False-positive myeloperoxidase binding activity due to DNA/anti-DNA antibody complexes: a source for analytical error in serologic evaluation of anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic autoantibodies

Anti-myeloperoxidase antibodies (anti-MPO) are a major type of anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibody (ANCA). While evaluating anti-MPO monoclonal antibodies from SCG/Kj mice, we observed several hybridomas that appeared to react with both MPO and DNA. Sera from some patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) also react with MPO and DNA. We hypothesized that the MPO binding activity is a false-positive result due to the binding of DNA, contained within the antigen binding site of anti-DNA antibodies, to the cationic MPO. Antibodies from tissue culture supernatants from 'dual reactive' hybridomas were purified under high-salt conditions (3 M NaCl) to remove any antigen bound to antibody. The MPO and DNA binding activity were measured by ELISA. The MPO binding activity was completely abrogated while the DNA binding activity remained. The MPO binding activity was restored, in a dose-dependent manner, by the addition of increasing amount of calf-thymus DNA (CT-DNA) to the purified antibody. Sera from six patients with SLE that reacted with both MPO and DNA were treated with DNase and showed a decrease in MPO binding activity compared with untreated samples. MPO binding activity was observed when CT-DNA was added to sera from SLE patients that initially reacted with DNA but not with MPO. These results suggest that the DNA contained within the antigen binding site of anti-DNA antibodies could bind to the highly cationic MPO used as substrate antigen in immunoassays, resulting in a false-positive test.     

Complexes of Serum Amyloid P Component and DNA in Serum from Healthy Individuals and Systemic Lupus Erythematosus Patients

Serum amyloid P component (SAP) bindsin vitro to DNA; based on findings in SAP-deficient mice it was proposed that SAP's role is to handle chromatin and DNA, thereby preventing formation of anti-DNA antibodies. For the first time we have shown the presence of Ca²⁺-dependent SAP-DNA complexes, measured by ELISA, in sera from both healthy volunteers and systemic lupus erythematosus patients (SLE). The concentration of SAP-DNA complexes in SLE sera was significantly lower than in normal sera and particularly low in sera from patients with anti-DNA titers exceeding 50. The complexes were dissociated by the SAP ligand heparin and were not demonstrable in EDTA plasma.Normal sera showed similar capacity to form SAP-DNA complexes with both thymus andEscherichia coli DNA, whereas significantly lower amounts of complexes, in particular withE. coli DNA, were formed in SLE sera. SLE patients with moderate to high anti-DNA titers showed a significant negative correlation between serum SAP's binding ofE. coli DNA and the anti-DNA titer.     

Selective strain distribution pattern of a germline VH gene for a pathogenic anti-DNA autoantibody family

Autoimmune NZB mice rarely develop nephritis, but the SNF1, progeny of Crosses between NZB and the normal SWR strain uniformly develop severe lupus nephritis, indicating that the normal SWR strain makes a genetic contribution to the development of nephritis. The SNF1 mice produce a select population of cationic IgG anti-DNA autoantibodies that share a recurrent cross-reactive idiotype called Id564 and these autoantibodies play a prominent role in the development of nephritis. These pathogenic autoantibodies of SNF1 possess the IgCH allotype of the SWR, indicating their origin from the normal parent. The leader-VH sequences of these Id564+ pathogenic anti-DNA autoantibodies are highly homologous and they are also related by 95% homology to a germline gene of normal C57BL/6 mice, called VH-23, that is a member of an anti-NP antibody gene family. Herein, we cloned the flanking and coding regions of the expressed VHDJH genes of the anti-DNA mAb 564, the prototype member of the pathogenic Id564 family. By restriction analysis and partial sequencing, we found that the VH564 gene is related but distinct in its 5' flanking region from all of the known anti-NP VH genes of C57BL/6 and BALB/c mice. Hybridization with four probes complementary to different segments of the flanking and coding regions of the expressed VH564 gene indicated that the germline gene for VH564 is contained in an approximately 5.2 kb EcoRI fragment of SWR genomic DNA. Moreover, high stringency hybridization with oligonucleotide probes complementary to unique CDR2 and 5' flanking sequences of the expressed VH564 gene revealed that the 'approximately 5.2 kb' germline allele for VH564 that is possessed by the normal SWR parental strain is lacking in the NZB parental strain. C57BL/6 mice also lack this allele of the anti-DNA VH564 germline gene, although this strain possesses the highly homologous, anti-NP-related VH-23 germline gene. Thus germline VH genes for certain pathogenic autoantibodies may have a selective strain distribution pattern.     

Toll-like receptor 9-independent aggravation of glomerulonephritis in a novel model of SLE

The generation of anti-DNA auto-antibodies is characteristic for the human autoimmune condition systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and its animal models. However, the contribution of the toll-like receptor (TLR) system of innate immunity receptors and, in particular, TLR9 to this B cell-mediated autoimmune process remains controversial. Here we report that in a novel murine model of SLE, based on hyper-reactive B cell activation mediated by mutant phospholipase Cg2, the genetic deficiency of TLR9 does not protect from spontaneous anti-DNA auto-antibody formation and glomerulonephritis. On the contrary, disease induction is aggravated and additional nucleolar antibody specificity develops in autoimmune TLR9-deficient mice. In vitro studies demonstrate that, in autoimmune-prone mice, dual signaling via the B cell receptor and non-CpG DNA results in synergistic B cell activation in a TLR9-independent manner. These results suggest that engagement of a TLR9-independent DNA activation pathway may promote autoimmunity, while TLR9 signaling can ameliorate SLE-like immune pathology in vivo.     

Reactive oxygen species modify human DNA, eliciting a more discriminating antigen for the diagnosis of systemic lupus erythematosus.

During the development of an ELISA to measure anti-DNA antibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) sera, native dsDNA was found not to be the most appropriate antigen to use in ELISA assays for differentiating between SLE patients and those with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), a disease also associated with circulating serum anti-DNA antibodies. By modifying the ELISA technique to incorporate human DNA, denatured by reactive oxygen species, to detect anti-DNA antibodies in SLE sera, results consistently showed an increase in antibody binding when compared with the native antigen; no such trend was observed in the comparable group of RA patients. Using this assay serum anti-dsDNA antibody levels were measured in a group of 20 controls, 20 RA patients (10 seropositive and 10 seronegative) and 30 SLE patients (15 with clinically active disease, 15 with inactive disease). A comparison with the standard radioimmunoassay used to measure anti-DNA antibodies for the diagnosis of SLE showed that the ELISA assay using modified DNA performed better than the standard radioimmunoassay offering an improvement in both clinical specificity and sensitivity. The improved method particularly reduced the problem of false-negative results for SLE patients shown clinically to be either mildly active or inactive.     

The role of neutrophils in skin damage induced by tissue‐deposited lupus IgG

Skin injury is the second most common clinical manifestation in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Neutrophils are crucial effector cells in the immune system but the significance of neutrophils in the pathogenesis of SLE is not clear. This study is to explore the role of neutrophils in the skin damage of SLE. We used lupus‐prone mice and a C57BL/6 mouse model of lupus serum IgG‐induced skin inflammation to investigate the role of neutrophils in skin damage of SLE. We found that a few neutrophils infiltrated the inflammatory sites of skin in lupus‐prone mice and the lupus‐IgG‐induced skin damage mouse model. Depletion of neutrophils did not affect the development of skin inflammation caused by lupus IgG, and lupus IgG can induce apoptosis of neutrophils. The apoptosis of neutrophils induced by lupus IgG is related to FcγRIII and Fas/Fas ligand pathways. Our study indicates that neutrophils are not major contributors in the skin damage caused by tissue‐deposited lupus IgG but death of neutrophils caused by lupus IgG may provide a resource of a large amount of autoantigens in SLE.     

Evaluation of antigen-based heteropolymer for treatment of systemic lupus erythematosus in a nonhuman primate model

Autoantibodies that react with double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) are a hallmark for diagnosis of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and are also considered the pathogenic subset that is most associated with lupus nephritis. As an agent to remove the pathogenic dsDNA antibodies from the circulation of SLE patients, we are developing an antigen-based heteropolymer (AHP). The AHP consists of a monoclonal antibody to the complement receptor (CR1) cross-linked to salmon testis dsDNA to effect clearance of anti-DNA antibodies by binding them to erythrocyte CR1. Utilizing a cynomolgus monkey model for SLE in which we infused plasma from SLE patients containing a high titer of high-avidity anti-dsDNA antibody, we have evaluated the safety and efficacy of AHP infusion. The results demonstrate that AHP rapidly (within 2 min of infusion) binds to monkey erythrocytes without causing any toxicological effects. We also demonstrate that human Ig (G+M) antibodies are rapidly bound to the AHP-erythrocyte complex. These events are mirrored in their kinetics by a substantial drop in the level of high-avidity dsDNA antibody in the plasma.     

Anti-DNA Antibody in Serum Measured by Radioimmunoassay (Fair Technique)

Anti-DNA antibody determination in serum is increasingly used because it supports the diagnosis of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) with high selectivity. The present work evaluates several of the technical variables of the Farr radioimmunoassay for anti-DNA antibody determination and describes a recommendable procedure, emphasizes the most important sources of error and gives the range of normal blood donors and a group of hospital patients without SLE.     

Specific suppression of anti-DNA productionin vitro

To investigate the regulation of anti-DNA antibody production, we generated anti-DNA-specific suppressor cells by exposing normal human T cells and a small percentage of adherent cells to high concentrations of DNA. These cells suppressed the production of anti-DNA by both autologous peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) and allogeneic PBMC derived from systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) patients. Anti-DNA production was suppressed significantly more than anti-RNA, antitetanus, or total immunoglobulin production. Specific suppression was enhanced by increasing the numbers of DNA-primed CD8⁺ cells and was obliterated by irradiation of the DNA-primed cells. In contrast to T cells from normal individuals, T cells obtained from two intensively studied SLE patients were unable to generate specific suppressor cells for anti-DNA production in both autologous and allogeneic test systems. Despite this defect, these patients were still capable of generating specific suppressor cells for antibody production directed against an exogenous antigen, tetanus toxoid.     

Systemic lupus erythematosus in mice, spontaneous and induced, is associated with autoimmunity to the C-terminal domain of p53 that recognizes damaged DNA

The tumor suppressor molecule p53 features a regulatory domain at the C terminus that recognizes damaged DNA. Since damaged DNA might be involved in activating anti-DNA autoantibodies, we tested whether autoimmunity to the C terminus of p53 might mark murine systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). We now report that MRL / MpJ-Fas(lpr) mice, which spontaneously develop SLE, produce antibodies both to the C terminus of p53 and to a monoclonal antibody (PAb-421) that binds the p53 C terminus. Anti-idiotypic antibodies to PAb-421 (sampled as monoclonal antibodies) could also bind DNA. Thus, the PAb-421 antibody mimics DNA, and the anti-idiotypic antibody to PAb-421 mimics the p53 DNA-binding site. This mimicry was functional; immunization of BALB / c mice to PAb-421 induced anti-DNA antibodies and antibodies to the C terminus of p53, and most of the mice developed an SLE-like disease. Immunization of C57BL / 6 mice to PAb-421 induced antibodies to p53, but not to its C-terminal domain. The C57BL / 6 mice also did not develop anti-DNA antibodies or the SLE-like disease. Thus, network autoimmunity to the domain of p53 that recognizes damaged DNA can be a pathogenic feature in SLE in genetically susceptible strains of mice.     

Gender-related influences on the development of chronic graft-versus-host disease-induced experimental lupus nephritis.

Autoimmune diseases are far more common in women than in men. In the incidence of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), the female-to-male ratio is as high as 10:1. This suggests that sex hormones may play a fundamental role in determining the susceptibility to these diseases. In order to investigate the sex-related differences in the inducibility of chronic graft-versus-host disease-related experimental lupus nephritis, lymphocytes from female DBA/2 donor mice were administered to either male or female (C57BL10 x DBA/2)F1 recipients. An additional group of male recipients received lymphocytes from male DBA/2 donors. After four cell transfers, female recipients developed a significantly higher albuminuria than both male groups. Serum concentrations of autoantibodies against glomerular basement membrane (GBM), collagen IV, and laminin were significantly higher in females 2-4 weeks after induction. Levels of circulating autoantibodies against renal tubular epithelial antigens (RTE) and nuclear antigens were not different between the sexes. In transfer studies, the necessity of the presence of anti-GBM and anti-RTE autoantibodies for the development of glomerulonephritis was confirmed. These findings indicate that: (i) in this model of lupus nephritis, susceptibility to glomerulonephritis is strongly influenced by sex-related genes; and (ii) among the variety of autoantibodies occurring in this model of SLE, both anti-GBM and anti-RTE autoantibodies play a key role in the pathogenesis of glomerulonephritis.     

Analysis of autoantibody production in SCID-systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) chimeras.

Mice with SCID disease have previously been successfully engrafted with human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) obtained from normal individuals and from patients with various diseases. To determine whether SCID mice engrafted with SLE PBMC produced autoantibodies with specificities similar to those in the SLE donor, and to investigate which variables influence autoantibody production in the SCID recipients, we injected PBMC from 16 SLE patients into SCID mice and tested the recipients for autoantibodies to DNA and to five recombinant autoantigens. Ten out of 16 (68%) lupus and six out of nine (67%) normal grafts were successful as determined by the presence of human IgG greater than or equal to 5 micrograms/ml of SCID serum post-transfer. Autoantibodies to La/SSB, Ro/SSA, and RNP were detected in five out of 10 SCID-SLE recipients by ELISA and immunoblotting up to 22 weeks post-engraftment. The detection of autoantibodies in SCID-SLE mice was more closely related to autoantibody levels in donor sera than to total IgG concentrations in the SCID recipients. Autoantibody activity/mg IgG was similar in the donor and recipient sera. Histological evaluation of eight SCID-SLE mice killed 4-22 weeks post-transfer revealed population of the SCID thymus and spleen with mononuclear cells, but no evidence of lupus nephritis or dermatitis. These findings indicate that SCID mice can be engrafted with PBMC from patients with lupus and that specific autoantibodies are produced up to 5 months post-transfer. Failure to develop glomerulonephritis may be explained by low or absent anti-DNA antibodies or by changes in the cellular composition of the PBMC grafts.     

The role of CD4CD25 T cells in autoantibody production in murine lupus

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a chronic, systemic autoimmune disease characterized by the loss of tolerance to self-antigen. Because it is currently not known if regulatory T (T(reg)) cells are involved in the pathogenesis, we determined the frequency of CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells and assayed the related gene expression levels in CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells isolated from both lupus mice (NZB/NZW F(1)) and normal control mice (DBA2/NZW F(1)). The results showed that the frequency of CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells in lupus mice was lower than that of normal mice. Except for the high expression level of interleukin (IL)-10 mRNA, CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells from lupus mice expressed normal forkhead box P3 (Foxp3) and transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta mRNA, and exerted suppressive functions. Furthermore, we depleted CD25(+) T(reg) cells of non-autoimmune mice with anti-CD25 antibody and broke their tolerance with apoptotic cell-pulsed dendritic cells for the follow-up of autoantibody levels. The mice in the CD25(+) cell-depleted group had higher titres of anti-double-strand/single-strand DNA antibodies than those of the isotype control antibody-treated group. These findings indicated that CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells might be involved in the regulatory mechanism of autoantibody production.     

Recent advances in understanding the clinical utility and underlying cause of antinucleosome (antichromatin) autoantibodies

The clinical utility of measuring antinucleosome autoantibodies (also known as antichromatin) in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) has recently been evaluated by a number of different groups. Many studies found that antinucleosome autoantibodies were more prevalent than anti-DNA in SLE patients. In addition, antinucleosome autoantibodies were usually found to correlate with glomerulonephritis or disease activity better than anti-DNA in these patients. Antinucleosome autoantibodies are also found in patients with drug-induced lupus and Type I autoimmune hepatitis, but not usually in other diseases, thus showing good specificity for the above diseases. Several studies have shown that individuals with SLE have T cells reactive with nucleosomes and have increased levels of nucleosomes in their sera. The antinucleosome response in murine models of SLE is also T-cell-dependent and appears to be driven by self antigen. Nucleosome-antinucleosome immune complexes bind to glomeruli in vitro, and antinucleosome autoantibodies have been eluted from the kidneys of people and mice with glomerulonephritis. In one strain of mouse it was shown that antinucleosome autoantibodies were necessary, but not sufficient, to cause glomerulonephritis. These findings all show that antinucleosome autoantibodies are a sensitive and specific diagnostic marker for SLE and contribute to the pathology of glomerulonephritis.     

The role of cell stress in systemic autoimmune disease]

Anti-DNA antibody is a characteristic feature of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and plays an important role in pathogenesis of lupus nephritis. However, the mechanism of anti-DNA antibody production, which may directly link to the etiology of SLE, remains uncertain. Mammalian DNA alone is not immunogenic. However, some anti-DNA antibodies cross-react with self antigens, and immunization of mice with a certain peptide could induce anti-DNA antibodies. These facts raise a question as to whether an antigenic trigger of anti-DNA antibodies production is DNA itself. Therefore, molecular mimicry of DNA by non DNA antigen is a possibility for the initial production of anti-DNA antibodies. We found that the human monoclonal nephritogenic anti-DNA antibody, O-81, specifically bound to an endoplasmic reticulum stress response protein, Herp. This suggests that lupus nephritogenic anti-DNA antibody cross-react with Herp and an epitope on Herp mimics DNA. Each time cells receive stress (for example, viral infection), the synthesis of Herp protein is induced. If the epitope is immunogenic, repetitive cell stress can be a trigger of anti-DNA antibodies production.     

Specificity and immunochemical properties of antibodies to bacterial DNA in sera of normal human subjects and patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE)

To elucidate the mechanisms of anti-DNA production, we assessed the binding of sera of normal human subjects (NHS) and patients with SLE to a panel of bacterial and mammalian DNA. Using single-stranded DNA as antigens in an ELISA, NHS showed significant binding to some but not all bacterial DNA, while lacking reactivity to calf thymus DNA. Among bacterial DNA, the highest levels of binding were observed with DNA from Micrococcus lysodeikticus and Staphylococcus aureus. In contrast, SLE sera showed high levels of binding to all DNA tested. To evaluate further immunochemical properties of the anti-DNA antibodies, the subclass distribution of these responses was evaluated by subclass-specific reagents. While NHS showed a predominance of IgG2 antibodies to bacterial DNA, SLE sera had a predominance of IgG1 antibodies to these antigens. Together, these results provide further evidence for the antigenicity of bacterial DNA and suggest that NHS and SLE anti-DNA differ in the patterns of epitope recognition as well as mechanisms of induction.     

The genotype of mice influences the autoimmune response to spliceosome proteins induced by cytomegalovirus gB immunization

In previous studies we have established a link between cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection and an autoimmune response to the U1-70 k protein of the spliceosome in man. This autoimmune response, generally referred to as the anti-RNP (ribonucleoprotein) antibodies, is observed in about 30% of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). We have also found that the CMV glycoprotein B (CMV gB) when expressed in a adenovirus vector (Ad) could induce a significant anti-U1-70 k antibody response in several strains of mice, such as C3H, MRL and BALB/c. In the present study we examined the autoimmune response induced by immunization with Ad-gB in A/J and C57BL/6 (B6) mice and determined whether there was any autoimmune phenotype similar to that observed in patients with SLE. Thus groups of A/J and B6 mice were immunized with Ad/gB or with Ad alone and then observed for possible skin or kidney disease. In addition the autoantibody response to the spliceosome was measured, and the target antigens identified by immunoblot techniques. All of the A/J mice mounted a very high IgG response primarily to the U1-70 k protein of the spliceosome, with evidence of a rapid spreading of the autoantibody response to other components of the complex. In contrast, B6 mice mounted only a very low titre autoantibody response and failed to show signs or symptoms of autoimmunity. The A/J but not the B6 mice were found to have deposits of IgG in their kidneys, which were consistent with abnormal levels of blood urea nitrogen in the A/J but not B6 mice. This study demonstrates the importance of the genetic background in the susceptibility to autoimmunity.     

Spontaneous B cell hyperactivity in autoimmune-prone MRL mice

The MRL-lpr/lpr mouse strain is a commonly used model of the human autoimmune disease systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Although much is known about the contribution of the lpr Fas mutation to B cell tolerance breakdown, the role of the genetic background of the MRL strain itself is less well explored. In this study, we use the MD4 anti-hen egg lysozyme Ig (IgHEL) transgenic system to explore B cell function in MRL+/+ and non-autoimmune mice. We demonstrate that MRL IgHEL B cells show spontaneous hyperactivity in the absence of self-antigen, which is associated with low total B cell numbers but an expansion of the marginal zone B cell population. However, B cell anergy is normal in the presence of soluble lysozyme [soluble hen egg lysozyme (sHEL)], and MRL IgHEL B cells undergo normal elimination in the presence of sHEL when competing with a polyclonal C57BL/6 B cell repertoire. We conclude that B cell hyperactivity may contribute to the autoimmune phenotype of MRL+/+ and MRL-lpr/lpr strains when it initiates antibody responses to rare or sequestered antigens that are below the threshold for tolerance induction, but that there is no B cell intrinsic defect in anergy in MRL mice.     

Disparate T cell requirements of two subsets of lupus-specific autoantibodies in pristane-treated mice

Intraperitoneal injection of pristane induces a lupus-like disease in BALB/c and other non-autoimmune mice characterized by autoantibody production and the development of immune complex disease closely resembling lupus nephritis. Two subsets of autoantibodies are induced by pristane: IgG anti-DNA DNA and -chromatin autoantibodies are strongly IL-6-dependent, whereas IgG anti-nRNP/Sm and -Su antibodies are not. The present studies were carried out to examine the role of T cells in establishing this dichotomy between the production of anti-nRNP/Sm/Su versus anti-DNA/chromatin autoantibodies. Autoantibody production and renal disease were evaluated in athymic (nude) mice treated with pristane. BALB/c nu/nu mice spontaneously developed IgM and IgG anti-single-stranded (ss)DNA and -chromatin, but not anti-nRNP/Sm or -Su, autoantibodies. Pristane treatment increased the levels of IgG anti-chromatin antibodies in nu/nu mice, but did not induce production of anti-nRNP/Sm or -Su antibodies. In contrast, BALB/c nu/+ and +/+ control mice did not spontaneously produce autoantibodies, whereas anti-nRNP/Sm and -Su autoantibodies were induced by pristane in approx. 50% of nu/+ and +/+ mice and anti-DNA/chromatin antibodies at lower frequencies. Nude mice spontaneously developed mild renal lesions that were marginally affected by pristane, but were generally milder than the lesions developing in pristane-treated nu/+ and +/+ mice. The data provide further evidence that two distinct pathways with different cytokine and T cell requirements are involved in autoantibody formation in pristane-induced lupus. This dichotomy may be relevant to understanding differences in the regulation of anti-DNA versus anti-nRNP/Sm autoantibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus, as well as the association of anti-DNA, but not anti-nRNP/Sm, with lupus nephritis.     

Autoreactive responses to environmental factors: 3. Mouse strain-specific differences in induction and regulation of anti-DNA antibody responses due to phthalate-isomers

Little is known of the role of specific environmental factors in promoting autoimmune disorders such as systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). This study addresses how exposure to phthalates, common environmental factors in foods, and biomedical devices could affect the immune functions of resistant and autoimmune-prone mice. We have previously shown that immunization with ortho-phthalate evokes anti-DNA antibody in BALB/c and NZB/W F1 mice, but only the latter suffer from nephritis and high mortality. BALB/c mice, in contrast, develop idiotype-specific CD8+ suppressor T cells downregulating autoreactive B cells. Here we report that all phthalate-isomers (ortho-, meta- and para-) are capable of inducing anti-DNA antibody responses and SLE-like syndromes. Kidney pathology worsens in NZB/W F1 and to a degree, in C57BL/6 mice after repeated exposure to phthalates. Only BALB/c and DBA/2 overcome adverse autoreactivity by induction of Ts cells; but in vivo depletion of these T cells renders these strains susceptible to autoreactivity. Anti-DNA antibodies in affected NZB/W F1 are largely IgG2a-type, while in BALB/c, DBA/2, and C57BL/6 mice IgG1-type. This is further corroborated by cytokine analyses that imply corresponding Th1/Th2 involvement. In summary, the commonly used phthalates appear harmful to susceptible strains, while BALB/c and DBA/2 are spared due to induction of Ts cells.