Surgical Approaches in Total Knee Arthroplasty: A Meta-Analysis Comparing the Midvastus and Subvastus to the Medial Peripatellar Approach

Subvastus, midvastus and medial parapatellar approaches are the most popular approaches in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). However, the superior approach in TKA still remains controversial. We therefore conducted a meta-analysis to quantitatively compare the midvastus and subvastus approaches to the medial parapatellar approach in TKA. A total of 32 randomized controlled trials (RCTs) with 2451 TKAs in 2129 patients were included in this study. The meta-analysis suggested that, when compared with the medial parapatellar approach, the midvastus approach showed better outcomes in pain and knee range of motion at postoperative 1–2 weeks but also was associated with longer operative time; the subvastus approach showed better outcomes in knee range of motion at postoperative 1 week, straight leg raise and lateral retinacular release.     

Comparison of early postoperative rehabilitation outcome following total knee arthroplasty using different surgical approaches and instrumentation

PURPOSE: To assess early postoperative rehabilitation outcome following computer-assisted total knee arthroplasty (TKA) or standard instrumentation TKA using a medial parapatellar or subvastus approach. METHODS: A prospective controlled trial of 70 consecutive patients undergoing TKA with a low contact stress rotating platform prosthesis was conducted. Patients were randomised to receive surgery with either computer navigation or standard instrumentation. A medial parapatellar or subvastus approach was used according to the surgeons' preference. Outcome measures included preoperative knee function, intra-operative factors, and postoperative rehabilitation. RESULTS: Duration of surgery was significantly longer when using computer navigation; however, operating time decreased with greater experience. A higher incidence and duration of early postoperative quadriceps dysfunction was associated with computer-assisted TKA through the medial parapatellar approach than through the subvastus approach or TKA performed with standard instrumentation. No patient who received surgery through the subvastus approach had a lag of more than 20 degrees, at 48 hours postoperatively, regardless of the instrumentation used. CONCLUSION: Computer-assisted TKA through a medial parapatellar approach was associated with delayed recovery of the quadriceps during early postoperative rehabilitation. This was due to the additional quadriceps dissection required to place the femoral tracking array. The subvastus approach is therefore recommended for computer-assisted TKA.     

Subvastus and medial parapatellar approaches in TKA: comparison of functional results

The purpose of this study was to compare the clinical results of total knee arthroplasty (TKA) in the early and late postoperative period using subvastus and medial parapatellar approach. A prospective randomized controlled study was conducted in a group of 169 patients (180 TKAs) with 2-year follow-up. Patients were divided into a study group (97 TKAs) with a subvastus approach and a control group (83 TKAs) with a parapatellar approach. Assessment of the results of both operating approaches was based on functional, clinical Knee Society Score, and pain (visual analog scale). Patients in the subvastus group achieved full active extension, better range of motion, and better Knee Society Score results at 12 days, 6 weeks, and 12 weeks earlier than patients in the medial parapatellar group. They also had less pain at 12 days. No statistically significant differences existed between assessed end points in both groups at 24- and 52-weeks, and 24-months postoperatively. The subvastus approach has given patients better early clinical results; however, at longer follow-up, both groups had similar outcomes. The potential benefits of the subvastus approach are: protection of the extensor mechanism from damage, less risk of damaging the blood supply to the patella, earlier clinical recovery, and less pain in the early postoperative period. The subvastus approach is an alternative to the standard medial parapatellar approach in TKA. It can be used with equally good results, especially taking into consideration positive clinical aspects in the early postoperative period.     

Outcome of subvastus approach in elderly nonobese patients undergoing bilateral simultaneous total knee arthroplasty: A randomized controlled study

Background:

Subvastus approach in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) spares the quadriceps and may assist in faster rehabilitation. The present randomised controlled study was conducted to determine if the subvastus approach results in early recovery, faster mobilization, shorter hospital stay, and improved function.

Materials and Methods:

100 patients undergoing simultaneous bilateral TKA were randomized into two groups: subvastus group and medial parapatellar group. The patients were assessed clinically using VAS, time to straight leg raise, ability to stand with walker, ability to use a commode chair, ability to climb stairs, flexion at discharge, and day of discharge. Perioperative blood loss and duration of surgery were also compared. The patient were kept on same pain management and physiotherapy protocol. The evaluation was done at day 0,1,3 and at discharge. Statistical analyses tested the null hypotheses of no differences in patients treated with either group at 95% significance level (P < 0.05).

Results:

The VAS score was significantly lower in subvastus group on day 1 and day 3. Also mean hospital stay was 2.04 days less in subvastus group. Patients with subvastus approach were able to perform straight leg raising 0.44 days earlier. Though time to stand with walker was same for both groups, the ability to use commode chair, and climb stairs was significantly early (P < 0.05) in the subvastus group. The average flexion at the time of discharge in subvastus and parapatellar group were 100.8 and 96.8°, respectively. The mean perioperative blood loss in subvastus group and parapatellar group were 343 ml and 372 ml, respectively. Average surgical time required for subvastus approach and parapatellar approach were 108.5 and 94.3 min, respectively.

Conclusions:

Subvastus approach produce appreciably less pain and faster mobilization due to lesser insult to quadriceps, thus assisting in early rehabilitation, shorter hospital stay, less expenditure, and more patient satisfaction.     

Computer Navigation Results in Less Severe Flexion Contracture Following Total Knee Arthroplasty

We compared postoperative flexion contracture in navigated total knee arthroplasty (TKA) versus conventional TKA. Two groups (Group 1: conventional, Group 2: navigated) of 235 consecutive patients matched for age and gender were retrospectively compared. Range of motion, mechanical axes, Knee Society Scores, Oxford Knee Scores and Short Form-36® (SF-36) scores were collected prospectively and compared preoperatively and at 2 years following TKA. At 2 years, patients who underwent navigated TKA averaged significantly lesser flexion contracture of 1 degree compared to 6 degrees in patients who underwent conventional TKA. There were a significantly larger proportion of outliers in the conventional group. Computer navigation results in less severe flexion contracture and less frequent flexion contracture of more than 5 degrees as compared to conventional techniques.     

Is Minimally Invasive Surgery in Total Knee Arthroplasty Really Minimally Invasive Surgery?

Minimization of soft-tissue damage is one of the primary purposes behind the application of minimally invasive surgery (MIS) in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). A consecutive series of 147 TKAs were enrolled in the present study, with 96 MIS-TKAs using 11 quadriceps-sparing, 46 subvastus, 32 midvastus, and 7 parapatellar approaches and 51 conventional TKAs using 22 subvastus, 9 midvastus, and 20 parapatellar approaches. Serum levels of creatinine phosphokinase, myoglobin, aldolase, lactate dehydrogenase, glutamic oxaloacetic transaminase, and creatinine were measured on postoperative days 0, 1, 2, 4, 7, and 14. Postoperative rising index (RI) was expressed as a proportion of the preoperative value. When RIs were compared between MIS-TKA and conventional TKA, no significant differences were found for any enzymes. Interestingly, the midvastus approach displayed the highest RIs for creatinine phosphokinase and myoglobin between the 4 vastus-splitting approaches. Consequently, degree of muscle damage was equivalent between MIS-TKA and conventional TKA, whereas types of vastus-splitting approach appeared closely related to muscle damage.     

Subvastus versus medial parapatellar approach in total knee arthroplasty

The subvastus approach for total knee replacement was compared with the standard medial parapatellar approach in terms of postoperative knee scores and quadriceps strength. Two groups of patients with similar characteristics were formed: the first group consisted of 12 knees of 9 patients who were implanted via the medial parapatellar approach, and for the second group the subvastus approach was used in 10 knees of 10 patients. The groups' knee scores and quadriceps strength were compared preoperatively and postoperatively at week 6, months 3 and 6. The knee scores improved similarly in both groups, but the change was more pronounced in the subvastus group. Quadriceps strength was greater in the subvastus group at postoperative week 6, but there was no significant difference between the groups in months 3 and 6. It was concluded that although the subvastus approach offers greater quadriceps strength in the early postoperative period, it has no significant advantage in this aspect over the medial parapatellar approach.     

Effects of Combined Application of Muscle Relaxants and Celecoxib Administration After Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) on Early Recovery: A Randomized,Double-Blind,Controlled Study

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of application of muscle relaxants and celecoxib in early recovery after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). One hundred and fifty patients were randomized 1:1:1 to receive either both of muscle relaxants and celecoxib or muscle relaxants alone or placebo for 2 weeks (50 patients in each group). VAS pain scores as primary efficacy, active range of motion, morphine consumption, blood loss, and postoperative complications including postoperative nausea and vomiting (PONV), extremities myasthenia and deep vein thrombosis (DVT) were determined postoperatively. Group A improved better with reduced VAS pain scores compared with another two groups. These results demonstrated that application of muscle relaxants and celecoxib into patients undergoing TKA for 2 weeks postoperative consequently improved their convalescence.     

Strength and voluntary activation of quadriceps femoris muscle in total knee arthroplasty with midvastus and subvastus approaches

To determine and compare the influence of 2 different approaches on quadriceps femoris muscle function in total knee arthroplasty (TKA), 20 patients (14 women, 6 men) with bilateral knee osteoarthritis underwent a 1-stage bilateral TKA. Surgical approaches (subvastus, midvastus) were performed by a random selection. Measurements of quadriceps voluntary activation and maximal voluntary contraction were estimated by a twitch interpolation technique before, 3 and 6 months after TKA. Knee pain was quantified by the Lewis Score. There was no difference between the 2 approaches at 3 and 6 months after TKA with regard to maximal voluntary contraction (P = 0.84, F = 0.041) and voluntary activation (P = .863, F = 0.031). In the subvastus group was a significantly higher knee pain until 6 months after surgery (P = .02). The subvastus approach for TKA does not provide any advantages compared with the midvastus approach with respect to the quadriceps femoris muscle strength in the early postoperative period. Furthermore, the subvastus approach caused significantly more pain postoperatively.     

Comparison of the modified subvastus and medial parapatellar approaches in total knee arthroplasty

In this paper, we evaluated the difference between the modified subvastus approach and the medial parapatellar approach in total knee arthroplasty(TKA). We assessed the time of active straight-leg raise (SLR) post-operatively and the range of flexion of the operated knee at the tenth post-operative day, 6 weeks and 6 months, 12 months and 3 years. We investigated the degree of the patellar tilt and subluxation 24 months post-operatively. The patients who underwent the modified subvastus approach performed active SLR earlier (mean 0.5 days) than the medial parapatellar approach patients (mean 2.2 days). Knee flexion was better at the tenth post-operative day in the modified subvastus approach group compared to the medial parapatellar approach group. There was no statistical difference between the two groups with regard to the patellar tilt and subluxation. We conclude that the modified subvastus approach is recommendable in primary TKA.

---

Résumé  Nous avons évalué la différence entre l’abord médial para patellaire et l’abord modifié subvastus lors de la mise en place d’une prothèse totale du genou. Nous avons apprécié le temps de récupération post-opératoire de l’extension active du genou et le degré de flexion de celui-ci à 10 jours, 6 semaines, 6, 12 et 36 mois. Nous avons également exploré les complications rotuliennes, notamment subluxations à 24 mois. Les patients ayant bénéficié d’un abord subvastus récupèrent une extension active plus précoce (en moyenne de 0,5 jours), contre 2,2 jours pour l’abord médian. L’amélioration de la flexion du genou est également meilleure à 10 jours post-opératoire dans ce groupe. Il n’y a pas de différence significative entre ces deux groupes en ce qui concerne les problèmes rotuliens. Nous pensons que l’abord subvastus est à recommander dans la mise en place d’une prothèse totale du genou.

     

Incidence,Predictors, and Effects of Residual Flexion Contracture on Clinical Outcomes of Total Knee Arthroplasty

Patients who present with large flexion contracture (FC) but have well maintained maximum flexion tend to have a flexion–extension gap mismatch, which can cause residual FC or flexion instability after TKA. We routinely use posterior-stabilized implants, perform soft tissue balancing and additional distal femur resection, and determine the polyethylene insert thickness based on flexion–extension gap difference to avoid postoperative FC and flexion instability. We retrospectively reviewed 911 TKAs performed with this protocol to determine the incidence, predictors and effects of postoperative FC on clinical outcomes. Knees with postoperative FC ≥ 10° were identified, and their clinical outcomes were compared with knees without FC. The average follow-up period was 35 months (range, 24–72 months). Eighteen (2.0%) of the 911 knees presented with postoperative FC. The occurrence of postoperative FC was associated with preoperative FC and anterior knee pain, but not with a flexion–extension gap mismatch. A mild to moderate postoperative FC does not increase pain, but may be detrimental to quality of life.     

Comparison of the subvastus and paramedian surgical approaches in bilateral knee arthroplasty

A prospective randomized study was performed on 20 patients undergoing one-stage bilateral knee arthroplasty. One knee was exposed using a standard median parapatellar arthrotomy and the other knee with a subvastus arthrotomy. All patients underwent quantitative strength testing before surgery and at I week, I month, and 3 months after surgery. The knees were also evaluated for range of motion, and patients, who were blinded as to the approach used, completed questionnaires at each evaluation period as to their preference, if any, regarding knee pain and level of function. There was no difference in the range of motion between knees exposed with the paramedian or subvastus arthrotomy at any time period. The subvastus knees demonstrated significantly greater strength at the 1-week and 1-month intervals, but there was no strength difference at the 3-month interval. There were more lateral releases performed in the paramedium knees, and three minor complications were related to the subvastus approach. Patients who expressed a preference chose the subvastus knee 4: 1 over the paramedian knee. The subvastus approach offers a reasonable alternative to the paramedian arthrotomy and preserves greater quadriceps strength in the early postoperative period.     

Subvastus and medial parapatellar approaches in total knee arthroplasty

This retrospective study compared the outcome of two consecutive groups of patients having primary total knee arthroplasty. The arthroplasties were performed in the first group (169 arthroplasties in 143 patients) from 1988 to 1992 using a medial parapatellar approach, and in the second group (167 arthroplasties in 148 patients) from 1992 to 1996 using a subvastus approach. The patient outcomes were evaluated at 6 months, and were based on clinical and radiographic measures, occurrence of intraoperative lateral retinacular release, and incidence of postoperative patellar subluxation. There were no significant differences between the two groups for range of motion, Knee Society knee and function scores, and stair climbing ability. The patella tracked centrally in significantly more knees with the subvastus approach (139 of 167 knees, 83%) than with the parapatellar approach (107 of 169 knees, 63%). There were significantly fewer knees in the subvastus group requiring a lateral retinacular release (62 of 167 knees, 37%), compared with the parapatellar group (113 of 169 knees, 67%). The authors concluded that the subvastus approach led to improved patellar tracking and stability. Although the surgical and rehabilitative protocols were identical for both groups, the results may have been affected by changing circumstances during the 9-year period of the study.     

Total knee arthroplasty using subvastus approach in stiff knee: A retrospective analysis of 110 cases

Background:

Subvastus approach used in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is known to produce an earlier recovery but is not commonly utilized for TKA when the preoperative range of motion (ROM) of the knee is limited. Subvastus approach is known for its ability to give earlier recovery due to less postoperative pain and early mobilization (due to rapid quadriceps recovery). Subvastus approach is considered as a relative contraindication for TKA in knees with limited ROM due to difficulty in exposure which can increase risk of complications such as patellar tendon avulsion or medial collateral injury. Short stature and obesity are also relative contraindications. Tarabichi successfully used subvastus approach in knees with limited preoperative ROM. However, there are no large series in literature with the experience of the subvatus approach in knees with limited preoperative ROM. We are presenting our experience of the subvastus approach for TKA in knees with limited ROM.

Materials and Methods:

We conducted retrospective analysis of patients with limited preoperative ROM (flexion ≤90°) of the knee who underwent TKA using subvastus approach and presenting the 2 years results. There were a total 84 patients (110 knees) with mean age 64 (range 49–79 years) years. The mean preoperative flexion was 72° (range 40°–90°) with a total ROM of 64° (range 36°–90°).

Results:

Postoperatively knee flexion improved by mean 38° (P < 0.05) which was significant as assed by Student''s t- test. The mean knee society score improved from 36 (range 20–60) to 80 (range 70–90) postoperatively (P < 0.05). There was one case of partial avulsion of patellar tendon from the tibial tubercle.

Conclusions:

We concluded that satisfactory results of TKA can be obtained in knees with limited preoperative ROM using subvastus approach maintaining the advantages of early mobilization.     

Mini-Midvastus Versus Mini-Medial Parapatellar Approach for Minimally Invasive Total Knee Arthroplasty : Outcomes Pendulum Is at Equilibrium

Comparisons between mini-midvastus (mMV) and mini-medial parapatellar approach (mMPP) for total knee arthroplasty (TKA) have reported variable results. We compared two approaches with minimum two year follow up. Forty consecutive patients who underwent staged bilateral TKA were prospectively randomized for mMPP approach in one knee and mMV approach in the other. Clinical parameters (muscle strength, pain, ROM, Knee Society Score) and surgic.l parameters (duration of surgery, blood loss, lateral releases) were assessed at 2, 6, 12 weeks and 6, 12, 24 months postoperatively. Clinical outcomes revealed inconsistent pattern of differences at various intervals. Surgical outcomes were not different. There were no major differences in outcomes between the two approaches. We recommend someone use surgical approach with which they are most familiar.     

股肌下结合微斜切入路全膝关节置换术治疗膝外翻

目的评估股肌下结合微斜切入路(SMOC)实施人工全膝关节置换术治疗膝关节外翻畸形的可行性及早期临床效果。 方法回顾性分析2015年4月至2017年10月在青岛大学附属医院关节外科50例(60膝)行初次人工膝关节置换术治疗并获得完整随访的膝外翻患者，排除年龄> 85岁、既往膝关节手术史及身体质量指数> 30 kg/m²的患者。男13例，女37例，年龄平均(60±8)岁。诊断为类风湿性关节炎42例52膝，骨关节炎5例5膝，创伤性关节炎3例3膝。采用SMOC入路行人工全膝关节置换术患者25例(31膝)，内侧髌旁入路者25例(29膝)。记录并比较两组患者的术前一般资料、血红蛋白、视觉模拟评分法(VAS)、美国特种外科医院(HSS)评分、膝关节被动活动度(ROM)、外翻角度；手术时间、术中出血量、外侧支持带松解率、术后2 d血红蛋白含量、术后引流量、输血率、直腿抬高时间、辅助镇痛药物使用情况、术后下肢力线、髌股适合角；24 h VAS，以及术后1周HSS评分及膝关节ROM，独立样本t检验或卡方检验比较分析两组差异。 结果术前一般资料两组无差异(P>0.05)，随访期间无感染及假体松动等并发症。术后外翻膝均得到矫正，两组在手术时间、术中出血量、术后引流量、术后2 d血红蛋白含量、输血率、术后下肢力线、髌股适合角方面两组差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)；SMOC组在直腿抬高时间(t＝10.500，P<0.01)、外侧支持带松解率(χ² ＝5.711，P<0.05)、辅助镇痛药使用(χ² ＝9.934，P<0.01)方面优于内侧髌旁入路。术后24 h VAS评分SMOC组低于髌旁组(t＝10.540，P<0.001)、1周HSS评分(t＝8.110，P<0.001)及ROM(t＝2.085，P<0.05)，SMOC组低于髌旁组。 结论利用SMOC入路全膝置换术可有效治疗膝外翻畸形，与髌旁入路相比，髌外侧支持带松解率更低，可获得更快速的近期康复效果。     

Total knee arthroplasty in valgus knees using minimally invasive medial-subvastus approach

Background:

An ideal approach for valgus knees must provide adequate exposure with minimal complications due to approach per se. Median parapatellar approach is most commonly used approach in TKA including valgus knees. A medial subvastus approach is seldom used for valgus knees and has definite advantages of maintaining extensor mechanism integrity and minimal effect on patellar tracking. The present study was conducted to evaluate outcomes of total knee arthroplasty (TKA) and efficacy of subvastus approach in valgus knees in terms of early functional recovery, limb alignment and complications.

Materials and Methods:

We retrospectively reviewed 112 knees with valgus deformity between January 2006 and December 2011. All patients were assessed postoperatively for pain using Visual Analog Scale (VAS) and quadriceps recovery in form of time to active straight leg raising (SLR) and staircase competency and clinical outcomes using American Knee Society (AKS) score and radiographic evaluation with average followup of 40 months (range 24–84 months).

Results:

The mean VAS on postoperative day (POD) 1 and POD2 at rest was 2.73 and 2.39, respectively and after mobilization was 3.28 and 3.08, respectively (P < 0.001). The quadriceps recovery was very early and 92 (86.7%) patients were able to do active SLR by POD1 with mean time of 21.98 h while reciprocal gait and staircase competency was possible at 43.05 h. The AKS and function score showed significant improvement from preoperative mean score of 39 and 36 to 91 and 79 (P < 0.001), respectively, and the mean range of motion increased from 102° preoperatively to 119° at recent followup (P < 0.001). The mean tibiofemoral valgus was corrected from preoperative 16° (range 10°–35°) to 5° (range 3°–9°) valgus (P < 0.001).

Conclusions:

Mini-subvastus quadriceps approach provides adequate exposure and excellent early recovery for TKA in valgus knees, without increase in incidence of complications.     

Early results of subvastus versus medial parapatellar approach in primary total knee arthroplasty

Introduction To evaluate the clinical and radiographic results immediately after total knee arthroplasty, we compared the parapatellar and subvastus approach.Materials and methods Fifty-two patients with osteoarthritis were randomly assigned to two groups. The measurement was based on clinical and radiographic features.Results There was a significant difference in passive range of motion. Patients in the subvastus approach group revealed a full knee extension and flexion of 90° significantly earlier than those in the parapatellar group. However, on the day of discharge, both groups were comparable. Radiological assessment revealed analogous results in both groups. Correction of varus or valgus deformity was required in 48 patients.Conclusion Regardless of the surgical approach, the anteroposterior tibial femoral angle improved significantly in both groups. Concerning pain, operation time, blood loss, blood substitution and complications, no major differences could be seen.     

Muscle torques in total knee arthroplasty with subvastus and parapatellar approaches

The current study was designed to compare muscle torques when using the subvastus and parapatellar approaches for unilateral total knee arthroplasty. Twelve female patients had unilateral total knee arthroplasty with the subvastus approach from January 1997 to June 1998. The historic control group consisted of 16 female patients who had unilateral total knee arthroplasty with the parapatellar approach from July 1994 to January 1997. Six and 12 months after surgery, a Cybex dynamometer was used to measure isometric and isokinetic muscle strength. Two parameters were used to compare the two approaches, the first parameter was the difference in peak torque between the surgically treated knee and the baseline value for the healthy knee, and the second parameter was the hamstring to quadriceps peak-torque ratio, again using the value for the healthy knee as baseline. The subvastus approach resulted in an initial higher peak torque in the quadriceps 6 months after surgery, but this difference became insignificant 12 months postoperative. Using the subvastus approach, the hamstring to quadriceps peak-torque ratio reached the normal range (0.50-0.80) sooner than was the case using the parapatellar approach. There is a phenomenon of cross adaptation of the untreated knee to the surgically treated knee, and knees operated on by the subvastus approach showed functional recovery at an earlier date than those operated on by the parapatellar approach.     

Postoperative opioid analgesic use after Nuss versus Ravitch pectus excavatum repair

Background/Purpose

Anticipated postoperative pain may affect procedure choice in patients with pectus excavatum. This study aims to compare postoperative pain in patients undergoing Nuss and Ravitch procedures.

Methods

A 5 year retrospective review was performed. Data on age, gender, Haller index, procedure, pain scores, pain medications, and length of hospital stay were collected. Total inpatient opioid administration was converted to morphine equivalent daily dose per kilogram (MEDD/kg) and compared between procedures.

Results

One hundred eighty-one patients underwent 125 (69%) Nuss and 56 (31%) Ravitch procedures. Ravitch patients were older (15.7 yo vs 14.6 yo, p = 0.004) and had a higher Haller index (5.21 vs 4.10, p = < 0.001). Nuss patients had higher average daily pain scores, received 25% more opioids (MEDD/kg 0.66 vs. 0.49, p = < 0.001), and received twice as much IV diazepam/kg. In the multivariate analysis, higher MEDD/kg correlated with both the Nuss procedure and older age in the Nuss group. Opioid administration did not correlate with Haller index or Nuss bar fixation technique. Increased NSAID administration did not correlate with lower use of opioids.

Conclusion

The Nuss procedure is associated with greater postoperative pain compared to the Ravitch procedure. Opioid use is higher in older patients undergoing the Nuss procedure, but is not associated with severity of deformity.