Translocation of an antibody transgene requires AID and occurs by interchromosomal switching to all switch regions except the mu switch region

Immunoglobulin (Ig) class switch recombination (CSR) occurs most often by intrachromosomal recombinations between switch (S) regions located on a single chromosome, but it can also occur by interchomosomal recombinations between Ig heavy chain (Igh) S regions located on chomosomal homologs. Interchromosomal recombinations have also been found between chromosomes that are not homologs; examples are Igh/c-myc and Igh/transgene translocations. Most, but not all, studies have indicated that activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) is important in Igh/c-myc translocations. The role of AID has not been determined for Igh/transgene translocations. We now show that the majority of Igh/transgene translocations between non-homologs from an Ig transgenic mouse are dependent on AID, but we also find a small number of these translocations that can occur in the absence of AID. Surprisingly, our results also indicate that, although Sγ switch sequences in the endogenous Igh locus participate in chromosomal translocations with the non-homolog transgene-bearing chromosome, Sμ switch sequences do not. This contrasts with the fact that both endogenous Sμ and Sγ sequences participate in intrachromosomal CSR. Our findings suggest the operation of a regulatory mechanism that can differentially control the accessibility of Sμ and Sγ regions for non-homolog translocations even when both are accessible for intrachromosomal recombination.     

Location of Myc, Igh, and Igk on Robertsonian fusion chromosomes is inconsequential for Myc translocations and plasmacytoma development in mice, but Rb(6.15)-carrying tumors prefer Igk-Myc inversions over translocations

The location of the Myc and immunoglobulin (Ig) loci on metacentric Robertsonian (Rb) fusion chromosomes may affect the development of mouse plasmacytomas (Pcts) by changing the probability with which chromosomal Myc-Ig translocations occur. To test this hypothesis, we induced Pcts in BALB/c (C) mice that carried Rb(4.12) and/or Rb(6.15) chromosomes. The Rb mice developed Pcts (n = 198) with similar onset and incidence to that in the inbred C mice. Karyotyping of 70 Rb-carrying Pcts demonstrated that in these tumors, just as in their counterparts in inbred C mice, the Igh heavy-chain locus was translocated with Myc more often than was the Igk light-chain locus. Pcts harboring Igh or Igk on normal and Rb chromosomes showed no bias toward either in generating Myc translocations. These findings indicated that the location of Myc, Igh, and Igk on normal or Rb chromosomes is inconsequential for Myc translocation and Pct development. In contrast, in Rb(6.15) mice, in which chromosomal inversions competed with chromosomal translocations for Igk-Myc juxtapositions, the former occurred more frequently than the latter in the resulting Pcts. This suggested that spatial proximity of Igk and Myc on the same chromosome facilitates the rearrangement of these loci. Myc translocation-dependent mouse Pct may provide a good model system for furthering our understanding of the relationship of higher-order genome organization in the interphase nucleus, origin of chromosomal translocations, and development of cancer.     

Lack of somatic mutation in a kappa light chain transgene

Analysis of mice transgenic for immunoglobulin genes should allow definition of the cis-acting DNA sequences required to target somatic mutation to antibody V genes. We have looked for mutations in a chimeric kappa transgene encoding a V region specific for the hapten 2-phenyloxazolone (phOx) linked to a rat C kappa gene. Two independent lines of transgenic mice were hyperimmunized with phOx and splenic hybridomas established. In B cells that had been selected by antigen and which used mouse anti-phOx genes, the endogenous sequences were found to be mutated whereas the transgene remained unchanged. These results suggest either that (a) if the transgene is a "passenger" gene expressed at a low level, transgene mutation is a rare event, or that (b) sequences far from the kappa coding region are necessary to direct somatic mutation.     

DNA immunization in relB-deficient mice discloses a role for dendritic cells in IgM → IgG1 switch in vivo

A single intraspleen inoculation of plasmid DNA coding for an immunoglobulin heavy chain gene initiates immunity and establishes immunologic memory against the antigenic determinants of transgenic immunoglobulins, somatic transgene immunization. During priming mice produce IgM but not IgG1 antibodies. Since IgM → IgG1 class switch occurs spontaneously during the primary immune response to protein antigens we investigated possible mechanisms for failure of spontaneous isotype switch in vivo in this model of immunity. We found that inoculation of plasmid DNA in the form of a chimeric gene coding for granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) was able to drive IgG1 class switch readily after priming. Since GM-CSF activates cells of the dendritic lineage we tested the possibility that dendritic cells (DC) may be involved in regulating IgM → IgG1 switch. To this end we used bone marrow chimeras constructed from mice carrying the null mutation for the relB member of the NF-κB/Rel family as these mice lack bone marrow-derived mature DC. RelB (-/-) mice and (-/-) bone marrow chimeras inoculated with DNA/GM-CSF did not produce IgG1 antibodies during the primary immune response. Since relB (-/-) bone marrow chimeras lack DC of donor origin but possess resident follicular dendritic cells we conclude that Ig class switch in vivo is regulated by the function of interdigitating dendritic cells (IDC). Thus, IDC may contribute to the qualitative aspects of the emerging immune response.     

The 3' Igkappa enhancer contains RNA polymerase II promoters: implications for endogenous and transgenic kappa gene expression

We have created a kappa transgene in which a polymerase (pol) III promoter replaces the pol II promoter. Two independent transgenic lines show somatic hypermutation of the transgene in B cells from hyperimmunized mice. Both lines transcribe transgenes from the pol III promoter in the liver. However, in spleen and spleen B cell-derived hybridomas, they also transcribe mRNA from pol II promoters located within the 3' kappa enhancer of the preceding transgene copy in a tandem transgene array. The findings demonstrate that in an array of multiple transgenes the expression (and somatic hypermutation) of an individual transgene copy must be considered in the context of the other copies. We also show that sequences around the 3' kappa enhancer in endogenous genes are transcribed. The possible role of these promoters in endogenous kappa gene expression is discussed. An unrelated finding in this study was a novel RNA splice in one hybridoma.     

Cellular and molecular studies of B cells exhibiting reverse somatic mutation throughout life

Somatic mutation of immunoglobulin (Ig) genes plays an important role in generating antibody diversity. The frequency of somatic mutation appears to vary throughout life. However, this process has been difficult to study in vivo because the DNA in and around rearranged V genes undergoes random mutation, causing silent or replacement mutations. Therefore, we have developed a transgenic mouse model for studying the frequency of B cells exhibiting mutation in young and old mice. The system is based on a reporter transgene (HuG-X) that encodes a chimeric Ig heavy chain composed of a murine VDJ segment and a human IgG1 constant region. The VDJ has been mutated to contain a TAG stop codon in the D segment. Therefore, the transgene is transcribed but not translated. Point mutation of the stop codon results in expression of the chimeric H chain, which is readily detected as human IgG1 expression. In vivo, we found that the transgene undergoes spontaneous reverse somatic mutation at a low frequency. Treatment of HuG-X mice with anti-IgD greatly increases the frequency of somatic mutation. The observed mutation frequency in anti-IgD-treated mice increases with age until adulthood, then plateaux and finally declines in aged mice. The mutations in the stop codon were associated with increased double-stranded DNA breaks (DSB) within and around the TAG site. Our results demonstrate that the rate of frequency of spontaneous reverse mutation is very low in vivo, yet it is significantly increased after stimulation with anti-IgD antibodies. The frequency of point mutation is age dependent and correlates with increased DSB.     

Somatic hypermutation of Ig genes is affected differently by failures in apoptosis caused by disruption of Fas (lpr mutation) or by overexpression of Bcl-2

The effects of the two main apoptotic pathways on the somatic hypermutation process were analysed. Transgenic mice carrying the V(kappa)Ox1-J(kappa)5 rat transgene were crossed with Fas-deficient lpr mice or with mice overexpressing the Bcl-2 protein. The transgenic V(kappa)Ox1 segment and the endogenous JH4-C(micro) Ig intron from Peyer's patches germinal centre B cells were sequenced to study the intrinsic somatic hypermutation process without the skewing effects of specific antigen selection. The lpr/ox mice displayed, in both regions, a high level of mutations with a normal pattern of substitutions. On the contrary, the bcl-2/ox mice displayed a lower level of mutations with an altered pattern, showing a decreased mutational rate in the intrinsic hotspots of the V(kappa)Ox1 gene. Our results suggest that the lpr mutation does not have a direct effect on the somatic hypermutation process, but rather on the negative selection of B cells in the germinal centres, leading to the accumulation of recurrent mutations. In contrast, Bcl-2 overexpression might influence the somatic hypermutational process either by altering the incorporation of mutations or by enhancing the repair mechanism(s). The present work supports the hypothesis that both apoptotic pathways, Fas and Bcl-2, play distinct roles in the germinal centre reactions.     

Apparent trans-chromosomal antibody class switch in mice bearing an Igh(a) mu-chain transgene on an Igh(b) genetic background

Native high molecular weight dextran induces a thymus-independent response in BALB/c mice. When the dextran epitope is linked to a protein carrier the response becomes thymus-dependent. IgG antibodies produced after secondary immunization had epitope specificity and idiotope of myeloma M104E. The antibody of M104E (mu, lambda1) is representative for antibodies produced by mice with immunoglobulin haplotype Igh(a) in response to immunization with dextran B1355S. Myeloma product and physiological antibodies share specificity for the alpha(1-3) glucosidic linkage and have idiotopes in common. Mice with haplotypes other than Igh(a) (e.g. Igh(b)) are unable to yield this type of response. A complete rearranged immunoglobulin mu-chain gene with a VDJ-region from BALB/c (Igh(a)) myeloma protein M104E had been introduced into the genome of BALB/c congenic mice having the haplotype Igh(b). As was shown previously in our laboratory the M104E mu-chain transgene confers Igh(a)-type reactivity to Igh(b) mice. In experiments described in this report we used the thymus-dependent form of the antigen to immunize mice bearing the M104E mu-chain, either alone or together with the lambda1-chain, as a transgene on an Igh(b) genetic background. Serological analysis revealed a class switch to IgG very similar to that seen in BALB/c mice with respect to magnitude, kinetics, epitope and idiotope specificity. The pattern of IgG subclass expression was indistinguishable in mu-chain transgenic Igh(b) and normal BALB/c mice. The class switch occurred even though, as is shown here, the transgene had become incorporated in a site not linked to the Igh locus on chromosome 12. We propose a model for this apparent trans-chromosomal class switch recombination which is based on mechanisms known for conventional switch recombination.     

In a model of immunoglobulin heavy-chain (IGH)/MYC translocation, the Igh 3' regulatory region induces MYC expression at the immature stage of B cell development

Reciprocal translocations involving the immunoglobulin loci and the cellular oncogene MYC are hallmark mutations of the human postgerminal center B cell neoplasm, Burkitt's lymphoma. They are occasionally found in other B cell lymphomas, as well. Translocations involving the heavy chain locus (IGH) place the MYC gene either in cis with both the intronic enhancer Emu and the IGH 3' regulatory region (3'RR) or in cis with only the 3'RR. The result is deregulated MYC expression. Recent studies have led to some controversy as to when, during B lymphocyte development, IGH/MYC chromosome translocations take place. A related issue, relevant not only to lymphoma development but also to normal controls on IGH gene expression, is the stage, during B lymphocyte development, at which the 3'RR is capable of activating MYC expression. We have developed mice transgenic for a human MYC (hMYC) gene under control of the four core enhancers from the mouse Igh 3'RR. Unlike other transgenic mouse models where premature and inappropriate MYC expression disrupts normal B cell development, the hMYC transgene in these studies carries a mutation that prohibits MYC protein synthesis. As a result, hMYC expression can be analyzed in all of the normal B cell compartments. Our data show that hMYC is expressed almost exclusively in B-lineage cells and is induced to high levels as soon as bone marrow cells reach the immature B cell stage.     

Monoclonal immunoglobulin A derived from peritoneal B cells is encoded by both germ line and somatically mutated VH genes and is reactive with commensal bacteria.

We transferred peritoneal cells from BALB/c mice into C.B17 scid/scid mice. Six to eight months after injection, only cells with the B1 phenotype were retained in the spleens and peritoneal cavities of these mice. The lamina propria of the intestine contained many peritoneal, donor-derived, immunoglobulin A (IgA)-producing cells. The mesenteric lymph nodes of these mice were found to be a major site of proliferation and generation of IgA plasmablasts. We established eight IgA-producing hybridomas from the mesenteric lymph nodes of such mice, and all the hybridomas reacted with different but partially overlapping fecal bacterial populations. Cloning and sequencing of the VH genes of these hybridomas showed that two hybridomas utilized germ line-encoded VH genes while the VH genes of the six hybridomas showed somatic mutations, some of which are indicative of an antigen-driven selection process.     

Class switch recombination and somatic hypermutation in early mouse B cells are mediated by B cell and Toll-like receptors

Activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) is required for immunoglobulin (Ig) gene class switch recombination (CSR), somatic hypermutation (SHM), and somatic hyperconversion. In general, high AID expression is found in mature B cells that are responding to antigens. However, AID expression and SHM have also been detected in developing B cells from transgenic mice that have a limited Ig repertoire. Here we demonstrate that AID expression, ongoing CSR, and active SHM occur in developing B cells from wild-type mice. Further, our results suggest that somatic variants arising from developing B cells in the bone marrow further diversify in the spleen of unimmunized mice. AID expression in developing B cells is T cell independent but involves engagement of B cell receptors and Toll-like receptors. Early AID expression can increase the preimmune repertoire of developing B cells, may provide an innate population of IgG- and IgA-expressing cells, and could be involved in receptor editing of self-reactive immature B cells.     

Identification of an AID-independent pathway for chromosomal translocations between the Igh switch region and Myc

Chromosomal translocations involving immunoglobulin heavy chain (Igh) switch regions and an oncogene such as Myc represent initiating events in the development of many B cell malignancies. These translocations are widely thought to result from aberrant class-switch recombination. To test this model, we measured translocations in mice deficient in activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) that lack class-switch recombination. We found that AID made no measurable contribution to the generation of initial translocations, indicating that the intrinsic fragility of the switch regions or a pathway unrelated to AID is responsible for these translocations. In contrast, the outgrowth of translocation-positive cells was dependent on AID, raising the possibility that AID is important in tumor progression, perhaps by virtue of its mutagenic properties.     

B cells are anergic in transgenic mice that express IgM anti-DNA antibodies

B lymphocytes in individuals with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) secrete pathogenic auto antibodies to DNA which cause clinical nephritis. (NZB x NZW) Fl (BW) female mice also secrete pathogenic anti-DNA auto antibodies, and therefore are considered to be an animal model of SLE. The rearranged immunoglobulin (Ig) genes that encode an anti-DNA antibody from a diseased BW mouse have been cloned, and transgenic (Tg) mice have been created by microinjection of these constructs into fertilized eggs from normal mice. As we reported previously, when the construct contains the Cγ2a heavy chain constant (C_H) region, the mice spontaneously secrete anti-DNA IgG and they develop mild nephritis. This demonstrated that the Ig encoded by the transgene is pathogenic. In contrast, here we report that when the construct contains the same anti-DNA Ig variable (V) regions used previously, along with the Cμ region, the auto reactive B cells are rendered tolerant. Most B cells in the Tg mice express the μ transgene product on their surface, and rearrangement of endogenous light chain genes is partially suppressed. Furthermore, most hybridomas made from Tg B cells secrete IgM anti-DNA. Despite this, the Tg mice have reduced levels of total serum Ig and they do not secrete anti-DNA IgM either spontaneously or following immunization with DNA. We conclude that most B cells in the Tg mice have been rendered anergic. Anergy is however reversible in vitro; lipopolysaccharide stimulation of Tg B cells leads to the production of a significant amount of IgM anti-DNA antibody. The studies demonstrate that in this line of Tg mice on a normal mouse genetic background potentially pathogenic B cells that express a high-affinity Ig specific for a natural autoantigen are subject to tolerance by induction of anergy.     

Excessive amounts of mu heavy chain block B-cell development

Antigen-independent B-cell development occurs in several stages that depend on the expression of Ig heavy and light chain. We identified a line of mice that lacked mature B cells in the spleen. This mouse line carried approximately 11 copies of a transgene of the murine heavy chain constant region locus, and B-lineage cells expressed excessive amounts of the intracellular μ heavy chain. B-cell development failed in the bone marrow at the pro/pre B-cell transition, and examination of other lines with various copy numbers of the same transgene suggested that deficiencies in B-cell development increased with increased transgene copy number. Expression of a transgenic (Tg) light chain along with the Tg μ heavy chain led to minimal rescue of B-cell development in the bone marrow and B cells in the spleen. There are several potential mechanisms for the death of pro/pre B cells as a consequence of excess heavy chain expression.