast, C57BL/6 anti-B10.A(5R) secondary MLC cells (genetically enriched for reactivity against the H-2Dd region gene products) contained a small population which reacted with the antibody 384.5. The determinant detected by antibody 384.5 was susceptible to trypsin treatment, and was reexpressed after overnight incubation. These results suggest that the monoclonal antibody 384.5 detects an endogenously synthesized clone-specific determinant associated with the cytolytic activity of the L3 CTL clone. These properties make antibody 384.5 an attractive candidate for an antibody that reacts with the antigen-recognition site of a cytolytic T cell antigen receptor.     

SYNERGY AMONG RESPONDING LYMPHOID CELLS IN THE ONE-WAY MIXED LYMPHOCYTE REACTION : INTERACTION BETWEEN TWO TYPES OF THYMUS-DEPENDENT CELLS

The present studies have shown that two subpopulations of thymus-dependent lymphocytes may act synergistically in the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) in the mouse. One subpopulation was well represented in the young adult thymus and the other in lymph nodes. For optimum synergy, both populations must be allogeneic to the stimulator cells. Pretreatment of either population with mitomycin-C abolished synergy. Anti-θ serum abolished both MLR responding and synergizing activities of lymphoid cells. The two thymus-dependent subpopulations were both present in the spleen, and displayed different migratory patterns when injected into irradiated mice: one population went to spleens of the irradiated mice, the other to lymph nodes. The effects of anti-thymocyte serum on the MLR and upon synergy were assessed. While minor differences exist and are herein described, our overall results strongly suggest that in our experiments with synergy in MLR, we may be dealing with the same T₁- and T₂-cell subpopulations described by Cantor and Asofsky and coworkers (1, 2, 4, 5, 14) as displaying synergy in the graft-vs.-host reaction.     

Human antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity. Isolation and identification of a subpopulation of peripheral blood lymphocytes which kill antibody-coated autologous target cells.

Antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC), has been shown to be independent in vitro of thymus-derived lymphocytes, but the precise nature of the effector lymphocyte has not been fully clarified. To further study the identity of the ADCC effector cell type(s), peripheral blood leukocytes were purified by Ficoll-Hypaque density centrifugation and fractionated into surface immunoglobulin-positive [Ig(+)] and surface immunoglobulin-negative [Ig(-)] populations by chromatographic separation on Sephadex G-200 anti-human immunoglobulin columns. After column fractionations, the ADCC effector activity against antibody-coated autologous lymphocytes was predominantly and consistently found in the Ig(-) fraction. This latter population was then further fractionated, by rosetting techniques, into two subpopulations, The first was depleted by lymphocytes with surface receptors for sheep red blood cells [E(+)]and the second was depleted of lymphocytes with receptors for sheep red blood cell-antibody-complement [EAC-(+)]. Analysis of these populations showed that ADCC effector activity was predominantly a property of the Ig(-) lmyphocytes which are E(-) but EAC(+). These lymphocytes have been referred to as "null lymphocytes" and probably represent a subset of bone marrow-derived (B) cells. In addition, variable and low levels of ADCC activity were observed in some Ig(+) populations (B cells). Further purification of the null cell population by filtration over nylon wool columns to reduce the number of contaminating latex ingesting monocytes did not reduce ADCC effector activity. Isolated null cell ADCC effector activity was inhibited by either rabbit anti-human F(ab)2 or normal pooled rabbit gamma globulin, but not by rabbit F(ab)2 anti-human F)ab)2 or media. This supports the contention previously suggested in studies using unfractionated lymphocyte populations that the ADCC effector cell recognizes the Fc portion of the antibody molecule. The variable and low level of activity noted in the Ig(+) populations is unexplained but possibly due to a variable population of null cell-derived Ig(+) lymphocytes within the whole Ig(+) population. In conclusion, these experiments demonstrate that, in vitro, the major ADCC effector activity of circulating human peripheral blood lymphocytes resides in the Ig(-), E(-), EAC-(+) subpopulation termed "null cells." Since it has been noted that in certain disease states, such as immunodeficiency syndromes, autoimmune disorders, and neoplasms, the percentage of this population of lymphocytes in the peripheral blood is elevated, it is speculated that these cells, perhaps through their ADCC function, may play an important pathophysiologic role in these diseases.     

POKEWEED MITOGEN-, CONCANAVALIN A-, AND PHYTOHEMAGGLUTININ-INDUCED DEVELOPMENT OF CYTOTOXIC EFFECTOR LYMPHOCYTES : AN EVALUATION OF THE MECHANISMS OF T CELL-MEDIATED CYTOTOXICITY

Cultures of chicken lymphoid tissues were tested for their capacity to lyse ⁵¹Cr-labeled chicken, burro (BRC), and human red blood cells (HRC) in the presence of phytomitogens. PHA-stimulated cultures lysed all three types of targets, while PWM and Con A showed a "target cell specificity" for HRC and BRC, respectively. In mixtures of target cells only the appropriate targets were lysed by lymphocytes activated by either Con A or PWM indicating that soluble lymphotoxins do not play a major role in these reactions. Preincubation experiments suggested that there may be a population of pre-existing aggressor cells which only require linking to the targets by the mitogens for activation of their cytotoxic potential. Strong cytotoxic reactions were found with spleen cells, peripheral blood leucocytes, and bone marrow cells. Thymocytes were less active but could be stimulated for significant cytotoxicity, while bursal cells were generally unreactive. Spleen cells from agammaglobulinemic chickens totally lacking serum immunoglobulins and B cells with surface-bound immunoglobulins were as active as cells from normal chickens. The activity of spleen cells, from which phagocytic cells were removed was also unimpaired. These results indicate that the development of cytotoxic effector lymphocytes in mitogen-treated leucocyte cultures is a property of T lymphocytes. Although bone marrow cells fail to proliferate in response to these phytomitogens, they do have strong cytotoxic reactivity suggesting that different subsets of thymic-derived lymphocytes are responsible for mitogen-induced transformation and mitogen-induced cytotoxicity.     

In vitro cell-mediated immune responses to the male specific(H-Y) antigen in mice

C57BL/10 female mice were primed to the male specific antigen H-Y, either by grafting with syngeneic male tail skin or by i.p. injection of syngeneic male spleen cells. Primed female spleen cells, either unseparated or filtered through nylon wool to remove most of the B lymphocytes, were then cultured for 5 days in vitro with irradiated syngeneic male spleen cells and assayed against 51Cr-labeled target cells. Both unseparated and nylon wool filtered female cells displayed significant cytotoxic activity restricted to male target cells. Pretreatment of sensitized female cells with antitheta serum and complement just before assay abolished cytotoxic responses. We were unable to demonstrate cell-mediated cytotoxic responses into two nonresponding strains, CBA and B10.A, which fail to reject male isografts. The cytotoxic activity of C57BL/10 female cells was restricted to male target cells histocompatible with C57BL/10 over at least a portion of the major (H-2) histocompatibility complex. We conclude that secondary in vitro cytotoxic responses against the H-Y antigen are mediated by cytotoxic T lymphocytes, and that the H-Y target cell antigen may be specified by the H-2 complex.     

Human bone marrow lymphocytes. Cytotoxic effector cells in the bone marrow of normal individuals.

This study was undertaken to determine the capability of lymphocytes in the bone marrow of normal individuals to mediate nonspecific killer cell functions in assays of phytohemagglutinin (PHA)-induced cellular cytotoxicity, and antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) against 51Cr-labeled chicken erythrocyte target cells. Relatively pure mononuclear cell suspensions were obtained from bone marrow aspirates in 30 normal volunteers by sucrose gradient centrifugations and from the peripheral blood of the same individuals by Hypaque-Ficoll density centrifugations. At an effector: target ratio of 10:1, the PHA-induced cellular cytotoxicity of peripheral blood was 78.8 +/- 1.3%, while that of bone marrow was not significantly less at 66 +/- 9% (P greater than 0.1). At low effector:target ratios, the ADCC of bone marrow was negligible, while at higher effector:target ratios (20:1) bone marrow ADCC was 69 +/- 3.7%, which was comparable to that of peripheral blood. The lymphocytes themselves in the mononuclear cell suspensions of both peripheral blood and bone marrow were capable of cytotoxicity activity since depletion of monocytes from the suspensions by adherence to rayon wool and G-10 Sephadex columns did not remove the cytotoxic activity. Blocking of the Fc receptor on the effector cells by the addition of aggregated gamma globulin to the cultures suppressed the ADCC but not the PHA-induced cellular cytotoxicity of both peripheral blood and bone marrow, indicating that ADCC is dependent on an Fc receptor on the effector cell in both compartments. These studies demonstrate that the bone marrow of normal humans contains populations of lymphoid cells which have highly efficient killer cell capacities. It is uncertain what portion of these cells arise in the bone marrow and what portion enter the bone marrow parenchyma as part of the recirculating lymphocyte pool. These findings have relevance in the clearer understanding of the killer cell potential of grafted human marrow, as well as the bone marrow sequestration of functionally capable lymphocyte subpopulations in disease states and during chemotherapy.     

Differential effects of chlorpromazine on the in vitro generation and effector function of cytotoxic lymphocytes

Allograft rejection represents a cytotoxic response mediated to a large degree by thymus-derived T lymphocytes (1). The study of such cell-mediated cytotoxic phenomena has been greatly facilitated by the discovery first noted by Hayry and Defendi (2) and Wunderlich and Cany (3), that a natural consequence of allogeneic stimulation in an unidirectional mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) was the appearance of cytotoxic lymphocytes specific for antigens present on the stimulator cells. Subsequent studies have shown that such in vitro generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes was dependent on the proliferative response in an MLC (4), was genetically determined (5), and possibly required the interaction of several subpopulations of T cells (6). We now report that the surface active agent chlorpromazine: (a) inhibits allogeneic stimulation of the proliferative response in an MLC; (b) inhibits the MLC generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes, (c) has no effect on the recognition, binding, or lysis of target cells by already sensitized lymphocytes; and (d) blocks a postproliferative membrane-mediated event, independent of proliferation, and necessary for the MLC generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes.     

Mixed lymphocyte reactivity and cell-mediated lympholysis to trinitrophenyl-modified autologous lymphocytes in C57BL/10 congenic and B10.A recombinant mouse strains

Cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) to trinitrophenyl (TNP)-modified autologous splenic lymphocytes has been recently reported in the mouse (1). Both the sensitization and effector phases of this phenomenon were shown to be T-cell mediated. Effector cell specificity studies indicated that modification of the target cells is a necessary but insufficient requirement for cytolysis, and suggested that altered cell surface components controlled by genes mapping in the mouse major histocompatibility H-2 complex (MHC) are important in the specificity of the cytotoxic reaction (1). In allogeneic models the generation of cytotoxic effector cells has been shown to be preceded or accompanied by immunogen- induced proliferation of responding lymphocytes, i.e. a mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) (2-5), although the generation of effectors may not necessarily always be the consequence of extensive cell proliferation (5). If the induction of cytotoxic effector lymphocytes by modified syngeneic spleen cells is characteristic of sensitization with cellular alloantigens, one would expect to find that sensitization with TNP-modified autologous cells would also induce thymidine incorporation by the responding cells in the culture. The present report demonstrates that both stimulation of thymidine incorporation and generation of cytotoxic effector cells are part of the in vitro response to TNP-modified autologous lymphocytes. However, the MLR to TNP- modified autologous cells consistently appeared to be less pronounced when compared with an allogeneic MLR, whereas the cytotoxic activity of the effector cells generated by sensitization against TNP-modified autologous cells was frequently as high as that detected against H-2 alloantigens. These two components of reactivity to “modified self” are verified in several C57BL/10 congenic and B10.A recombinant mouse strains.     

The in vitro effects of Bordetella pertussis lymphocytosis-promoting factor on murine lymphocytes. IV. Generation, characterization, and specificity of cytotoxic lymphocytes

Cytotoxic effector lymphocytes were induced in cultures of mouse spleen or lymph node cells by lymphocytosis promoting factor (LPF). The LPF-activated cytotoxic cells: (a) were not generated unless proliferation occurred; (b) sedimented in the lighter density fraction of a bovine serum albumin gradient; (c) were large, blast-like cells; and (d) were lysed by Thy-1.2 antiserum plus complement and, therefore, were T cells. Neither LPF alone nor supernates from stimulated cultures were cytotoxic. Unlike the situation with concanavalin A and phytohemagglutinin P, LPF-stimulated cytotoxic effector lymphocytes required no further addition of mitogen for maximal cytotoxicity. The effector cells displayed specificity, destroying only allogeneic but not syngeneic normal cells; in the case of tumor cells, both allogeneic and syngeneic cells werelysed in the absence of added mitogen. The reason for differentiated cytotoxicity toward syngeneic tumor and normal cells is not clear but may have some relevance to in vivo tumor rejection initiated by Bordetella pertussis.     

In vitro generation of tumor-specific cytotoxic lymphocytes. Secondary allogeneic mixed tumor lymphocyte culture of normal murine spleen cells

In vivo or in vitro immunity to murine leukemia virus (MuLV)-induced leukemia cells which do not effectively produce virus, has been difficult to demonstrate. Because immunizations with allogeneic murine leukemia cells have been used to confer syngeneic tumor immunity to virus- producing cells, we attempted to generate lymphocytes, cytotoxic to syngeneic nonproducer leukemia cells, by stimulating normal murine spleen cells with allogeneic nonproducer leukemia cells in mixed tumor lymphocyte culture (MTLC) reactions in vitro. Secondary allogeneic MTLC of normal C57BL/6 or DBA/2 spleen cells effectively produced syngeneic tumor-specific cytotoxic lymphocytes. Target cells lysed in lymphocyte- mediated cytolysis (LMC) assays, included both Friend and Rauscher virus- induced syngeneic murine leukemia cells and chemically-induced hematopoietic tumor cells. Syngeneic tumor cells were lysed regardless of whether they produced infectious MuLV or expressed viral antigens gp-71, p-30, or p-12 at the cell surface. Syngeneic normal cells (thymus, lymph node, or Concanavalin A-stimulated spleen cells) used as targets in LMC assays were uneffected by lymphocytes harvested from secondary allogeneic MTLC. Several other in vitro culture treatments including secondary syngeneic MTLC and repetitive mixed lymphocyte culture stimulations were incapable of generating tumor-specific cytotoxic lymphocytes. Based upon these results, we propose that secondary MTLC stimulation of normal spleen cells with allogeneic nonproducer leukemia cells selects for the proliferation of two subpopulations of antigen-specific cytotoxic lymphocytes. The population capable of effecting syngeneic tumor cell lysis is directed against tumor-associated cell surface antigens which may be distinct from viral structural proteins or glycoproteins. The growth of these tumor-specific cytotoxic lymphocytes may be enhanced by a soluble allogeneic effect factor produced by the proliferation of the second subpopulation of lymphocytes generated in repetitive allogeneic MTLC, namely those lymphocytes with specificities directed against differing histocompatibility antigens.