In vivo kinematics of anterior cruciate ligament deficient knees during pivot and squat activities

Background

Knee kinematics during pivoting activities are not well studied, but might provide insight critical to understanding the pathology of the anterior cruciate ligament deficient knee. The purpose of this study was to compare in vivo kinematics during weight bearing pivot and squat activities in patients with unilateral anterior cruciate ligament deficient knees, and to contrast those kinematics with the uninjured contralateral knees.

Methods

Eight unilateral anterior cruciate ligament deficient patients with a mean age of 41 (SD 7) years were enrolled. Anterior cruciate injury was confirmed by positive Lachman test and MRI. Lateral fluoroscopic images of pivot and squat activities were recorded for both anterior cruciate ligament deficient and contralateral knees. Three-dimensional tibiofemoral kinematics and centers of rotation for each knee were determined using 3D–2D model registration techniques.

Findings

During pivoting, the tibia of the anterior cruciate ligament deficient knee was significantly more anterior than the contralateral knee during tibial neutral to internal rotation. The pivot activity showed lateral centers of rotation in both anterior cruciate ligament deficient and contralateral knees while squatting showed medial centers of rotation.

Interpretation

This dynamic method might be useful to objectively characterize restoration of dynamic function in knees with various types of anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions. These results also indicate kinematics during squatting type activities cannot be extrapolated to predict knee kinematics during pivoting types of activities.     

Knee joint moments during stair climbing of patients with anterior cruciate ligament deficiency

OBJECTIVE: To establish the gait adaptations of patients with anterior cruciate ligament deficiency during stair ascent. DESIGN: Joint kinematics and kinetics during stair climbing were measured in both knees of normal subjects and unilateral anterior cruciate ligament deficient patients. BACKGROUND: As there is limited research pertaining to activities other than level walking, the purpose of the current study was to elucidate the gait of patients with anterior cruciate ligament deficiency during stair climbing to determine the effects of the deficiency on knee joint motion and moments as compared with normal knee function. METHODS: A motion analysis system was used to measure and calculate kinematic and kinetic data for six normal subjects and nine patients with unilateral anterior cruciate ligament deficiency during stair ascent on a specially constructed staircase. Left and right leg data were analysed to reveal between-limb differences for each subject. RESULTS: Patients with anterior cruciate ligament deficiency displayed a significant (P < 0.05) reduction of up to 50% in peak knee flexion moments in their involved knee. In the present study where a step height of 15.5 cm was used, peak flexion moments in all subjects' limbs occurred at knee flexion angles of about 40 degrees during single limb support. CONCLUSION: The current study showed that most patients with an anterior cruciate deficient knee adapted their gait during stair ascent. RELEVANCE: As stair climbing is a common activity, its effect on gait is relevant to better understand appropriate treatment and management strategies of patients with anterior cruciate ligament deficient knees.     

Stride-to-stride variability is altered during backward walking in anterior cruciate ligament deficient patients

Background

Recently backward walking is used by physical therapists to strengthen the hamstring muscles and thus improve the function of the knee joint of anterior cruciate ligament deficient patients. The aim of this study was to examine the stride-to-stride variability of anterior cruciate ligament deficient patients during backward walking. The variation of how a motor behavior emerges in time is best captured by tools derived from nonlinear dynamics, for which the temporal sequence in a series of values is the facet of interest.

Methods

Fifteen patients with unilateral anterior cruciate ligament deficiency and eleven healthy controls walked backwards at their self-selected speed on a treadmill while three-dimensional knee kinematics were collected (100 Hz). A nonlinear measure, the largest Lyapunov Exponent was calculated from the resulted knee joint flexion–extension data of both groups to assess the stride-to-stride variability.

Findings

Both knees of the deficient patients exhibited significantly lower Lyapunov Exponent values as compared to the healthy control group revealing more rigid movement pattern. The intact knee of the deficient patients showed significantly lower Lyapunov Exponent values as compared to the deficient knee.

Interpretation

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency leads to loss of optimal variability regardless of the walking direction (forwards in previous studies or backwards here) as compared to healthy individuals. This could imply diminished functional responsiveness to the environmental demands for both knees of ACL deficient patients which could result in the knees being more susceptible to injury.     

Anterior cruciate ligament rupture translates the axes of motion within the knee

OBJECTIVE: To quantify the dynamic effects of anterior cruciate ligament deficiency on human knee joint motion. DESIGN: Three-dimensional motion was assessed by measuring the kinematics of intact and anterior cruciate ligament deficient knee joint specimens during simulated flexion-extension cycles. BACKGROUND: It is known that the anterior cruciate ligament plays an important role in controlling three-dimensional knee joint motion. Nevertheless, dynamic effects of deficiency are not fully understood. METHODS: Six cadaveric knees were tested in a knee joint motion and loading apparatus prior to and after anterior cruciate ligament resection. To determine if the kinematic results depended on additional loading, internal and external rotation moments of 3.4 Nm were axially applied to the tibia. The kinematics were analysed in terms of finite helical axes. RESULTS: Sectioning the anterior cruciate ligament had little effect on the orientations of the finite helical axes. However, applying moments did affect the axes orientation. In contrast, relative translations of the axes were significantly affected by the deficiency for all rotational moments applied. Referring to the individual knee anatomy the largest translation of 12.5 mm (median) occurred in medial/lateral direction. CONCLUSIONS: Anterior cruciate ligament rupture primarily causes a translation of the finite helical axes in medial/lateral direction. Consequently, increased anterior excursion of the tibia occurs (subluxation) and therefore dynamic instability.     

Biomechanical changes elicited by an anterior cruciate ligament deficiency during steady rate cycling

OBJECTIVES: To identify any changes to lower limb biomechanics during steady rate cycling as a result of an anterior cruciate ligament deficiency. DESIGN: Comparative study in which healthy and anterior cruciate ligament injured individuals underwent biomechanical analysis during stationary cycling. BACKGROUND: Individuals with an anterior cruciate ligament deficiency often exhibit reductions in the magnitude of quadriceps muscle activity and subsequent knee joint extensor moments during walking. It is not known whether these compensations are present during cycling, an exercise frequently used to retrain anterior cruciate ligament injured individuals. METHODS: Ten healthy and 10 unilateral anterior cruciate ligament deficient individuals participated. All participants were required to cycle for approximately 30 s at each of six different cycling intensities while lower limb EMG, kinetics, and kinematics were collected bilaterally. Before riding, participants performed submaximal isometric contractions to generate normalizing data. RESULTS: In addition to reduced quadriceps activation and net knee joint extensor moments, the anterior cruciate ligament deficient limbs exhibited decreases in linear impulse of the resultant pedal force, knee joint flexor moments, hip and ankle extensor moments, and muscle activity from gluteus maximus. These decreases were counteracted by an increase in output from the anterior cruciate ligament intact limb. CONCLUSION: Anterior cruciate ligament injured individuals exhibited a limb attenuation strategy during cycling activities. RELEVANCE: This study reports lower limb kinetic and electromyographic data from anterior cruciate ligament deficient individuals during stationary cycling, and shows that these individuals exhibit a limb attenuation strategy on the very leg that is undergoing rehabilitation.     

Alterations in patellofemoral kinematics following vastus medialis transection in the anterior cruciate ligament deficient rabbit knee

Background

Anterior cruciate ligament deficiency and quadriceps muscle weakness are considered to be important risk factors for aberrant patellar tracking and subsequent patellofemoral osteoarthritis. However, data from in vivo experiments looking at dynamic patellar joint kinematics and muscle force are scarce. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of anterior cruciate ligament transection and loss of vastus medialis force on patellar tracking in the rabbit knee in vivo.

Methods

Eight skeletally mature New Zealand White Rabbits, weighing 6.0 kg (0.6 kg standard deviation) were used. The experimental trials consisted of active, concentric and eccentric movements of the knee joint. Measurements were performed with the intact, the anterior cruciate ligament deficient, and the vastus medialis transected knee. Patellofemoral kinematics (shift, rotation) were quantified from high speed video.

Findings

Following anterior cruciate ligament transection, patellar tracking occurred more laterally, and caused a significant lateral rotation of the patella. The addition of vastus medialis transection did not alter patellar tracking or rotation significantly for any of the force-matched experimental conditions.

Interpretation

The loss of the anterior cruciate ligament results in lateral patellar shift and rotation while the loss of vastus medialis muscle force does not affect patellar tracking or rotation in the anterior cruciate ligament deficient knee. We suggest that the current results should be considered carefully in future interpretations of knee extensor imbalance. More research is needed to describe the contribution of vastus medialis muscle strength to medial patellofemoral stability and confirm these results in the human knee.     

Gait perturbation response in chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficiency and repair

OBJECTIVE: To determine how chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficient and surgically repaired subjects react to unexpected forward perturbations during gait as compared to healthy controls. DESIGN: Gait testing of 10 chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects prior to and three months following reconstructive surgery, and 10 uninjured controls. BACKGROUND: The ability of an anterior cruciate ligament injured individual to react and maintain equilibrium during gait perturbations is critical for the prevention of reinjury. No studies have investigated how these individuals respond to unexpected perturbations during normal gait. METHODS: An unexpected forward perturbation was induced upon heel strike using a force plate capable of translational movement. RESULTS: Prior to surgery, the anterior cruciate ligament subjects exhibited a greater knee extensor moment in response to the perturbation compared to healthy controls. Following surgery, the anterior cruciate ligament injured subjects exhibited a static knee position and a sustained knee extensor moment throughout stance in response to the perturbation as compared to controls. CONCLUSIONS: These data suggest that chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects rely heavily on knee extensor musculature to prevent collapse in response to an unexpected perturbation. This same reactive response was more pronounced 3 months following surgery. RELEVANCE: The results suggest that, prior to and following surgery, chronic anterior cruciate ligament injured subjects respond differently than healthy controls to an unexpected perturbation during gait. Anterior cruciate ligament injured or repaired subjects do not reduce or avoid vigorous contraction of the quadriceps muscles when responding to gait perturbations.     

Muscular compensation and lesion of the anterior cruciate ligament: contribution of the soleus muscle during recovery from a forward fall

BACKGROUND: Knee stability following an anterior cruciate ligament lesion has been widely studied. Only recent studies focused on the contribution of the soleus muscle. Our purpose was to characterize the dynamic and muscular activity of balance recovery in healthy subjects and patients with an anterior cruciate ligament rupture. The role of the soleus was investigated in the ipsilateral compensation developed to stabilize the knee and in the contralateral compensation to recover balance. METHODS: Twelve anterior cruciate ligament deficient patients, ten anterior cruciate ligament repaired patients and 14 control subjects were recorded during a forward fall involving stepping to recover balance. FINDINGS: The dynamic of the centre of gravity remained normal when compared to the control group regardless of the treatment, suggesting an adapted compensation to knee instability in this situation. A bilateral increase in soleus activity was related to an increased duration in the balance recovery process in all patients. Patients used one of two strategies to recover balance regardless of the treatment: reducing the step length, involving an early recruitment of the soleus before heel contact, or anticipating braking with a similar step length requiring a predominant activity of the hamstrings. INTERPRETATIONS: These results suggest that bilateral activity of the soleus is involved to compensate for instability and highlight the contribution of the soleus to rehabilitation after an anterior cruciate ligament lesion, not only as a compensatory muscle acting at the knee level but also at a higher level in the bilateral control of stance.     

novel Award Second Prize Paper. Functional monitoring during rehabilitation following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.

OBJECTIVE: It was hypothesized that testing of ambulatory function and more demanding activities were more appropriate predictors of dynamic knee function before and after reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament than conventional measures of functional evaluation. It was assumed that assessment of dynamic plantar pressure distribution would represent a practical tool for guidance of the rehabilitation process after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. DESIGN: In a prospective study, 10 patients with isolated anterior cruciate deficiency were examined before and after replacement of the anterior cruciate (6, 12, 24 weeks) in a standardized technique. BACKGROUND: Today, functional assessment following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction relies on clinical examination supplemented by instrumented testing of knee laxity and on isokinetic evaluation of muscle performance. Gait analysis has not been used as a quantitative measure of rehabilitation progress after surgery. METHODS: All patients were subjected to the same physiotherapy protocol. The clinical results were documented using the International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) protocol and the degree of knee laxity by an instrumented anterior drawer test. Muscular performance was evaluated by isokinetic testing. Dynamic pedography (EMED-SF 4) was performed to compare the non-injured and the operated leg during level walking and while descending stairs. RESULTS: Gait performance six weeks after surgery tended to be inferior to preoperative and late postoperative values. While the slight increase of maximum knee extensor torque in the operated leg and the improvement of the IKDC score during the rehabilitation period were not statistically significant, a significantly decreased gait asymmetry could be observed 12 weeks after surgery. The descending stairs test revealed functional deficits better than level walking. The latter test exhibited a strong correlation with the preoperative IKDC level and the maximum knee extensor deficit at 60 degrees /s. CONCLUSIONS: Dynamic pedography during level walking and while descending stairs is a valuable tool for monitoring the rehabilitation process after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. RELEVANCE: Due to the better resolution of functional deficits compared with indirect measures of function (isokinetic testing) assessment of the plantar pressure distribution may provide a more individualized adaptation for the rehabilitation program.     

Effect of hamstrings muscle action on stability of the ACL-deficient knee in isokinetic extension exercise

Objective. To quantify the effect of hamstrings muscle action on stability of the anterior cruciate ligament deficient knee during isokinetic exercise at various speeds.

Design. Mathematical modeling and forward-dynamics computer simulation were used to study the interactions between knee-extension speed, hamstrings co-contraction activity, and anterior tibial translation in the intact and anterior cruciate deficient knee.

Background. There is much experimental evidence available to believe that hamstrings co-contraction can reduce anterior tibial translation in the anterior cruciate deficient knee. Little is known, however, about the level of hamstrings activation needed to keep anterior tibial translation within normal limits during functional activity.

Methods. Isokinetic knee-extension was simulated with a sagittal-plane model used previously to study load sharing between the muscles, ligaments, and bones during isometric knee-extension exercise, isokinetic exercise, and squatting exercise.

Conclusions. Some amount of hamstrings activation is needed to stabilize an anterior cruciate deficient knee irrespective of how fast the knee extends. The level of hamstrings co-contraction needed to stabilize an anterior cruciate deficient knee is inversely related to extension speed. Hamstrings co-contraction is more effective in reducing anterior tibial translation than low-resistance extension exercise.Relevance

Excessive anterior tibial translation during knee-extension exercise may lead to damage of the meniscus and other passive structures inside the knee. If anterior cruciate deficient patients can be trained to co-contract their hamstrings during isokinetic knee-extension, then this exercise is appropriate for maintaining strength of the thigh muscles without compromising the anterior stability of the knee.     

The effect of insufficient quadriceps strength on gait after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the effect of quadriceps strength and joint stability on gait patterns after anterior cruciate ligament injury and reconstruction. DESIGN: Cross-sectional comparative study in which four groups underwent motion analysis with surface electromyography. BACKGROUND: Individuals following anterior cruciate ligament rupture often demonstrate reduced knee angles and moments during the early stance phase of gait. Alterations in gait can neither be ascribed to instability nor to quadriceps weakness alone when both are present. METHODS: Twenty-eight individuals with complete anterior cruciate ligament rupture (10 patients with acute rupture, 8 patients following reconstruction with quadriceps strength >90% of the uninvolved side [strong-anterior cruciate ligament reconstructed group], and 10 patients after reconstruction with quadriceps strength <80% of the uninvolved side [weak-anterior cruciate ligament reconstructed group]), and 10 uninjured subjects underwent an examination of their lower extremity to collect kinematics, kinetics, and electromyography during walking and jogging. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction was arthroscopically assisted and a double loop semitendinosis-gracilis autograft or allograft was used as a graft source. All reconstructed subjects had stable knees, full range of motion, and no effusion or pain at the time of testing (more than three months after surgery). RESULTS: Knee angles and moments of the strong group were indistinguishable from the uninjured group during early stance of both walking and jogging. The weak subjects had reduced knee angles and moments during walking, and jogged similarly to the deficient subjects. Regression analysis revealed a significant effect between early stance phase knee angles and moments and quadriceps strength during both walking and jogging. CONCLUSION: Inadequate quadriceps strength contributes to altered gait patterns following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. RELEVANCE: Rapid strengthening following anterior cruciate ligament injury or reconstruction may contribute to a safe return to high-level activities.     

Influence of a mono-centric knee brace on the tension of the collateral ligaments in knee joints after sectioning of the anterior cruciate ligament--an in vitro study

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the influence of knee bracing on the tension of the medial and lateral collateral ligaments in anterior cruciate ligament deficiency. DESIGN: The tension of the collateral ligaments in anterior cruciate ligament deficient knees was measured with and without knee bracing using an in vitro model. BACKGROUND: Anterior cruciate ligament deficiency increases the tension in both collateral ligaments at the knee joint. Therefore knee braces should reduce that tension increase. However, that effect has never been proven quantitatively. METHODS: After anterior cruciate ligament-transection, the forces of the medial (anterior/posterior part) and lateral collateral ligament were measured in ten fresh human cadaver knees at 0 degrees, 20 degrees, 40 degrees, 60 degrees, 80 degrees and 100 degrees of flexion, with and without application of a mono-centric knee brace. To quantify the ligament forces, strain gauges were fixed at the bony origins of the ligaments. RESULTS: Bracing led to a significant decrease of ligament forces (20-100 degrees: P < 0.0001) in the anterior part of the medial collateral ligament in all joint positions. In the posterior aspect, this effect was observed only at 40 degrees (P < 0.0001) and 80 degrees (P = 0.001) of flexion. In the lateral collateral ligament, bracing caused a strain reduction from 60 degrees to 100 degrees of flexion (P < 0.0001). Therefore a flexion angle dependent effect of knee bracing on the strain was seen in the posterior aspect of the medial and in the lateral collateral ligament in anterior cruciate ligament deficient knee joints. CONCLUSIONS: Application of a mono-centric knee brace leads to a significant position dependent reduction of collateral ligament tension after anterior cruciate ligament-rupture.     

Quantitative analysis of anterior cruciate ligament instability

The purpose of this study was to quantify end-feel by evaluating instantaneous stiffness and change in stiffness of the tibiofemoral joint. Normal (n = 26), anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficient (n = 6), and posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) deficient (n = 2) subjects were tested using the KT 2000 knee ligament arthrometer. Analogue force and displacement data were digitized, filtered, and calibrated. Force-displacement curves in the region of anterior tibial displacement were approximated using 5th degree polynomial functions. Stiffness and change in stiffness were determined analytically by the first and second derivatives of these functions. Subjects with confirmed ACL deficiency had lower values for stiffness and change in stiffness in the region of the curves believed to be indicative of ACL function, compared to contralateral knees and control subjects. RELEVANCE: First and second derivatives of tibiofemoral force-displacement curves give the stiffness and the change in stiffness respectively for anterior displacement of the tibia relative to the femur. This information concerning knee stability in vivo may be useful for diagnosis and follow-up.     

Knee rotational laxity: an investigation of bilateral asymmetry for comparison with the contralateral uninjured knee

Background

Instability associated with anterior cruciate ligament injury is commonly evaluated against the patient's contralateral knee. The objectives of this study were, therefore, to assess symmetry of rotational knee laxity in vivo under passive torsional loading in uninjured subjects, and to compare mean rotation of this control group with the contralateral, intact knees of anterior cruciate ligament deficient patients.

Methods

Axial knee rotation was measured in 29 patients with unilateral anterior cruciate ligament injury and 15 uninjured age and gender-matched control subjects using an imaging-compatible torsional loading device. Side-to-side differences in internal, external, and range of knee rotation were assessed in the control group and mean bilateral knee rotation was compared to the patients' contralateral knee data at both full extension and 30° of flexion.

Findings

Statistically significant differences in symmetry were found in three of the six measures of transverse plane rotation in the uninjured knees; a mean side-to-side difference of 2.2° in range of rotation was detected in the flexed position. No significant differences were observed between the mean values of the healthy control group and the contralateral knees of the anterior cruciate ligament deficient patients.

Interpretation

Bilateral asymmetry of rotational laxity occurs in healthy individuals. Nevertheless, comparability of rotational knee laxity between the contralateral limbs of patients and the uninjured population was evidence that rotational laxity was not inherent or developed in the contralateral knees of the anterior cruciate ligament deficient participants.     

A Novel Approach to Measure Variability in the Anterior Cruciate Ligament Deficient Knee During Walking: The Use of the Approximate Entropy in Orthopaedics

Objective. The evaluation of variability of biological rhythmic activities through measures such as Approximate Entropy (ApEn) has provided important information regarding pathology in disciplines such as cardiology and neurology. This research lead to the “loss of complexity hypothesis” where decreased variability is associated with loss of healthy flexibility rendering the system more rigid and unable to adapt to stresses. ApEn as a measure of variability and complexity, correlates well with pathology while, in some cases, it is predictive of subsequent clinical changes. The study of human gait could benefit from the application of ApEn since it is also a rhythmical oscillation. Our aim was to assess the variability of the ACL deficient knee, since ACL rupture is a common musculoskeletal injury and is accompanied by altered gait patterns and future pathology in the joint. We hypothesized that the ACL deficient knee will exhibit more regular and less variable walking patterns than the contralateral intact knee. Methods. Ten subjects with unilateral deficiency walked on a treadmill at their self-selected speed, 20% faster, and 20% slower, while kinematics were collected (50 Hz) from 80 consecutive strides for each condition. The ApEn of the resulted knee joint flexion-extension time series was calculated. Results. Significantly smaller ApEn values were found in the ACL deficient knee when compared with the contralateral intact (F = 5.57, p = 0.022), for all speeds. ApEn values significantly increased (F = 5.79, p = 0.005) with increases in walking speed. Conclusions. The altered properties of the ACL deficient knee, which exhibits more regular and less variable patterns than the contralateral intact knee, may decrease the adaptability of the system rendering it less able to adjust to perturbations. This could explain the increased future pathology found in the deficient knee. ApEn can be an important tool in assessing pathology and therapeutic interventions in orthopaedics.     

Differences in the movement pattern of a forward lunge in two types of anterior cruciate ligament deficient patients: copers and non-copers

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether differences in the knee joint movement pattern of a forward lunge could be quantified in healthy subjects and in anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects who were able to return to the same activity level as before their injury (copers) and in those who were not (non-copers). DESIGN: The movement patterns of the injured leg of the coper and non-coper anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects and the right leg of the control subjects were compared statistically. BACKGROUND: The forward lunge seems to be a less stressful test than the commonly used one-legged hop test, which makes it a possible tool for evaluating and comparing the functional performance of non-copers and copers. METHODS: The movement pattern of a forward lunge was analysed by using a two-dimensional inverse dynamics method. The electromyographic activity of the quadriceps and hamstring muscles were recorded. RESULTS: The non-copers moved more slowly and loaded the knee joint less than the copers and controls. The copers moved more slowly during the knee flexion phase but as fast as the controls during the knee extension. The EMG results suggest that the copers stabilized their knee joint by increasing the co-contraction of the hamstrings during the extension phase. CONCLUSIONS: Differences between the three groups' movement patterns could be quantified. The forward lunge test seems appropriate to discriminate between the knee function in coper and non-coper anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects. RELEVANCE: Information about the performance of movements, which significantly load the knee joint in coper and non-coper anterior cruciate ligament deficient patients may contribute to a better understanding of dynamic knee joint stabilization, which is relevant in relation to the development of rehabilitation strategies.     

Gait mechanics in chronic ACL deficiency and subsequent repair

OBJECTIVE: To determine how normal gait patterns may change as a result of chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficiency and subsequent reconstructive surgery. DESIGN: Gait testing of 10 chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects prior to and 3 months following reconstructive surgery, and 10 uninjured controls. BACKGROUND: There is controversy whether persons with chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficiency develop a "quadriceps avoidance" pattern and how anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery influences gait mechanics in these same individuals. METHODS: Gait analysis was employed to determine kinematic, kinetic, and muscle Electromyographic data. RESULTS: Prior to surgery, no anterior cruciate ligament deficient subject exhibited a quadriceps avoidance pattern. Following surgery, the subjects exhibited a significantly greater knee extensor moment during early stance as compared to the control group. Prior to and following surgery, anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects demonstrated a significantly greater hip extensor moment possibly to reduce anterior tibial translation. CONCLUSIONS; These data suggest that (1) development of a quadriceps avoidance pattern is less common than previously reported, (2) anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects accommodate through alterations of hip joint mechanics, (3) surgical repair significantly alters lower extremity gait patterns, and (4) re-establishment of pre-injury gait patterns takes longer than 3 months to occur. RELEVANCE: The results suggest that chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects do not exhibit a quadriceps avoidance gait pattern. Surgical intervention significantly alters lower extremity gait mechanics in a population that has accommodated to anterior cruciate ligament deficiency.     

Bilateral accommodations to anterior cruciate ligament deficiency and surgery

OBJECTIVE To determine bilateral lower extremity joint accommodations during gait in anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects and uninjured controls. DESIGN: Gait testing of 10 chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects prior to and 3 months following reconstructive surgery, and 10 uninjured controls. BACKGROUND: It is possible that bilateral joint accommodations could occur as a result of anterior cruciate ligament injury and in response to surgical repair. Few studies have investigated bilateral joint accommodations to anterior cruciate ligament injury and there is little consistency in the reported results. METHODS: Bilateral lower extremity kinematic and kinetic data were collected from 12 walking trials and inverse dynamics calculations were made to estimate bilateral knee and hip joint angle, moment, and power patterns during the stance phase of gait. RESULTS: Control subjects exhibited asymmetrical hip but symmetrical knee joint moment and power patterns. In contrast, the anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects exhibited symmetrical hip and asymmetrical knee joint moment and power patterns prior to and following reconstructive surgery. CONCLUSIONS: Gait asymmetry in healthy subjects should not be considered pathological. In addition, chronic anterior cruciate ligament injury results in joint specific, bilateral lower extremity accommodations in gait mechanics. These accommodations persist 3 months following surgical repair.     

A clinically applicable EMG-force model to quantify active stabilization of the knee after a lesion of the anterior cruciate ligament

OBJECTIVES: To investigate whether a simple electromyography-force (EMG-force) model can be used to measure different levels of co-contraction about the knee for healthy subjects and patients with an anterior cruciate ligament deficiency. DESIGN: To evaluate an EMG-to-force processing model, two groups of subjects, with and without deficiency of the anterior cruciate ligament, participated in experiments in which surface EMG, kinematics and kinetics about the knee were recorded during isokinetic and functional movements. BACKGROUND: Clinical and biomechanical evidence supports the hypothesis that higher level of co-contraction of quadriceps and hamstrings provide an active stabilization of the knee to compensate for the lost anterior cruciate ligament. To quantify the level of co-contraction, the contribution of both agonist and antagonist muscles to the net joint moment must be known. METHODS: Surface EMG levels were calibrated to moment by means of a limited number of isokinetic contractions about the knee. With these calibration values, an estimate of the muscle moments during a vertical jump were obtained and compared with the net joint moment, calculated with inverse dynamics. Also co-contraction indices were determined. RESULTS: The EMG-force model provided a fair estimate of the net joint moment. The co-contraction index in anterior cruciate ligament deficient subjects was significantly higher (mean 0.54 (SD, 0.04)) compared to healthy subjects (mean 0.25 (SD, 0.07)). CONCLUSIONS: Although the EMG-to-force processing model is not perfectly accurate, it is appropriate within a clinical context. RELEVANCE: Previous research supports the hypothesis that subjects with an anterior cruciate ligament deficiency compensate the loss of passive stability by developing higher co-activation levels of the knee muscles, i.e. active stabilization. Quantifying co-contraction may serve as a valuable parameter to evaluate clinical interventions and rehabilitation processes. The EMG-force model presented in this study appears to be a useful instrument for this purpose.     

Coordination stability between the legs is reduced after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

BackgroundThe study was designed to examine coordination differences in walking between individuals with an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction compared with healthy matched controls. Predictions from the extended Haken, Kelso, and Bunz coupled oscillator model were tested in these populations.MethodsSeventeen persons with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and 17 matched controls participated in the study. Sagittal plane angular knee displacement was recorded using electrogoniometers over the lateral right and left knee joints while participants walked at five walking speeds overground. Coordination pattern and stability between the knees were quantified by mean and standard deviation of relative phase, respectively.FindingsMean relative phase was not influenced by walking speed or group. For both groups, coordination stability was maximal when individual's walked at their preferred gait speed. However, the anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction group demonstrated reduced coordination stability compared with healthy controls across the five speeds. Multiple regression analyses found that people with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction who deviated more from antiphase coordination had decreased coordination stability.InterpretationAnterior cruciate ligament reconstruction results in decreased coordination stability, indicative of reduced coupling strength between the legs. This change in gait coordination, which has not previously been found in the literature, may contribute to the increased rate of re-injury and degeneration in individuals who have had this reconstructive surgery. Application of a motor control model enhances our understanding of the influence of an injury on coordination during gait.