Autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction in man. X. T-T autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction in young and aging humans

T cells upon activation with mitogens or autologous non T cells express surface HLA-DR antigens and are capable of stimulating autologous T cells in the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (T-T AMLR). We have examined T-TA AMLR, using T-non T AMLR activated-(TA) T cells as stimulators in young (21-32 yr) and aging humans (62-84 yr). In aging subjects a significantly (p less than 0 . 01) higher proliferative response was observed in T-TA AMLR as compared to simultaneously studied young subjects. In allogeneic MLR, no significant difference was observed between young and aging subjects. The increased T-TA AMLR could be a mechanism responsible for deficient T-non T AMLR reported in aging humans.     

Human autologous mixed lymphocyte reactivity is primarily specific for xenoprotein determinants adsorbed to antigen-presenting cells during rosette formation with sheep erythrocytes

We present evidence that most T cells proliferating in response to autologous sheep erythrocyte (SRBC)-separated non-T cells (NT) cells are not specific for autoantigens but for antigens derived from xenogeneic sources. The conclusion was based on the following three observations. First, we found that NT cells isolated in the absence of xenoproteins by means of density gradient centrifugation on Percoll only weakly stimulated autologous T cells. Because this weak proliferation could not be expanded in restimulation experiments, its significance as an immune recognitive event remains questionable. NT cells isolated by the above method in the absence of xenogeneic determinants readily acquired stimulatory capacity after brief exposure to either SRBC or fetal calf serum. Second, restimulation of T memory cells generated in 1 degree autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR) against SRBC-separated autologous NT cells was exclusively seen when NT cells exposed to or separated with xenoproteins were used for restimulation. Third, T memory cells generated against SRBC-separated autologous NT cells were specifically restimulated by autologous Percoll-separated NT cells that had been pulsed with a variety of xenogeneic mammalian sera. These xenogeneic determinants were preferentially recognized in context with autologous HLA-DR+ cells. From these findings and from our previous results that indicated an absolute requirement of HLA-DR+-adherent NT cells (8), we conclude that human AMLR primarily does not represent an autoantigen but a xenoantigen response that is genetically restricted by the HLA-DR type of the antigen-presenting cell.     

Distinct features of dendritic cells and anti-Ig activated B cells as stimulators of the primary mixed leukocyte reaction

Highly enriched populations of B lymphoblasts have been isolated after culture with anti-Ig-Sepharose and compared with dendritic cells as stimulators of CD4+ T cells in the murine MLR. The two populations clearly differed in phenotype; anti-Ig blasts were FcR+, B220+, 33D1-, while dendritic cells were FcR-, B220-, 33D1+. However, as MLR stimulators, they shared many common features. Both cells (a) expressed comparable levels of class II MHC products; (b) independently stimulated the primary MLR and the production of several T derived lymphokines including IL-2 and IL-4; and (c) were comparable in stimulating freshly sensitized T cells. However, the relative potencies of dendritic cells and anti-Ig blasts as primary MLR stimulators varied in a strain-dependent fashion. Only anti-Ig blasts could stimulate across an Mls barrier, being at least 100 times more active in stimulating Mls-mismatched, MHC-matched T cells, relative to syngeneic T cells. In contrast, dendritic cells were 10-30 times more potent than anti-Ig blasts when stimulating across an MHC barrier and were likewise more effective in binding MHC-disparate T cells to form the clusters in which the MLR was generated. Dendritic cell-T cell clustering was resistant to anti-LFA-1 mAb, while B blast-T cell clustering was totally blocked. Thus, anti-Ig B lymphoblasts and dendritic cells, two cell types which differ markedly in phenotype, also differ in efficiency and mechanism for initiating responses in allogeneic T cells.     

Autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction in the peripheral blood and pleural effusions of cancer patients.

T cells proliferate in response to autologous non-T cells in the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR). AMLR was impaired in the peripheral blood of patients with advanced lung cancer (4,159 +/- 3,878 delta cpm vs. 11,221 +/- 4,156 delta cpm for normal donors) but normal or even higher in their malignant pleural effusions (13,257 +/- 7,075 delta cpm vs. 10, 870 +/- 5,013 delta cpm for nonmalignant control effusions). Blood T cells also failed to respond to autologous effusion non-T cells, while effusion T cells strongly responded to autologous erythrocytes blood non-T cells. The presence of blood T cells did not inhibit effusion AMLR of the same patients. A subset of T cells that form rosettes with autologous erythrocytes if found to proliferate in AMLR. The number of autorosette-forming cells was lower in blood T cells of cancer patients than in blood T cells of normal donors and in effusion T cells of the patients. After enrichment of autorosette-forming cells, there was no difference in AMLR of normal blood and cancer blood and effusions. These results indicate that the loss of AMLR in the blood of cancer patients is due to a reduction of number of autoreactive T cells and not to a defect of autologous stimulator non-T cells.     

Responder cells in the human autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction.

Isolated human T4+ cells proliferate in the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR), whereas isolated T8+ cells do not. However, in the presence of Interleukin 2 or T4+ cells, the T8+ cells demonstrated substantial proliferation. These studies suggest that T8+ cells recognize signals from autologous non-T cells, but require an additional factor for the subsequent proliferative response. Since this stimulus can be provided by T4+ cells, the AMLR appears to constitute an inducer circuit. Different defects in this circuit may be responsible for the common abnormality of the AMLR in different diseases.     

Autologous rosette-forming T cells as the responding cells in human autologous mixed-lymphocyte reaction.

Autologous rosette-forming cells (Tar cells) have surface and functional characteristics of post-thymic precursors and among these characteristics there are some that have been identified in the responsive cell of the autologous mixed-lymphocyte reaction (AMLR). We therefore did AMLR with circulating mononuclear cells from normal subjects using as responding cells either total T cells, T cells depleted of Tar cells, or purified Tar cells. The response of Tar cells in AMLR was significantly greater than that of total T cells and these responded significantly more than Tar-depleted T cells. Conversely, Tar cells responded less than total T cells or T cells depleted of Tar cells in allogeneic mixed-lymphocyte reactions. Increasing numbers of Tar cells gave significantly greater AMLR responses both alone and when added to diminishing proportions of Tar-depleted T cells to keep the number of T cells constant in the system. Tar cells are the responding cells in AMLR but not in allogeneic mixed-lymphocyte reactions.     

Enhancement of the impaired autologous mixed leukocyte reaction in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus.

The cellular basis of the impaired autologous mixed leukocyte reaction (AMLR) in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) was investigated. Non-T cells from normal subjects and from SLE patients were fractionated into low and high density subpopulations. SLE patients were found to have an increased proportion of low density to high density non-T cells when compared to normal subjects. Although normal low-density non-T cells were highly enriched in AMLR stimulatory capacity, SLE low-density non-T cells induced minimal proliferation by autologous T cells. Brief incubation of SLE non-T cells with phorbol myristate acetate or formalin-treated Staphylococcus aureus resulted in marked augmentation of the capacity of those non-T cells to stimulate an AMLR, although the magnitude of the activated non-T cell-induced AMLR did not achieve that observed in normal subjects. No significant alterations in the expression of Ia molecules on the surface of the non-T cells were detected after in vitro activation. These experiments support the hypothesis that the impaired capacity of SLE T lymphocytes to proliferate in response to autologous non-T cells may in part represent a failure of SLE non-T cells to present an appropriate stimulus for the generation of a T cell response.     

Deficient autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction in Kaposi's sarcoma associated with deficiency of Leu-3+ responder T cells.

Autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR) and T cell subsets defined with monoclonal antibodies were analyzed in the peripheral blood of homosexual males with Kaposi's sarcoma (KS). All seven patients demonstrated decreased AMLR (P less than 0.001) when compared with age- and sex-matched simultaneously studied controls. These patients also showed decreased proportions of Leu-3+ (helper/inducer phenotype) and an increase in the proportion of Leu-2+ (suppressor/cytotoxic phenotype) T cells. Leu-3+ T cells were purified from two patients by depleting Leu-2+ T cells in complement-dependent cytotoxicity. Leu-3+ T cells from both patients demonstrated poor proliferative response in the AMLR. In allogeneic MLR, patients' T cells were poor responders and their non-T cells were poor stimulators against healthy controls. This study demonstrates deficiency of both AMLR and allogeneic MLR in patients with KS. The decreased AMLR is associated with qualitative and functional deficiency of Leu-3+ responder T cells. Whether the functional deficiency of Leu-3+ responder T cells in the AMLR is a general phenomena or a feature of a subset of patients with KS remains to be determined.     

Autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction in man. VI. Deficiency of autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction in type I (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus

Autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR) was examined in the peripheral blood from 20 patients with type I (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus. Six of 20 patients demonstrated deficient AMLR when compared to the range for simultaneously studied age and sex matched healthy controls. The kinetics of AMLR with regard to duration of the peak proliferative response was similar to controls, the peak response being on day 6. In allogeneic MLR. T cells from patients responded normally. However, non-T cells from patients were poor stimulators against responder T cells from healthy controls. This study demonstrates a deficiency of AMLR in a subset of patients with type I diabetes that further supports an abnormal immune regulation and might be an important mechanism in the pathogenesis and autoimmune manifestations of type I diabetes.     

Human immune responses to hapten-conjugated cells. I. Primary and secondary proliferative responses in vitro

An in vitro model was developed to study both primary and secondary proliferative responses of human lymphocytes to hapten-conjugated peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Coculture of human lymphocytes with autologous trinitrophenyl (TNP)-conjugated stimulator cells resulted in primary proliferative responses. Subjects segregated into high and low primary responders with mean stimulation indices of 11 and 2.1, respectively. Restimulation of primed cells from high responder subjects 3 wk after initial sensitization generated secondary proliferative responses. To investigate the antigenic requirements for secondary stimulation, autologous TNP-conjugate primed responders were restimulated with both autologous and allogeneic TNP-conjugated stimulators. In all experiments restimulation with autologous conjugated cells yielded substantially greater proliferative responses than with allogeneic conjugates. Experiments were then performed to ascertain whether HLA determinant homology between primed responder and stimulator cells influenced the level of secondary responsiveness. Homology for HLA-A and B locus serologic determinants was not associated with enhanced responsiveness. In contrast, D region determinant homology, detected by B-cell antigen typing, showed a highly significant positive correlation with the magnitude of secondary responses. The data thus strongly suggest that for secondary proliferative responses to TNP, human T cells recognize hapten in association with HLA-D region determinants.     

Antigen-reactive T cells can be activated buy autologous macrophages in the absence of added antigen

T cells responsive to macrophages (M phi) in the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR) contain those cells that can be induced to proliferate by soluble antigens. Negative solution (5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine and light) of T cells activated by autologous M phi also removed those cells required for reactivity to Candida albicans and purified protein derivative. Positive selection of T cells responsive to autologous M phi yields a population that is simultaneously enriched in antigen reactivity. Some patients demonstrating cutaneous anergy and diminished in vitro blast transformation in response to soluble antigen also lack T cells responsive to the AMLR to M phi. When considered in conjunction with previously reported data, these findings indicate the AMLR occurring between T cells and M phi in the absence of soluble antigen represents self recognition occurring between antigen-reactive T cells and antigen-presenting M phi.     

Inhibition of T cell responses by activated human CD8+ T cells is mediated by interferon-gamma and is defective in chronic progressive multiple sclerosis.

The autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR) involves the activation of T cells by autologous antigen presenting cells. Cells are generated during the course of the AMLR that have suppressive properties in vitro. In the present study we investigated the induction of CD8+ T cells in the AMLR with suppressive properties and the mechanism by which these cells downregulate in vitro proliferative responses. Purified CD8+ but not CD4+ T cells activated in the AMLR in conditioned medium inhibited proliferation of autologous T cells by anti-CD3 or PPD. Nonactivated CD8+ T cells did not suppress. The CD8+ T cells activated in the AMLR in the presence of conditioned medium (CD8+ Tact) were CD11b negative and were noncytotoxic. The inhibitory effect of CD8+ Tact cells was completely abrogated by anti-IFN-gamma antibody, but not by anti-IL-4, anti-IL-10, or anti-TGF-beta antibody. The induction of CD8+ Tact cells in the AMLR was blocked by anti-IL-2 or by anti-GM-CSF antibody and the combination of these two recombinant cytokines could support the induction of suppressive CD8+ Tact cells. CD8+ Tact cells were defective in patients with chronic progressive multiple sclerosis (MS) as compared to patients with relapsing-remitting MS or normal controls. Our studies provide a basis for understanding the mechanism of suppression by human CD8+ T cells in terms of specific cytokines, and demonstrate the potential importance of these cells in a human autoimmune disease as their function is defective in patients with progressive MS.     

Impairment of the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction in atopic dermatitis.

The T cell proliferative response to autologous non-T cells is termed the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR). Recent studies have suggested that the AMLR represents an inducer circuit for the activation of T8+ suppressor/cytotoxic effector cells. Since atopic dermatitis (AD) patients are deficient in T8+ cytolytic T cell function, we investigated the AMLR in AD. When sheep erythrocytes were used to separate T cells from non-T cells, the AMLR was found to be significantly decreased (P less than 0.001) in AD patients (n = 11; delta cpm = 1,550 +/- 393) when compared with normal control subjects (n = 13; delta cpm = 25,819 +/- 4,609). To exclude the possibility that these results were an artifact of the sheep erythrocyte separation, T cells were also separated on a fluorescence-activated cell sorter after treatment of peripheral blood lymphocytes with the OKT3 monoclonal antibody. AD T cells separated by the latter method were also found to have a significantly reduced AMLR response when compared with similarly treated normal T cells. Co-culture studies using cells from AD patients and their HLA identical siblings indicated that the defect resided at the responder T cell level rather than at the stimulator non-T cell level. Co-culture studies revealed no evidence for excessive suppressor cell activity resulting in the decreased AMLR. However, enumeration of T cells reactive with the monoclonal antibody T29, which recognizes a subset of T cells proliferating in the AMLR, demonstrated that AD patients (n = 8; % T29 = 2.5 +/- 0.7) had a significantly decreased (P less than 0.001) number of circulating T29+ T cells when compared with normal controls (n = 8; % T29 = 10.4 +/- 0.8). These studies suggest that a deficiency of T4+ T29+ cells contributes to the deficient AMLR in AD and possibly underlies the abnormalities of T8+ effector cells present in this disease.     

Helper cells in the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction. III. Production of helper factor(s) distinct from interleukin 2

In normal mice, the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR) can activate helper T cells that, in the presence of hapten-modified syngeneic cells, can induce a hapten-specific cytotoxic response. Supernatants from AMLR cultures contain a factor(s) that will mediate a cytotoxic T cell response to hapten-altered self. The AMLR factor is effective in facilitating the generation of cytotoxicity only in those cultures containing both T cells and hapten-altered, syngeneic, nonstimulatory cells. Factor production requires an interaction between Lyt-1+23- cells and non-T cells (the T cells synthesize it). The AMLR factor does not appear to be interleukin 2 (IL-2) because it does not activate thymocytes in the presence of antigen, nor does it maintain an IL-2-dependent cell line or function in co-stimulator assays. For the AMLR factor to facilitate the generation of cytotoxicity, thymic adherent cells are a necessary intermediate. These data suggest that the factor recoverable from AMLR cultures acts early in the cytotoxic pathway, before IL-1 production.     

Decreased autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction in Sj?gren's syndrome.

The autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR) measures the response of peripheral blood T cells to antigens present on the surface of non-T cells. The AMLR was studied in 25 patients with Sjögren's syndrome (SS). The AMLR was decreased in 15 of 25 (60%) of patients with SS (5,272 +/- 6,738 cpm vs. 14,396 +/- 10,092 cpm for the normal controls, P < 0.001). The AMLR was decreased in 8 of 15 patients with only glandular disease who were not on any systemic medications. Patients with SS and associated disease had lower responses than patients with SS alone. Two patients with pseudolymphoma had absent response. The decreased AMLR correlated with a decreased response to concanavalin A, suggesting a possible abnormality of a T cell subpopulation. There was no correlation between the decreased AMLR and age, focus score, serum immunoglobulin concentration, the titer of antilymphocyte antibody, or phytohemagglutinin response. In allogeneic MLR, SS non-T cells and macrophages stimulated normal allogeneic T cells less well than normal non-T cells and macrophages, suggesting a possible abnormality in the cells that stimulate in the cells that stimulate in the allogeneic MLR.     

Production of a cytokine with interleukin 3-like properties and cytokine-dependent proliferation in human autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction

The autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR) was assayed in a medium containing fresh autologous serum, by using nylon-adherent stimulator cells and nonadherent responder T cells, which were prepared from human peripheral blood mononuclear cells in the absence of fetal calf serum (FCS) to avoid any sensitization to xenogeneic protein antigens. DNA replication without a background proliferative response was induced by stimulator cells in the responder cells. The addition of monoclonal anti-HLA-DR antibody to the culture or treatment of the responder cells with complement plus anti-T4 but not anti-T8 monoclonal antibody suppressed the AMLR, suggesting that this specific AMLR involves an interaction between HLA-DR antigens and helper/inducer T cells. Regardless of this specific DNA replication, the AMLR generated no production of interleukin 2 (IL-2) and interferon gamma (IFN-gamma), both of which could be found in the allogeneic (allo) MLR. In addition, DNA replication in the AMLR was not inhibited by the addition of specific antisera for IL-2 and IFN-gamma, both of which significantly inhibited the DNA replication in allo-MLR. The AMLR was accompanied by production of a soluble factor, which could stimulate the proliferation of murine interleukin 3 (IL-3)-dependent cell line 32Dcl but not the proliferation of IL-2-dependent cell lines. This factor was also found to be responsible for proliferation of responder nonadherent cells in the AMLR. It strongly stimulated bone marrow cells, as did the murine IL-3. The factor had an Mr range, as determined by gel filtration, of 15,000-28,000, but it did not bind to fast protein liquid chromatography (FPLC)-MonoQ column. Thus, the factor is distinguishable from IL-2 in physicochemical or biological properties, but similar to murine IL-3. These results suggest that the human AMLR may be primarily a phenomenon in which non-T cells mediated by the HLA-DR antigens on the cell stimulate helper/inducer T cells to produce a lymphokine with IL-3-like properties, but no IL-2, which in turn stimulates the factor-dependent cells to proliferate.     

HLA-DR histocompatibility leukocyte antigens permit cultured human melanoma cells from early but not advanced disease to stimulate autologous lymphocytes.

HLA-DR histocompatibility antigens are commonly expressed by the melanocytes of melanoma and its precursors, but not by the melanocyte of normal skin. Further, the primary lesion of biologically early melanoma is commonly infiltrated with host T cells. Advanced disease is characterized by a paucity of such cells. To investigate the interaction of melanoma cells and autologous lymphocytes and its dependence on HLA-DR expression, we have established cell lines from biologically early (4 lines) and advanced disease (11 lines) and examined their capacity to stimulate blastogenesis of autologous T cells in vitro. Melanocytes from early disease expressed HLA-DR antigens and stimulated autologous T cells. Those from advanced disease, irrespective of DR expression, were nonstimulatory. To determine whether expression of DR was required for melanoma cells to be stimulatory, we first treated a stimulating cell line of DR3 allospecificity with anti-DR3-specific serum and demonstrated marked inhibition of its capacity to provoke blastogenesis. Next we used fluorescence-activated flow cytometry to sort a stimulating line heterogeneous for DR expression into DR-enriched and -depleted populations. When such cells were examined in the lymphocyte proliferation assay, their stimulatory capacity was proportional to their quantitative expression of HLA-DR. These studies indicate that cell lines may reflect important biological differences between early and advanced melanoma. HLA-DR expression may be an early event in neoplasia of melanocytes. These antigens are able to interact directly with autologous T cells; and their expression is necessary, but not sufficient, for melanoma cells to induce lymphocyte proliferation.     

Dendritic cells stimulate primary human cytolytic lymphocyte responses in the absence of CD4+ helper T cells

Cytotoxic lymphocytes are typically generated from unfractionated suspensions of human lymphocytes by stimulating with heterogeneous APCs and exogeneous growth factors. We have found that human blood dendritic cells can directly stimulate allogeneic human CD8+ T cells to proliferate and express antigen-specific cytotoxic activity. These primary responses, which are accompanied by the release of T cell growth factor(s), are induced in the absence of CD4+ helper T cells and are not inhibited by anti-CD4 mAb. Both antigen-specific CTL as well as nonspecific NK cells can be elicited by dendritic cells. The NK cell response can be depleted at the precursor level by panning with an anti-CD11b mAb, which removes a CD11b+/CD28-, CD16+ subset from the starting CD4- responders. Allogeneic blood monocytes are neither stimulatory nor inhibitory of these primary CD4- MLRs, even though monocytes present alloantigen in such a way as to be recognized as specific targets for CTL that have been sensitized by dendritic cells. The number of CD8+ cells that are blast transformed and express an activated phenotype (i.e., HLA DR/DQ+, CD25/IL-2R+, CD45R-) reaches 30-40% of the culture at day 4-5, the peak of the helper-independent response. We conclude that antigen-presentation by dendritic cells is sufficient in itself to prime cytolytic precursors. We speculate that using dendritic cell stimulators and CD4- responders in MLRs may be more efficient than standard tissue typing approaches for the detection of subtle, but important class I MHC-restricted histoincompatibilities in human transplantation.     

Allogeneic suppressive effects of pregnancy sera on monocytes of responding cells in human mixed lymphocyte reactions

The purified human monocytes of a responding donor preincubated with heat-inactivated serum T1264 or T1295 derived from pregnant women for 30 min at 37 degrees C expressed allogeneic suppressive effects on the proliferative response of the lymphocytes from the same donor in the allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). The pregnancy serum in our experiments was found not to contain any antibodies to DR and DQ antigens on monocytes of the responding donor. Accordingly, the suppressive effects mediated by monocytes were not based on the blocking of DR and DQ antigens on monocytes of the responding donor by DR and DQ antibodies in the serum. These highly reproducible allogeneic suppressive effects by monocytes of the responding donor were demonstrated in the MLR specific for DRw9-positive stimulating cells, whereas no inhibition was seen in the cultures with other stimulating cells of different DR phenotypes. Additionally, these suppressive effects appeared on the monocytes of a DR2-positive responding donor, but not on the monocytes of a DR2-negative responding donor. These suppressive effects were abolished when the absorbed pregnancy serum by monocytes of the DR2-positive responding donor was used. In this suppression phenomenon that we discovered, monocytes of the responding donor appear to act as regulatory cells on the proliferative response of the allogeneic MLR. This regulatory function of monocytes could be expressed through the specific molecules distinct from DR and DQ determinants on monocytes in cooperation with antibodies (IgG class) in the pregnancy serum.     

Lymphocyte Transformation Induced by Autologous Cells: Stimulation by Cultured Lymphoblast Lines

The ability of cultured lymphoblasts to stimulate autologous lymphocyte transformation in "one-way" mixed leukocyte culture has been studied. Intact, cultured lymphoblasts required physical contact with responding lymphocytes to induce transformation. In quantitative terms, lymphocytes incorporate as much thymidine when mixed with irradiated cultured lymphoblasts as they do in response to phytohemagglutinin. The stimulation of lymphocyte transformation by allogeneic cultured lymphoblasts did not parallel the stimulation of lymphocyte transformation by leukocytes from the donor of the lymphoblast culture. The stimulatory determinants on the cultured lymphoblast are unaffected by neuraminidase but destroyed by trypsin. The trypsin-treated cultured lymphoblasts regain their capacity to stimulate autologous lymphocyte transformation within 48 hr in culture. Cultured lymphoblasts possess concanavalin A binding sites. Concanavalin A inhibits the capacity of cultured lymphoblasts to stimulate autologous lymphocyte transformation. The relevance of these findings to EB virus infection of cultured lymphoblasts and to immune surveillance is discussed.