Buccal cell FISH and blood PCR-Y detect high rates of X chromosomal mosaicism and Y chromosomal derivatives in patients with Turner syndrome

Turner syndrome (TS) is the result of (partial) X chromosome monosomy. In general, the diagnosis is based on karyotyping of 30 blood lymphocytes. This technique, however, does not rule out tissue mosaicism or low grade mosaicism in the blood. Because of the associated risk of gonadoblastoma, mosaicism is especially important in case this involves a Y chromosome. We investigated different approaches to improve the detection of mosaicisms in 162 adult women with TS (mean age 29.9 ± 10.3). Standard karyotyping identified 75 patients (46.3%) with a non-mosaic monosomy 45,X. Of these 75 patients, 63 underwent additional investigations including FISH on buccal cells with X- and Y-specific probes and PCR-Y on blood. FISH analysis of buccal cells revealed a mosaicism in 19 of the 63 patients (30.2%). In five patients the additional cell lines contained a (derivative) Y chromosome. With sensitive real-time PCR we confirmed the presence of this Y chromosome in blood in three of the five cases. Although Y chromosome material was established in ovarian tissue in two patients, no gonadoblastoma was found. Our results confirm the notion that TS patients with 45,X on conventional karyotyping often have tissue specific mosaicisms, some of which include a Y chromosome. Although further investigations are needed to estimate the risk of gonadoblastoma in patients with Y chromosome material in buccal cells, we conclude that FISH or real-time PCR on buccal cells should be considered in TS patients with 45,X on standard karyotyping.     

Detection of Y‐specific sequences in 122 patients with Turner syndrome: Nested PCR is not a reliable method

The incidence of Y chromosome sequences in patients with Turner syndrome has been evaluated in several studies, and its frequency varied from 0% to 61%, depending on the molecular methodology used. The aim of our study was to screen for Y chromosome sequences in 122 patients with Turner syndrome without cytogenetic evidence of this chromosome. DNA of 100 normal women was also screened and it was used as a negative control. To identify cryptic Y mosaicism, eight regions of Y chromosome were amplified by PCR. In order to increase the sensitivity of Y sequence detection, a nested PCR of the SRY and TSPY genes was also performed. All patients had several stigmata of Turner syndrome and none of them presented with signs of virilization. The most frequent karyotype was 45,X (54.1%), followed by mosaicism involving structural aberration of the X chromosome. There were 12 patients who carried a marker or ring chromosome. First‐round PCR identified Y chromosome sequences in only four patients (3%), and all of them had a chromosome mosaicism with at least one cell lineage with a marker chromosome. After nested PCR, 25% of the patients and 14% of the normal women were positive for the presence of Y sequences. Contamination with extraneous genomic DNA was ruled out by microsatellite studies, but we cannot eliminate the possibility of contamination with PCR products, despite careful handling. We conclude that nested PCR overestimated the frequency of Y sequences in patients with Turner syndrome and should be avoided to prevent false positive results, which lead to unnecessary surgical treatment of these patients. © 2001 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Frequency of Y chromosomal material in Mexican patients with Ullrich-Turner syndrome

Cytogenetic studies have shown that 40–60% of patients with Ullrich-Turner syndrome (UTS) are 45,X, whereas the rest have structural aberrations of the X chromosome or mosaicism with a second cell line containing a structurally normal or abnormal X or Y chromosome. However, molecular analysis has demonstrated a higher proportion of mosaicism, and studies in different populations have shown an extremely variable frequency of Y mosaicism of 0–61%. We used Southern blot analysis and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to detect the presence of Ycen, ZFY, SRY, and Yqh in 50 Mexican patients with UTS and different karyotypes to determine the origin of marker chromosomes and the presence of Y sequences. Our results indicated the origin of the marker chromosome in 1 patient and detected the presence of Y sequences in 4 45,X patients. Taken together, we found a 12% incidence of Y sequences in individuals with UTS. The amount of Y-derived material was variable, making the correlation between phenotype and molecular data difficult. Only 1 patient had a gonadoblastoma. We discuss the presence of Y chromosomes or Y sequences in patients with UTS and compare our frequency with that previously reported. Am. J. Med. Genet. 76:120–124, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Detection of Y-specific sequences in 122 patients with Turner syndrome: nested PCR is not a reliable method

The incidence of Y chromosome sequences in patients with Turner syndrome has been evaluated in several studies, and its frequency varied from 0% to 61%, depending on the molecular methodology used. The aim of our study was to screen for Y chromosome sequences in 122 patients with Turner syndrome without cytogenetic evidence of this chromosome. DNA of 100 normal women was also screened and it was used as a negative control. To identify cryptic Y mosaicism, eight regions of Y chromosome were amplified by PCR. In order to increase the sensitivity of Y sequence detection, a nested PCR of the SRY and TSPY genes was also performed. All patients had several stigmata of Turner syndrome and none of them presented with signs of virilization. The most frequent karyotype was 45,X (54.1%), followed by mosaicism involving structural aberration of the X chromosome. There were 12 patients who carried a marker or ring chromosome. First-round PCR identified Y chromosome sequences in only four patients (3%), and all of them had a chromosome mosaicism with at least one cell lineage with a marker chromosome. After nested PCR, 25% of the patients and 14% of the normal women were positive for the presence of Y sequences. Contamination with extraneous genomic DNA was ruled out by microsatellite studies, but we cannot eliminate the possibility of contamination with PCR products, despite careful handling. We conclude that nested PCR overestimated the frequency of Y sequences in patients with Turner syndrome and should be avoided to prevent false positive results, which lead to unnecessary surgical treatment of these patients.     

Cytogenetic and molecular investigations of Y chromosome sequences and their role in Turner syndrome

It has been proposed that all live born females with Turner syndrome carry a cell line containing two sex chromosomes, which may be present at a low level of mosaicism (Hook & Warburton, 1983; Hassold et al . 1985; 1988; Connor & Loughlin, 1989). If the second sex chromosome is a Y, these patients are at risk of developing gonadoblastoma. In this study, 50 patients found to have a 45,X karyotype by conventional cytogenetic analysis, were screened by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), for the presence of Y chromosome sequences. Two patients were positive for six of the eight Y chromosome loci tested and additional cytogenetic analysis confirmed the presence of a marker chromosome, in 8% and 3% of cells respectively. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) was used to confirm that the markers were of Y chromosome origin and helped to elucidate their structure. In addition, four other patients were found to have a Y chromosome by initial routine cytogenetic analysis. FISH, in conjunction with PCR, elucidated the structure of the Y chromosomes. This study illustrates the value of using a combination of cytogenetic and molecular techniques, to identify Y chromosome sequences in Turner syndrome.     

Detection of low level sex chromosome mosaicism in Ullrich-Turner syndrome patients

Ullrich-Turner syndrome (UTS) is most commonly due to a 45,X chromosome defect, but is also seen in patients with a variety of X-chromosome abnormalities or 45,X/46,XY mosaicism. The phenotype of UTS patients is highly variable, and depends largely on the karyotype. Patients are at an increased risk of gonadoblastoma when a Y-derived chromosome or chromosome fragment is present. Since constitutional mosaicism is present in approximately 50% of UTS patients, the identification of minor cell populations is clinically important and a challenge to laboratories. We identified 50 females with a 45,X karyotype as the sole abnormality or as part of a more complex karyotype. Twenty two (44%) had a 45,X karyotype; mosaicism for a second normal or structurally abnormal X was observed in 24 (48%) samples, and mosaicism for Y chromosomal material in 4 (8%) cases. To further investigate the possibility of mosaicism in the 22 patients with an apparently non-mosaic 45,X karyotype, we performed FISH using centromere probes for the X and Y chromosomes. A minor XX cell line was identified in 3 patients, and the 45,X result was confirmed in 19 samples. No samples with XY mosaicism were identified. We describe our validation process for a FISH assay to be used in clinical practice to identify XX or XY mosaicism. FISH as an adjunct to karyotype analysis provides a sensitive and cost-effective technique to identify sex chromosome mosaicism in UTS patients.     

Supernumerary marker chromosomes (SMCs) in Turner syndrome are mostly derived from the Y chromosome

DNA and FISH (fluorescence in situ hybridization) analysis were carried out in 12 patients with stigmata of Turner syndrome to determine whether the Supernumerary M arker C hromosome (SMC) found cytogenetically in each of these patients was derived from the Y chromosome. The presence of a Y chromosome in these patients may predispose them to develop gonadoblastoma. PCR-Southern blot analysis, followed by FISH, was used to detect the presence of Y chromosome material. The S ex determining R egion Y (SRY), T estis S pecific P rotein Y -encoded (TSPY) and Y -chromosome R NA R ecognition M otif (YRRM) genes, which map at Yp11.31, Yp11.1–11.2 and Yp11.2/Yq11.21–11.23, respectively, were selected as markers, because they span the whole Y chromosome, and more importantly, they are considered to be involved in the development of gonadoblastoma. It was shown that in 12 patients, all of whom had an SMC, the SMC of 11 was derived from the Y chromosome. Furthermore, the presence of the SRY, TSPY and YRRM gene sequences was determined and FISH analysis confirmed the Y origin of the SMCs. The methodology described in this report is a rapid, reliable and sensitive approach which may be easily applied to determine the Y origin of an SMC carried in Turner syndrome. The identification of an SMC is important for the clinical management and prognostic counseling of these patients with Turner syndrome.     

PCR detection of Y-specific sequences in patients with Ullrich-Turner syndrome: Clinical implications and limitations

Cytogenetic analysis of patients with Ullrich-Turner syndrome (UTS) may fail to detect low levels of Y chromosome mosaicism or Y-derived marker chromosomes. More sensitive polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based tests have been developed; however, applicability of these data to prognosis of virilization and gonadoblastoma development has not been investigated adequately. We used a multiplex PCR-based method to detect two Y-specific sequences, SRY and AMGLY. Thirteen patients with UTS without cytogenetically detected Y chromosomes were studied. Y-specific sequences were detected in 5 patients by multiplex PCR. A cryptic translocation involving the Y chromosome was found in one patient with severe virilization of external genitalia and a male phenotype. Y chromosomal mosaicism was detected in peripheral blood and in both gonads of one patient, and only in the left gonad of another patient. Existence of a Y-derived marker was demonstrated in 2 patients, one of whom had no testicular tissue or virilization. Consistent with previous reports, we conclude that PCR is more sensitive than classical cytogenetic analysis and detects patients with Y-specific sequences in blood cells. However, the absence of Y-specific material in blood is not a sufficient reason to reject surgical treatment in case of virilization. Am. J. Med. Genet. 76:283–287, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

In situ hybridization analysis of the Y chromosome in gonadoblastoma

Gonadoblastoma is a rare tumor arising in the streak gonads of about 30% of 46, XY sex-reversed females. Because gonadoblastoma develops only in patients who have Y-chromosome material and dysgenetic gonads, it has been hypothesized that positive expression of a gene (or genes) on the Y chromosome (GBY) is involved in the etiology of the tumor. To examine the Y chromosome directly in tumors, we performed nonisotopic in situ hybridization of a biotin-labeled Y-specific probe for the DYZI locus on formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded sections of tumor samples from four different patients. After hybridization to DYZI, the Y chromosome was found to be present in all gonadoblastoma foci in the four patients studied, and the gonadoblastoma foci showed an average of 85% cell nuclei positive for the Y chromosome on tissue sections. Normal male and female control tissues showed an average of 78% and 0% positive nuclei, respectively. One patient with bilateral gonadoblastoma had previously been shown to be mosaic, with a 45, X/46, XY karyotype in lymphocytes, skin fibroblasts, and cultures from both gonads. Examination of sections of this patient's gonads showed 79% positive nuclei within the gonadoblastoma foci, whereas the nontumor stromal tissue had 19% positive nuclei. These results indicate that, in this mosaic gonad, tumor foci developed only from cells that had a Y chromosome. Our results support the hypothesis that there is a GBY locus on the Y chromosome and that the Y chromosome is retained in the gonadoblastoma foci during the development of the tumor. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Gonadoblastoma in Turner syndrome patients with nonmosaic 45,X karyotype and Y chromosome sequences

Turner syndrome (TS) is a disorder caused by partial or complete X-chromosome monosomy. Studies in TS patients with different karyotypes have demonstrated the presence of Y-chromosome-derived sequences (4-61%). Early detection of Y-chromosome sequences in TS is of great importance because of the high risk of gonadal tumor development. We investigated the presence of Y-chromosome sequences in TS patients with a 45,X karyotype. One hundred seven unrelated 45,X Mexican TS patients recruited between 1992 and 2003 were included. Y-chromosome-derived sequences were found by polymerase chain reaction in 10 (9.3%) patients. Six subjects underwent gonadectomy and in one of them a gonadoblastoma was found; another developed a gonadoblastoma with dysgerminoma. Because of the high proportion (33%) of gonadal tumors in patients with Y-chromosome sequences found among our patients of mestizo origin, adequate counseling regarding a gonadectomy should be given.     

Taschenatlas der Genetik. Eberhard Passarge. Georg Thieme Verlag,Stuttgart, New York, 1994, 406 pp

The presence of Y chromosome sequences in Ullrich-Turner syndrome (UTS) patients has been suggested in previous work. Karyotype analysis estimated at about 60% of patients with a 45, X constitution and molecular analysis (Southern blot analysis with several Y chromosome probes and PCR of specific sequences) identified the presence of Y chromosome material in about 40% of 45, X patients. We have developed a very sensitive, PCR-based method to detect Y specific sequences in DNA from UTS patients. This protocol permits the detection of a single cell carrying a Y sequence among 105 Y-negative cells. We studied 18 UTS patients with 4 Y-specific sequences. In 11 patients we detected a positive amplification for at least one Y sequence. The existence of a simple and sensitive method for the detection of Y sequences has important implications for UTS patients, in view of the risk for some of the females carrying Y-chromosome material of developing gonadoblastoma and viriliza-tion. Additionally, some of the UTS associated phenotypes, such as renal anomalies, could be correlated with the presence of Y chromosome specific sequences. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Usefulness of imprint cytology of gonadoblastoma with dysgerminoma in a patient with Turner syndrome and a Y chromosome: A case report and literature review

Ovarian gonadoblastoma coexisting with a dysgerminoma is extremely rare in patients with Turner syndrome (TS) and a Y chromosome. The cytological findings, including imprint cytology, of these unusual ovarian tumors have rarely been reported. We report a rare patient with a gonadoblastoma with dysgerminoma, 3.0 × 2.0 cm in size; she was a 19‐year‐old woman with TS and a Y chromosome. She underwent laparoscopic bilateral gonadectomy, and the tumor was classified as stage IA (pT1aNxM0) according to the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics classification system. Intraoperative imprint cytology revealed two types of neoplastic cells: small tumor cells surrounding light green‐stained or eosinophilic hyaline globules with marked calcification, suspicious for gonadoblastoma; and large, round, atypical cells with abundant cytoplasm, macronucleoli, and marked lymphocytic infiltration (two‐cell pattern), suspicious for dysgerminoma. The cytology results in our patient may represent the second reported results of imprint cytology describing a gonadoblastoma with dysgerminoma. They are the first reported results in a patient with TS and a Y chromosome.     

Gonadoblastoma and Y-chromosome fluorescence

In this report we summarize our experience in 4 patients with 45,X/46,XY, one patient with 45,X/47,XYY mosaicism, and one patient with 46,XY karyotype and ambiguous external genitalia. In the 3 patients with a fluorescent Y-chromosome, the development of one or two gonadoblastomas was found, independent of the age of the patients at the time of examination. In the 3 patients with 45,X/46,XYnf mosaicism no gonadoblastoma was detected. This finding prompted us to review the data on patients reported with 45,X/46,XYnf mosaicism. Up to now, no patient with well documented 45,X/46,XYnf mosaicism and convincing evidence of development of gonadoblastoma has been reported. These data seem to confirm that alterations of the characteristic distal fluorescence of Yq may protect the dysgenetic gonad against tumoral degeneration in patients with 45,X/46,XY mosaicism. Possible mechanisms responsible for these changes in the oncogenic potential of Yq in relation with the Y chromosome fluorescence are discussed.     

Sex chromosome mosaicism in gonads of a fetus with cystic hygroma and deletion of the short arm of Y chromosome including loss of SRY

The SRY gene on the short arm of the Y chromosome is necessary for male development. Without SRY, patients with 46,XY karyotype develop as females, fail to achieve normal puberty and have dysgenic gonads and a high incidence of gonadoblastoma. Here we report a female fetus, aborted at 17 weeks of pregnancy, with a non-mosaic 46,X,del(Y)(p11.2).ish del(Y)(SRY-) karyotype diagnosed by classical cytogenetics and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). Ovarian tissue was full of oocytes and mitotic figures. FISH studies of ovarian tissues with X and Y centromere probes revealed extensive sex chromosome mosaicism, manifested by loss of the Y chromosome and polysomy of the X chromosome. We propose that X chromosome polysomy is a post-zygotic event that arises to facilitate gonadal differentiation in the absence of all factors necessary for normal gonadal development.     

An infant with a mosaic 45,X/46,X,psu dic(Y) (pter→q11.2:q11.2→pter) karyotype and mixed gonadal dysgenesis studied for extent of mosaicism in the gonads

An infant with mixed gonadal dysgenesis was found to have a 45,X/46,X,psu dic(Y) karyotype. A low level (8%) of mosaicism for the dic(Y) cell line was observed in peripheral blood lymphocytes and skin fibroblasts. The dicentric nature of the Y chromosome became apparent in fluorescence in situ hybridization studies. The presence of Y centromeric sequences was demonstrated in the paraffin-embedded testis and streak ovary sections. The ratio of Y-positive cells was higher in the testis than in the streak ovary. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Presence of the AZF region in a female with an idic(Y)(q11)

In a child with some features of Turner's syndrome, gonosomal mosaicism with an isodicentric nonfluorescent (idic)Y chromosome was detected (mos 45,X/47,X,idic(Y)(q11),idic(Y)(11)/46,X,idic(Y)(q11)). Histopathological examination showed streak gonads with some evidence of ovarian stroma and no sign of gonadoblastoma. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis in blood lymphocytes and gonadal tissues using primers of seven loci along the Y chromosome, including the sex determined region (SRY), azoospermia factor region (AZF) and the deleted in azoospermia ( DAZ ) gene was positive for all loci tested, confirming the isodicentric character of the Y chromosome and indicating the presence of the AZF region. It is remarkable that the existence of spermatogenesis controlling genes does not play an important role in gonadal development and differentiation in a phenotypic female with some Turner stigmata. The data presented here are briefly discussed with previously-described patients.     

DNA analysis of two patients with a non-fluorescent y chromosome

Summary Results of DNA study on two patients of gonadal dysgenesis with a 45,X/46,X,Ynf (non-fluorescent Y chromosome) karyotype are described. In one patient who developed gonadoblastoma, all 12 loci on the non-fluorescent part of Yq were detected. Another patient did not have gonadoblastoma at 20 years, and only the proximal 6 loci out of 12 were detected.     

Parental origin of the X chromosome, X chromosome mosaicism and screening for "hidden" Y chromosome in 45,X Turner syndrome ascertained cytogenetically

Our study confirms the finding that about 85% of X chromosomes in Turner girls are maternally derived. A new observation is the detection of a high frequency of mosaicism (15%) in Turner girls who by cytogenetic analysis were thought to have a pure 45,X karyotype. DNA examination of the material was done by hybridization with digoxigenin labelled, non-radioactive probes, and PCR products for microsatellite analysis were run on polyacrylamide gels. We screened for the presence of "hidden" Y chromosome mosaicism, using the primers SRY, ZFY, DYZ3, DYZ1 and DYS132. Contrary to other reports using the PCR technique to unravel "hidden" Y chromosome mosaics, we did not find any positive cases. A precise technical protocol for these new techniques is given, and the advantages are discussed.     

Partial gonadal dysgenesis in a patient with a marker Y chromosome

We evaluated a patient with partial gonadal dysgenesis including a right dysgenetic testis and a left streak gonad with rudimentary fallopian tube and uterus. She had ambiguous external genitalia and was raised female. Although her height is normal (25th centile at age 12 years), she has some findings of Ullrich–Turner syndrome. Her karyotype was reported to be 46, X, + marker; subsequent molecular investigations showed the marker to be the short arm of the Y chromosome. Genomic DNA, isolated from leukocytes of the patient and her father, was digested with a variety of restriction endonucleases and subjected to Southern blot analysis. A positive hybridization signal was obtained with probes for the short arm of the Y chromosome (pRsY0.55, SRY, ZFY, 47Z, pY-190, and YC-2) in DNA from the patient, indicating the presence of most if not all of the short arm, while long arm probes (HinfA and pY3.4) indicated that at least 75% of the long arm of the Y chromosome was missing. The gene responsible for testicular determination (TDF) is on the distal portion of the short arm of the Y chromosome; Yq has no known influence on sex determination. Hence, the deletion of the long arm of the Y chromosome cannot explain the gonadal dysgenesis in this patient. One explanation for the gonadal dysgenesis and Ullrich–Turner phenotype in the patient could be undetected 45, X/46,X, + marY mosaicism but no such mosaicism was observed in peripheral lymphocytes. Several investigators have suggested the presence of an “anti-Turner” gene near TDF. Hence it is possible that the clinical phenotype in our patient results from a Y chromosomal defect in sequences flanking TDF, which reduces the function of both TDF and the “anti-Turner” genes.     

Isodicentric Y chromosome in an Ullrich‐Turner patient without virilization

We report on a 17‐year‐old young woman with Ullrich‐Turner syndrome (UTS), who was found to have a karyotype 45,X/46,X,idic(Y)(q11). She had age‐appropriate genitalia without virilization in spite of the presence of the Y‐derived marker chromosome and SRY locus in 70% of her lymphocytes. Having reviewed the literature, we conclude that a possible explanation for the lack of virilization in these mosaic patients is most likely an uneven distribution of tissue mosaicism (gonadal mosaicism). Am. J. Med. Genet. 91:99–101, 2000. © 2000 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.