Deep brain stimulation for pain relief: a meta-analysis.

Deep brain stimulation (DBS) has been used to treat intractable pain for over 50 years. Variations in targets and surgical technique complicate the interpretation of many studies. To better understand its efficacy, we performed a meta-analysis of DBS for pain relief. MEDLINE (1966 to February 2003) and EMBASE (1980 to January 2003) databases were searched using key words deep brain stimulation, sensory thalamus, periventricular gray and pain. Inclusion criteria were based on patient characteristics and protocol clarity. Six studies (between 1977-1997) fitting the criteria were identified. Stimulation sites included the periventricular/periaqueductal grey matter (PVG/PAG), internal capsule (IC), and sensory thalamus (ST). The long-term pain alleviation rate was highest with DBS of the PVG/PAG (79%), or the PVG/PAG plus sensory thalamus/internal capsule (87%). Stimulation of the sensory thalamus alone was less effective (58% long-term success) (p < 0.05). DBS was more effective for nociceptive than deafferentation pain (63% vs 47% long-term success; p < 0.01). Long-term success was attained in over 80% of patients with intractable low back pain (failed back surgery) following successful trial stimulation. Trial stimulation was successful in approximately 50% of those with post-stroke pain, and 58% of patients permanently implanted achieved ongoing pain relief. Higher rates of success were seen with phantom limb pain and neuropathies. We conclude that DBS is frequently effective when used in well-selected patients. Neuroimaging and neuromodulation technology advances complicate the application of these results to modern practice. Ongoing investigations should shed further light on this complex clinical conundrum.     

The periaqueductal grey area and control of blood pressure in neurodegeneration

The periaqueductal/periventricular grey area (PAG/PVG) is a midbrain nucleus with an important role in pain signalling and autonomic control. We present the case of an initially hypertensive man who developed a presumed neurodegenerative disorder over a decade, characterised by progressive right-sided chronic pain, extra-pyramidal symptoms and autonomic dysfunction including postural hypotension, sleep apnoea, and bladder instability. He underwent a variety of treatments for his symptoms, including deep brain stimulation (DBS) of the PAG/PVG. 24-h blood pressure monitoring was carried out 1 and 5 years after implantation. Although the DBS initially produced a significant reduction in blood pressure, the effect was significantly reversed when the same tests were repeated 5 years after surgery. This may imply a functional involvement of the PAG/PVG in the neurodegenerative process.     

Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Correlates of Ventral Striatal Deep Brain Stimulation for Poststroke Pain

ObjectiveDeep brain stimulation (DBS) for pain has largely been implemented in an uncontrolled manner to target the somatosensory component of pain, with research leading to mixed results. We have previously shown that patients with poststroke pain syndrome who were treated with DBS targeting the ventral striatum/anterior limb of the internal capsule (VS/ALIC) demonstrated a significant improvement in measures related to the affective sphere of pain. In this study, we sought to determine how DBS targeting the VS/ALIC modifies brain activation in response to pain.Materials and MethodsFive patients with poststroke pain syndrome who were blinded to DBS status (ON/OFF) and six age- and sex-matched healthy controls underwent functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) measuring blood oxygen level-dependent activation in a block design. In this design, each participant received heat stimuli to the affected or unaffected wrist area. Statistical comparisons were performed using fMRI z-maps.ResultsIn response to pain, patients in the DBS OFF state showed significant activation (p < 0.001) in the same regions as healthy controls (thalamus, insula, and operculum) and in additional regions (orbitofrontal and superior convexity cortical areas). DBS significantly reduced activation of these additional regions and introduced foci of significant inhibitory activation (p < 0.001) in the hippocampi when painful stimulation was applied to the affected side.ConclusionsThese findings suggest that DBS of the VS/ALIC modulates affective neural networks.     

Abnormal thalamocortical dynamics may be altered by deep brain stimulation: Using magnetoencephalography to study phantom limb pain

Deep brain stimulation (DBS) is used to alleviate chronic pain. Using magnetoencephalography (MEG) to study the mechanisms of DBS for pain is difficult because of the artefact caused by the stimulator. We were able to record activity over the occipital lobe of a patient using DBS for phantom limb pain during presentation of a visual stimulus. This demonstrates that MEG can be used to study patients undergoing DBS provided control stimuli are used to check the reliability of the data. We then asked the patient to rate his pain during and off DBS. Correlations were found between these ratings and power in theta (6–9) and beta bands (12–30). Further, there was a tendency for frequencies under 25 Hz to correlate with each other after a period off stimulation compared with immediately after DBS. The results are interpreted as reflecting abnormal thalamocortical dynamics, previously implicated in painful syndromes.     

Ventral posterolateral deep brain stimulation treatment for neuropathic pain shortens pain response after cold stimuli

Neuropathic pain is often severe. Deep brain stimulation (DBS) is a treatment method for neuropathic pain, but its mechanism of action remains unclear. Patients with neuropathic pain are affected by various stimulations, such as mechanical and cold stimuli, but studies of cold allodynia showed the associated pain to be less than that caused by mechanical stimuli. This study focused on the effects of DBS on cold allodynia in rats. To observe the effects of DBS, we established three groups: a normal group (normal), a neuropathic pain group (pain), and a DBS with neuropathic pain group (DBS). The stimulation target was the ventral posterolateral nucleus (VPL). We observed differences in the degree of cold allodynia elicited between a conventional method that measured the number of pain responses and our altered novel method that measured the duration of pain responses. Cold allodynia after DBS did not differ when conventional analysis was applied, but the pain response duration was decreased. We suggest that VPL DBS was partially effective in cold allodynia, implicating complex pathways of pain signaling. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Deep brain stimulation of the centre median-parafascicular complex in patients with movement disorders

The centre median-parafascicular (CM-Pf) complex of the thalamus is considered to be a possible target for deep brain stimulation (DBS) in patients with movement disorders. In a prospective study on the effect of CM-Pf DBS versus somatosensory thalamic DBS on chronic neuropathic pain, three of 12 patients had additional movement disorders. Bifocal quadripolar electrodes were implanted by computed tomography guided stereotactic surgery under local anaesthesia contralaterally to the side of the pain for test stimulation. Two of the three patients with movement disorders had permanent implantation of CM-Pf electrodes. During test stimulation of the left CM-Pf complex for several days, a 67 year old woman received no benefit with respect to the neuropathic pain, but the choreoathetotic movements of her right foot ceased. As the pain syndrome was not improved, she decided not to have permanent implantation. A 74 year old man with postzoster neuralgia and allodynia enjoyed excellent relief from his pain with chronic CM-Pf DBS. In addition, improvement in the tremor at rest was noted. A 72 year old man had sustained reduction in his stump dyskinesias. Further evaluation of the possible role of the "forgotten" central and medial thalamic nuclei in the treatment of movement disorders may be warranted.     

beta-Endorphin and monoamine metabolite concentrations in patients with intractable pain--changes before and after deep brain or spinal dorsal column stimulation

Baseline concentrations of beta-endorphin (beta-EP) and monoamine metabolites (MHPG: 3-methoxy-4-hydroxy-phenylglycol, HVA: homovanillic acid, 5-HIAA: 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid) in lumbar CSF (LCSF) and ventricular CSF (VCSF) were measured in 18 patients with intractable pain; 10 with deafferented pain and 8 with peripheral pain. Control values were obtained from 37 individuals of various ages. Changes in the concentrations of these substances were determined before and after giving stimulations (2-5 V, 0.2-0.5 msec, 40-50 Hz, 20-sec duration) to 6 patients through electrodes implanted in deep brain structures (DBS; posterior limb of the internal capsule in 5 patients and rostral mesencephalic lemniscus medialis in one patient), and to 2 other patients through electrodes implanted in the spinal dorsal column (DCS). The control value of beta-EP in LCSF was 57.6 +/- 24.7 pg/ml, which was not significantly different from that of VCSF. Great variation in the individual control LCSF beta-EP concentrations was found, but it was not related to differences in age. The mean baseline LCSF beta-EP concentration was significantly higher (p less than 0.05) than the control in the patients with deaffernted pain before stimulation. One of the monoamine-metabolites, MHPG, showed higher level in the patients with peripheral pain (p less than 0.01). The LCSF beta-EP concentration was not affected by deep brain stimulation, but was increased by dorsal column stimulation. In one patient with excellent pain relief by stimulation of the posterior limb of the internal capsule, the LCSF HVA and 5-HIAA concentrations were conspicuously increased.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Deep brain stimulation therapy: control of human brain function by chronically implanted electrodes]

During the last decade, it has become increasingly clear that deep brain stimulation(DBS) is useful for controlling various neurological disorders, including intractable pain and involuntary movements. The development of an implantable and programmable pulse-generator has greatly facilitated the clinical application of DBS therapy. The history and clinical data of DBS therapy currently available from the literature, together with our own cases treated by DBS, are reviewed. DBS therapy has many advantages over conventional neuroablative therapies, including reversibility of the procedure, controllability and relative selectivity of the effects, and possible plastic effects on neural function. Further evolution of the stimulation system, such as through integration with neuromonitoring devices, would open up a new field of restorative neurology and neurosurgery.     

The eloquence of silent cortex: analysis of afferent input to deafferented cortex in arm amputees

Cortical reorganisation after limb amputation includes topographic displacements of body representation areas and changes of areal extent. Remarkably, truncated nerves, which had innervated amputated limb parts and remained in the residual limbs, can retain access to the deafferented somatosensory cortex. Using somatosensory evoked potentials (SEP) we characterized afferences from electrically stimulated truncated nerves to the brachial plexus and cortex in 12 arm amputees. While peripheral responses were highly variable, thalamocortical input to S-1, as reflected by the primary cortical SEP component, was present in 11 of 12 patients. Despite long-term deafferentation, macroscopic phenomena of inhibition/refractoriness, as assessed by stimulus rate variations, appeared to be changed only marginally. Thus, deafferented cortex remains responsive when given artificial phantom input and could provide a neuronal substrate for spontaneous phantom limb sensations, including phantom pain.     

Deep Brain Stimulation of the Subgenual Cingulate Cortex for the Treatment of Chronic Low Back Pain

ObjectivesDespite converging basic scientific and clinical evidence of the link between chronic pain and depression, existing therapies do not often take advantage of this overlap. Here, we provide a critical review of the literature that highlights the intersection in brain networks between chronic low back pain (CLBP) and depression and discuss findings from previous deep brain stimulation (DBS) studies for pain. Based on a multidimensional model of pain processing and the connectivity of the subgenual cingulate cortex (SCC) with areas that are implicated in both CLBP and depression, we propose a novel approach to the treatment of CLBP using DBS of the SCC.Materials and MethodsA narrative review with literature assessment.ResultsCLBP is associated with a shift away from somatosensory representation toward brain regions that mediate emotional processes. There is a high degree of overlap between these regions and those involved in depression, including the anterior cingulate cortex, medial prefrontal cortex, nucleus accumbens, and amygdala. Whereas target sites from previous DBS trials for pain were not anatomically positioned to engage these areas and their associated networks, the SCC is structurally connected to all of these regions as well as others involved in mediating sensory, cognitive, and affective processing in CLBP.ConclusionsCLBP and depression share a common underlying brain network interconnected by the SCC. Current data and novel technology provide an optimal opportunity to develop clinically effective trials of SCC DBS for CLBP.     

Improvement in a quantitative measure of bradykinesia after microelectrode recording in patients with Parkinson's disease during deep brain stimulation surgery.

It is widely accepted that patients with Parkinson's disease experience immediate but temporary improvement in motor signs after surgical implantation of subthalamic nucleus (STN) deep brain stimulating electrodes before the electrodes are activated, although this has never been formally studied. Based on anecdotal observations that limb mobility improved just after microelectrode recording (MER) during deep brain stimulation (DBS) procedures, we designed a prospective study to measure upper extremity bradykinesia using a quantitative measure of angular velocity. Measurements were made pre- and post-MER and during intraoperative DBS. Analysis of 98 STN DBS procedures performed on 61 patients showed that MER did not create adverse clinical symptoms despite concerns that MER increases morbidity. Quantitative upper extremity bradykinesia improved after MER alone, and further improvement was seen during intraoperative DBS. Electrophysiological data from each case were then compared to the improvement in bradykinesia post-MER alone and a significant correlation was found between the improvement in arm bradykinesia, the number of passes through the STN with somatosensory driving, and also with the number of arm cells with somatosensory driving in the STN, but not with total number of passes, total number of passes through the STN, or total number of cells with somatosensory driving in the STN. This study demonstrates that there is a significant improvement in upper extremity bradykinesia just after MER, before inserting or activating the DBS electrode in patients with Parkinson's disease who undergo STN DBS.     

VPL-DBS on neuropathic pain rat model is effective in mechanical allodynia than cold allodynia

Recently, deep brain stimulation (DBS) is widely used in various types of neurodegenerative disorders for minimal invasiveness and safety of the procedure. Deep brain stimulation is consistently applied for the treatment of patients with neuropathic pain even though the success rate is not as high as other neurodegenerative disorders. Furthermore, it is also unclear how DBS improves neuropathic pain. In this study, we investigated the role of DBS following the stimulation parameter for analgesic effect on mechanical allodynia and cold allodynia in neuropathic pain rats. We used a sciatic nerve injury model to induce neuropathic pain, and observed responses to mechanical and cold stimulation by the von Frey test and acetone test, respectively. We classified the rats into four groups: na?ve (na?ve, n?=?10), na?ve?+?DBS (N?+?DBS, n?=?10), neuropathic pain (NP, n?=?10), and neuropathic pain?+?DBS (NP?+?DBS, n?=?10). We inserted the DBS electrode into the ventral posterolateral nucleus (VPL) into the rats (VPL-DBS). The score for mechanical allodynia was significantly decreased in NP?+?DBS group (p?<?0.01). However, the score for cold allodynia did not significantly drop in any groups including NP?+?DBS group (p?>?0.05). In this study, we found that the electrical stimulation of the VPL works more effectively with mechanical allodynia than cold one, and pain signal induced by mechanical stimulus and cold stimulus may be processed through different pathways in the brain.     

Electrophysiological mapping of body representation in the cortex of the blind mole rat.

The cortex of the blind mole rat (Spalax ehrenbergi) was explored for somatosensory responses with special reference to an extension into the occipital cortex which serves vision in sighted mammals. Head and body representation was similar as in other rodents or mammals. However, the somatosensory area extended far into the occipital cortex. No responses to auditory or visual stimulation were found caudal to the somatosensory area. However, auditory responses were recorded in an area lateral to and slightly caudal to the head representation. It is concluded that in this naturally blind animal the area normally occupied by the visual cortex serves somatosensory function.     

Subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation improves somatosensory function in Parkinson's disease

An established treatment for the motor symptoms of Parkinson's disease (PD) is deep brain stimulation (DBS) of the subthalamic nucleus (STN). Mounting evidence suggests that PD is also associated with somatosensory deficits, yet the effect of STN‐DBS on somatosensory processing is largely unknown. This study investigated whether STN‐DBS affects somatosensory processing, specifically the processing of tactile and proprioceptive cues, by systematically examining the accuracy of haptic perception of object size. (Haptic perception refers to one's ability to extract object features such as shape and size by active touch.) Without vision, 13 PD patients with implanted STN‐DBS and 13 healthy controls haptically explored the heights of 2 successively presented 3‐dimensional (3D) blocks using a precision grip. Participants verbally indicated which block was taller and then used their nonprobing hand to motorically match the perceived size of the comparison block. Patients were tested during ON and OFF stimulation, following a 12‐hour medication washout period. First, when compared to controls, the PD group's haptic discrimination threshold during OFF stimulation was elevated by 192% and mean hand aperture error was increased by 105%. Second, DBS lowered the haptic discrimination threshold by 26% and aperture error decreased by 20%. Third, during DBS ON, probing with the motorically more affected hand decreased haptic precision compared to probing with the less affected hand. This study offers the first evidence that STN‐DBS improves haptic precision, further indicating that somatosensory function is improved by STN‐DBS. We conclude that DBS‐related improvements are not explained by improvements in motor function alone, but rather by enhanced somatosensory processing. © 2013 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society     

Invasive brain stimulation for the treatment of neuropathic pain

Neurostimulation therapy is indicated for neuropathic pain that is refractory to medical treatment, and includes stimulation of the dorsal spinal cord, deep brain structures, and the precentral motor cortex. Spinal cord stimulation is validated in the treatment of selected types of chronic pain syndromes, such as failed back surgery syndrome. Deep brain stimulation (DBS) has shown promise as a treatment for peripheral neuropathic pain and phantom limb pain. Compared with DBS, motor cortex stimulation (MCS) is currently more frequently used, mainly because it is more easily performed, and has a wider range of indications (including central poststroke pain). Controlled trials have demonstrated the efficacy of MCS in the treatment of various types of neuropathic pain, although these trials included a limited number of patients and need to be confirmed by large, controlled, multicenter studies. Despite technical progress in neurosurgical navigation, results from studies of MCS are variable, and validated criteria for selecting good candidates for implantation are lacking. However, the evidence in favor of MCS is sufficient to include it in the range of therapeutic options for refractory neuropathic pain. In this Review, the respective efficacies and mechanisms of action of DBS and MCS are discussed.     

Deep brain stimulation for stroke: Current uses and future directions

Background

Survivors of stroke often experience significant disability and impaired quality of life related to ongoing maladaptive responses and persistent neurologic deficits. Novel therapeutic options are urgently needed to augment current approaches. One way to promote recovery and ameliorate symptoms may be to electrically stimulate the surviving brain. Various forms of brain stimulation have been investigated for use in stroke, including deep brain stimulation (DBS).

Effects of DBS on auditory and somatosensory processing in Parkinson's disease

Motor symptoms of Parkinson's disease (PD) can be relieved by deep brain stimulation (DBS). The mechanism of action of DBS is largely unclear. Magnetoencephalography (MEG) studies on DBS patients have been unfeasible because of strong magnetic artifacts. An artifact suppression method known as spatiotemporal signal space separation (tSSS) has mainly overcome these difficulties. We wanted to clarify whether tSSS enables noninvasive measurement of the modulation of cortical activity caused by DBS. We have studied auditory and somatosensory‐evoked fields (AEFs and SEFs) of advanced PD patients with bilateral subthalamic nucleus (STN) DBS using MEG. AEFs were elicited by 1‐kHz tones and SEFs by electrical pulses to the median nerve with DBS on and off. Data could be successfully acquired and analyzed from 12 out of 16 measured patients. The motor symptoms were significantly relieved by DBS, which clearly enhanced the ipsilateral auditory N100m responses in the right hemisphere. Contralateral N100m responses and somatosensory P60m responses also had a tendency to increase when bilateral DBS was on. MEG with tSSS offers a novel and powerful tool to investigate DBS modulation of the evoked cortical activity in PD with high temporal and spatial resolution. The results suggest that STN‐DBS modulates auditory processing in advanced PD. Hum Brain Mapp, 2011. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Sensorimotor retuning [corrected] in complex regional pain syndrome parallels pain reduction

Patients with complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) and intractable pain showed a shrinkage of cortical maps on primary (SI) and secondary somatosensory cortex (SII) contralateral to the affected limb. This was paralleled by an impairment of the two-point discrimination thresholds. Behavioral treatment over 1 to 6 months consisting of graded sensorimotor retuning led to a persistent decrease in pain intensity, which was accompanied by a restoration of the impaired tactile discrimination and regaining of cortical map size in contralateral SI and SII. This suggests that the reversal of tactile impairment and cortical reorganization in CRPS is associated with a decrease in pain.     

Motor cortex stimulation in patients with post-stroke pain: conscious somatosensory response and pain control

We analyzed the conscious sensory responses to cortical stimulation of 31 patients with post-stroke pain who underwent motor cortex stimulation (MCS) therapy. During surgery for electrode placement, a sensory response (tingle projected to a localized peripheral area) was elicited by high-frequency stimulation (50 Hz) in 23 (84%) from the somatosensory cortex, and in 16 (52%) from the motor cortex without muscle contraction. Unpleasant painful sensation was induced or their original pain was exacerbated in 12 patients (39%) when the somatosensory cortex was stimulated and in two (6%) when the motor cortex was stimulated. Somatosensory responses were induced in eight (25%) even by low-frequency stimulation (1-2 Hz) of the motor cortex at an intensity below the threshold for muscle contraction. In contrast, among 20 nonpain patients who underwent a similar procedure for cortical mapping in epilepsy or brain tumor surgery, a sensory response was produced by high-frequency stimulation in only eight (40%; p < 0.02) from the somatosensory cortex and four (20%; p < 0.03) from the motor cortex. Pain sensation was not induced by stimulation of the somatosensory cortex (p < 0.002) or motor cortex in any of these patients. In addition, none of these patients reported a sensory response to low-frequency stimulation. In both of the two post-stroke pain patients who reported abnormal pain sensation in response to stimulation of the motor cortex, MCS failed to control their post-stroke pain. These findings imply that the sensitivity of the perceptual system even to activity of the motor cortex is heightened in post-stroke pain patients, which can sometimes hinder pain control by MCS.     

Efficient internal pallidal stimulation in Gilles de la Tourette syndrome: a case report.

The usefulness of deep brain stimulation (DBS) of thalamic nuclei in Gilles de la Tourette syndrome (GTS) has recently been advocated. We report on a 14-month follow-up study of a patient with intractable GTS in whom bilateral DBS of the internal globus pallidus was carried out. Tic frequency per minute decreased by 73% in the postoperative phase and in particular the vocal tics became less intense. Pronation/ supination bradykinesia of the left extremities was a well-tolerated, permanent side effect. Pallidal DBS could become a valuable rescue therapy for otherwise intractable GTS.