Adaptation of dental plaque to metabolise maltitol compared with other sweeteners

There is some evidence that plaque can adapt to regular exposure to some bulk sweeteners, leading to increased metabolism and acidogenic potential of the sweetener. This potential for adaptation varies between non-sugar sweeteners and has important implications for manufacturers of food, confectionery and medicines used long-term. Maltitol (99% purity crystalline D-maltitol) is a relatively newly approved non-sugar sweetener and appears to have potentially good dental properties. OBJECTIVES: To compare plaque adaptation to pure sucrose, sorbitol, xylitol or maltitol and the effect of their prolonged use on acid production by plaque from sucrose, in vivo. METHODS: Two series of plaque pH experiments were carried out. Each experiment involved a 14 day adaptive period when four 5 g lozenges of the sweetener were taken between meals each day. Each experiment was separated by a 14 day wash-out period. Acid production was quantified as: (a) minimum pH; and (b) cH area (difference between plaque pH curve and resting value, expressed as cH units). RESULTS: Thirteen adults, of mean age 41 years completed the study. When adaptation of dental plaque to the metabolism of sweeteners was compared, there was a statistically significant difference (p = 0.033) between xylitol and sorbitol, and between xylitol and sucrose but not between xylitol and maltitol. When the effect of prolonged use of sweeteners on acid production after sucrose rinsing was compared, there were no statistically significant differences between the sweeteners. CONCLUSION: Dental plaque does not adapt to metabolise xylitol or maltitol following prolonged exposure over 14 days.     

Dental plaque formation and salivary mutans streptococci in schoolchildren after use of xylitol-containing chewing gum

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of a fixed daily dose of xylitol on mutans streptococci in saliva and the amount of visible dental plaque. A second aim was to explore if the possible effects differed between children with and without caries experience. METHODS: The study was designed as a double-blind randomized controlled trial with two parallel arms. All pupils (n=149) in grades 1-6 in a comprehensive school in northern Sweden were invited, and 128 children (mean age=12.7 years) consented to participate. The children were stratified as having caries experience (DMFS/dmfs>or=1) or not before the random allocation to a test or control group. The control group (A) was given two pellets containing sorbitol and maltitol three times daily for 4 weeks, and the test group (B) received corresponding pellets with xylitol as single sweetener (total dose=6.18 g day). Clinical scoring and saliva samples were collected at baseline and immediately after the test period. The outcome measures were visible plaque index, salivary mutans streptococci counts and salivary lactic acid production. RESULTS: The amount of visible plaque was significantly reduced in both groups after 4 weeks (P<0.05). Likewise, the sucrose-induced lactic acid formation in saliva diminished in both groups (P<0.05). The proportion of mutans streptococci decreased significantly in the test group compared to baseline, but not in the control group (P<0.05). The alterations in the test group seemed most prominent among children without previous caries experience. CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest that chewing gum with xylitol or sorbitol/maltitol can reduce the amount of dental plaque and acid production in saliva in schoolchildren, but only the xylitol-containing gum may also interfere with the microbial composition.     

The effect of sweeteners on acid production in plaque

In studies of the pH response of dental plaque in situ to rinses with conventional sugars, glucose and maltose give similar falls in pH, and fructose only slightly smaller effects compared with sucrose. Lactose and galactose are less acidogenic, while the pH response to glucose syrups varies according to their composition. Of the sugar alcohols, sorbitol, mannitol, maltitol and lactitol are all slowly fermented to acid by oral bacterial, and xylitol is virtually non-fermentable. Acid formation in plaque by fermentable sugar alcohols can be too slow to overcome the buffering power of plaque and saliva and plaque pH can rise following exposure to these compounds. Lycasin, a synthetic sweetener containing sorbitol, maltitol and some higher sugar alcohols gives effects similar to its major constituents. Palatinit, L-sorbose and trichlorogalactosucrose are of low acidogenicity, but coupling sugar is more fermentable and can give rise to a substantial pH response, albeit less than sucrose. Non-nutritive intense sweeteners may affect plaque pH by their sialogogue effects.     

Microbiological aspects of some caloric sugar substitutes

Several caloric sugar substitutes are available today, e.g. maltitol, Lycasin, sorbitol, xylitol, palatinit, sorbose, coupling sugar, palatinose, fructose and invert sugar. When evaluating the cariogenicity of these sugar substitutes from a bacteriological point of view, different analytical procedures should be considered. In vitro studies on the capacity of pure oral bacterial strains and dental plaque material to decompose the substitute to acid. Studies on the catabolism of the substitute. Possible adaptation of the oral microflora to metabolize the substitute in vivo as well as in vitro. Studies on any inhibitory effect of the substitute on the microbial activities in dental plaque and on the oral microflora. The capacity of oral bacteria, e.g. Streptococcus mutans, to induce caries in animal experiments should also be considered. Results from such microbiological studies make it possible to classify the caloric sugar substitutes into different groups. The first, most suitable, group seems to consist of xylitol and sorbose. These substitutes are fermented by few oral bacteria and no negative adaptation of the oral flora has been observed. A reducing effect upon dental plaque formation and on acid production from glucose has been reported. A second group consists of maltitol, palatinite, palatinose, sorbitol and Lycasin. These substitutes are fermented by certain groups of organisms within the oral genera Actinomyces, Lactobacillus and Streptococcus. Adaptation of oral bacteria to palatinose and to sorbitol, resulting in a more pronounced acid production, has been observed. No inhibitory effects have been reported. The results from experimental studies suggest that these sugar substitutes have no or little cariogenic action in rodents inoculated with S. mutans.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Acid production from Lycasin, maltitol, sorbitol and xylitol by oral streptococci and lactobacilli.

The acid production from maltitol was compared with the acid production from hydrogenated starch hydrolysate (Lycasin), sorbitol and xylitol by a number of oral strains and reference strains of Streptococcus mutans, S. sanguis, S. salivarius, S. mitior, S. milleri, S. faecalis, S. faecium, S. avium, Lactobacillus casei and L. salivarius. The polyols were added to a final concentration of 1.0% to two different basal media. Incubation was performed at 37 degrees C for 7 days after which the pH was recorded. Maltitol was fermented only by the lactobacilli (about two thirds of the strains). Lycasin was fermented by all strains of S. faecalis, more than 90% of the lactobacilli, about half of the S. sanguis strains, about one third of the S. mutans strains, and by a few other streptococcal strains. Acid production from sorbitol was observed among more than 80% of the S. mutans strains and the S. faecalis strains and most of the lactobacilli strains. Sorbitol-fermenting strains of S. sanguis and of S. mitior, all isolated from sorbitol-consumers, were observed. No other sorbitol-fermenting streptococci were found. Only the reference strains L. salivarius subsp. salivarius ATCC 11741 and S. avium ATCC 14025 fermented xylitol.     

Sugar alcohols: what is the evidence for caries-preventive and caries-therapeutic effects?

The most widely used sugar alcohols are: xylitol, sorbitol, mannitol, maltitol, lactitol and the products Lycasin and Palatinit. It is often claimed that xylitol is superior to the other sugar alcohols for caries control. This paper examines clinical studies on the caries-preventive and therapeutic effects of sugar alcohols with emphasis on sorbitol and xylitol. It is concluded that chewing sugar-free gum 3 or more times daily for prolonged periods of time may reduce caries incidence irrespective of the type of sugar alcohol used. It may be sufficient to do this only on school days. Sucking xylitol-containing candies or tablets may have a similar effect as chewing xylitol chewing gum. Clinical trials suggest greater caries reductions from chewing gums sweetened with xylitol than from gums sweetened with sorbitol. However, the superiority of xylitol was not confirmed in 2 out of 4 clinical trials comparing the caries-preventive effect of xylitol- with sorbitol-sweetened gums. The caries-preventive effects of polyol-containing gums and candies seem to be based on stimulation of the salivary flow, although an antimicrobial effect cannot be excluded. There is no evidence for a caries-therapeutic effect of xylitol. These conclusions are in line with those of recent reviews and with the conclusions of the Scientific Committee on Medicinal Products and Medical Devices of the EU Commission.     

Decreased salivary uptake of [14C]-xylitol after a four-week xylitol chewing gum regimen

PURPOSE: The aims were to evaluate a simple method to disclose a microbial shift in saliva and to investigate the short- and long-term effects of daily use of xylitol-containing chewing gums on mutans streptococci (MS) and [14C]-xylitol uptake in saliva. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In a pilot set-up, saliva samples were collected from 15 healthy adults and the uptake of xylitol was compared with a specific assay determining xylitol-sensitive MS. The main study consisted of 109 schoolchildren (mean age 9.9 years) who volunteered after informed consent. The children were randomly allocated to a test or control group. The control group was given two pellets containing sorbitol and maltitol 3 times daily for 4 weeks and the test group received identical pellets with xylitol as single sweetener (total dose 6.2 g/day). Saliva samples were collected at baseline, after 4 weeks and 6 months after the intervention. The outcome measures were MS and total viable counts, proportion of MS and salivary uptake of [14C]-xylitol. RESULTS: The pilot study disclosed a fair positive correlation (p < 0.05) between the assays. The proportions of MS and salivary xylitol uptake decreased significantly in the xylitol group by 60% and 30% respectively after 4 weeks compared to baseline which was in contrast to the sorbitol/maltitol group (p < 0.05). Six months after the intervention, the outcome measures did not differ significantly from baseline in any of the groups. CONCLUSION: A relatively high daily dose of xylitol could alter salivary microbial composition during the intervention period but no long-term impact was observed.     

Effect of xylitol-containing carbohydrate mixtures on acid and ammonia production in suspensions of salivary sediment

pH changes and the production of lactic acid, acetic acid and ammonia were studied in suspensions of salivary sediment supplemented with mixtures of xylitol and other carbohydrate sweeteners. The only mixtures which increased the pH values of the suspensions were those containing xylitol alone or mixtures of xylitol and sorbitol. Mixtures of xylitol and Lycasin 80/55 caused a relatively small pH reduction. Xylitol was not able to inhibit the acid production from the easily fermented glucose, fructose and Lycasin 05/60. The levels of lactic acid, determined in the incubation mixtures, directly reflected these pH changes. The levels of acetic acid and ammonia were, however, relatively similar in all incubation mixtures. The results suggest that the inhibitory effects of xylitol on acid production of oral flora should be retained, provided that xylitol is used either alone or in mixtures with slowly fermentable carbohydrates, such as sorbitol and Lycasin 80/55.     

Does the presence of xylitol in a sorbitol-containing chewing gum affect the adaptation to sorbitol by dental plaque?

It is known that xylitol inhibits sorbitol metabolism in some bacteria in vitro. The effect of xylitol/sorbitol-containing chewing gum on sorbitol adaptation of dental plaque was therefore examined. Ten subjects used this chewing gum for 12 wk, and plaque was collected before (control plaque) and after (test plaque) the exposure to sorbitol/xylitol. The metabolism of sorbitol by the plaque was examined with ^l4C-labeled sorbitol, and the radioactive metabolites were detected by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). A considerable individual variation in acid formation was found. The mean values of total acids in the test plaque increased, as compared with the control plaque. An adaptation of dental plaque to sorbitol thus occurred in spite of the presence of xylitol in the chewing gum. The concentration of acetic acid predominated over other acids in both the control and test plaques. The proportions of acids expressed in percentage of total acids differed only slightly. Thus, long-term use of xylitol/sorbitol-containing chewing gum did not eliminate the adaptation of dental plaque to sorbitol.     

Effects of a carbohydrate-free diet and sugar substitutes on dental plaque accumulation

Abstract Plaque accumulation and characteristics were determined gravimetrically, planimetrically, visually, and microbiologically in 24 human subjects who consumed a carbohydrate-free diet for 4 days. In addition, the effects of xylitol-, sorbitol- and sucrose-containing can dies upon plaque formed during consumption of the diet were ascertained. Experimental design was such that all 24 subjects traversed each 4-day test period; a 9-day interval between test periods was observed. All plaque measurement methods demonstrated that the subjects in all groups, including a control group which received no candies, accumulated significant amounts of dental plaque. No significant differences in plaque amount could be detected among the xylitol, sorbitol and control groups. However, subjects receiving sucrose-containing candies clearly exhibited larger amounts of plaque. The bacteriological investigations corroborated the clinical observations. The number of microbial colonies from plaque samples taken from the sucrose test group was clearly higher than in the other three groups. In addition, the number of bacteria in plaque samples from the sorbitol group was higher than in the xylitol group. A statistically significant increase in the proportion of anaerobic sorbitol-and xylitol-fermenting bacteria was detected in the sorbitol and xylitol test groups during the 4-day test periods.     

Plaque growth while chewing sorbitol and xylitol simultaneously with sucrose flavored gum

In a recent study, sorbitol flavored chewing gum was found neither to increase nor decrease the normal rate of plaque formation, whereas high plaque scores were obtained with sucrose gum during 4 days of no mechanical tooth cleaning. The aim of the present study was to see if chewing sorbitol or xylitol flavored gum together with sucrose gum would affect the growth rate of plaque and whether chewing of xylitol flavored gum could reduce the amount of already formed plaque. Twenty-seven dental students refrained from mechanical oral hygiene measures from Monday to Friday morning for 3 weeks. The students were randomly divided into three groups. A three time crossed-over double-blind approach was used. During each test period one group chewed a combination of one piece sorbitol and one piece sucrose flavored gum five times per day, the second group correspondingly chewed xylitol and sucrose flavored gum, while the third group served as a no hygiene control group. After each test period the students in the control group chewed one piece of xylitol gum every 15 minutes for 2.5 hours. The participants started out each week with clean teeth and were at the end of each test period scored for visible plaque on the facial, mesial and lingual surfaces of their teeth. There was somewhat more plaque after 4 days of chewing sucrose-sorbitol and sucrose-xylitol gum combinations than after no oral hygiene alone. There was no difference between the two test treatments. The 2.5-hour chewing of xylitol flavored gum after the no oral hygiene period did not result in a reduction of the 4-day-old plaque.     

Effects of xylitol, xylitolsorbitol, and placebo chewing gums on the plaque of habitual xylitol consumers

Xylitol reduces plaque but the reduction mechanism is largely unknown. The main aim of the present study was to determine whether the xylitol-induced reduction in the amount of plaque and the number of mutans streptococci could be demonstrated in subjects with (presumably) high levels of xylitol-resistant (X^R; not inhibited by xylitol) mutans streptococci acquired following previous xylitol consumptions. 37 healthy dental students participated in the double-blind study. All subjects had been uncontrolled, habitual consumers of xylitol-containing products for at least 1 yr before the study, A 1-month washout period was followed by a 2-week test period during which either xylitol, xylitol-sorbitol or unsweetened chewing gum base was chewed 3–5 × a day. Plaque and saliva samples were collected at baseline and at the 2-week point for determination of the amount of plaque, microbiological variables, and hydrolytic enzymes. Mixtures of xylitol and sorbitol seemed to perform equally well with respect to reduction in the amount of plaque but not the number of mutans streptococci. Thus, polyols were the active ingredients of chewing gums able to modulate the amount of plaque and its microbial composition. Xylitol reduced plaque with a mechanism which appeared not to be associated with the study-induced changes in the proportion (%) of mutans streptococci in plaque, the number of salivary mutans streptococci, the proportion of X^R strains in plaque or saliva, or the hydrolytic enzyme activities of plaque.     

Effect of xylitol-containing chewing gum on sorbitol metabolism in dental plaque

The aim of the present study was to examine whether a long-term use of chewing gum with xylitol as the only sweetener would affect sorbitol metabolism in dental plaque. Ten test subjects used xylitol-sweetened chewing gum for 12 weeks. Plaque was collected at three occasions; 1) Control plaque; 2) Test plaque I: plaque collected after 12 weeks of chewing xylitol-containing chewing gum; 3) Test plaque II: sucrose-stimulated plaque collected 2 d after Test plaque I was collected. Plaque suspensions were incubated with [¹⁴C]sorbitol, and uptake of sorbitol and production of sorbitol metabolites were determined by HPLC. Plaque formation and sorbitol uptake were significantly reduced.     

Mutans streptococci dose response to xylitol chewing gum

Xylitol is promoted in caries-preventive strategies, yet its effective dose range is unclear. This study determined the dose-response of mutans streptococci in plaque and unstimulated saliva to xylitol gum. Participants (n = 132) were randomized: controls (G1) (sorbitol/maltitol), or combinations giving xylitol 3.44 g/day (G2), 6.88 g/day (G3), or 10.32 g/day (G4). Groups chewed 3 pellets/4 times/d. Samples were taken at baseline, 5 wks, and 6 mos, and were cultured on modified Mitis Salivarius agar for mutans streptococci and on blood agar for total culturable flora. At 5 wks, mutans streptococci levels in plaque were 10x lower than baseline in G3 and G4 (P = 0.007/0.003). There were no differences in saliva. At 6 mos, mutans streptococci in plaque for G3 and G4 remained 10x lower than baseline (P = 0.007/0.04). Saliva for G3 and G4 was lower than baseline by 8 to 9x (P = 0.011/0.038). Xylitol at 6.44 g/day and 10.32 g/day reduces mutans streptococci in plaque at 5 wks, and in plaque and unstimulated saliva at 6 mos. A plateau effect is suggested between 6.44 g and 10.32 g xylitol/day.     

Long-term effect of xylitol gum use on mutans streptococci in adults

Many studies have shown the effects of chewing xylitol gum on mutans streptococci (MS) over short- and long-term periods in children; however, few studies have addressed long-term periods in adults. The objective of this investigation was to examine for 6 months the effects of chewing xylitol gum on MS in saliva and plaque in 127 adults (mean age 28.0 years). The participants were assigned to three groups according to gum type, in part taking preference for flavor into account and in part at random: xylitol (XYL), maltitol (MAL) and control (CR); 33, 34 and 27 subjects in each group, respectively, completed the trial. Daily gum use of the XYL and MAL groups was 7.9 and 7.1 g, respectively. MS levels, which declined significantly in saliva (p < 0.05) and plaque (p < 0.001) in the XYL group after 6 months, exhibited a significant increase in plaque in the MAL group (p < 0.001). Differences in relative changes of MS levels in plaque during the experimental period were significant between the XYL group and the CR (p < 0.05) and MAL groups (p < 0.001). Differences in relative change of amount of plaque during the experimental period were not statistically significant between the groups. The present study demonstrated that chewing xylitol gum for 6 months continued to inhibit the growth of mutans streptococci in adults.     

Effect of dentifrices containing either xylitol and glycerol or sorbitol on mutans streptococci in saliva.

In 76 adults, randomly distributed between two groups, a comparison was made of the effect on the level of mutans streptococci in saliva between two dentifrices containing: (1) xylitol (9.9%) and glycerol (20%) or (2) sorbitol (28%) as humectants. After the use of the dentifrices twice daily for 3 months, the levels of mutans streptococci had not changed significantly in the sorbitol-treated group, whereas a significant reduction (p less than 0.0005) was found in subjects using the xylitol/glycerol dentifrice. The difference between the two dentifrice groups based on the changes observed during the 3-month period was also significant (p less than 0.02).     

Acid production from sorbitol in human dental plaque.

Acid production from glucose and sorbitol in dental plaque suspensions and the pH changes in dental plaque in vivo after mouth rinses with 10 per cent solutions of glucose and sorbitol were studied before and after 4–6 weeks of frequent daily mouth rinses with sorbitol in 18 subjects. The mean acid production from sorbitol, in per cent of that from glucose, increased about 21 per cent (p < 0.001) and mean initial (resting) plaque pH values were approximately 0.2 units higher (p < 0.01) after the sorbitol adaptation period. The pH-decreases from sorbitol were significantly more pronounced after the 6-week adaptation period (p < 0.01). Acid production activity from sorbitol and the pH-decreases after mouth rinses with sorbitol were considerably smaller than the corresponding values found with glucose before as well as after the adaptation period.     

The optimum time to initiate habitual xylitol gum-chewing for obtaining long-term caries prevention

Habitual xylitol gum-chewing may have a long-term preventive effect by reducing the caries risk for several years after the habitual chewing has ended. The goal of this report was (1) to determine if sorbitol and sorbitol/xylitol mixtures provide a long-term benefit, and (2) to determine which teeth benefit most from two-year habitual gum-chewing - those erupting before, during, or after habitual gum-chewing. Children, on average 6 years old, chewed gums sweetened with xylitol, sorbitol, or xylitol/sorbitol mixtures. There was a "no-gum" control group. Five years after the two-year program of habitual gum-chewing ended, 288 children were re-examined. Compared with the no-gum group, sorbitol gums had no significant long-term effect (relative risk [RR], 0.65; 95% confidence interval [c.i.], 0.39 to 1.07; p < 0.18). Xylitol gum and, to a lesser extent, xylitol/sorbitol gum had a long-term preventive effect. During the 5 years after habitual gum-chewing ended, xylitol gums reduced the caries risk 59% (RR, 0.41; 95% c.i., 0.23 to 0.75; p < 0.0034). Xylitol-sorbitol gums reduced the caries risk 44% (RR, 0.56; 95% c.i., 0.36 to 0.89; p < 0.02). The long-term caries risk reduction associated with xylitol strongly depended on when teeth erupted (p < 0.02). Teeth that erupted after 1 year of gum-chewing or after the two-year habitual gum use ended had long-term caries risk reductions of 93% (p < 0.0054) and 88% (p < 0.0004), respectively. Teeth that erupted before the gum-chewing started had no significant long-term prevention (p < 0.30). We concluded that for long-term caries-preventive effects to be maximized, habitual xylitol gum-chewing should be started at least one year before permanent teeth erupt.     

Amylolytic breakdown of Lycasin compared with other carbohydrate derivatives

Lycasin, its parent glucose syrup, maize starch and sorbitol were subjected to the action of a specific amyloglucosidase at 37 degrees C, and samples were analysed at set intervals for D-glucose and total reducing sugars. Glucose syrup was hydrolysed rapidly and completely to D-glucose, but Lycasin produced only 40-50% as much, and D-glucose production ceased after the first 2-4 h. Dimers of linked D-glucose and sorbitol units remaining after degradation of the Lycasin oligosaccharides were cleaved at a much lower rate by the amyloglucosidase.     

Turku sugar studies XX. Microbiological findings and plaque index values in relation to 1-year use of xylitol chewing gum.

The aim was to study possible alterations in the microbial flora of plaque and saliva in relation to partial substitution of dietary sucrose with xylitol. The development of plaque index values was observed simultaneously. These observations were carried out during a 1-year clinical trial, the effects of sucrose (S) and xylitol (X) chewing gum on the incidence of dental caries being observed in 100 young adults. Paraffin-stimulated saliva samples were diluted stepwise and cultivated on Rogosa S.L. agar and Sabouraud agar aerobically. Lyophilized dental plaque samples were cultivated on phenol red agar under anaerobic and aerobic conditions. The pH-values were measured after incubating the mixed plaque flora for 1 and 7 days in the presence of various sugars. Both the arithmetic and geometric means of the total CFU values on Rogosa S.L. agar decreased in the S-group at the 6-month phase but returned to the starting level after one year, whereas in the X-group they decreased or remained on the starting level. At the 6-month phase the difference between the groups was significant (U-test, p = 0.0013) and almost significant (U-test, p = 0.0569) at the end of the study. No significant differences or changes could be seen between or within the groups on Sabouraud agar. The geometric mean values of S. sanguis and S. mutans as well as the total CFU values on phenol red agar decreased considerably in both the S- and X-groups, but no significant differences could be detected in any of the streptococcal counts between the groups. The pH of the carbohydrate-containing culture media infected with mixed dental plaque significantly decreased, with the exception of the xylitol containing ones in which the pH values were not lowered even after 7 days' incubation. A significant decrease in plaque formation in relation of chewing per se was demonstrable. The difference in the plaque index values equalling or exceeding 2 was significant between the S- and X-groups. No bacterial adaptation to utilize xylitol occurred during the trial.