Hierarchy of responsiveness in vivo and in vitro among T cells expressing distinct Mls-1a-reactive v beta domains.

In this report we have compared responses of T cells bearing different T cell receptor (TcR) V beta domains, including V beta 6, 7, 8.1 and 9, to the minor lymphocyte stimulatory locus (Mls-1a). The virtually complete deletion of peripheral T cells using these TcR V beta domains in mice expressing Mls-1a verified their Mls-1a reactivity. However, varied responses among these cells following stimulation with Mls-1a in vitro suggested a hierarchy of TcR reactivities for Mls-1a with V beta 6 and V beta 9 greater than V beta 8.1 much greater than V beta 7. This hierarchy was further supported by in vivo studies which showed that V beta 6+CD4+ cells dominated responses to Mls-1a.     

Thymic epithelium induces neither clonal deletion nor anergy to Mls 1a antigens.

Grafting of thymic anlagen from day-10 DBA/2 (H-2d; Mls-1a) embryos to newborn athymic BALB/c (H-2d; Mls-1b) mice leads to reconstitution of T cell populations in the recipients. Analysis of adult chimeras shows that their V beta T cell receptor (TcR) repertoires, particularly V beta 6 and V beta 8.1, do not significantly differ in most animals (10 out of 13) from those scored in control chimeras that received syngeneic thymic anlagen. In all cases analyzed, such Mls-1a-reactive T cells could be stimulated at levels comparable to control responses, both in vitro and in vivo. The few cases in which Mls-1a reactive V beta TcR were reduced seem to reflect the variability in TcR V beta repertoires found in this experimental system. In contrast, BALB/c mice, injected at birth with DBA/2 spleen cells show a marked, albeit variable, reduction in the frequencies of V beta 6- and V beta 8.1-bearing CD4+ T cells, and lower frequencies of Mls-1a-reactive T cells in limiting dilution analyses. It appears, however, that V beta 6- and V beta 8.1-bearing T cells remaining in these mice are functionally competent. We conclude that Mls-1 antigens are not expressed by thymic epithelium.     

A cortisone sensitive CD3low subset of CD4+CD8- thymocytes represents an intermediate stage in intrathymic repertoire selection.

Two populations of CD4 single positive (SP) thymocytes were found in transgenic mice bearing class I-restricted Mls-1a reactive (V beta 8.1) TCR genes in the absence of the restriction element. CD3high CD4 SP cells were deleted in the presence of Mls-1a and were cortisone resistant, whereas CD3low CD4 SP cells were not deleted in the presence of Mls-1a and were cortisone sensitive. Intravenous transfer of CD3low CD4 SP cells into nude mice resulted in significant peripheral expansion of these cells with apparent upregulation of CD3. These data indicate that CD3low CD4 SP thymocytes represent an intermediate stage in the transition from CD3low double positive (DP) to CD3high SP thymocytes and raise the possibility that these cells may hve undergone positive but not negative selection events (at least to Mls-1a). Furthermore the fact that CD3high DP thymocytes were also deleted by Mls-1a in these mice suggests strongly that sensitivity to Mls-1a deletion is dependent upon stage of thymic maturation (as revealed by TCR density) rather than CD4/CD8 phenotype.     

Human HLA-DQ beta chain presents minor lymphocyte stimulating locus gene products and clonally deletes TCR V beta 6+, V beta 8.1+ T cells in single transgenic mice

Minor lymphocyte stimulating locus (Mls) gene products in association with mouse major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules are known to determine the repertoire of T-cell receptor (TCR) in mature T cells. In order to test whether human class II molecules can present mouse Mls, HLA-DQ beta transgenic mice were generated. The expression and function of the DQ beta transgene were studied in the progeny of one selected founder which was H-2f and H-2E negative. In these mice, DQ beta molecules pairing with mouse A alpha chain and invariant chain are expressed on the cell surface in a tissue-specific manner. When the DQ beta gene was bred into the Mls-1a strain DBA/1 (H-2q), T cells bearing V beta 6 and V beta 8.1 TCR were clonally deleted in the thymus of DQ beta+ transgenics but not in DQ beta-negative full sibs. Thus, the data presented here clearly demonstrate that the human MHC DQ beta chain can present Mls in the clonal deletion of T cells. Our results also suggest the requirement for an interaction between CD4 and class II molecules (alpha chain) for clonal deletion of T cells to occur.     

Anergy and suppression as coexistent mechanisms for the maintenance of peripheral T cell tolerance

Using T cell receptor (TCR) V(beta)8.1 transgenic mice, we have developed an in vivo system for the study of peripheral T cell tolerance, in which two distinct mechanisms of peripheral tolerance are observed to act simultaneously during the maintenance phase of the nonresponsive state. These two mechanisms, anergy and suppression, have been studied using the CD4+ T cell lineage markers 6C10 and CD25, which can be employed to purify the cells involved in each form of tolerance. Findings and perspectives gained through the study of peripheral tolerance in our model, as well as relevant observations from the literature, will be reviewed.     

Mechanisms of peripheral immune tolerance

Our studies on the immune response to foreign antigens are reviewed as they relate to the mechanisms of peripheral immune tolerance. The activation of suppressor T cells by distinct modes of antigen presentation is discussed. Through the use of mice expressing transgenic T-cell receptors specific for foreign antigens, we have concluded that the separable mechanisms of anergy and active suppression by CD25+ T cells work in concert to produce peripheral tolerance. In T-cell receptor Vbeta8.1 transgenic mice rendered tolerant of Mls-1a, the absence of the cell surface marker 6C10 defines the anergic population of CD4+ T cells, while 6C10+ CD4+ T cells are actively suppressed by CD25+ T cells. Through discussion of these observations, we have developed a historical perspective on recent advances in the understanding of mechanisms of peripheral tolerance.     

V beta1+ J beta1.1+/V alpha2+ J alpha49+ CD4+ T cells mediate resistance against infection with Blastomyces dermatitidis

Immunization with a cell wall/membrane (CW/M) and yeast cytosol extract (YCE) crude antigen from Blastomyces dermatitidis confers T-cell-mediated resistance against lethal experimental infection in mice. We isolated and characterized T cells that recognize components of these protective antigens and mediate protection. CD4+ T-cell clones elicited with CW/M antigen adoptively transferred protective immunity when they expressed a V alpha2+ J alpha49+/V beta1+ J beta1.1+ heterodimeric T-cell receptor (TCR) and produced high levels of gamma interferon (IFN-gamma). In contrast, V beta8.1/8.2+ CD4+ T-cell clones that were reactive against CW/M and YCE antigens and produced little or no IFN-gamma either failed to mediate protection or exacerbated the infection depending on the level of interleukin-5 expression. Thus, the outgrowth of protective T-cell clones against immunodominant antigens of B. dermatitidis is biased by a combination of the TCR repertoire and Th1 cytokine production.     

Intrathymic selection of murine TCR alpha beta+CD4-CD8- thymocytes

The CD4-CD8- thymocyte population contains the precursors of all other thymocytes. However, it also contains a significant proportion of cells which express surface TCR alpha beta, and have little or no precursor activity. Like peripheral T cells, but unlike most other thymocytes, these TCR alpha beta+CD4-CD8- thymocytes do not express heat stable antigen. Both the origin and developmental status of these cells are unclear, and are the subject of this report. We have measured the proportion of V beta 8.1+ cells amongst TCR+HSA-CD4-CD8- thymocytes in MIs-1a versus MIs-1b mice, in order to determine whether they have undergone negative selection. The proportions were similar in both strains, in contrast to mature T cells, indicating that neither they nor their precursors had undergone clonal deletion. We also measured the accumulation of these cells over the early life of the animal and found that it was extremely slow. Our data also show that although TCR-V beta 8.1+ cells are reactive to MIs-1a in association with MHC class II, most mature TCR-V beta 8.1+ cells in MIs-1b mice are CD8+, suggesting an additional reactivity with MHC class I. We raise the possibility that TCR-V beta 8.1+CD4-CD8- thymocytes are derived from TCR-V beta 8.1+CD4+CD8+ thymocytes, and that the reactivity of TCR-V beta 8.1 with both MHC classes I and II has resulted in the down-regulation of both CD4 and CD8.     

A self-reactive T cell population that is not subject to negative selection.

In male mice expressing a transgenic alpha beta TCR which recognizes a male antigen (HY), T cells which do not express normal levels of CD8 escape thymic deletion and appear in the periphery. These consist of two distinct populations, one which lacks expression of both CD4 and CD8, and one with low levels of CD8. Neither population has anti-HY reactivity, consistent with the known requirement of this TCR for CD8. We now describe the consequences of expression of both the anti-HY TCR transgene and a constitutive CD8.1 transgene on T cells of male mice. Peripheral T cells in these male 'double transgenic' mice express both the anti-HY TCR and normal levels of CD8, and can proliferate to male antigen in vitro. These cells do not express the endogenous allele of CD8 (CD8.2), suggesting that the increase in CD8 levels due to the CD8.1 transgene leads to the deletion of the CD8.2low population. In contrast, the CD8.1 transgene does not lead to the deletion of the CD8.2- population. This implies that, unlike the majority of alpha beta T cells, TCR+CD4-CD8- cells in TCR transgenic mice are not subject to deletion.     

Characterization of CD4+ T helper cells in patients with Kawasaki disease (KD): preferential production of tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) by V beta 2- or V beta 8- CD4+ T helper cells.

KD is an acute febrile illness in children characterized by coronary arteritis accompanied by aneurysm and thrombotic occlusion. The etiology of KD is unknown. It has been recently reported that KD is associated with the selective expansion of V beta 2+ and V beta 8.1+ T cells in peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL), by studying the T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire of in vitro activated T cells. KD may therefore be caused by a superantigen [1-3]. To understand better the immunopathology of KD, we investigated TCR V beta 2 and V beta 8.1 expression on both the T cells of freshly isolated PBL and T cell clones (TCC) from patients with KD. Cytokine production by TCC was also studied. Blood samples were obtained from patients with acute (n = 20) and convalescent (n = 20) KD, age-matched children with non-infectious diseases (n = 18), and healthy adults (n = 20). Among these four groups, there were no significant differences in the percentages of either V beta 2+ or V beta 8.1+ T cells of freshly isolated PBL. The same was true for the CD4+ or CD8+ T cell subsets. One hundred and five TCC (98 CD3+ CD4+ CD8- and seven CD3+ CD4- CD8+) established from the affected skin, lymph node or PBL of six patients with KD were also negative for either V beta 2 or V beta 8.1 TCR. Sixty-eight of 105 TCC (65%) produced detectable levels (> 5 pg/ml) of TNF-alpha (6-1016 pg/ml), in the absence of any stimuli. In contrast, only 11 (10%) of 105 TCC or 7 (7%) of 97 TCC produced detectable levels of IL-2 or IL-6, respectively, in the absence of any stimuli. Stimulation with phytohaemagglutinin (PHA) and phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) induced most TCC to produce higher amounts of TNF-alpha, IL-2 and IL-6. These results suggest that CD4+ T helper cells expressing TCR-beta other than V beta 2 or V beta 8 receptor, primarily through TNF-alpha production, are involved in the immunopathology of KD.     

In vivo presentation of Mls-1 antigen by T and B lymphocytes.

Previous studies of minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls) presenting lymphoid cells had shown that B cells rather than T cells present stimulatory Mls-1 antigen in vitro whereas B as well as T cells present Mls-1 antigen in vivo. Deletion of Mls-1 reactive T cells in the thymus of newborn mice is induced by T cells rather than by B cells. Applying a recently developed method for measuring the Mls-1 response in Mls-1- mice we assessed the Mls-1 stimulatory activity of T and B cells quantitatively. B cells are significantly more effective than T cells in this process. Both Mls-1+ T and B cells are also capable of inducing Mls-1 anergy in Mls-1- mice. Remarkably few lymphoid cells from Mls-1+ animals are needed for this effect: a few thousand B cells or 10(4) to 10(5) T cells per mouse induce substantial Mls-1 anergy in Mls-1- mice. These low cellular requirements for Mls-1 anergy production correspond well to the low T cell requirements described for the induction of Mls-1 tolerance in newborn mice. However, the high efficacy of B cells in inducing peripheral Mls-1 anergy contrasts with their failure to induce neonatal tolerance in newborn animals. We attribute this discrepancy to the previous notion that stimulatory Mls-1 antigen is not delivered to the thymus and that B cells and T cells present qualitatively different Mls-1 related signals to Mls-1 reactive T cells.     

The requirement of intrathymic mixed chimerism and clonal deletion for a long-lasting skin allograft tolerance in cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance

Mechanisms of cyclophosphamide (CY)-induced tolerance were studied. When C3H/He Slc (C3H; H-2k, Mls-1b) mice were primed i.v. with 1 x 10(8) viable spleen cells from H-2-identical AKR/J Sea (AKR; H-2k, Mls-1a) mice and treated with 200 mg/kg of CY 2 days later, a long-lasting skin allograft tolerance to AKR was established. When [C57BL/6 Sea (B6; H-2b, Mls-1b) x AKR]F1 (B6AKF1) cells were used as the tolerogen, however, only a moderate, but not long-lasting, skin tolerance to AKR was observed. In the C3H mice treated with AKR cells and CY, the intrathymic clonal deletion of V beta 6+ T cells, which are strongly correlated with reactivity to Mls-1a antigens, was observed in the chimeric thymus on day 35, although neither the clonal deletion of V beta 6-bearing T cells nor the mixed chimerism was observed in the thymus on day 14. In the C3H mice treated with B6AFKF1 cells followed by CY, however, neither the clonal deletion of V beta 6+ T cells nor the mixed chimerism was observed in the thymus throughout the test period. In the lymph nodes of the C3H mice treated with AKR cells and CY, only CD4+ V beta 6+ T cells, bur not CD8+V beta 6+ T cells, had selectively decreased by day 14, and they were hardly detectable on day 35. The selective decrease of CD4+V beta 6+ T cells in the lymph nodes was also observed by day 14 when B6AKF1 cells were used as the tolerogen, although CD4+V beta 6+ T cells gradually increased on day 35, at which time almost all skin grafts from AKR had already been rejected. These results strongly support the necessity of the intrathymic mixed chimerism and clonal deletion of donor-reactive T cells for a long-lasting skin allograft tolerance in CY-induced tolerance.     

Deletion of self-reactive T cells in the donor-derived T cells but not in the host-derived T cells in fully allogeneic radiation chimeras. Mls-reactive T cells in allogeneic radiation chimeras

Kinetics of T cells bearing V beta 6 capable of recognizing Mls-1a were examined in the thymus and peripheral lymphoid organs of two allogeneic bone marrow chimeras; AKR/J(H-2k, Thy1.1,Mls-1a)----C3H/He(H-2k, Thy1.2,Mls-1b) and AKR/J----C57BL/6(H-2b,Thy1.2, Mls-1b). Sequential appearance of host- and donor-derived T cells occurred in the thymus and the peripheral lymphoid organs of both AKR----C3H and AKR----B6 chimeras. The first cells to repopulate the thymus were Thy1.2+ host-derived radioresistant cells, which were synchronized in their development. The host-derived cells in thymus of AKR----B6 chimeras differentiate more rapidly than those in AKR----C3H chimeras. An almost complete replacement from host-derived cells to donor-derived cells occurred by day 21 after reconstitution in AKR----C3H and AKR----B6 chimeras. In the donor-derived thymocytes, none of CD4- or CD8-single positive thymocytes expressed high density of V beta 6 in either AKR----C3H or AKR----B6 chimeras, whereas the host-derived thymocytes in AKR----B6 chimeras contained an appreciable number of CD4-single positive thymocytes bearing V beta 6. In the peripheral lymphoid organs, T cells bearing V beta 6 were virtually abolished in Thy1.1+ cell pool of both AKR----C3H and AKR----B6 chimeras. While V beta 6+ T cells of host-origin were detected in the peripheral lymphoid organs in AKR----B6 chimeras. These result indicated that the donor-derived mature T cells showed deletion of V beta 6 in the thymus and the peripheral lymphoid organs in both AKR----C3H and AKR----B6 chimeras, whereas lack of V beta 6 deletion was observed in the host-derived mature T cells in the AKR----B6 chimeras. These results suggested that the host-derived thymocytes may likely to escape undergoing a negative selection against donor-phenotype in the radiation bone marrow chimeras.     

Role of CD4 molecule in intrathymic T-cell development.

We have investigated the role of CD4 molecules in intrathymic T-cell repertoire selection. The administration of monoclonal antibody (mAb) to CD4 in organ culture of murine foetal thymus (FTOC) completely inhibited the development of CD4+8- cells, and additional treatment with anti-class II MHC (Ia) mAb caused no further effects on this inhibition. On the other hand, when the potentially autoreactive cells in Mls-1a mice were monitored by expression of the Mls-1a-reactive V beta 6 gene product of T-cell receptor alpha beta (TcR alpha beta), the treatment with anti-CD4 resulted in the appearance of V beta 6-bearing cells to some extent, but this effect was considerably reinforced by the combinatory use of anti-Ia mAb with anti-CD4. In a model system where the bacterial superantigen staphylococcal enterotoxin B serves as self-antigen to deplete V beta 8-bearing cells in FTOC, the depletion of V beta 8+ cells was restored partially by anti-CD4 alone but completely by the combination with anti-Ia. These results suggest that CD4 is indispensable for positive selection of all CD4+8- thymocytes, whereas participation of CD4 in negative selection is only partial. It was also observed that the development of TcR alpha beta-bearing cells in the CD4-8- population was inhibited by the treatment with anti-CD4 mAb. In Mls-1a mice, V beta 6-bearing cells were developed in CD4-8+, CD4+8+, and also in CD4-8- populations after anti-CD4 mAb treatment. It is suggested that TcR alpha beta-bearing CD4-8- cells are possibly originated from CD4+ cells and undergo CD4-mediated thymic selection.     

A critical role for the T cell receptor alpha-chain connecting peptide domain in positive selection of CD1-independent NKT cells.

Natural killer T (NKT) cells are a subset of mature alpha beta TCR(+) cells that co-express NK lineage markers. Whereas most NKT cells express a canonical Valpha14/Vbeta8.2 TCR and are selected by CD1d, a minority of NKT cells express a diverse TCR repertoire and develop independently of CD1d. Little is known about the selection requirements of CD1d-independent NKT cells. We show here that NKT cells develop in RAG-deficient mice expressing an MHC class II-restricted transgenic TCR (Valpha2/Vbeta8.1) but only under conditions that lead to negative selection of conventional T cells. Moreover development of NKT cells in these mice is absolutely dependent upon an intact TCR alpha-chain connecting peptide domain, which is required for positive selection of conventional T cells via recruitment of the ERK signaling pathway. Collectively our data demonstrate that NKT cells can develop as a result of high avidity TCR/MHC class II interactions and suggest that common signaling pathways are involved in the positive selection of CD1d-independent NKT cells and conventional T cells.     

T cell receptor V beta genes expressed by IgG anti-DNA autoantibody-inducing T cells in lupus nephritis: forbidden receptors and double-negative T cells

In the (SWR x NZB)F1 (SNF1) model of lupus nephritis, pathogenic variety of IgG anti-DNA autoantibodies are induced by certain T helper (Th) cells that are either CD4+ or CD4-CD8- (double negative; DN) in phenotype. From the spleens of eight SNF1 mice with lupus nephritis, 149 T cell lines were derived and out of these only 25 lines (approximately 17%) were capable of augmenting the production of pathogenic anti-DNA autoantibodies. Herein, we analyzed the T cell receptor (TcR) V beta genes used by 16 such pathogenic autoantibody-inducing Th cell lines. Twelve of the Th lines were CD4+ and among these five lines expressed V beta 8 (8.2 or 8.3). The V beta 8 gene family is contributed by the NZB parent to the SNF1 mice, since it is absent in the SWR parental strain. Three other CD4+ Th lines expressed V beta 4, another was V beta 2+ and one line with poor autoantibody-inducing capability expressed V beta 1. Four autoantibody-inducing Th lines from the SNF1 mice had a DN phenotype and these lines were also autoreactive, proliferating in response to syngeneic spleen cells. Among these DN Th lines, two expressed V beta 6 and one expressed V beta 8.1 TcR. Both of these are forbidden TcR directed against Mls-1a (Mlsa) autoantigens expressed by the SNF1 mice and such autoreactive T cells should have been deleted during thymic ontogeny. Thus, the DN Th cells of non-lpr SNF1 mice are different from the DN cells or MRL-lpr which lack helper activity and do not express forbidden TcR. The spleens of 6 out of 19 nephritic SNF1 animals tested also showed an expansion of forbidden autoreactive TcR+ cells that were mainly DN. Two of these animals expressed high levels of V beta 6 (anti-Mlsa) and V beta 11 (anti-I-E) TcR+ cells, three others had high levels of V beta 11+ cells alone and one animal had an expanded population of V beta 17a+ (anti-I-E) cells. The I-E-reactive TcR again should have been eliminated in the SNF1 thymus, since they express I-E molecules contributed by the NZB parent. The SWR parents of SNF1, are I-E-; moreover, they lack the V beta 11 gene but they express V beta 17a in peripheral T cells. Whereas the NZB parents are I-E+, they lack a functional V beta 17a gene and they delete mature V beta 11+ T cells.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The primary in vivo immune response to Mls-1 (Mtv-7 sag). Route of injection determines the immune response pattern.

Injection of cells expressing the retroviral superantigen Mls-1 (Mtv-7 sag) into adult Mls-1- mice induces a strong immune response including both T- and B-cell activation. This model was used for studying qualitative aspects of the immune response in normal mice with a defined antigen-presenting cell (the B cell) and without the use of adjuvant. BALB/c mice were injected locally or systemically with Mls-1-expressing spleen cells from Mls-1-congenic BALB.D2 mice. Intravenous injection led to an initially strong expansion of Mls-1-reactive V beta 6+ CD4+ cells mainly in the spleen, to a large degree explained by the trapping of reactive cells, and a rapid down-regulation of interleukin-2 (IL-2) and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) production, consistent with the proposed tolerogenic property of B cells as antigen-presenting cells. However, these mice developed a slowly appearing but persistent B-cell response dominated by IgG1-producing cells, suggesting a shift in lymphokines produced rather than complete unresponsiveness. Subcutaneous injection into the hind footpad with the same number of cells led to a strong local response in the draining lymph node, characterized by a dramatic increase of V beta 6+ CD4+ T cells, local production of IL-2 and IFN-gamma and a strong but short-lived antibody response dominated by IgG2a-producing cells, characteristic of a T-helper type 1 (Th1) type of response. Both routes of injection led ultimately to deletion of reactive T cells and anergy, as defined by the inability to produce IL-2 upon in vitro stimulation with Mls-1. It is concluded that Mls-1 presented by B cells induces qualitatively different responses in vivo dependent on the route of injection. We propose that the different responses result from the migration of the injected cells to different micro-anatomical sites in the lymphoid tissue. Furthermore, these results suggest that B cells may function as professional antigen-presenting cells in vivo present in an appropriate environment.     

Superantigen-induced anergy of V beta 8+ CD4+ T cells induces functional but non-proliferative T cells in vivo.

The response profile of staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB)-primed murine V beta 8+ CD4+ and V beta 8+ CD8+ T cells was analysed upon rechallenge in vitro. While in vitro responses to secondary stimulation with SEB were reduced to background levels, the in vivo reactivity after rechallenge with SEB was retained, in that SEB-primed mice succumbed to lethal T-cell shock, lymphokines [interleukin-1 (IL-1), IL-2, Il-4, IL-6, IL-10, interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha)], and lymphokine-specific mRNA accumulation could be detected in V beta 8+ CD4+ and V beta 8+ CD8+ T cells. However, V beta 8+ CD4+ T cells failed to enter the cell cycle. While the phenotype of V beta 8+ CD8+ T cells was indistinguishable from that of their counterparts from naive mice, V beta 8+ CD4+ T cells exhibited in vivo an unusual phenotype as non-proliferative but functional T cells. We conclude that in vitro-defined anergy does not disclose the functional abilities of ligand-reactive V beta 8+ T cells in vivo, and that priming with superantigen (SAg) induces in vivo a differentiation of SEB-reactive V beta 8+ CD4+ T cells into a non-proliferative but functional phenotype.