Complex urethral disruptions: In pursuit of a successful reconstruction

OBJECTIVES: We analyzed the methods and outcomes of urethroplasty in men with complex urethral disruptions. METHODS: The medical records of 40 men with complex urethral disruptions were analyzed. Surgical methods were individualized according to stricture location, severity and length of the stricture, bladder neck characteristics and presence of complicating factors. Patients were divided into four groups based on the above characteristics. RESULTS: End-to-end urethroplasty performed in six patients with short bulbar strictures (<3 cm) was successful in all. Elaborated perineal repair was performed in 10 patients with intermediate (3-6 cm) strictures with or without complicating factors. Elaborated perineal repair with urethral substitution was performed in nine patients with long segment stricture (>6 cm). Abdominal transpubic repair was successfully applied to patients with rectourethral fistula or lacerated bladder neck. Success rate of anastomotic urethroplasty was 95% while over all success rate was 85%. CONCLUSION: Guidelines for urethral reconstruction of complex urethral disruptions are predicated on stricture length, location, bladder neck characteristics and associated complicating factors. End-to-end urethroplasty with stricture excision is highly reliable for short strictures for which previous operative repair have failed. Elaborated perineal repair is extremely versatile for intermediate and longer strictures with associated complicating factors. Abdominal transpubic urethroplasty is effective for patients with rectourethral fistula or lacerated bladder neck.     

Single Stage Reconstruction of Complex Anterior Urethral Strictures: Combined Tissue Transfer Techniques

Purpose

Reconstruction of most urethral strictures is possible with anastomotic, graft or skin flap procedures alone. We describe the combination of tissue transfer techniques to preserve the urethral plate and reconstruct long and complex urethral strictures in 1 stage.

Materials and Methods

We reviewed the results in 25 patients who underwent anterior urethroplasty requiring more than 1 tissue transfer technique to achieve urethral reconstruction in 1 stage.

Results

Outcome was excellent in 22 patients (88%). Seven patients with pan-urethral strictures (mean length 19 cm.) required a fasciocutaneous flap combined with a buccal mucosa, bladder epithelium or skin graft. A total of 13 patients with focally dense strictures underwent excision of the most severe portion of the stricture with dorsal reapproximation, thereby improving the quality of the urethral plate and allowing simultaneous flap or graft onlay reconstruction. Five patients with multiple separate strictures required a distal onlay fasciocutaneous flap with excision and end-to-end anastomosis of a separate, more proximal stricture.

Conclusions

A thorough knowledge of the vascular supply of the urethra allowed creative application of different tissue transfer techniques, enabling 1-stage reconstruction of complex urethral strictures. An excellent outcome was achieved by preserving or revising the urethral plate and avoiding the problems associated with hair-bearing flaps and 2-stage procedures.     

PENILE CIRCULAR FASCIOCUTANEOUS SKIN FLAP IN 1-STAGE RECONSTRUCTION OF COMPLEX ANTERIOR URETHRAL STRICTURES

Purpose

We review the applications and outcomes of penile circular fasciocutaneous flap urethroplasty in 66 patients at our institution.

Materials and Methods

We used a circular distal penile skin flap for urethral reconstruction in 66 men with complex urethral strictures. Average stricture length in this series was 9.08 cm. and mean followup was 41 months (range 1 to 7 years).

Results

The initial overall success rate was 79% (52 of 66 cases). Recurrent stenosis was noted in 7 of the 54 onlay (13%) and 7 of the 12 tubularized repairs (58%). Most recurrent strictures were successfully treated with a single subsequent procedure, including repeat urethroplasty in 5 cases and optical urethrotomy or dilation in 6. Two patients required perineal urethrostomy and 1 awaits further reconstruction. Including subsequent procedures, the overall long-term followup success rate was 95%. Neurovascular lower extremity complications developed in 4 patients after prolonged high lithotomy positioning.

Conclusions

Circular fasciocutaneous flap urethroplasty is a highly effective 1-stage method of reconstructing complex urethral strictures. Onlay repairs appear to be more successful than those involving flap tubularization. Limiting the time that the patient spends in the high lithotomy position appears to prevent neurovascular extremity complications.     

Treatment of Complex Anterior Urethral Stricture Disease With Mesh Graft Urethroplasty

Purpose

Treatment of complex anterior urethral strictures complicated by a lack of sufficient penile skin for primary flap repair has generally consisted of 2-stage scrotal inlay urethroplasty. Scrotal skin has shortcomings, most notably hair formation, diverticula and stricture recurrence from urine induced dermatitis. As an alternative, we present our results with staged mesh graft urethroplasty using split-thickness skin, which is nonhair-bearing, easier to size and seemingly less permeable to urine penetration.

Materials and Methods

Between 1990 and 1995, 20 men underwent mesh graft urethroplasty for complex strictures, most after failed urethroplasty. Meshed split-thickness skin graft from the thigh (17 men) or full-thickness foreskin (3) was used.

Results

Overall median time to closure was 5.5 months, and 6 men required revision before closure (revision of ostia in 3, chordee release in 2 and lysis of graft adhesions in 1). A successful outcome, as evidenced by retrograde urethrography and history, was achieved in 12 of 15 men (80%) with a median followup of 38 months. Five men have not undergone closure due to patient refusal (2) or because the graft is not ready to be closed (3). Of the failures 2 men had retrograde urethrographic evidence of stricture at the proximal anastomosis and 1 had recurrent stenosis of the entire neourethra by 2 years.

Conclusions

Mesh graft urethroplasty is not a panacea but it is a valuable adjunct in the treatment of complex urethral strictures, offering comparable results to and benefits over scrotal inlay procedures. In a significant percentage of cases it is a multistage rather than a 2-stage procedure.     

Traitement des sténoses de l’urètre par urétrotomie interne endoscopique: résultats anatomiques et fonctionnels d’une série de 244 cas

Objective

To evaluate the results of a homogeneous series of urethral strictures treated exclusively by endoscopic internal urethrotomy and to determine the factors that may predict the outcome.

Patients and Methods

Between 1989 and 2007, 244 patients were treated for urethral stricture. All of them were subjected to endoscopic direct vision internal urethrotomy (DVIU).

Results

34.3% of good results were achieved after the first DVIU. Mean follow-up was 3.5 years. No mortality was encountered, while the rate of morbidity was 5%. Better results were achieved in patients with short (< 2 cm) and single strictures in the proximal urethra. Mean post-operative catheterization was 2 days; a further extension of the catheterization time did not yield any significant improvement. Unsatisfactory results (65.5%) were found in patients with large urethral strictures located in the distal urethra or in elderly patients. 62.5% of the patients showed a satisfactory outcome after a second urethrotomy, while the other patients required urethral dilatation or urethroplasty.

Conclusion

DVIU is a simple procedure which does not have a high rate of morbidity and requires short hospitalization. With a steady success rate of around 75.4% after a follow-up of 3.5 years we feel that DVIU can be recommended as treatment of choice for all short, single and proximal urethral strictures, preferably in young patients without previous interventions on the urethra     

MANAGEMENT OF URETHRAL STRICTURES AFTER HYPOSPADIAS REPAIR

Purpose

We conducted a retrospective study of patients with strictures after hypospadias repair to identify factors contributing to the development of strictures and to attempt to define an optimal strategy for management.

Materials and Methods

patients with the diagnosis of hypospadias who had undergone direct vision internal urethrotomy, urethral dilation or urethroplasty were identified. The original location of the meatus, type of initial repair, subsequent procedures and outcome of the interventions were recorded.

Results

A total of 38 patients were identified. Of the 29 patients who were initially treated with direct vision internal urethrotomy or urethral dilation 23 (79%) ultimately required open urethroplasty and did well. Of the 8 patients treated with initial urethroplasty 7 had successful outcomes. Overall success, defined as asymptomatic voiding without fistula or residual stricture, was 78% at a mean followup of 6.3 years.

Conclusions

Stricture disease continues to be a significant complication of hypospadias reconstruction. Initial therapy should be urethral dilation but it should be recognized that the majority of these patients will ultimately require open urethroplasty.     

后尿道狭窄外科治疗191例临床分析

目的探讨后尿道手术方法的选择及疗效。方法回顾分析1990年1月-2006年1月本院收治的191例后尿道狭窄或闭锁患者的临床资料。术前191例均行尿道造影,62例行尿道超声检查,48例行尿道镜检查,4例行尿道磁共振成像（MRI）检查。26例患者行尿道内切开;165例患者行开放性手术,其中单纯经会阴尿道吻合术66例,经会阴切开阴茎中隔48例,经会阴切除耻骨下缘30例,经耻骨尿道吻合术18例,尿道拖入术3例。术后随访6～48个月,平均26．6个月。结果后尿道狭窄或闭锁长度为1．5～8．0cm,平均3．6cm。后尿道狭窄（尿道连续性尚存）31例（16％）;后尿道完全闭锁160例（84％）,其中闭锁段〈3cm者102例（53．4％）,闭锁段〉3cm者58例（30．6％）。手术总体成功率（最大尿流率〉15ml／s）为84．3％（161／191）,其中尿道内切开为69％（18／26）,开放性手术为86．6％（143／165）。单纯经会阴尿道吻合术、经会阴切开阴茎中隔、经会阴切除耻骨下缘、经耻骨尿道吻合术及尿道拖入术的成功率分别为97％（64／66）、79％（38／48）、80％（24／30）、83％（15／18）和67％（2／3）。后尿道狭窄（尿道连续性尚存）的成功率为94％（29／31）;闭锁段〈3cm的患者为90％（92／102）;闭锁段〉3cm患者为69％（40／58）。结论开放性手术疗效优于尿道内切开,后尿道狭窄或闭锁段〈3cm患者疗效较好。     

Internal Urethrotomy Versus Dilation as Treatment for Male Urethral Strictures: A Prospective, Randomized Comparison

Purpose

We compared the efficacy of dilation versus internal urethrotomy as initial outpatient treatment for male urethral stricture disease.

Materials and Methods

A total of 210 men with proved urethral strictures was randomized to undergo filiform dilation (106) or optical internal urethrotomy (104) with local anesthesia on an outpatient basis.

Results

Life table survival analysis showed no significant difference between the 2 treatments with regard to stricture recurrence. Hazard function analysis showed that the risk of stricture recurrence was greatest at 6 months, whereas the risk of failure after 12 months was slight. The recurrence rate at 12 months was approximately 40% for strictures shorter than 2 cm. and 80% for those longer than 4 cm., whereas the recurrence rate for strictures 2 to 4 cm. long increased from approximately 50% at 12 months to approximately 75% at 48 months. Cox regression analysis showed that for each 1 cm. increase in length of the stricture the risk of recurrence was increased by 1.22 (95% confidence interval 1.05 to 1.43).

Conclusions

There is no significant difference in efficacy between dilation and internal urethrotomy as initial treatment for strictures. Both methods become less effective with increasing stricture length. We recommend dilation or internal urethrotomy for strictures shorter than 2 cm., primary urethroplasty for those longer than 4 cm. and a trial of dilation or urethrotomy for those 2 to 4 cm. long.     

Buccal mucosal urethroplasty for balanitis xerotica obliterans related urethral strictures: the outcome of 1 and 2-stage techniques

PURPOSE: Balanitis xerotica obliterans (BXO) related strictures are complex and generally managed by 2-staged urethroplasty. We present our results with 1-stage dorsal onlay and 2-stage buccal mucosal urethroplasty for such strictures. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Between January 2000 and April 2004, 39 patients underwent buccal mucosal urethroplasty for BXO related anterior urethral strictures. The 25 patients with a salvageable urethral plate (group 1) were treated with 1-stage dorsal onlay urethroplasty using a cosmetic incision. The 14 patients with a severely scarred urethral plate, focally dense segments or active infection (group 2) underwent 2-stage urethroplasty. Outcomes in terms of cosmetic appearance, stricture recurrence and complications in the 2 groups were assessed. RESULTS: At a mean followup of 32.5 months (range 3 to 52) 3 patients (12%) in group 1 had recurrent stricture, of which 2 and 1 were treated with optical urethrotomy and urethral dilation, respectively. All patients had a normal slit-like meatus and none had chordee or erectile dysfunction. Four group 2 patients (28.6%) required stomal revision and 2 had glans cleft narrowing after stage 1 urethroplasty. Following stage 2, 3 patients had recurrent stricture, of whom 2 were treated with optical urethrotomy and 1 underwent repeat urethroplasty. CONCLUSIONS: In BXO related strictures with a viable urethral plate 1-stage dorsal onlay buccal mucosal urethroplasty provides excellent intermediate term results. The cosmetic incision described provides a normal, wide caliber, slit-like glans. Two-stage procedures provide satisfactory outcomes but they are associated with a higher revision rate.     

One-stage repair of long bulbar urethral strictures using augmented Russell dorsal strip anastomosis: outcome of 234 cases

Objectives

Long bulbar urethral strictures (>2 cm) are not amenable to stricture excision and primary anastomosis procedure, which may result in a short urethra and chordee formation. For such strictures many procedures have been advocated including stricturotomy with subsequent graft or flap onlay, augmented anastomosis, and staged procedures, which is a combination of the Russell graft. We present our 10-yr experience with the augmented Russell procedure using a ventral onlay buccal mucosal patch graft for treatment of long bulbar urethral strictures not amenable to excision and primary anastomosis.

Methods

A total of 234 patients diagnosed by urethrograms as having long bulbar urethral strictures (mean, 4.2 cm) were managed by the augmented Russell urethroplasty. The procedure included excision of most of the diseased segment (mean, 2.8 cm) and anastomosis of a dorsal strip leaving an oval ventral defect. Augmentation was done in all patients using a buccal mucosa patch graft (mean, 4.7 cm).

Results

Mean follow-up was 36 mo. Urethrograms were done at 3 wk and 3 and 6 mo postoperatively and if the patients were symptomatic thereafter. Urethrocystoscopy was performed at 12 and 18 mo. A total of 223 patients completed the follow-up protocol; the overall success rate was 93.7% with 14 (6.3%) patients showing stricture recurrence at different intervals postoperatively. Ten patients in the failure group were successfully managed by single visualized internal urethrotomy (VIU), whereas the other four patients were treated by ventral penile pedicled flap. Postoperative dribbling of urine was noticed by 90 patients (40.4%) and temporary perioral numbness in most patients; no major donor site complications were noted in our series.

Conclusion

The augmented Russell technique is beneficial for long bulbar urethral strictures; 93.7% of the patients were stricture free. In the bulbar region, both ventral and dorsal onlays are applicable with nearly equal success rates. The buccal mucosa patch graft offers excellent material for augmentation.     

Posterior urethroplasty in children

A series of 33 posterior urethral strictures in children is presented. The etiology was traumatic in 31 cases and iatrogenic in 2. Complex strictures were treated by a transpubic approach (20 cases) or by a posterior scroto-urethral inlay (1 case). Simple strictures were directly treated via the perineum: by a push-in technique (6 cases); by end-to-end anastomosis (3 cases); by a skin pedicled tube urethroplasty (1 case); by free skin graft (1 case), and by endoscopic urethrotomy (1 case). The use of omentum, employed in 19 cases, is considered a necessary step in transpubic urethroplasty. Favorable results were observed in 18 out of 20 transpubic procedures, in 8 out of 9 perineal urethroplasties and in 3 out of 4 other techniques, with an overall success rate of 87.8%.     

Reconstruction of Membranous Urethral Strictures

Purpose of Review

Due to the proximity of the rhabdosphincter and cavernous nerves to the membranous urethra, reconstruction of membranous urethral stricture implies a risk of urinary incontinence and erectile dysfunction. To avoid these complications, endoscopic management of membranous urethral strictures is traditionally favored, and bulboprostatic anastomosis is reserved as the main classical approach for open reconstruction of recalcitrant membranous urethral stricture. The preference for the anastomotic urethroplasty among reconstructive urologists is likely influenced by the familiarity and experience with trauma-related injuries. We review the literature focusing on the anatomy of membranous urethra and on the evolution of treatments for membranous urethral strictures.

Recent Findings

Non-traumatic strictures affecting bulbomembranous urethra are typically sequelae of instrumentation, transurethral resection of the prostate, prostate cancer treatment, and pelvic irradiation. Being a different entity from trauma-related injuries where urethra is not in continuity, a new understanding of membranous urethral anatomy is necessary for the development of novel reconstruction techniques. Although efficacious and durable to achieve urethral patency, classical bulboprostatic anastomosis carries a risk of de-novo incontinence and impotence. Newer and relatively less invasive reconstructive alternatives include bulbar vessel-sparing intra-sphincteric bulboprostatic anastomosis and buccal mucosa graft augmented membranous urethroplasty techniques. The accumulated experience with these techniques is relatively scarce, but several published series present promising results. These approaches are especially indicated in patients with previous transurethral resection of the prostate in which sparing of rhabdosphincter and the cavernous nerves is important in attempt to preserve continence and potency. Additionally, introduction of buccal mucosa onlay grafts could be especially beneficial in radiation-induced strictures to avoid transection of the sphincter in continent patients, and to preserve the blood supply to the urethra for incontinent patients who will require artificial urinary sphincter placement. The evidence regarding erectile functional outcomes is less solid and this item should be furtherly investigated.

     

Perineal anastomotic urethroplasty for managing post-traumatic urethral strictures in children: the long-term outcome

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the long‐term results of one‐stage perineal anastomotic urethroplasty for post‐traumatic paediatric urethral strictures.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Thirty‐five boys who had a perineal anastomotic urethroplasty for post‐traumatic bulbous or posterior urethral strictures between 1991 and 2003 were analysed retrospectively. Patients were followed up for a mean (range) of 46 (6–132) months by a history, urinary flow rate estimate, retrograde urethrography and voiding cysto‐urethrography.

RESULTS

The mean (range) age of the patients was 11.9 (6–18) years. The estimated radiographic stricture length before surgery was 2.6 (1–5) cm. The perineal anastomotic repair was successful in 31 of 35 (89%) patients. All treatment failures were at the anastomosis and were within the first year. Failed repairs were successfully managed endoscopically in two patients and by repeat perineal anastomotic repair in the remaining two, giving a final success rate of 100%. All boys are continent except two who had early stress incontinence, and that resolved with time. There was no chordee, penile shortening or urethral diverticula during the follow‐up.

CONCLUSIONS

The overall success of a one‐stage perineal anastomotic repair of post‐traumatic urethral strictures in boys is excellent, with minimal morbidity. Substitution urethroplasty or abdomino‐perineal repair should be reserved for the occasional patients with concomitant anterior urethral stricture disease or a complex posterior urethral stricture, respectively.

     

DORSAL ONLAY GRAFT URETHROPLASTY USING PENILE SKIN OR BUCCAL MUCOSA IN ADULT BULBOURETHRAL STRICTURES

Purpose

Preputial skin graft is used routinely for urethral reconstruction in patients with stricture disease. Alternative donor sites include extrapenile skin, bladder mucosa and buccal mucosa. Recently buccal mucosa graft has been suggested when local epithelial tissue is not available. We describe our experience with 37 patients undergoing 1-stage correction of bulbar urethral stricture using a penile skin (31) or buccal mucosa (6) graft.

Materials and Methods

In 37 patients with bulbar urethral strictures a nontubularized dorsal onlay graft was used for urethral reconstruction. A preputial skin graft was used in 31 patients and a buccal mucosa graft in 6 with a paucity of local skin. Buccal mucosa graft length ranged from 2.5 to 5 cm. (average 4) and preputial skin graft was 2.5 to 12 cm. long (average 4.7). A dorsal approach to the urethral lumen was used in all patients who underwent onlay graft urethroplasty.

Results

Mean followup was 21.5 months for all 37 patients, 23 months for 31 treated with preputial skin graft and 13.5 months for 6 treated with buccal mucosa graft. The clinical outcomes were considered a failure anytime postoperative instrumentation was needed, including dilatation. In the series 34 cases (92%) were classified as a success and 3 (8%) as failure.

Conclusions

Onlay graft urethroplasty provided excellent results in 92% of adults with bulbourethral stricture. The dorsal approach to the urethra allowed the use of foreskin or buccal mucosa graft for reconstruction of the adequate urethral lumen.     

Management of adult anterior urethral stricture disease: nationwide survey among urologists in the Netherlands

Background

Adult anterior urethral stricture disease is most often treated with dilatation or direct vision internal urethrotomy (DVIU). Although evidence suggests that anastomotic urethroplasty for short bulbar strictures is more efficient and cost effective in the long term, no consensus exists. It is unclear by whom and how often urethroplasties are performed in The Netherlands and how results are being evaluated.

Objective

To determine national practice patterns on management of anterior urethral strictures among Dutch urologists. This information will help to define the nationwide need for training in urethral surgery.

Design, setting, and participants

We conducted a 16-question survey among all 323 Dutch urologists.

Results and limitations

The response rate was 74%. DVIU was practised by 97% of urologists. Urethroplasty was performed at least once yearly by 23%, with 6% performing more than five urethroplasties annually. In the group of urologists younger than 50 yr of age, 13% performed urethroplasty, with 3% of those performing more than five annually. In the case of a 3.5-cm-long bulbar stricture, DVIU was preferred by 49% of responders. Even after two recurrences, 20% continued to manage a 1-cm-long bulbar stricture endoscopically. Of responders, 79% believed that urethroplasty should be proposed only after a failed endoscopic attempt. Diagnostic workup and evaluation of success varied greatly.

Conclusions

Most Dutch urologists believe that urethroplasty is an option only after failed DVIU. Endoscopic procedures are widely used, even when the risk of recurrence is virtually 100%. The definition of success is hampered by nonstandardised methods of follow-up. Only a small group of mainly older urologists frequently performs urethroplasties. Training programmes seem necessary to guarantee a high standard of care for stricture disease in The Netherlands. A pan-European practice survey might be interesting to clarify the need for centralised fellowship programmes.     

Result of suprapubic cystostomy only as primary management of posterior urethral rupture following pelvic fracture

Forty-five patients with posterior urethral injury following pelvic fractures were managed by suprapubic cystostomy alone as primary management. Simultaneous voiding cystourethrogram with retrograde urethrogram six weeks later revealed non-obliterative stricture in eight and total block in 36. Impotence was seen in 20 patients. Eight patients with non-obliterative stricture responded to optical internal urethrotomy. Out of 36 total block, 30 had long strictures in the posterior urethra and required transpubic urethroplasty. Impotence was not affected by transpubic urethroplasty.     

Endoscopic Evaluation and Treatment of Anastomotic Strictures After Radical Retropubic Prostatectomy

Purpose

We describe endoscopic findings and treatment outcome in 17 men who presented with a symptomatic anastomotic stricture after radical prostatectomy.

Materials and Methods

Endoscopic evaluation revealed an immature stricture in 6 men, which was treated by initial dilation and subsequent cold-knife urethrotomy. The 11 men with a mature anastomic stricture were treated by initial cold-knife urethrotomy (10) or dilation followed by urethrotomy (1).

Results

There were no long-term complications from treatment, which was successful in 15 of the 17 men (88 percent).

Conclusions

Initial dilation with subsequent urethrotomy for immature or initial urethrotomy for mature anastomotic strictures is a safe and effective treatment plan.     

Internal urethrotomy and intraurethral submucosal injection of triamcinolone in short bulbar urethral strictures

Objectives

In clinical practice, internal urethrotomy is an easy procedure and is offered as a first modality for treatment of short urethral strictures. Internal urethrotomy refers to any procedure that opens the stricture by incising or ablating it transurethrally. The most common complication of internal urethrotomy is stricture recurrence. The curative success rate of internal urethrotomy is approximately 20%. Triamcinolone has antifibroblast and anticollagen properties. This study evaluated the efficacy of triamcinolone in the prevention of anterior urethral stricture recurrence after internal urethrotomy.

Methods

Fifty male patients with anterior urethral stricture were randomized to undergo internal urethrotomy with or without urethral submucosal injection of triamcinolone. Using general anesthesia urethrotomy was performed. Triamcinolone (40 mg) was injected submucosally at the urethrotomy site in 25 patients. The patients were followed for at least 12 months and the stricture recurrence rate was compared between the two groups.

Results

23 patients in the triamcinolone group and 22 in the control group completed the study. There were no significant differences in the baseline characteristics of the patients or the etiology of the stricture between the two groups. Mean follow-up time was 13.7 ± 5.5 months (range: 1–25 months). Urethral stricture recurred in five patients (21.7%) in the triamcinolone group and in 11 patients (50%) in the control group (P = 0.04).

Conclusions

Injection of triamcinolone significantly reduced stricture recurrence after internal urethrotomy. Further investigations are warranted to confirm its efficacy and safety.     

One-Stage Anterior Urethroplasty

Purpose

A deficient urethral segment was replaced with penile skin during a 1-stage procedure in patients with a long, tight urethral stricture, multiple attempts at hypospadias repair or severe hypospadias and circumcision.

Materials and Methods

In 29 patients a pedicled circumferential strip of distal penile skin was used to construct a neourethral floor. The roof was formed by regeneration of the epithelium from the edges of the floor over Buck's fascia. In our series the urethra was reconstructed because of an anterior urethral stricture in 11 patients, multiple failed hypospadias repairs in 6 and severe hypospadias with circumcision in 12.

Results

A neourethra of sufficient caliber and length was constructed with minimal postoperative complications in all patients. There were 2 cases of urethrocutaneous fistula at the subcoronal region, 1 meatal stenosis, 1 persistent chordee and 1 small distal penile skin patch slough that required only prolonged dressings. Mean followup was 19 months.

Conclusion

Our urethroplasty technique can be used to correct various types of anterior urethral stricture or hypospadias associated with insufficient penile or preputial skin.     

What is the Best Technique for Urethroplasty?

Context

There is no clear evidence that determines which type of urethroplasty to perform under which particular circumstance.

Objective

To review the options for urethroplasty at different sites in the urethra and for different types of stricture indicating which procedure should be used in which circumstances according to the best available evidence.

Evidence acquisition

Recent publications have been reviewed and supplemented with the authors’ personal experience.

Evidence synthesis

Currently, in the developed world, the most common types of stricture are relatively short and are situated in the bulbar urethra. There is good evidence that these are best treated by excision and end-to-end anastomosis if they are short enough or by patch urethroplasty using a buccal mucosal graft if they are longer.Distal penile urethral strictures are the next most common type of stricture, but the evidence base is weaker, although there is agreement that penile strictures due to lichen sclerosus often require a staged approach to reconstruction, again using buccal mucosal grafts.Urethroplasty for pelvic fracture urethral injury is an altogether different type of technique for an altogether different type of pathology. There is good evidence that this is best treated by bulbo-prostatic anastomotic urethroplasty.Other types of strictures and salvage surgery have no good evidence base and are specialised areas where experience and judgement are necessary.

Conclusions

The evidence base for urethral surgery has been developed for the more common types of urethral strictures in the last 20 yr, but it is still as much an art as it is a science.